I'm glad that there is only one more of there WCS Championship type of events planned (Summer Champ) because this plain single elimination tournament is not a good way to award the biggest prizes in the foreign SC2 scene.

Single elimination is meant to find a single winner, and all placements below it are unclear. The winner might have knocked the 2nd best out in Ro32 but we never know. The same can also happen in any of the match-ups (2nd place defeats true 3rd in ro16, etc). So the prize money and WCS points below the winner are distributed rather randomly dictated by bracket-luck and seeding based largely on these very same random results. With enough events the randomness would even out but there are only three Championships in a year.

The single elimination has its pros too: it's fast, every match counts, the luck factor creates surprising results (or stories as the production calls them). But these benefits don't overweight the cons when it's the format of the most important event in the foreign scene.

Of course the most fair way would be a full round-robin (all vs all) but there is no time for that and it's very anti-hype and thus unfit for a show-type event. So let us use the GSL format (two double elim. groups followed by a single elim. bracket) which is superior in terms of defining the true placements of the competitors even though it also can suffer from bad seeding. Please?

Penev

28522 Posts

May 05 2016 10:32 GMT

#57

EnVyUs has this

Nerchio

Poland2633 Posts

May 05 2016 10:46 GMT

#58

On May 05 2016 19:28 Azhrak wrote:
I'm glad that there is only one more of there WCS Championship type of events planned (Summer Champ) because this plain single elimination tournament is not a good way to award the biggest prizes in the foreign SC2 scene.

Single elimination is meant to find a single winner, and all placements below it are unclear. The winner might have knocked the 2nd best out in Ro32 but we never know. The same can also happen in any of the match-ups (2nd place defeats true 3rd in ro16, etc). So the prize money and WCS points below the winner are distributed rather randomly dictated by bracket-luck and seeding based largely on these very same random results. With enough events the randomness would even out but there are only three Championships in a year.

The single elimination has its pros too: it's fast, every match counts, the luck factor creates surprising results (or stories as the production calls them). But these benefits don't overweight the cons when it's the format of the most important event in the foreign scene.

Of course the most fair way would be a full round-robin (all vs all) but there is no time for that and it's very anti-hype and thus unfit for a show-type event. So let us use the GSL format (two double elim. groups followed by a single elim. bracket) which is superior in terms of defining the true placements of the competitors even though it also can suffer from bad seeding. Please?

Please

rotta

5604 Posts

May 05 2016 11:07 GMT

#59

On May 05 2016 19:28 Azhrak wrote:
Single elimination is meant to find a single winner, and all placements below it are unclear. The winner might have knocked the 2nd best out in Ro32 but we never know

Yeah, Zest vs. Maru in Code A is no fun at all.

IArako

Germany195 Posts

May 05 2016 13:05 GMT

#60

i dont like the bracket either the seeding is kinda messed up

poor showtime in 2nd round vs snute i was hoping to see him go far he had quite a lot of bracket misfortune the last tourneys but if he beats snute he has a really good shot at the finals so we will see

overall i'd say top half >> lower half