Sexual Harassment In the Dota Scene - Page 11
| Forum Index > Dota 2 General |
We understand that this topic evokes strong feelings. In the interest of maintaining a necessary and productive discussion, we will be taking a strong stance against posters that clearly do not contribute to this aim. Dishonest and bad faith arguments, victim blaming, and attacks on other users, will be strictly moderated. A post which only serves to muddy the waters and dishonestly portray the nature of assault and harassment (and corresponding accusations) is also unwelcome. This is a serious topic. Please treat it as such. If you have feedback on how we should approach this topic on LiquidDota, please see here. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
| ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2854 Posts
On June 27 2020 10:44 Dracolich70 wrote: Somehow I am not surprised you don't. Oof, care to elaborate? | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 10:45 Fleetfeet wrote: Because you need serious memory loss, if you can't remember something as significant as giving your friend legal advice. And if you had such a severe memory loss, you would with the same certainty say you didn't as he did with "and I have not been paying his legal fees.".I genuinely don't see it as a red flag. Oof, care to elaborate? | ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2854 Posts
On June 27 2020 10:50 Dracolich70 wrote: Because you need serious memory loss, if you can't remember something as significant as giving your friend legal advice. And if you had such a severe memory loss, you would with the same certainty say you didn't as he did with "and I have not been paying his legal fees.". How is "I cannot recall ever offering Grant legal advice" at all ambiguous? Is your argument that he's allowing himself that tiny window where someone can now post a message of him giving grant legal advice and he can go "oh yeah haha I forgot about that"? Doesn't believing that require already believing that LD is a bad actor, in which case it doesn't matter what the fuck his statement is, it's going to taste sour to you? | ||
|
Firebolt145
Lalalaland34510 Posts
I am trying to keep an open mind based on what I have observed so far. If in the future more evidence is released that LD and others lied, or maliciously held back information, then I will change my opinion of him. However you have clearly decided they are so severely in the wrong to the point that you appear automatically biased against his comments. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 10:57 Fleetfeet wrote: Either you did or you didn't. Convenient memory loss is only not a huge red flag for people that are willfully blind. This is not rocket science.How is "I cannot recall ever offering Grant legal advice" at all ambiguous? Is your argument that he's allowing himself that tiny window where someone can now post a message of him giving grant legal advice and he can go "oh yeah haha I forgot about that". Doesn't believing that require already believing that LD is a bad actor, in which case it doesn't matter what the fuck his statement is, it's going to taste sour to you? | ||
|
Firebolt145
Lalalaland34510 Posts
edit: It's fine for others to chip in with their opinions, I just mean that I'll withdraw from this specific discussion for now. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 10:57 Firebolt145 wrote: Then you would not shield yourself behind a "Recall", but you suggested him to talk to a lawyer or I didn't give him any legal advice. The same person states with certainty in the same instance that he didn't pay for his legal fees.I disagree. Legal advice could be as simple as, 'talk to your lawyer', and there is no way anyone could confidently say they never discussed something like that from 5 years ago or whenever it was. If we assume an honest statement (which I have no reason not to) then 'I do not recall' suggests to me that there was never serious in depth discussion, which is the point he is trying to make. On the other hand, spending money on legal fees would be much more concrete in the mind. I am trying to keep an open mind based on what I have observed so far. If in the future more evidence is released that LD and others lied, or maliciously held back information, then I will change my opinion of him. However you have clearly decided they are so severely in the wrong to the point that you appear automatically biased against his comments. I do not recall is a well known shield against being called a liar, if reports come out that he did. Something you do with a purpose. | ||
|
Firebolt145
Lalalaland34510 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:05 Dracolich70 wrote: Then you would not shield yourself behind a "Recall", but you suggested him to talk to a lawyer or I didn't give him any legal advice. The same person states with certainty in the same instance that he didn't pay for his legal fees. I do not recall is a well known shield against being called a liar, if reports come out that he did. Something you do with a purpose. I've heard 'I do not recall' being used by politicians and I felt the same way you did then as you appear to feel now. I do not view LD in the same negative light that I see politicians. | ||
|
juuto
809 Posts
On June 27 2020 10:35 Fleetfeet wrote: Except it's consistent with mistakenly believing in a redemption arc given that grant, like many others from HON days or early dota, was a total piece of shit that grew up. Apparently Grant didn't grow up. LD admitted that he should have actually verified that Grant was no longer a piece of shit and failed by not looking it into it further. I get that you have a hatred for BTS. I, too, am waiting on some -actual- action from them moving forward where they implement meaningful change. That said, I don't think you get to ubiquitously declare it a blatant lie when the thing you're contesting is LD saying "I had no idea Grant sexually assaulted / harassed anyone" and your response is LIE, -link to GodZ responding in a thread where Grant was being an awful human (racist, not sexist or sexually harassing anyone) 6 years ago- Forgive me, but that's not evidence that LD was lying. You wanna say he lied? I'm listening, show me. At what point in his statement does he acknowledge the racism? At what point does he acknowledge the multiple women he harassed before on Twitch while making it to the front page of Reddit every single time? What I Knew I want to start by sharing what I personally knew prior to the disclosures of the last few days. Until a few days ago, I had no idea that Grant Harris had ever been accused of sexually/physically assaulting anyone. The extent of what I knew about Grant’s past before we hired him was that he sometimes got too drunk at events and on his stream back in 2012-2014. I had interacted with him while he was intoxicated and occasionally loud/belligerent at those events (including the International 2012), but I never saw or heard of him sexually/physically assaulting anyone. I had heard that Llama had sued Grant, but until a few days ago, I was under the impression that the case had been dismissed. I have never seen any of the court records and do not know any of the specifics. Lying by omission is still lying. How is it not significant enough to mention that they did much more than knowingly hire a guy who was sometimes drunk on stream? He was a misogynist, he was a racist, an antisemite, and a total bigot in general. To say that Grant was just a guy who "sometimes got too drunk at events" is a lie. They hired a well known bigot and decided to prioritize him over his victims. They knew his past, they knew what an awful person he was, Llama even directly came to them concerned about her safety, and yet they're acting as if they hired a guy who just got too drunk sometimes. At no point did they ask themselves: Maybe they shouldn't have rehabilitated the image of a well known scumbag. Maybe they should've thought about the Llama situation again and figure out if they were on the right side of it. Nope. It had to get to a point where the choice was taken out of their hands before they distanced themselves from him. To boil down my issues with them into "hatred" for BTS is so insulting. A company that engages in frequent homophobia (as evidenced by Zyori's video), hires a well known racist, and doesn't take a woman's harassment claim seriously did it because they were bigots who didn't care about the safety of anybody else besides themselves. How am I supposed to believe a company like this just happened to make an honest mistake on Llama's harassment by Grant? Just last year, their response to criticisms of the sexist humor at the Summit were also met with a dismissive response. Yet I'm supposed to believe BTS were full of girl power warriors who just made an honest mistake in their quest of achieving ultimate feminism. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:05 Firebolt145 wrote: Yeah, it seems that way. I can't make the blind see, if they want to be blind or are inherently blind.It is clear we disagree on this matter and it is unlikely we'll ever persuade each other differently. Let's move on. edit: It's fine for others to chip in with their opinions, I just mean that I'll withdraw from this specific discussion for now. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:07 Firebolt145 wrote: It is also a well known legal advice. Whether you believe it is a red flag or not, or even if LD is genuine in suffering from convenient memory loss, you can't disregard that this is a moment of great fragility of BTS and LD.I've heard 'I do not recall' being used by politicians and I felt the same way you did then as you appear to feel now. I do not view LD in the same negative light that I see politicians. | ||
|
Firebolt145
Lalalaland34510 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:07 Dracolich70 wrote: Yeah, it seems that way. I can't make the blind see, if they want to be blind or are inherently blind. It is not respectable of you to repeatedly try to insert the occasional personal attack. I don't want to derail this thread further. | ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2854 Posts
Not paying legal fees, on the other hand, would be pretty easy for him to refute with evidence. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:09 Firebolt145 wrote: Then why do you butt in once again by the same argument as in the other thread? It is quite clear you refuse to see, because you don't want to. Outside that you do admit it is something you associate with politicians.It is not respectable of you to repeatedly try to insert the occasional personal attack. I don't want to derail this thread further. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:12 Fleetfeet wrote: It would be pretty imperative, that if he with certainty can relieve himself of suspicion he would do so, aka, "I didn't give him any legal advice". Then there would be no red flag of bullshit. Of course it would be more damaging than saying, "I can't recall I did", if the truth came out, that he actually did. So he chose the lesser evil at this point, which is quite telling. His post also has 3 different uses of "Not that I recall", or "Not to my recollection".Or maybe it's a time where accusations are being flung around and LD understands that openly refuting them without evidence isn't well-received or appropriate, so he allowed space for himself to be contested out of respect, not out of malice. Not paying legal fees, on the other hand, would be pretty easy for him to refute with evidence. Not giving any legal advice would also be easy for him to refute. Either he did or he didn't. "I am not entirely sure if I did", is a huge red flag. It is something as significant as whether you gave legal advice to a friend under serious charges, not whether he gave a grocery list on a specific day. | ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2854 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:07 juuto wrote: At what point in his statement does he acknowledge the racism? At what point does he acknowledge the multiple women he harassed before on Twitch while making it to the front page of Reddit every single time? Lying by omission is still lying. How is it not significant enough to mention that they did much more than knowingly hire a guy who was sometimes drunk on stream? He was a misogynist, he was a racist, an antisemite, and a total bigot in general. To say that Grant was just a guy who "sometimes got too drunk at events" is a lie. They hired a well known bigot and decided to prioritize him over his victims. They knew his past, they knew what an awful person he was, Llama even directly came to them concerned about her safety, and yet they're acting as if they hired a guy who just got too drunk sometimes. At no point did they ask themselves: Maybe they shouldn't have rehabilitated the image of a well known scumbag. Maybe they should've thought about the Llama situation again and figure out if they were on the right side of it. Nope. It had to get to a point where the choice was taken out of their hands before they distanced themselves from him. To boil down my issues with them into "hatred" for BTS is so insulting. A company that engages in frequent homophobia (as evidenced by Zyori's video), hires a well known racist, and doesn't take a woman's harassment claim seriously did it because they were bigots who didn't care about the safety of anybody else besides themselves. How am I supposed to believe a company like this just happened to make an honest mistake on Llama's harassment by Grant? Just last year, their response to criticisms of the sexist humor at the Summit were also met with a dismissive response. Yet I'm supposed to believe BTS were full of girl power warriors who just made an honest mistake in their quest of achieving ultimate feminism. Genuinely, thank you. Things like this help me understand. I disagree with you on your perspective of BTS regarding frequent homophobia (I believe I explain sufficiently how this ties in to toxic masculinity and not inherent flaws of character, though it does not acquit them of possible homophobia. Zyori himself admits he played along with the gay jokes and 'bro culture' - why can't it be true that everyone was doing it?) and some other points you address, but I -think- I get where you're coming from. I know I probably gave some troll red flags somewhere along the way, but I hope you know I'm listening and trying to understand as hard as I possibly can. On June 27 2020 11:17 Dracolich70 wrote: It would be pretty imperative, that if he with certainty can relieve himself of suspicion he would do so, aka, "I didn't give him any legal advice". Then there would be no red flag of bullshit. Of course it would be more damaging than saying, "I can't recall I did", if the truth came out, that he actually did. So he chose the lesser evil at this point, which is quite telling. His post also has 3 different uses of "Not that I recall", or "Not to my recollection". Not giving any legal advice would also be easy for him to refute. Either he did or he didn't. "I am not entirely sure if I did", is a huge red flag. I still disagree that it is a red flag, and believe it requires entering LD's statement expecting him to be a bad actor. I'm not there, yet. | ||
|
Firebolt145
Lalalaland34510 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:13 Dracolich70 wrote: Then why do you butt in once again by the same argument as in the other thread? It is quite clear you refuse to see, because you don't want to. Outside that you do admit it is something you associate with politicians. The three threads are similar and so I forget which is which. I associate it with politicians and see it negatively as such because of other negative things politicians do. I don't see LD the same way I see politicians yet. If it changes in the future then so be it. | ||
|
Dracolich70
Denmark3820 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:28 Firebolt145 wrote: Well, when you are dealing with PR any legal advice or expert advice would be similar, for the very same reasons. It is as said also a well known legal advice for similar reasons.The three threads are similar and so I forget which is which. I associate it with politicians and see it negatively as such because of other negative things politicians do. I don't see LD the same way I see politicians yet. If it changes in the future then so be it. As said, even if you don't see a red flag I am sure you see that it would be pretty damning in times of "Let's protect the survivors, this is their story not ours!", if he actually protected his friend as far as giving legal advice against a woman that was sexually harassed and reported death threats. | ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2854 Posts
On June 27 2020 11:34 Dracolich70 wrote: Well, when you are dealing with PR any legal advice or expert advice would be similar, for the very same reasons. It is as said also a well known legal advice for similar reasons. As said, even if you don't see a red flag I am sure you see that it would be pretty damning in times of "Let's protect the survivors, this is their story not ours!", if he actually protected his friend as far as giving legal advice against a woman that was sexually harassed and reported death threats. LLama was harassed out of the scene, afaik not sexually, and the death threats were hers, not his? Am I getting it wrong? (E : Llama is harassment, not sexual harassment, and I can't find mention of death threats.) If LD gave legal advice to grant it would have been about dealing with the civil case Llama raised against Grant based on his harassment of her. Not sexual harassment? Trying to keep the narrative straight. | ||
| ||
