On February 22 2014 22:37 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Oh btw smurf, i thought kush is town because i thought Toad is town and his "i quit mafia if Toad flips town" was something i don't think he would never say as mafia if Toad was town.

You still haven't told me if you think Kush not reading the thread is town or scum since you made a big deal about it earlier.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 13:41 GMT

#1731

Yeah, I can get behind a Kush lynch.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 13:45 GMT

#1733

Would Toad just give up like he did if his scumbuddies were still trying hard? If not it's likely we're looking at Kush/Ala.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 14:12 GMT

#1739

On February 22 2014 23:11 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Or Palmar, can you explain the prplhz read?

Neither of those, but it's mostly because he was starting a lot of stuff and being very proactive at the start. Feel he's dropped off a bit though.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 15:15 GMT

#1778

Palmar do you actually believe the garbage you're vomiting into the thread or are you just doing anything you can to get me lynched? If it's the former I may have to policy you for being dumber than Mafiascum players.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 16:21 GMT

#1838

Palmar is unfortunately town. He's in the I wanna be scum but my mom won't let me category.
Suki don't you feel like Balla's filter length and content alone, regardless of the quality is indicative of him probably being town? I don't think he'd try this hard as scum, especially with Toad going down the drain so quickly.
I need to check out prplhz again. Dude's been mysteriously afk.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 16:24 GMT

#1846

On February 23 2014 01:22 suki wrote:
It's funny because I picked up on that too, but I found your dealings with toad more likely to come from town rayn, and your exchange with balla looks really good, and just a bunch of other things that made me decide you were town.

Is this a read you made yourself or is this something you're taking marv's word for?

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 16:26 GMT

#1850

On February 23 2014 01:24 suki wrote:

Show nested quote +

I made the read myself. Seriously.

I like this answer. Quick, decisive and confident.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 16:29 GMT

#1854

On February 23 2014 01:26 suki wrote:
So Palmar is town and he's just straight up wrong on me?

Palmar hasn't put serious effort in since ever in this game. He's not trying to influence the game in any mafia like fashion. I don't think Day 1 would've been a clear wash on Toad if he was scum. I don't think Mafia had much thread presence at all.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 16:34 GMT

#1858

Suki have you revisited prplhz at all? I haven't but I haven't seen him do anything in the thread in quite some time and it's worrying me.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 16:37 GMT

#1860

I'm worried because in the early game he was very active but as Toad was caught he's starting to do less and less. Could be demotivation.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 16:41 GMT

#1864

On February 23 2014 01:39 marvellosity wrote:
suki might be town for regularly playing mafia before breakfast

A+ reasoning.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 17:47 GMT

#1876

On February 23 2014 02:32 Palmar wrote:
Palmar this thread would be greatly improved with no posting from you.

Fixed that for you.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 18:04 GMT

#1878

Prplhz:
In the early stages of the game he went after Rayn's plan like Toad did. It seems unlikely that both scum would go for it, but it's not unheard of. Prplhz's filter in Carnival Cruise as mafia was very short though (4 pages), and he lived all the way until endgame.
This game doesn't feel like Carnival Cruise at all and a lot more like Roulette. Meta says he's probably town. He's paranoid too whereas his accusations felt more certain during CC. In Roulette he was more uncertain which I feel parallels this game.

Lack of interaction with Toad I can explain from the fact that they had the same gut response to Rayn's plan so I can imagine pr giving Toad a blind eye for that. Yeah I think Prplhz is town.

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 18:07 GMT

#1881

On February 23 2014 03:06 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

in other news, Palmar is still insufferable

CuteFluffyPuppy

Afghanistan138 Posts

February 22 2014 18:15 GMT

#1884

It could be suki but I don't want her to be scum because she's putting in so much effort