GlowingRed - You are playing in such a different fashion from other games I've seen you in and makes me think you might be mafia.
I missed Tolkien's description of how the votes went down So your vote is now basically just a flavor vote because MeatPolice wouldn't have voted on himself so he was likely to switch to the RNG guy at some point anyways. So hoping on late wasn't actually to hammer which was what I was giving you some town points for (and taking them from Tolkien) I now am thinking the reads you have been giving may not be from just a silly point of view but might be from a mafia point of view.
I said it at the start of the day that your case with the Jenny/Seeya Connection was very weird/odd. It didn't seem to hold water. It also was already making connections between people that frankly shouldn't have been made at the time. I also think you got way overly defensive when I said I was vigi and going to shoot you in the night. + Show Spoiler +
I'm going to pretend like I'm all the roles. So As medic I'm saving jenny. As Cop I'm checking between Teemu/Seeya/Meat and outting with a red check of any kind. As Vigi I'm shooting GB for trying to make roles claim when they don't need to.
I'm going to give a hard bang, marry kill soon. Enjoy!
ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Do you all read me as mafia??? Really???
Wtf I give up
The kind of attitude was silly from an offhand comment. You also are quick to want the day to just be on MeatPie and not really moving on from there.
I think that your game play has been to throw scum on people and also the reasons you had from not being here in day 1 while probably all true felt like you wanted to have a good reason to be afk.
I think you might be mafia with RNG and I'm going to see what kind of interaction you guys had.
GB Can you explain why you reacted like you did to me threatening to shoot you? Can you also explain to me what your top 3 suspects are as mafia and why?
Lil'Quiet - You've been doing things that show you know the game but haven't made me feel you ooze town
I feel like day one you tried to buddy up to me... while I like friends I like friends that want to be my friend for a good reason. I feel like your read on me was a bit premature maybe you just had a good beat and went with it. I've been there before but it felt kinda like a mafia buddying up to me.
Also your vote on RNG guy came early with me but I didn't feel like you were pushing for him to really go away. Like you were sitting your vote there almost to keep the blood off your hands if MeatPretzel got lynched. I think that you were in the right and your reads seem okay but I'd Like to see you out here pushing more on them really trying to steer town in the direction they're suppose to go.
I think that if you continue to stay sorta in the shadows you get more and more mafia. I think mafia could easily lynch onto me and keep me alive knowing that you can just feed off me and sheep my reads and by agreeing and being my "yes man" stab me in the back. This is over generalizing and I don't think you've been doing this all game but I want it to be known.
Can you tell me who I should filter dive first? Who would you think is the scummiest townie? And why do you read them as such?
On August 01 2014 22:22 meatpudding wrote: Here's my M/B/K and where I'm starting from d2.
To be declared a union under holy matrimony
Banks - The most espoused in town. His vote critical to the lynch. The only way he's mafia is if he's trying to solo the game. (Sure I wouldn't rule it out)
Make you breakfast
Teemu - 666's case on you makes no sense if you're mafia. Post some reads yourself instead of only arguing what others have posted.
Tolkien - Just another face in the crowd. I would lean town, but I feel it's too early. You've been bumped up for landing the hammer vote.
Just one dance
Jenny - I still feel pretty safe around you but not as much on before. I think your analysis is usually good but it was lacking at the end of d1. If you thought DC was scum you didn't try to argue it.
GB - I think you should be focusing on who's in your town circle before I put you in mine. You're playing a bit inconsistent and when you are serious it seems too serious and mafia contrived.
lilwade - I was a bit cautious on reading you d1. Also you were able to go under the radar for the most part. I think we should get to know each other a little better.
Leave you in a ditch
cya -
On August 01 2014 12:31 Seeyalater wrote:
Meatpudding- I'm going to stick to my guns on MP, mainly because I still don't like his push on Teemu last night. I feel like, he would almost have to be donkey mafia to continue to try to save his mafia partner even though Clockwork had basically dug his own grave and thrown himself in it, but at the same time, how could he not see the logic between the clockwork push? He was also one like Clockwork, who seemed to dissapear out of nowhere in the last few hours, unlike everyone else who always let everyone know when they will be heading off.
If there was logic behind the clockwork push, I didn't see it. You were there before I dropped off, so anyone had the chance to argue but you didn't. You pushed no case for Numbers Guy and then try and switch focus after the flip. Scum I say.
On July 31 2014 18:17 Seeyalater wrote: Man, this vote is hard. I honestly can't say I'm a fan of either Clockwork or Meat, but who to hammer before bed.
Check his reasoning on me. Does it look ok to you? It looks like someone who is having his chance to call someone scum because people are confused about him. I tried to look silly specially when poof started posting he had a plan. I thought his plan was to confuse mafia about my alignment and I played with it. That's because I thought I was the hammer. I remember checking roles and there was no vigi. That's why a freely picked on it
Poof I'm traveling but I'll explain it soon. I'm actually all for meatpudding. I don't have a solid case instead of him. But I'll try to write what is off about those two I'll bring up
On August 02 2014 08:53 Tehpoofter wrote: Its dinner time for me!
PEOPLE THAT ARE AROUND REVIEW MY CASES!!! WHICH ONE DO YOU LIKE? WHY? WHAT CASE NEEDS THE MOST WORK???
I don't actually think everyone is mafia but I really want to see where people stand prove that anyone could be mafia!!
We win today. For our fallen townie Batman Jenny we WILL GET THEM!
None of them.
There's not enough
in them all.
jk, I'll look after LCS and I get some other stuff done. I'll be finished with a couple filter dives of my own soon (tm), and I should be significantly more active starting tomorrow anyways.
Oh good morning. Anyone around? I'll take this question from poofl.
On August 02 2014 06:29 Tehpoofter wrote: Can you just walk me through your thought process of where you were at when you were making the decision not to vote on someone to survive and what posts you've made that you think I should read you townie from? Who should I be pushing on? If you have already said these things please do them again. We need to get organized as town and not let mafia coast so proving your towniness is paramount.
You're thinking in reverse. It's about who didn't vote. Also, reading Teemu's filter make me think it was likely mafia. He posts sead end questions. It would have been more helpful to town to analyse what had gone on up to the events, instead of fake claiming medic and being aggressive without trying to back it up. I'd be pushing on lilwade, GB and cya today.
Lil'Quiet - You've been doing things that show you know the game but haven't made me feel you ooze town
I feel like day one you tried to buddy up to me... while I like friends I like friends that want to be my friend for a good reason. I feel like your read on me was a bit premature maybe you just had a good beat and went with it. I've been there before but it felt kinda like a mafia buddying up to me.
Also your vote on RNG guy came early with me but I didn't feel like you were pushing for him to really go away. Like you were sitting your vote there almost to keep the blood off your hands if MeatPretzel got lynched. I think that you were in the right and your reads seem okay but I'd Like to see you out here pushing more on them really trying to steer town in the direction they're suppose to go.
I think that if you continue to stay sorta in the shadows you get more and more mafia. I think mafia could easily lynch onto me and keep me alive knowing that you can just feed off me and sheep my reads and by agreeing and being my "yes man" stab me in the back. This is over generalizing and I don't think you've been doing this all game but I want it to be known.
Can you tell me who I should filter dive first? Who would you think is the scummiest townie? And why do you read them as such?
My top 3 scum list right now is Meat , Seeya , and GB.
Id like to see some reads on GB more in depth he is the one person this game I am having trouble getting a decent read on Bit busy today, but I feel like we are getting some good info... What is going on with meat, I feel like he disregards almost every post and just throws random things out there. what do you think?
On August 02 2014 06:29 Tehpoofter wrote: Can you just walk me through your thought process of where you were at when you were making the decision not to vote on someone to survive and what posts you've made that you think I should read you townie from? Who should I be pushing on? If you have already said these things please do them again. We need to get organized as town and not let mafia coast so proving your towniness is paramount.
You're thinking in reverse. It's about who didn't vote. Also, reading Teemu's filter make me think it was likely mafia. He posts sead end questions. It would have been more helpful to town to analyse what had gone on up to the events, instead of fake claiming medic and being aggressive without trying to back it up. I'd be pushing on lilwade, GB and cya today.
On August 02 2014 09:01 GlowingBear wrote: Poof I'm traveling but I'll explain it soon. I'm actually all for meatpudding. I don't have a solid case instead of him. But I'll try to write what is off about those two I'll bring up
Lil'Quiet - You've been doing things that show you know the game but haven't made me feel you ooze town
I feel like day one you tried to buddy up to me... while I like friends I like friends that want to be my friend for a good reason. I feel like your read on me was a bit premature maybe you just had a good beat and went with it. I've been there before but it felt kinda like a mafia buddying up to me.
Also your vote on RNG guy came early with me but I didn't feel like you were pushing for him to really go away. Like you were sitting your vote there almost to keep the blood off your hands if MeatPretzel got lynched. I think that you were in the right and your reads seem okay but I'd Like to see you out here pushing more on them really trying to steer town in the direction they're suppose to go.
I think that if you continue to stay sorta in the shadows you get more and more mafia. I think mafia could easily lynch onto me and keep me alive knowing that you can just feed off me and sheep my reads and by agreeing and being my "yes man" stab me in the back. This is over generalizing and I don't think you've been doing this all game but I want it to be known.
Can you tell me who I should filter dive first? Who would you think is the scummiest townie? And why do you read them as such?
My top 3 scum list right now is Meat , Seeya , and GB.
Id like to see some reads on GB more in depth he is the one person this game I am having trouble getting a decent read on Bit busy today, but I feel like we are getting some good info... What is going on with meat, I feel like he disregards almost every post and just throws random things out there. what do you think?
Hes a big MeatPile. I can't get my barrings on him.... What of my cases do you like the least/best?
On August 02 2014 09:01 GlowingBear wrote: Poof I'm traveling but I'll explain it soon. I'm actually all for meatpudding. I don't have a solid case instead of him. But I'll try to write what is off about those two I'll bring up
Explain it for me!
Poof,
Seeyalater has got a lot of fluff on his posts which is a mafia trait. So, it makes me consider him as possible mafia. There's nothing remarkable coming from him.
Lilwade has been lurking a lot and when he comes to the topic he contributes for nothing. It makes him possible mafia for it.
Meatpudding has a long list of wrong traits. Lurking almost 36 hours on day one and bringing a terrible list, goes back to lurking? check On that list, gives free town pass to 666 with no reasoning whatsoever? check Refuses to vote the other wagon to save himself considering Teemu more scum than we considered 666? check Votes WITH flipped scum in a possible townie, possibly leading to a mislynch? check When asked to talk about Teemu, brings full case. When asked to talk about 666, quotes other people's opinion. When specifically asked to bring opinion regarding 666, refuses to do so (look at how many attempts I tried. Mafia is uncomfortable of talking about other mafia, that's why I always try to make people to talk about each other, specially when I believe both are mafia). check
I thought I was the one who hammered 666. Vote count was confusing, as you know. I thought I would die because I would be confirmed town for that. You said you had a plan and talked about vigi, an impossible role in this game. I believed you were trying to draw suspicions on me so I wouldn't be killed at night. That was me faking being silly.
Other than that, my posts were genuine thoughts. If you think they are silly, there's nothing I can do
On August 02 2014 09:01 GlowingBear wrote: Poof I'm traveling but I'll explain it soon. I'm actually all for meatpudding. I don't have a solid case instead of him. But I'll try to write what is off about those two I'll bring up
Explain it for me!
Poof,
Seeyalater has got a lot of fluff on his posts which is a mafia trait. So, it makes me consider him as possible mafia. There's nothing remarkable coming from him.
Lilwade has been lurking a lot and when he comes to the topic he contributes for nothing. It makes him possible mafia for it.
Meatpudding has a long list of wrong traits. Lurking almost 36 hours on day one and bringing a terrible list, goes back to lurking? check On that list, gives free town pass to 666 with no reasoning whatsoever? check Refuses to vote the other wagon to save himself considering Teemu more scum than we considered 666? check Votes WITH flipped scum in a possible townie, possibly leading to a mislynch? check When asked to talk about Teemu, brings full case. When asked to talk about 666, quotes other people's opinion. When specifically asked to bring opinion regarding 666, refuses to do so (look at how many attempts I tried. Mafia is uncomfortable of talking about other mafia, that's why I always try to make people to talk about each other, specially when I believe both are mafia). check
I thought I was the one who hammered 666. Vote count was confusing, as you know. I thought I would die because I would be confirmed town for that. You said you had a plan and talked about vigi, an impossible role in this game. I believed you were trying to draw suspicions on me so I wouldn't be killed at night. That was me faking being silly.
Other than that, my posts were genuine thoughts. If you think they are silly, there's nothing I can do
I still think you're silly. And If I was vigi I would have shot you tbh I still am unsure.
Basically where I'm at this game is that I think its probably ez game ez rares with Seeya or MeatPlum but if its not town is ain a SHIT spot because neither of them is dying at night. We only need one more lynch and tbh if felt like night killing Jenny led to a lot of suspicion on you. I'd be like "bad idea" as mafia. IT just is weird. idk.
On August 02 2014 11:07 GlowingBear wrote: You're ignoring my reasoning and you still think I'm silly, there's nothing I can do. I hope that if I die you reevaluate your reads
I read what you have to say. I want to hear other people talk. I've been talking a lot
On August 02 2014 11:07 GlowingBear wrote: You're ignoring my reasoning and you still think I'm silly, there's nothing I can do. I hope that if I die you reevaluate your reads
Also I'm just 1 vote I hold no more weight than anyone else here. You acting like this right now just makes me think you are again overreacting to some pressure... a mafia trait.
On August 02 2014 11:07 GlowingBear wrote: You're ignoring my reasoning and you still think I'm silly, there's nothing I can do. I hope that if I die you reevaluate your reads
I read what you have to say. I want to hear other people talk. I've been talking a lot
LIL WAYNE TEEMU SEEYA
MEATPROPANE SAY SOMETHING
Banks is going crazy. Too bad you lost your wife mate. I think LT is townies, but luckiest. I don't like Bear's tunnelling on me. There are too many loose ends. I like that you made a case on everyone in the game. Cya and lilwade need to talk more. Teemu I'd deduce is green.
On August 02 2014 11:07 GlowingBear wrote: You're ignoring my reasoning and you still think I'm silly, there's nothing I can do. I hope that if I die you reevaluate your reads
Also I'm just 1 vote I hold no more weight than anyone else here. You acting like this right now just makes me think you are again overreacting to some pressure... a mafia trait.
I'm not overreacting, I've just ran out of argument. I've been saying what I'm saying over and over again. It's the third game people call me silly but it's the third game I've got right reads. I just have nothing more to do. I'm just hoping that when I flip you see that you were wrong and reevaluate your reads on me, in case I die today. That's all.
EPT
I still am unsure. ![[image loading]](http://justcuteanimals.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/cute-animals-seal-pup-sleeping-snow-pics.jpg)
