|
I remember one thing that BW had in common was every major website had a list of bugs that were not allowed to use in tournaments or leagues and I haven't really been able to find a similar list anywhere on SC2. I realize there are still less bugs at this point that are super abuseable but I can think of a few off the top of my head. So the question is maybe we can consolidate a list of the abusive bugs so that tournament admins can have a more concrete reason to remove someone from abusing these bugs?
What I can think of so far:
- Building a bunker/barracks from inside a bunker
- Repairing from inside a bunker or medivac (I thought this was fixed but I swore I saw someone do this the other day
- Intentionally casting fungal growth or neural parasite with a burrowed Infestor (it's possible but extremely rare to do this on accident)
What else can you guys think of to add to this list because I'm drawing a blank when I feel like there are more.
|
I think those are the big ones Realcun. I can only think of one other one:
Using the pathing system to see if rocks that you don't have vision of are broken.
There's also being able to see MULE and depot calldowns through fog of war, but I'm not sure how you would account for somebody not taking advantage of that.
|
On September 16 2010 07:48 Ketara wrote: I think those are the big ones Realcun. I can only think of one other one:
Using the pathing system to see if rocks that you don't have vision of are broken.
There's also being able to see MULE and depot calldowns through fog of war, but I'm not sure how you would account for somebody not taking advantage of that.
That one is a bit difficult, because it can often be done by accident (I'd admit, it saved me one game by accident.), and its not easy to tell if it's intentional.
|
On September 16 2010 07:48 Ketara wrote: Using the pathing system to see if rocks that you don't have vision of are broken.
I've accidentally used this bug many time before, my units will just randomly wander off in what seems like the wrong direction, and I immediately realize, "oh, he took the rocks down." I'm not sure how you could ban something that happens accidentally like this.
|
That one's really tough too because you can set it up where it looks like it could be an accident when it really isn't as well. Probably best to stay away from that one being disallowed as it would just cause a bit shitstorm every time it came up. I still feel like I'm missing a big one which is why I posted... I just can't remember what it is.
On September 16 2010 07:52 Authweight wrote:Show nested quote +On September 16 2010 07:48 Ketara wrote: Using the pathing system to see if rocks that you don't have vision of are broken.
I've accidentally used this bug many time before, my units will just randomly wander off in what seems like the wrong direction, and I immediately realize, "oh, he took the rocks down." I'm not sure how you could ban something that happens accidentally like this.
That is true too sometimes it takes players a little while to realize why their unit is doing this so that it often becomes unintentional too hard to prove they did it on purpose
|
Why would you want to ban any of those "bugs?" Just because they're bugs? I can't think of a single game where someone has won on behalf of those bugs, but you're a caster so perhaps you have?
- Building a bunker/rax from inside a bunker -- I don't see when this would ever be feasible. - Repairing from inside a bunker - if you can repair the bunker itself and this is indeed a bug (weren't you supposed to be able to use abilities from inside bunkers? I remember reading that but I play Zerg and haven't figured out how to do that) then this makes sense to ban I guess. - Underground fungal or np is just a flashy gimmick. You have to be unburrowed to begin with anyway, correct?
|
Wonder if they meant to make it possible for people to discover an observer while zooming in and out. I know its kinda hard to prevent this because zooming causes movement, but i think it should only be visible while the obs itself is moving.
|
Yeah, if I were running a tournament I'd steer clear of moderating that one.
You could add it to the list though just for lists-sake. Having a bug list in general is a good thing to have, might prevent redundant threads from cropping up. Well, no it wouldn't, but it'd let you complain about it!
Edit: The observer thing I think may be intentional. That's a tough one to call.
|
Not every bug is bad. Much like Starcraft 1, some bug add to the game. If Blizzard does not intend to patch it, I consider it as part of the game. I saw the thread discussing the Infestor trick a while back, and it sounded like quite a challenge to pull off. This also reminds me of the other thread that discussed the game 'gun and love' (I think?) where the gun slash movement bug became a defining move in the game.
I would be very sad to see all bugs banned.
|
about the repairing from inside a bunker: afaik, because the bunker gives additional range, the SCV inside the bunker gets a range of 1 on its repair, allowing it to repair buildings adjacent to the bunker. This could be used as a part of a wall-in to prepare for a counter push after a major battle.
|
On September 16 2010 07:43 iCCup.Raelcun wrote:I remember one thing that BW had in common was every major website had a list of bugs that were not allowed to use in tournaments or leagues and I haven't really been able to find a similar list anywhere on SC2. I realize there are still less bugs at this point that are super abuseable but I can think of a few off the top of my head. So the question is maybe we can consolidate a list of the abusive bugs so that tournament admins can have a more concrete reason to remove someone from abusing these bugs? What I can think of so far: - Building a bunker/barracks from inside a bunker
- Repairing from inside a bunker or medivac (I thought this was fixed but I swore I saw someone do this the other day
- Intentionally casting fungal growth or neural parasite with a burrowed Infestor (it's possible but extremely rare to do this on accident)
What else can you guys think of to add to this list because I'm drawing a blank when I feel like there are more.
Do you mean repairing a unit outside the bunker or medivac or do you mean repairing a unit insiide the bunker/medicac? If you mean the latter, it costs something like 7x the cost of the unit to repair inside a medivac or bunker. It is infact something that can lose you the game for you if you leave autorepair on and load a damaged tank and a scv.
|
On September 16 2010 07:54 NrG.NeverExpo wrote: Wonder if they meant to make it possible for people to discover an observer while zooming in and out. I know its kinda hard to prevent this because zooming causes movement, but i think it should only be visible while the obs itself is moving. Isn't the distortion there even when they're not moving? I play on Low and finding observers is so damn hard =[
|
I don't think any of these should be banned :/.
|
Yes, you can see the distortion if you zoom the camera in-out while the Observer is stationary.
I've seen Trump do this to snipe them on his stream before, it's pretty sick.
|
The only ones I think are really game breaking are the ones involving bunkers, because they can really swing things early on in the game, making bunker cheese maybe a bit too powerful.
But things like burrowed infesters is not a problem IMO. By the time they come out, you can have detection. So I feel like it just adds to the unit without making them horribly broken.
|
Lol. None of these are game breaking. It's like mutastacking in BW. It made mutalisks good. It wasn't like the CC slide or the flying templar... The repairing inside a medivac isn't a bug btw.
|
I think there was a thread a while back saying that if a Viking on the ground gets lifted up by a Phoenix, it can change to flight mode while under the effects of the beam?
Not 100% sure on that one, I may be making it up.
|
the NR + Burrow one takes some micro so I don't see the problem in this one at all. Its extremly risky and dangerous, so if you can pull that off (for example storm with a templar) you should be able to reap the rewards.
|
wow, who ever said using burrowed NP or fungal is illegal?
|
On September 16 2010 08:06 Ketara wrote: I think there was a thread a while back saying that if a Viking on the ground gets lifted up by a Phoenix, it can change to flight mode while under the effects of the beam?
Not 100% sure on that one, I may be making it up.
That's just awesome.
None of these bugs should be banned, I think - it's not as if they are being abused in competitive play.
|
|
|
|
|
|