|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On November 21 2014 06:39 VisceraEyes wrote:
Rayn all I was saying is that I think Chez is town, and that the only scenario that makes sense to me if Chez is mafia is if Hopeless is mafia with him and he moved his vote off his scumbuddy. But the kink in that thinking is why does Chez draw attention to Hopeless in the first place if they're both mafia, so that doesn't really make sense either. It's just an expanded townread of Chezinu basically.
Also, this read is weird because the last time you posted anything about hopeless iirc he WAS your scum read. So the world where they could be scum together should be very real, especially as chez is MOVING his vote onto sicklucker away from the person you think is mafia which COULD indicate that they are mafia together. Why do you have huge leaps of knowledge that just seem really farfetched??
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
god you guys haven't done much since i left
|
On November 21 2014 19:18 Holyflare wrote:
god you guys haven't done much since i left
man's gotta work y'kno?
|
saw holyfart talk about sicklucker, decided to read his filter, started; then i found this:
On November 21 2014 04:17 sicklucker wrote:
I kinda wanna mislynch you again to ff ^_^. I got some time to contribute rereading the thread.
ritoky is town. Hes trying to keep the peace and get that horribly overreacted fight done with. I dont think a mafia ever has the balls or the motive to keep the peace when we have people threatening to veggie shoot people two hours into the gamee.
scumslip much? how you know that ff is town BRO?
|
also i find both gb and damdred underwhelming today, both have had narrow focuses and shallow reads.
damdred also not following through on his questioning or really pushing for answers which be strange yo!
that said though, lian is literally figuratively giving me cancer with his posts.
|
Holy this is my first day one. Im giving my first reaction reads because im trying to help. Im sorry if there not up to your standards. Try to see that im trying with my inexperience I could lurk all day and no one would care.
|
That was just an inside joke because I just mislynched him and he was salty about it. In that game he also tried to vote me out with all the new players because of a "scumslip" Those reads are terrible from my limited experience.
The fact I was the bigger man and made peace with him when he was actually pissed at me... Thats where I got my ff read from
|
your Country52797 Posts
On November 21 2014 20:58 sicklucker wrote:
That was just an inside joke because I just mislynched him and he was salty about it. In that game he also tried to vote me out with all the new players because of a "scumslip" Those reads are terrible from my limited experience.
The fact I was the bigger man and made peace with him when he was actually pissed at me... Thats where I got my ff read from
Can we not base our reads on stuff related to other games, unless it's important meta?
|
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/4AjsIiX.png)
I think VE is mafia based solely on that post I've analysed. I still have to read the thread properly but I'm busy/lazy.
|
I thought it was important there but I agree
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
this game just isn't very fun and i don't know why
|
On November 21 2014 22:58 Holyflare wrote:
this game just isn't very fun and i don't know why
Because no one is trying.
Vote VE with me. If VE was town, he would flip the fuck out when I posted my analysis on his post. Or he would try to reason it better. Instead, he just avoid giving traction to that call out because he knows I've nailed him and he didn't want to draw attention.
VE has no confidence in this game. He is just throwing random questions and not taking hard stances
|
On November 20 2014 14:51 VisceraEyes wrote:
So my first instinct when I want to appear active as mafia is to just get in the thread and comment on something - ANYTHING. Like, it doesn't even have to be important, it just has to be a random comment about something happening in the thread.
As town to appear active your first instinct is to just post. But that's different from the above. What mafia want to do is comment on something. Because it can be seen as some kind of contribution. Townies will post just anything.
Arguably that's what fecal is doing in response to Chezinu's posts, but the difference is that fecal is making Paint pictures to comment on Chez, and he's basically saying "This is all I see when you post that", which is frankly a pretty townie response to Chezinu imo.
Chez pointed out Hopeless, and I don't disagree so I like him.
Damdred is a gut read. If I'm wrong it's about Damdred.
Horrible post. He can't draw all these conclusions already at page two. It's funny that in his first paragraph he does exactly what he says mafia always does.
Second paragraph isn't true. I started to give traction in a game I was town by calling an entrance out. That's my way to drive discussion.
Third paragraph is so NULL, so NULL that hurts. That's not alignment indicative at all.
Again, nothing that hopeless have posted at that time was alignment indicative. It makes no sense to me.
|
Nevermind the "not taking hard stances" thing. He is
But he is taking them weirdly. He suddenly thought HF was mafia when he was pretty sure hopeless was scum. It did not follow a stream of thought, a process of sudden realisation. He saw Rayn calling out HF and THEN he started to drop reasons on why HF was weird. He didn't show any attempt of trying to figure HF out before.
Like, if you are town an you START to believe SOMEONE ELSE is scum, it's because you saw something weird. You see it and you push it. THIS IS NOT WHAT HAPPENED. What happened was Rayn saying HF is weird (without giving reasons) and then VE IMEDDIATELY flips his vote and attention to HF, and locks on him.
|
omg STOP GB. "VE is maf because of this. WELLLLLLLLL now that I've filtered him that's not true, but he's maf for THIS I guess"
You were wrong the first time, and you're still wrong. I'm town. The reason I didn't react to your analysis is because it's wrong and I'm not getting lynched today. If I start getting lynched maybe I'll respond to said analysis.
|
On November 21 2014 18:09 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2014 06:39 VisceraEyes wrote:
Rayn all I was saying is that I think Chez is town, and that the only scenario that makes sense to me if Chez is mafia is if Hopeless is mafia with him and he moved his vote off his scumbuddy. But the kink in that thinking is why does Chez draw attention to Hopeless in the first place if they're both mafia, so that doesn't really make sense either. It's just an expanded townread of Chezinu basically. Also, this read is weird because the last time you posted anything about hopeless iirc he WAS your scum read. So the world where they could be scum together should be very real, especially as chez is MOVING his vote onto sicklucker away from the person you think is mafia which COULD indicate that they are mafia together. Why do you have huge leaps of knowledge that just seem really farfetched??
Why is this read weird? I've given specific reasoning for thinking Chezinu is town, and I've given specific reasoning for thinking he's not mafia. I don't care how real the world where Chez and Hopeless are both maf COULD be because based on Chez voting him in the FIRST place (like I said) I find it really unlikely that they're partners. Maybe I'm wrong and bad, but that's my opinion based on what's in the thread.
What's weird about that Holyflare? Go on, explain it.
|
I was wrong about you not taking solid stances, but that's all.
Your stream of thought fits much more a mafia mindset than a town mindset
|
On November 21 2014 23:44 GlowingBear wrote:
I was wrong about you not taking solid stances, but that's all.
Your stream of thought fits much more a mafia mindset than a town mindset
No it doesn't, because I'm town. You're being ridiculous. Some more.
|
On November 21 2014 23:14 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2014 22:58 Holyflare wrote:
this game just isn't very fun and i don't know why Because no one is trying. Vote VE with me. If VE was town, he would flip the fuck out when I posted my analysis on his post. Or he would try to reason it better. Instead, he just avoid giving traction to that call out because he knows I've nailed him and he didn't want to draw attention. VE has no confidence in this game. He is just throwing random questions and not taking hard stances
Bolded is incorrect. I flip out when people who I think can get me lynched make posts that are good about me. Now when people who CAN'T get me lynched make BAD posts about me. So no, I wouldn't flip out.
You haven't "nailed" me. Everything you post about me is wrong. Try harder sir.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
