[M][N] A Simple Game of Mafia - Page 3

On December 15 2017 07:05 Kmatt wrote:
So we can't make any concrete rulings from a single night's scan. It's even possible that all three are green. This is gonna boil down to whether or not HF can produce anything to back up his own cop claim.

Still think we should lynch the three of you. If it turns out to be a triple green flip and Arya was the scum or something I'll eat my shoe.

On December 15 2017 07:40 Forumite wrote:
Palmar gets 3 checks, but none of them are reliable. He needs a second round of checks, preferably at the same people, and even then its not certain to give results. Your power is actually more reliable, although it takes an extra day to use.

On December 15 2017 08:42 Forumite wrote:
WIFOM but still:

Both confirmed scum had very few posts, but both talked a lot about Palmar, especially early game. Oats got on the early Palmar-wagon to which grack said scum might try to distance themselves from other scum. When Oats wagon got speed Grack stayed away and said Palmar was a better lynch, but that wagon had allready halted.

It might be nothing, WIFOM, maybe them being starstruck and focusing, and we should probably wait for Palmars N2 checks, but something I noticed rereading with focus on Oats+Grack.

On December 15 2017 09:22 Kmatt wrote:
I just checked myself, both Grack and Oats were openly taking shots at each other when they graced us with theit presence. Additionally, Palmar was one of the only other things they both talked about. It could still be that Palmar was their ideal first mislynch, but depending on how this roleclaim fiasco plays out it's quite possible Palmar was the third sum player and they decided to try playing super-insular as opposed to distancing themselves.

On December 07 2017 02:15 Damdred wrote:
Setup:

Closed setup, any number of roles can be present as long as they fall within criteria.

Hint: The criteria will be normal type roles that would generally be in normal games.

On December 15 2017 21:09 Forumite wrote:
I like how his case on me hasn't changed since D1.

His 3 checks could all be townies, so there's an out there if we lynch 3 times. I'm not 100% sure on HF though, but he looks much better than Palmar after this claim circus.

On December 16 2017 00:33 Holyflare wrote:
You weren't sure until now if you were multi shot vig so you claimed cop at night to bait out getting shot so you were clear instead of being the lynch?

*clap*

On December 16 2017 06:36 Forumite wrote:
Is there any truth to your pleas? They haven´t helped town any, just muddled up D2 and made sure that you are the lynch. It doesn´t even make sense from a town perspective, you claimed cop during the night, putting a huge target on yourself. That wouldn´t have been a problem if you were a 1-shot vig with the Roleblocker dead, except at the time you say you thought you had unlimited shots. If you thought you could just keep shooting then why paint a huge target on yourself by claiming DT? Also, you are usually so confident with your ability to find scum, so you would throw away that and your blue ability by claiming. Did you expect the WIFOM and confusion of claiming to confuse scum enough to shoot someone else? It makes more sense that you are scum and claimed blue because you wanted town-cred and were not afraid of getting shot during the night. Then after Grack flipped you became desperate or lost interest in the game and just went crazy with claiming several different roles.