EPTNewbie Mini Mafia XXXII - Page 9
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Mr. Cheesecake
United States3756 Posts
| ||
|
Arnarnion
Canada39 Posts
1) I haven't played a game yet, but I did obs XXXII 2) I am of the opinion that lynches should be saved for top scum reads and that removing inactive players might not be as productive for town as it is for scum, since were just doing their work for them. 3)(Oats)- Don't give me none of that pie or cheesecake, the only true dessert is ice cream. (CC)- Green. | ||
|
AxleGreaser
Australia1154 Posts
lolcat <= a C&C warning // mafia {on cue}{Enters stage right}{runs into the spotlight} {leaps in the air and pirouettes} {lands delicately on one foot, falls flat on face} {rolls around on floor like a beached whale} {struggles in an ungainly manner to feet} {spins around , fingers spread wide} “#*#Fos everyone in the Room, yer all scum!” {pauses, gears turn, looks carefully at fingers, notices a spare one, looks skyward} “#*#Fos the host too, yer all scum, until evidence of intention proves otherwise!” Thinks<I like Lego House and I like chocolate.> <so obviously simple logic proves a chocolate Lego house must be double yummy!> “#*#unFos host yer now my top read from beginning to the very end!.” Thinks so if what you say is true... in this game Roles... then {Rechecks PM.} “#*#unFos me I know know 100% what I am. Now you will too.” A valid Association case first post day 1 !rulez. end Lolcat popcorn mode off. I believe yamato and Oats were asked a question? I have not yet heard an actual answer | ||
|
Rad
United States935 Posts
Now on to CC's questions... =P 1. I've played 2 games of mafia, NMM XXVIII and XXX, town in both. First was vig, second vt. I obs'd a good amount of chrono until it became overwhelming (think I got 140 pages in then my head exploded) and all of last NMM, and some of paranoid. Played a lot of sc2mafia the past week or two which probably translates to shit for TL mafia skills, but we'll see. 2. No idea cheese, I feel like that scenario would have to be played out however it should be at the time. I can't see myself leaning one way or the other 100% of the time =/ Probably lean towards lurker lynch I guess? minor-moderate is going to be pretty subjective... 3. Green. I'll let you figure out why (spoiler: it's cause I'm a genius). | ||
yamato77
11589 Posts
I think we can at least pressure lurkers with the policy lynch into posting more so that it makes more difficult for scum to hide. | ||
|
Rad
United States935 Posts
On December 04 2012 10:26 Arnarnion wrote: Alright 1) I haven't played a game yet, but I did obs XXXII 2) I am of the opinion that lynches should be saved for top scum reads and that removing inactive players might not be as productive for town as it is for scum, since were just doing their work for them. 3)(Oats)- Don't give me none of that pie or cheesecake, the only true dessert is ice cream. (CC)- Green. Regarding #2, what about scum who lurk? I think that's the point of it. Obviously if we knew all lurkers were town we'd never want to lynch them over a semi-scummy player. | ||
|
sour_eraser
Canada932 Posts
2. I would lynch a lurker but not on D1 because lack of information. Other days, Yes I am in favor more so than minor scumbead. Someone not contributing, or contributing very little has no value to the town IMO. But then... I have no experience in this field I might be wrong :o 3. Black / I don't like pie and cheesecake | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On December 04 2012 10:29 AxleGreaser wrote: pocorn mode on lolcat <= a C&C warning // mafia {on cue}{Enters stage right}{runs into the spotlight} {leaps in the air and pirouettes} {lands delicately on one foot, falls flat on face} {rolls around on floor like a beached whale} {struggles in an ungainly manner to feet} {spins around , fingers spread wide} “#*#Fos everyone in the Room, yer all scum!” {pauses, gears turn, looks carefully at fingers, notices a spare one, looks skyward} “#*#Fos the host too, yer all scum, until evidence of intention proves otherwise!” Thinks<I like Lego House and I like chocolate.> <so obviously simple logic proves a chocolate Lego house must be double yummy!> “#*#unFos host yer now my top read from beginning to the very end!.” Thinks so if what you say is true... in this game Roles... then {Rechecks PM.} “#*#unFos me I know know 100% what I am. Now you will too.” A valid Association case first post day 1 !rulez. end Lolcat popcorn mode off. I believe yamato and Oats were asked a question? I have not yet heard an actual answer You were asked plenty of questions but you responded to none. I gave my answer to the lurker lynch idea in the thread quite explicitly. | ||
|
AxleGreaser
Australia1154 Posts
| ||
|
Mr. Cheesecake
United States3756 Posts
Also, Axle, opinion on lurker lynching over a moderate scumread - GO. | ||
|
Arnarnion
Canada39 Posts
| ||
|
Kickstart
United States1941 Posts
This will be my third game, my first game was Mario Mini Mafia where we won as town, my second game was Newbie Mini Mafia XXXI where I lost as scum. On lurker lynch policy I am of the opinion you lynch top scum reads, that is the goal of the game after all. If someone lurking seriously becomes an issue then they can be dealt with at the adequate time. | ||
|
AxleGreaser
Australia1154 Posts
Which I found instructive. I have not played any other mafia anywhere. Although last night i had dream and I think I once did talk about mafia 20 years ago but I dont really remember. | ||
|
AxleGreaser
Australia1154 Posts
> Also, Axle, opinion on lurker lynching over a moderate scumread - GO. The answer is in the story above. Everybody is intially suspicious until shown otherwise by evidence of intention. If i was hunting scum and i am I could answer promptly. cont in next post | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
Axle - why are you avoiding talking about lurker lynches? | ||
|
AxleGreaser
Australia1154 Posts
yes i was asked many questions some of them repeats. Some of them no longer important if someone is finding it hard to say how they feel on the lurker lynch question. Thats why I sat there hanging in the silence waiting to post. | ||
|
Kickstart
United States1941 Posts
| ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
| ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On December 04 2012 10:49 Kickstart wrote: That depends entirely on how much the person is lurking and many other factors. Point is enacting a lurker lynch is silly because if everyone says "Ok we will lynch lurkers" then why would mafia lurk? Trick question - they wouldn't. The goal is to find scum - anyone putting any other objective above this is suspect to me. That's WIFOM and a bad argument. Also, even if you are correct in your conclusion that mafia wouldn't lurk, it is actually good for town because that gives them more chances to distinguish themselves from the average townie. | ||
|
Kickstart
United States1941 Posts
| ||
| ||
