Should be ending now.

scum: Damdred, idk...
fishy: Oats (because he is making sense), Xatalos (i would expect more from him so far)
town: GB, yamato
dunno: Robik, geript

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 18 2014 10:07 GMT

#227

oh yeah poofer has posted a lot but i don't remember anything he has said. Could be mafia too.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

August 18 2014 10:12 GMT

#228

On August 18 2014 19:07 raynpelikoneet wrote:
oh yeah poofer has posted a lot but i don't remember anything he has said. Could be mafia too.

Haha. This is actually a reasoning I used successfully once I think :D

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 18 2014 10:13 GMT

#229

Deadline is btw in ~45min.
The Night post says so.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 18 2014 10:16 GMT

#230

So Xatalos some reads please?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

August 18 2014 10:19 GMT

#231

I think I'll post some reads closer to the deadline since there's apparently no specific action deadline...

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

August 18 2014 10:20 GMT

#232

The lack of a filter collection in the OP is killing me

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 18 2014 10:23 GMT

#233

Who cares if you get shot?
Talk. If you are scum and i get shot i can't tell people you are scum before i die.
scumhunt. now.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

August 18 2014 10:36 GMT

#234

Hahaha

Well, I guess the benefits of discussing reads now might outweigh the benefits of making the actions harder for scum.

yamato: I'm thinking that he's scum based on the fact that there isn't a single constructive / helpful post from him yet. That's why I (correctly) read him as scum in the PYP game and why I (correctly) read him as town in the Vendetta Strada game (I mean in that game he actually did post helpful stuff...) - if this continues during D1 I think he's definitely scum

Tehpoofter - I don't really like him either. His posts are mostly one-liners that don't really push the game forward in any way and he has many wishy-washy reads.

Damdred - a couple of pretty weird posts, potential scum I guess

rayn - Probably town, at least a lot more helpful than in Neat & Tidy

Oats - I don't really remember how to read him atm, wanting to see more from him

GB - leaning town, it felt easy to discuss with him earlier

rest - no idea atm

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 18 2014 10:42 GMT

#235

I don't agree with your yamato read. Obviously.

I agree with poofer although i do not remember if he usually plays at the start of the game or not because here he sure isn't.

I am pretty sure Damdred is mafia. His post about me & GB and his read on yamato doesn't really make any sense. That's pretty much all he has said.

Oats feels too laid back. It is strange. I haven't played with him in ages so i guess time will tell. Sure worth keeping eye on. I didn't like how he agreed with my post on Damdred but didn't push Damdred about it (as he implied he figured out same stuff i did). That's not town!Oats'y imo.

Your read on me is BS - you can't say what you did in the first place because i can't possibly comment on it in any way.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

August 18 2014 10:48 GMT

#236

Yeah that's true, it was a bad choice of example. Let's just say that I generally like you better when you act arrogantly and try to lead the game instead of whining about stuff and being more irresponsible about the flow of the game

And you do have a lot of reasonable reads already. That's just how I read you.

Could you explain more about your yamato read? Because I think he played almost exactly like this as scum before.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

August 18 2014 10:53 GMT

#237

Or it's not exactly the same after all. I think I'll wait a bit more to see how he develops instead of judging immediately.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 18 2014 10:58 GMT

#238

I don't whine about stuff unless it's idiotic. I am nowadays way more laid back and don't even want to lead because it makes me analyze the game better and i do not focus on stupid stuff. Also i am (and have been) incredibly busy on every single weekend so i just basically do not have time to play on weekends.

When yamato is scum he says some dumb stuff that doesn't have to do with anything. He tells people how busy he is and why he couldn't post and "gets mad" at them for wanting to lynch him for not doing shit etc etc. When he is town - while he can be lazy and not say "anything useful" (which is not even correct) his posting shows that he actually reads the thread and bases his stuff on something. I don't remember if you played in the game where we lynched Corazon on D1 and then all the scum quit the game on N1. People were pushing yamato as he looked like he was just being a prick and not doing anything useful. People are generally bad at reading yamato when he is town and I am pretty sure yamato is town this game.