Disallowed Bugs? - Page 2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Nokarot
United States1410 Posts
| ||
|
Ndugu
United States1078 Posts
On September 16 2010 08:07 gogogadgetflow wrote: That's just awesome. None of these bugs should be banned, I think - it's not as if they are being abused in competitive play. I think pros should abuse every bug in existence until Blizzard patches them. Too easy to arbitrarily decide something like 7% mineral boost is fine but Void Ray fazing no no no! (for example, if fazing still existed) | ||
|
SuperGnu
Sweden240 Posts
On September 16 2010 08:07 GGzerG wrote: wow, who ever said using burrowed NP or fungal is illegal? No one did but they should have rules in tournaments for stuff like this. | ||
|
Noam
Israel2209 Posts
I also believe the GSL disallowed the endless assimilator create/cancel on an enemy's geyser. | ||
|
Raelcun
United States3747 Posts
On September 16 2010 08:12 SuperGnu wrote: No one did but they should have rules for tournaments for stuff like this. Yeah most tournaments just have penalties for "abusing bugs" but don't list which ones so thats why I made this topic to get a more clear list of bugs that are out there so many people can be more specific with their disallowed Bugs list like there were in Brood War events. On September 16 2010 08:12 Noam wrote: Perhaps add parking a probe in the middle of a vespene geyser so it can only be killed with a ranged unit. I also believe the GSL disallowed the endless assimilator create/cancel on an enemy's geyser. The first one maybe, but the second one is kind of dumb just kill the probe that takes a good amount of skill to keep the worker alive long enough to do that plus wasting minerals. | ||
|
TelecoM
United States10896 Posts
| ||
|
Kikuichimonji
United States102 Posts
On September 16 2010 08:12 Noam wrote: How do you do that? >>Perhaps add parking a probe in the middle of a vespene geyser so it can only be killed with a ranged unit. | ||
|
Raelcun
United States3747 Posts
On September 16 2010 08:15 GGzerG wrote: burrowed NP / burrowed fungal is gosu, not abusing The skill required isn't the issue to me as an event organizer/commentator the main issue is doing something that removes a crucial mechanic. IE an scv building repairing needs to be vulnerable to attack it's a Terran mechanic removing that by building/repairing while inside of a structure cancels that issue. An infestor is supposed to be vulnerable while casting NP or Fungal being able to possibly get that off before detection is out is removing a key mechanic of the Infestor in that when it's unburrowed it gets the better spells but is more easily attackable. Good players could even queue i up so the infestor stops under other friendly units. Hence why I included it in the list. | ||
|
Sqq
Norway2023 Posts
| ||
|
Tennet
United States1458 Posts
| ||
|
TelecoM
United States10896 Posts
edit : burrowed NP and fungal are very hard to do, and should be allowed in games / I do it in alot of games, its a very good mechanic and makes infestors / NP alot more viable. Also in this very long thread that Zelniq made about using burrowed infestors http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=136181 , this makes all of zelniq's hard work go to shame saying that burrowed infestors should be a dissallowed bug, I strongly disagree with burrowed casting being a dissallowed bug. | ||
|
Ketara
United States15065 Posts
Just list everything that could be a bug, and allow the individual event organizers to pick and choose. What you don't want to happen is for an event organizer to not know about something, and then it to get used in a game and cause drama. Like, I'd probably even put sock folding up there, even though sock folding is awesome. | ||
|
a_flayer
Netherlands2826 Posts
| ||
|
terranghost
United States980 Posts
On September 16 2010 08:06 Ketara wrote: I think there was a thread a while back saying that if a Viking on the ground gets lifted up by a Phoenix, it can change to flight mode while under the effects of the beam? Not 100% sure on that one, I may be making it up. Don't think so I remember seeing this happen to me and tried to switch it to air mode and it wouldn't let me. | ||
|
blitzkrieger
United States512 Posts
On September 16 2010 07:48 Ketara wrote: I think those are the big ones Realcun. I can only think of one other one: Using the pathing system to see if rocks that you don't have vision of are broken. There's also being able to see MULE and depot calldowns through fog of war, but I'm not sure how you would account for somebody not taking advantage of that. Wow that really should be patched tbh. Like have pathing be based on fog of war or special checks for rocks... Good to know though although I will have to keep myself from abusing it... sigh.. | ||
|
Squirrel
United States1102 Posts
And since it works the same way, the infester trick as well. | ||
|
SuperGnu
Sweden240 Posts
On September 16 2010 08:23 GGzerG wrote: The infestor is not supposed to be vulnerable while casting , why would this be necessary? edit : burrowed NP and fungal are very hard to do, and should be allowed in games / I do it in alot of games, its a very good mechanic and makes infestors / NP alot more viable. Also in this very long thread that Zelniq made about using burrowed infestors http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=136181 , this makes all of zelniq's hard work go to shame saying that burrowed infestors should be a dissallowed bug, I strongly disagree with burrowed casting being a dissallowed bug. If i manage to maky my PF to fly it would be okey as long as i have dedicated a lot of time and written a post with pictures to make it possible for me and everyone else? No just no. | ||
|
QuothTheRaven
United States5524 Posts
With Starcraft 2, if there's ever any seriously abusable bug/exploit, it'll get patched very quickly. There's no need to put extra strain on tournament admins and organizers. That being said if there IS an absolutely game-breaking bug, it'd make sense to ban it for the few days between bug discovery and the inevitable patch hotfix. But I'd only do this for something universally recognize as unfair and destructive to competitive play. | ||
|
Anther
United States87 Posts
It's really silly to enforce a bunch of rules for the sake of enforcing rules, especially if suggesting things that aren't broken, such as burrowed infestor casting. | ||
|
Aquafresh
United States824 Posts
On September 16 2010 07:43 iCCup.Raelcun wrote: [*]Intentionally casting fungal growth or neural parasite with a burrowed Infestor (it's possible but extremely rare to do this on accident) When banning a bug or technique from competitive play you should avoid dealing with that word. As soon as you have people judging intent, you have a subjective unenforceable nightmare to deal with. Building a bunker from within a bunker is pretty much impossible to do accidentally, and immediately obvious to a referee. The burrowed infestor tricks can happen accidentally, therefore if you wish to ban it from play you have to judge intent. I'm not saying any of these are worth banning, just saying that you should avoid situations where tourney admins have to make potential disqualification decisions based on what they think a players intentions were. | ||
| ||