|
On October 22 2013 08:33 onlywonderboy wrote:
I think nyx's bad play was him not knowing what to do, July's seems more like he's trying to look like a town player and just failing. I felt much more like nyx in my first game and was why I sympathized with him. I mean, it could have easily been a mafia ploy, but his frustration ended up being genuine.
Really? Because to me it doesn't look at all like how you were playing. You at least tried to defend yourself. You came up with your own reads.
I was ok with it when you first brought up how you sympathized with it but I don't know... it just doesn't sit right with me now. I wish others would chime in though on this case, because I feel like i'm tunnel visioning.
|
United States23745 Posts
On October 22 2013 08:56 Balla24 wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2013 08:33 onlywonderboy wrote:
I think nyx's bad play was him not knowing what to do, July's seems more like he's trying to look like a town player and just failing. I felt much more like nyx in my first game and was why I sympathized with him. I mean, it could have easily been a mafia ploy, but his frustration ended up being genuine. Really? Because to me it doesn't look at all like how you were playing. You at least tried to defend yourself. You came up with your own reads. I was ok with it when you first brought up how you sympathized with it but I don't know... it just doesn't sit right with me now. I wish others would chime in though on this case, because I feel like i'm tunnel visioning.
It's how I felt though. I attempted to make reads but the entire time I felt like I was just digging my own grave and I felt futile trying to defend myself. I didn't shut down like nyx did, but I was almost at that point.
|
Onlywonderboy, since you are pushing for july after all, who do you think is the third mafia with him and GGTemplar? Or your biggest suspects if you don't know exactly.
|
United States23745 Posts
I'm leaning towards him being SK. He didn't really have any interactions with GGTemplar so it's hard to judge there. Honestly his lack of interaction with most players is why I think he's SK over mafia.
|
Can we get a votecount and countdown pls?
|
On October 22 2013 06:13 LoneMeow wrote:
Strange vote (slave) count:
onlywonderboy (1): Balla24
E00e (1): SagaZ
July617 (2): onlywonderboy, E00e
Balla24 (1): Bereft
Not voting (2): July617, istandwithmitt
Currently, July617 is set to be lynched.
to deadline. Remember, voting is mandatory!
If there are errors, please let us know.
|
|
|
While I accept the vote on myself and like SagaZ do not like how this vote train is going The only ones on the chopping block are E00e , only and balla , with that said even if i wasn't to be lynched tonight I will most likely die from the SK , why the SK is keeping us around is beyond me, but I know i've been dodging lynch after lynch and come night I probably wont be saved if there are still any blues left.
So with that said : While i'd like to vote for onlywonderboy, i still think he's just playing frustrated town, look we're all frustrated here but we can't let that cloud our reasoning , lynching townies is a mistake people .
##Vote E00e
|
I, vote (slave) count:
onlywonderboy (1): Balla24
E00e (2): SagaZ, July617
July617 (2): onlywonderboy, E00e
Balla24 (1): Bereft
Not voting (1): istandwithmitt
Currently, July617 is set to be lynched.
to deadline. Remember, voting is mandatory!
If there are errors, please let us know.
|
Bereft, july and mitt, please tell me you guys are around.
Don't let mafia take control, town need to do something.
E00e is mafia it's so obvious. Look at that smooth July train taking advantage of the silence of the town. Look at the extreme defensiveness of his posts. It makes so much sense.
|
OK first things first: if you are town you should be rallying around me or else making a strong case why you think we should vote a separate way. Mitt/July, I'm looking at you.
right now, I'm reading Sagaz and E00e as GGTemplar's scum buddies with Balla and OWB as SK as previously stated. right now I am comfortable with putting my vote on E00e unless he wants to claim a blue role (please tell me he hasn't gone to bed).
I'm typing from a phone so pardon the lack of quotes but I build my case on the following:
his posting has been completely irrational for someone who's town.
in his very first post he chooses to single out 2 things:
1. saying GG's theory crafting or whatever you call it is useful and pro town- it wasn't. I don't see why GG's post would've stood out at all to anyone at that point except for being substance less. I remember this seeming bizarre to me when I first read it.
2. the cop "soft claim". the only reason to do this as town is (a) you're a newb cop or (b) idk, you are absolutely forward thinking and want to rally around the cop preemptively.
I am confident at this point that it isn't (a). I do not think it can be (b) either because notice how he never brings it up again except to say "he may or may not be" but doesn't want to specify. if you are not the cop and you've given the impression that you are to fellow townies, why would you not flat out deny it unless you are self sacrificial and want to confuse mafia from other targets such as Seuss? I think it was pretty obvious that wasn't going to happen, so it makes no sense unless you want to confuse the town.
apologies for the ineloquent case - I will be home and at a computer in 20 mins approx.
##Unvote
##Vote: E00e
|
wtf, why would you die from SK tonight???
|
If wonderboy is SK then he'll shoot me tonight , and be done with it .
|
Ender's vote (slave) count:
onlywonderboy (1): Balla24
E00e (3): SagaZ, July617, Bereft
July617 (2): onlywonderboy, E00e
Balla24 (0): Bereft
Not voting (1): istandwithmitt
Currently, E00e is set to be lynched.
to deadline. Remember, voting is mandatory!
If there are errors, please let us know.
|
On October 22 2013 10:09 July617 wrote:
If wonderboy is SK then he'll shoot me tonight , and be done with it .
what's the rationale behind that?
|
On October 22 2013 09:35 onlywonderboy wrote:
I'm leaning towards him being SK. He didn't really have any interactions with GGTemplar so it's hard to judge there. Honestly his lack of interaction with most players is why I think he's SK over mafia.
you're saying you think July is the SK???
how do you explain his complete lack of self preservation during yesterday's lynch?? you do realize survival is the SK's one and only win con??
|
United States23745 Posts
I just don't think he gave himself much to work with in terms of defending himself. He's been quiet all game long and doesn't have any pro town actions to fall back on because he was content to lurk instead.
|
who else is around besides me and OWB? July are you here? Balla?
|
|
|
I'm here. Re-reading the case on E00e.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
