[N]A Mostly Normal Game of Mafia - Page 5

On November 26 2020 04:57 Tictock wrote:


I was just wondering if you had a real "oh yea this is his mafia play" read on me or if it was a low-hanging fruit thing

On November 26 2020 05:52 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Elaborate please. Where does this come from?

On November 26 2020 06:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:

The problem i see here is that it should be quite clear why i decided to change my lynch preference, as i said so. After that you start thinking Hapa and Trfel are mafia, not TT anymore, who was btw one of the people who at least quickly jumped on Grack is mafia train.

Like i would be totally fine with your eod if you started yelling me "look this super scummy TT is gonna make you change the lynch!!" but no, that's not what you did. Even though TT technically at least possibly played a role in that.

Another thing is that you had no problem with me lynching FF while you didn't think he was the best lynch. Suddenly there was a big nono when i move to some other target that is STILL not your preferred lynch.

On November 26 2020 06:49 raynpelikoneet wrote:

No it would implicate you MORE. It still may make you mafia because mafia often times react in completely retarded ways on something they dont expect to happen.

On November 26 2020 07:35 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Let me ask you this Slam:

When i asked you about your scumreads on Hapa and Trfel, why did you decide to answer me before looking at the flip? I mean like, if Grack had flipped mafia you should have said "i am dumb fuck me" and that is a reasonable answer.

On November 26 2020 07:42 raynpelikoneet wrote:
right on what?

On November 26 2020 08:15 raynpelikoneet wrote:

So you think Hapa is town and not that Hapa and Trfel are mafia anymore?

On November 26 2020 08:17 Trfel wrote:
In other news, I'm starting to think less and less that raynpelikoneet is mafia. And I'm wondering more about Fecalfeast. Though I'm not sure if Fecalfeast would be quite this useless as mafia? Probably a terrible metric.

Not really confident at all on who else is mafia (regardless of if I am right or not on Jockmcplop), unfortunately.

Also, I won't be around for the deadline tomorrow, since it's a night deadline that should be fine though.

On November 26 2020 08:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:
you must be mafia because you drink decaf btw...

On November 26 2020 08:39 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Basically Grack flipping the worst fucking role for the town ever was just a coincidence. Also how can you be right and Hapa be right at the same time if you are both same alignment and thought completely opposite things?!?!?!?

On November 26 2020 09:58 raynpelikoneet wrote:
eh.. i dont think you understand my point

On November 26 2020 10:13 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am gonna try to explain before i go to bed.

My point is this:
Prior to Grackaroni's flip you seemed to think that Hapa and Trfel are mafia because they are sitting in a corner trying to push something. After Grackaroni flips you seem to have changed your opinion on that (at least) Hapa isn't mafia for that anymore. That doesn't make much sense to me because if we assume Hapa is mafia then he doesn't know if Grackaroni is town or 3p, he only knows that Grackaroni is not mafia. I dont understand why Grackaroni flipping NOT mafia would give any town credit to Hapa (or anyone else in itself)? Because it does not make any sense.

As to my original argument i still don't see any reason to change my view on that i think it is plausible you knew Grackaroni is not mafia before the flip. That's because of how you reacted to other people when i changed my lynch preference, and how you did NOT react to TT's posting at the time. It looks very bad to me tbh. Also coupled with the fact that -- where this argument went to -- you are simultaneously... idk like ... uhh.. trying to give Hapa credit for pointing out grack as not town and then also saying you were right on that grack was not mafia. It feels really weird for me, if you really think hapa can somehow discern 3p from town D1 then why should YOU be happy for being "right"? Shouldnt you be able to do that aswell if you were to get any credit?

It seems like you are treating one and only one -- same situation one way for one person and the other way for another person.

On November 26 2020 10:15 raynpelikoneet wrote:
In simple words, if you think hapa should have any credit for figuring out a 3p, why should you have any credit for not doing so? Right now you are saying both of you should, because grack was not town nor mafia lol..

On November 26 2020 10:26 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I know you didnt ask for credit, i just subtly read it as so, because of "i was not quite wrong".
In my world you saying "i was not quite wrong" and "hapa was right", one of the things is wrong. If you dont get why i think this, maybe someone who speaks better english and is smart can explain it in english...

Now i have to go to bed, so good night.

On November 26 2020 10:42 Fecalfeast wrote:
So how's everyone doing?

On November 26 2020 11:17 Tictock wrote:


Seems like he is just saying neither was totally wrong since he flipped neither town nor scum

To mafia Gracks flip would have been a nice bonus as they just thought they were getting a mislynch.

On November 26 2020 12:41 Trfel wrote:
Honestly a bit down IRL still, but recovering. If anyone wants to talk about anything I am happy to!