I don't find any way that this could have been a roleblock. He is the first one posting on day 2 and says he got roleblocked, if that was a fake one he would be betting that there is no roleblock or that no one else got roleblocked. think of how akward this starts to look if day 2 starts, he says he got RB'd and someone else comes right after him saying "hey me too!"

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 18 2013 15:59 GMT

#554

bleh, I meant "i don't find any way this could have been a FAKE roleblock"

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 18 2013 16:32 GMT

#562

You don't want to give a reason or anything?

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 18 2013 21:27 GMT

#589

On October 19 2013 05:40 Bereft wrote:
that was my argument actually. but I realize now that my argument assumes mafia thought (like playerboy and I did) that you were soft claiming. which may not necessarily be the case - because going back and rereading your filter a second time, it doesn't come off like a soft claim after all. I think at the time I was largely convinced by playerboy aggressive reaction.

I guess the question that faces us now is that if we think nyx is the SK (as I think there's a very slim chance he's scum), would we prefer to target him instead of a potential scum read? if he's our safest bet right now at avoiding a mislynch I would be fine with it.

Avoiding miss lynch is number 1 priority; if we have a choice, I think lynching SK first is definitely better. I think the reason should be fairly obvious.

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 18 2013 23:13 GMT

#623

[/b] Can you tell us what will happen to july in the hypotetical case he doesn't show up to vote? Does he get modkilled or reemplaced?
If he's going to get modkilled we're wasting our precious lynch.

Wonderboy has reasonable scum reads now that he expressed them, so I won't be voting for him.
##Unvote
##Vote: Nyxnyxnyx
Despite the fact that SK might kill a mafia at night, he is still a scum role, and we can't afford a misslynch today. With our votes all over the place and the likehood of july getting modkilled, I would not like mafia to swing our votes to another towny. They'd need very little effort for it. I'll go with safe on this one.

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 19 2013 00:10 GMT

#639

Are you implying that mitt and nyx are in your town circle?
Can you clarify when you refer to "your town circle" that might have been invaded by mafia?

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 19 2013 00:12 GMT

#645

Honestly, if some1 can get mitt in here this could become the funniest 2 hours of mafia ever

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 19 2013 00:15 GMT

#649

actually I'm voting nyx right now Umasi

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 20 2013 18:52 GMT

#715

On October 20 2013 23:42 E00e wrote:
GGTemplar had Odin (confirmed town later),Bereft as a strong town read which makes me think Bereft is not Mafia.
Templar also said there are 1 or 2 mafia in the Vonthin voters which makes me think there is at most 1 mafia there preferably 0.
Templar tried to kill me day2 and put me in circles with various other people. I like to think that in those circles there was a Mafia so that when I am lynched day2 and turn out town the other people in that circle are thought of as town.

I think July is the 2nd mafia. I got that feeling from reading July's and GGTemplar's posts and I cant deliver strong evidence right now. Maybe someone else can confirm/deny.

Who's the third mafia then? I really had a scum read on July, but if he is mafia, who the hell is the other?
My only guess was that it was you E00e. Balla and wonderboy voted for him in past days. Bereft is town, mitt is either town or SK. So when you say july is mafia, are you suggesting mafia bussing each others? Is that what you are doing right now? Realizing that July is in bad position and now that GGTemplar is dead you are trying to cover your track?

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 21 2013 03:23 GMT

#718

On October 21 2013 03:56 E00e wrote:
I had you (SagaZ) or Balla as 3rd Mafia but im less sure about that.

Oh really now? From the people that are here, almost everyone had a vote on July at some point, or posts pointing him as a very probable scum. In fact, everyone but you until your last post.

What I think is going on here is this: You are trying to take advantage of the town being fairly innactive to push a vote on what appears to you as a "easy lynch". You see it that way because he was very close of getting lynched yesterday and gave a crappy defense. But as pointed, the only way July as mafia works is if there is some heavy mafia voting on mafia action going on.

This is the first accusation you make in this whole game, baring some weak nyx vote bandwagon. It is completely different from your other posts which all have been all about defending yourself.
You come trying to make some sort of mafia play and push a weak town. But your accusation doesn't make any sense with how the game evolved, and you overlooked that because as mafia you knew all along that nyx was town. I think your "accusation" on July is a big mafia slip.

For emphasis:
Vote E00e

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 21 2013 03:23 GMT

#719

##Vote E00e
Forgot the thingys

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 21 2013 12:30 GMT

#723

I was curious to see if pointing what I tough was flawed in your theory could get more stuff from you.
But you apparently stick on it. You still believe July is the 2nd mafia and the third one went on him at some point. But you also point that the bussing might not have been as hard as I previously tough.
At this point, I still read your statement as a slip, but I will not comment further on the subject, July should be the one defending himself. So vote stands until I hear more from others.
Please post people, game was cool and active but since night 2 no one is saying anything anymore =(

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 21 2013 23:38 GMT

#759

Nyx lynch made perfect sense because we tough he was SK. July had several accusations on him in the past days that always put him back to suspicion. I don't really believe mafia casting suspicion onto each others is what happened, especially in day 1 and 2.
I am extremely uncomfortable about how strong and easy this July vote train is looking.
Bereft and mitt what do you guys think?

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 22 2013 00:27 GMT

#763

Onlywonderboy, since you are pushing for july after all, who do you think is the third mafia with him and GGTemplar? Or your biggest suspects if you don't know exactly.

SagaZ

France3460 Posts

October 22 2013 01:05 GMT

#770

Bereft, july and mitt, please tell me you guys are around.
Don't let mafia take control, town need to do something.
E00e is mafia it's so obvious. Look at that smooth July train taking advantage of the silence of the town. Look at the extreme defensiveness of his posts. It makes so much sense.