EPTWho Is Who ICCup Season I - Page 12
| Forum Index > Closed |
|
CapO
United States1615 Posts
| ||
NonY
8748 Posts
| ||
|
CapO
United States1615 Posts
On June 30 2007 09:41 NonY[rC] wrote: judging from the gameplay of the replay posted, i'd say it's not NaDa. but if he was just being really lazy or drunk or something, it could be him. his apm was a bit lower than normal too i'm not sure about the gameplay, but i think SindongWook's apm could be NaDa's. here's the rep of NaDa vs Draco match 2, in which NaDa has 335 apm in the 14 min long game, and in the game vs TL_typeS, NaDa has 327 apm in the 27 min long game. http://download.yousendit.com/C2335C0D2A3817DD | ||
|
FirstBorn
Romania3955 Posts
| ||
|
CapO
United States1615 Posts
On June 30 2007 09:56 FirstBorn wrote: There's a lot of 400 apm korean amateurs and semi-pros. His apm proves nothing. when NonY and i were talking about APM, we meant APM and Hotkeys.  | ||
|
Dionyseus
United States2068 Posts
As for building placement, check out the Nada vs Bisu first game from their match (May 19, 2007), played in Longinus. Nada starts out at 3 o'clock base just like the SinDongWook rep, notice how Nada places the buildings just like SinDongWook does. Everything, the supply depots, the barracks, the factory, exactly the same. SinDongWook = Nada | ||
|
Puosu
6985 Posts
On June 30 2007 09:55 CapO wrote: i'm not sure about the gameplay, but i think SindongWook's apm could be NaDa's. here's the rep of NaDa vs Draco match 2, in which NaDa has 335 apm in the 14 min long game, and in the game vs TL_typeS, NaDa has 327 apm in the 27 min long game. http://download.yousendit.com/C2335C0D2A3817DD I'm pretty sure NaDa has higher apm in such a short games, more like 400~ But if it is NaDa, he probably does not play too seriously, so the APM probably is not as much as in actual pro matches. | ||
|
CapO
United States1615 Posts
On June 30 2007 10:25 Puosu wrote: I'm pretty sure NaDa has higher apm in such a short games, more like 400~ But if it is NaDa, he probably does not play too seriously, so the APM probably is not as much as in actual pro matches. the game was from WWI, which means it was broadcasted on tv. the replay isn't fake | ||
|
MoNKeYSpanKeR
United States2869 Posts
As you can see TL_TypeS was banned for inspecific reasons | ||
|
CapO
United States1615 Posts
On June 30 2007 10:33 MoNKeYSpanKeR wrote: http://img519.imageshack.us/my.php?image=tltypeslw5.png As you can see TL_TypeS was banned for inspecific reasons half of server? i'd say it's a pretty good reason.  | ||
|
jimminy_kriket
Canada5501 Posts
 | ||
|
CapO
United States1615 Posts
On June 30 2007 10:39 jimminy_kriket wrote: Half of server what? I cant see the pic it says, "TL_typeS - clear and lock - half of server have complaints on it." | ||
|
CruiseR
Poland4014 Posts
i would be surprised if its really him, since he's got so many (for one of top players ever) losses o.o | ||
|
merz
Sweden2760 Posts
| ||
|
Dionyseus
United States2068 Posts
On June 30 2007 10:25 Puosu wrote: I'm pretty sure NaDa has higher apm in such a short games, more like 400~ But if it is NaDa, he probably does not play too seriously, so the APM probably is not as much as in actual pro matches. From the NaDa rep pack that I found somewhere in the forums here, NaDa's apm average is 318 based on 637 games which have an average length of 20 minutes. His APM ranges from a high of 559 (from a 15 minute game played in 2003 against starrbren), to a low of 158 (from a 38 minute game played in 2001 against Garimto). That rep pack has 26 of his games from his time on Gamei back in 2001, there his apm average was 263. It's interesting to note that even back in 2001 NaDa still used the same hotkey signature he has now. NaDa = SinDongWook | ||
|
Dionyseus
United States2068 Posts
Compare NaDa's building placement in that rep with SinDongWook's building placement in this rep: http://www.sendspace.com/file/kp90ji identical | ||
|
CapO
United States1615 Posts
| ||
IefNaij
Canada291 Posts
| ||
|
CruiseR
Poland4014 Posts
On June 30 2007 12:04 IefNaij wrote: I havent seen the replay but building placement proves nothing...Same with APM and similar hotkeys, they prove nothing, theres many koreans out there whose apm/hotkeying is similar to famous progamers -_- Some "detectives" like roMAD and MidiaN can discover the player looking only at the BWChart Hotkeys (assigning+ hotkey selection on). In fact, APM and micro/macro can be very similar, but this Hotkey Chart during all game is very characteristic for every player. | ||
|
eXigent.
Canada2419 Posts
| ||
| ||
