Newbie Mini Mafia LV - Page 7

On May 02 2014 08:28 27ninjabunnies wrote:
Okay, so he was town, but luckily just town and not a role.
Which means we have two roles still alive (and this is what I am stating as a possibility).

I feel bad about voting him off, but then again, he had done nothing to try and sway our votes off of him. Even as just a vt, you'd think he's fight to the death (I know I would).

Tamburini, I suggest to you that you claim your night kill closer towards the end of the night, that way mafia can't blitz at last second if they do not have a role blocker.

Also, I'm going to reread Sweet's filter to find anything that stands out, and anyone who had addressed him. I hope I'll have something substantial to give to town after I read.

On April 29 2014 12:15 Eden1892 wrote:
Right, then, time to get to work.

##VOTE: Sweetfrost

On April 30 2014 02:27 Amiko wrote:
@ashwtini:
-snip-
- Any thoughts on sweetfrost at this point in the game?

On April 30 2014 03:32 Epishade wrote:
Ok guys, I'm back for a bit before I need to get to class. I'll give some thoughts on current situation.
Sweetfrost: 5 minutes after Dfs brings up that Sqrt clears Yellow as town, Sweetfrost restates what Dfs says without adding anything new from his own opinion. He does give his opinion on Bunny though by saying that he thinks Bunny is acting too hard as town and thinks it is making her look like a Scum trying to get town support. I disagree with this as I feel that Bunny was trying to get information. He also mentions her defending him when he got random voted by Eden as a possible support for his idea that Bunny was trying to gather town support, but I disagree with this too, as she didn't really defend him. This is all that she said:



I don't see that as defending him at all. Eden casted his vote on Sweetfrost only because he hasn't spoken yet because he was in a different timezone. The vote didn't really mean anything, but Sweetfrost seemed to think he was defended by Bunny from the vote, or at least wanted people to think that was what happened. He also agrees on lynching Yellow without much provocation. I'm leaning scum on Sweetfrost for now. If Yellow does get lynched and flips scum, Sweetfrost clears town for me.

On April 30 2014 15:29 Epishade wrote:
So looking back through again, it seems I have missed something. I hadn't seen the vote count until after posting this but,

Sweetfrost actually voted for Sqrt while Tamburini voted for Yellow. That is quite strange to me, but Sweetfrost could have been keeping his vote on Sqrt early, just to switch on Yellow when more people jumped on Yellow so he doesn't look as scummy. His rationale for voting Sqrt was just that he thought either Bunny or Yellow was scum, but not both, so he didn't want to risk it and voted Sqrt. I don't think anybody else has any real fear of Bunny being actual scum right now, and her actions read town to me, so I think Sqrt was covering his tracks through his action here, ready to switch the vote out later when people started calling Yellow scum again.

On May 02 2014 09:27 mtamburini wrote:
You guys talk to much im trying to sleep... LOL

On May 02 2014 09:35 Epishade wrote:

I think you made a mistake, I didn't townread sweetfrost. I scumread him with my scumteam post, and then I made this post because his vote made little sense to me. It kind of contradicted with what I thought earlier about the scumteam consolidating votes, but then I found reasoning for it (in that he could switch later) and wanted to explain that as an appendage to my scumteam post.

Sweetfrost did little to actually defend himself. Lynching him gave us information to move forward. It sucks that he ended up being town, but I don't think voting for him was the "wrong" move given the information we had to work with at the time.

As for your claim that I was piggybacking on Bunny's vote on Sweetfrost:
I may have been doing that a bit. I generally want to see what other people think about my theories before I try pushing them. Other people may see things that I overlooked. If it turns out that they agree with them, I figure I didn't overlook anything and I'll continue with my theory. It might make me look scummy, but I think it'd look worse withholding this information if someone else found it later - but I did the same thing before with Tamburini. I made my scumteam post, then Meat agreed with me and voted for Tamburini, and then I voted for Tamburini as well. I believe my theories are correct when I come up with them (who wouldn't believe in their own theories?), but I always accept the possibility that I'm probably way off. I judge other people's acceptance of my theories as to how well my theories are and if I should continue with them or not.

Even if Bunny didn't end up voting for Sweetfrost though, I still would have. It was a toss-up between Tamburini and Sweetfrost for me, and I felt that Sweetfrost was a better pick between the two.

I did switch a lot too. One of those switches was on Eden, but that was only because I thought there could only be 1 potential vigi in the game. Eden cleared that up for me and I admit I read the rules wrong. And, hell, everyone was just arguing for and against Tamburini and Sweetfrost that I didn't know who to pick. Ended up going with Sweetfrost in the end obv, but I didn't make up my mind until a couple hours before the lynch.

On May 02 2014 09:40 Epishade wrote:


Can you explain why this is for me, as a new player?

On May 02 2014 09:57 Epishade wrote:
Very well, I can wait until the next day to make my case if I'm still alive.