EPTTL Mafia LXX: Guardians of the Galaxy
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
| ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
| ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
nope just started a little ago. Eden seems townie which makes you seem towny On March 19 2015 08:25 Eden1892 wrote: In case there's any doubt, rsoultin is town. Mindmeld + godreads. You're welcome town Like this post is very similar to posts ive seen eden make as town havnt really seen him play scum (like once) idk if he gives townreads that easily. Even so it's a good read but idk how relevant this is at this stage haha. Is there anything i should look at right now? else im just going to keep going from where i am. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 19 2015 09:45 Alakaslam wrote: well that leaves me with only SL to ask SL SL is just wifom to me. He needs to die a few times as town and come around to knowledge of the game before I can really do much with him. I had a policy of lynching him. If no one is going for HF (really hard d1 with good reason, but I reiterate he is 80% Mafia in my eyes) I am not agianst SL lynch. So i really like this post. Basically what i think slam is saying which is what i think is that SL can say stupid things but it doesn't make him mafia. He obviously read the emoticon thing in horn and is just remembering wrong like he even thinks he was mafia in that game. This is similar to JOAT where he claimed to make all these reads in the thread that he actually hadn't. What does SL get out of this emoticon argument as in saying it wasn't a read eden made on rsoul or he wasn't in that game or w/e. The answer is nothing. If anything makes SL scum its that for the part of the game ive read he has done nothing but seemingly try to piss slam off plus have a random read on rsoul. On March 19 2015 09:05 Alakaslam wrote: Nothing to say; always resorts to derision. Always. Someone, tell me why I SCUMREAD HF, why HF SCUMREAD me, and te supporting points on each side. I don't think anyone voting me can without either sheeping HF or unvoting and reconsidering. I also like this from slam. Him and Hf are going at it and slam tries to bring other peoples opinions into it. Feels more townie because if he is town he doesn't have the fear of people analyzing his posts. Can't read slam for shit though so not putting much into this other than I wouldn't vote for him | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 19 2015 09:35 sicklucker wrote: So let me get this straight. You guys are calling me mafia for not remembering townie things people said in a game where i was mafia and not trying to find towns. Is this correct? Which is retarded because he was town in the game he was referring to so what is he not reading this thread? This doesn't even make him mafia though it just makes him sicklucker. Also i googled blanda upp. Not sure what I was expecting | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 19 2015 19:15 Holyflare wrote: at least we know this guy isn't reading the thread at all  im still catching up and i feel like shit leave me alone | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
| ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 19 2015 19:20 Holyflare wrote: no I wasn't kidding because you're just saying what everyone has already said I think it was different enough. I havn't seen anyone say that Sl's own self meta about not reading the thread as mafia is implicating him here. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
This lead me to the conclusion that Slam and HF are both town and mafia was going to just let that fight continue. But it could also just be a thing where early on peple don't want to interfere in stuff so they can get reads on people. I'm on pg 44 and catching up fast i slept for like 12 hours so feel elss shit should be around more today | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 20 2015 08:47 Trfel wrote: Eden and Breshke, let's talk about stuff that happened 40 pages ago together! XD I actually have a question for you. So you were talking with toad about his palmar scum read and you were basically along the lines of you don't really see it as palmar being scummy. I'd actually agree with toad that it is. So palmar reads toad as scum for reasons and cbf's explaining them so jsut spams kill toad. Toad gets lynched and is town. I know that you trefel are very self conscious when you are wrong even if your case is really good and you try to change things so you don't make the same mistakes. Why then do you think that palmar isn't doing that and seemingly ignores past mistakes. Obviously you arn't the same person but would you not think that it would cross palmars mind that oh I read toad as scum for doing this and he was town. Toad is doing these things again maybe this isn't a reason to call him scum. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 20 2015 09:03 sicklucker wrote: STFU HE HAS THE GREATEST READ ON ME OF ALL TIME ALL TIME huh? What is my great read on you? I havn't actually read this post from damdred but i can't blame him for reading me this way. I suck a lot more as mafia than I do as town and I've done nothing this game so therefore sucking. Also i just realized that suck was probably a autocorrect from scum but it is fairly appropriate and fitting haha. I think what damdred needs to consider is my D1 play and how hard i normally finnd it to like get a good footing especially when I miss a lot of the first 24 hours. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 20 2015 09:16 rsoultin wrote: lol >< bresh i'm here talk to me ^^ there was a post and damn me if i can remember where...toad actually posted it with his earlier entrance right beside the entrance this game, and frankly...it wasn't like omg he's scum but it oozed a little lol so i don't see a huge problem with palmar pinging him on that I think i know what you are talking about but i was more referring to the fact that i felt like a town palmar would be more cautious about pining toad about similar things and would not drop it totally but not make it a focus. I really like trfels response to me though. Why do you think SL is town reading me. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 19 2015 13:13 Eden1892 wrote: + Show Spoiler + ohhh, duh. lol. ya it seems pretty silly but i haven't actually watched it. i just wikipedia'd some references so i could make a funny miller fakeclaim. could be a fun movie to watch tho i guess soooo i kinda think slam is town now. thoughts? I don't understand why you say you wikipedia'd references when you most likely just read it from the OP | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 19 2015 16:40 ExO_ wrote: Read the filter of SL, and the case against him seemed very silly to me. It's a huge stretch to me that he got caught in a lie about emoticons, and the reason he lied was because he slipped as mafia in some way. Damdred/Rsoultin hopping onto that seemed poor to me. However Eden is who really stuck out to me from that whole ordeal. And his filter is huge. Normally largest filter = town, or at least that's my initial thought. But as I read through it, he's giving out town reads on a whim it seems like, a considerable number of them. And his scum reads seem like just throwing shit out there to see what sticks. I didn't like what I see. But again, he is the largest poster and is at least to some degree driving discussion. Says damdred and rsoultin look poor but never goes back to them. Commits his entire postings to being about you even though he expressed doubts on damdred's and rsoultins alignment. Rso for one has been town read by a majority of people so if his opinion differs on this why not explain it to the group. This also reminds me of me as scum i get comfortable with a scum read and just constantly post questions and attack that person. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 20 2015 10:15 Eden1892 wrote: rso said so basically. And he DOES look like he's digging and trying early in his filter (mainly in those first 30 pgs I read). I would love it if the guy who was a dick to me earlier was mafia tho. It is hella weird that after going after me like he did, he just drops off the planet as soon as I give him some actual info. Maybe he is mafia. I am trying not to get tunneled on him though because he was hella fuckin rude earlier and it'd be easy for me to want to lynch him Yeah the stuff with trefel i get like i see the thought process there but from then on there is nothing at all i like. RSo care to comment why you then think exo is town? On March 20 2015 10:03 rsoultin wrote: lol it's SL who the hell knows...on the surface it just looks like he's happy that someone's on his side xP ironically though almost everyone has said what you said  Yeah exactly it doesn't make sense. In one of my few posts i even said that there WAS reasons to read him as scum. I don't understand why he would think im town enough to defend me. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 20 2015 10:40 Superbia wrote: Breshke what are you reads so far? Im only on pg 60 but im up to the point where i think iv'e read this stuff before but still need to filter specific people but i can give you a list that probably wont have a number of people and i wont be writing shitty one line reasons because they always feel fake to me so ask about certain ones if you need to. Town RSo Toad Eden (maybe down a tier) Tref Town lean Slam HF Damdred (could easily go up a tier) Scum lean Palmar Scum Exo SL Im missing like half the players here but will hopefully start reading filters soon. VE for example could easily go into town lean but i kinda want to read more into him but i liked the bit where he was going aaginst RSo about FF. | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
I don't like the him and toad interaction. Scum reading toad for something he has scum read him for before. Toad flipped town in the game where this happened before which seemingly doesn't phase palmar. If he was town i think he would reconsider his approach. I don't have much confidence with this though as i wasn't involved in that game and people who were and that I am also reading town (trefel) do not agree with me which gives me pause. See this post specifically. [QUOTE]On March 20 2015 09:09 Trfel wrote: [QUOTE]On March 20 2015 09:03 Breshke wrote: [QUOTE]On March 20 2015 08:47 Trfel wrote: Eden and Breshke, let's talk about stuff that happened 40 pages ago together! XD[/QUOTE] I actually have a question for you. So you were talking with toad about his palmar scum read and you were basically along the lines of you don't really see it as palmar being scummy. I'd actually agree with toad that it is. So palmar reads toad as scum for reasons and cbf's explaining them so jsut spams kill toad. Toad gets lynched and is town. I know that you trefel are very self conscious when you are wrong even if your case is really good and you try to change things so you don't make the same mistakes. Why then do you think that palmar isn't doing that and seemingly ignores past mistakes. Obviously you arn't the same person but would you not think that it would cross palmars mind that oh I read toad as scum for doing this and he was town. Toad is doing these things again maybe this isn't a reason to call him scum.[/QUOTE]I don't think that the argument between Palmar and Toadesstern says much about Palmar's alignment, but I do think it suggests that Toadesstern is town. As for it not making Palmar scum, Palmar's played really lazily for many games lately (Linux, Down Under 2, etc). Palmar also really likes to use tonereads. I can understand Palmar seeing Toadesstern's opening, and remembering it being different from the heavily formatted, fancy, and pristine opening that he used in Hammertime Mafia, and saying that Toadesstern is scum for it. I wouldn't actually expect Palmar to check Toadesstern's other games here (which clearly show that Toadesstern's opening post isn't alignment indicative). And if Palmar only knows Toadesstern's play in Hammertime Mafia and this game, his scumread of Toadesstern wasn't that horrible of a play (I would still disagree, but not that horrible). I guess the difference is probably that I have different expectations for Palmar than you and Toadesstern do.[/QUOTE | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
| ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
##Vote: Sicklucker Super do you still think damdred is scummy after his most recent explanation? | ||
|
Breshke
Australia3749 Posts
On March 20 2015 11:39 Superbia wrote: Damdred felt like he was hopping on. IIRC he said something like "I'd be okay with lynching Super today". That kind of weak jumpon is exactly something I would expect from mafia. Can't you look at it the same way like that mafia wouldn't jump on so weakly and would tend to over justify themselves instead of jsut being like ehh i can settle for this. | ||
| ||
