|
On December 14 2017 01:53 prplhz wrote:Show nested quote +On December 14 2017 01:49 Kmatt wrote:
I was thinking between Palmar and Forumite one of them is scum. I think I can get behind Palmar at this point, Forumite being town makes a lot more sense to me. Did you just pick two random names and decide that one and only one is scum?
As I reread today I was scumreading both but it seems like a weird time for them to "pretend" to be at odds. That doesn't feel to me like two townies going at it. I'm going with my gut on this. Forumite may not be my favorite poster in the thread, but he's at least asking questions. Palmar durdled around without making any real reads (he made a few townreads earlier but made sure to tack on how "super weak" they were), then dumps his wall. Just seems very inorganic. Goes from zero to 99 to 100 on a guy.
|
On December 14 2017 02:13 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On December 14 2017 02:03 Kmatt wrote:On December 14 2017 01:53 prplhz wrote:On December 14 2017 01:49 Kmatt wrote:
I was thinking between Palmar and Forumite one of them is scum. I think I can get behind Palmar at this point, Forumite being town makes a lot more sense to me. Did you just pick two random names and decide that one and only one is scum? Forumite may not be my favorite poster in the thread, but he's at least asking questions. well now I know how to beat you as mafia.
The "at least" part was in comparison to you.
|
On December 14 2017 02:22 Arya321 wrote:
Also Kmatt can you please read Oat's filter for me and tell me what you think of him please?
None of his posts are individually bad, but there's nothing of value/interest in there either. He doesn't seem to have any reads or stances other than that Koshi and VE were playing "forced townie", not unlike what I said earlier. Other than that he's about as impactful on this game as any of the pseudo-afks (Grack, Oats, Ever). I'm still pretty new, so I don't know if that counts as scum play, but it definitely isn't town play. If he's our lynch today I wouldn't shed a tear.
|
On December 14 2017 02:30 Grackaroni wrote:
Oats' filter is pretty terrible. There's very little scumhunting direction and just a lot of sniping at other people's reads and calling other people bad.
That's what was keeping me from townreading him from the start, those "bad read" posts. Is it bad because it was reasoned poorly, bad because you see it as coming from scum, bad because it conflicts with your own well-reasoned read? The world may never know.
|
On December 14 2017 04:37 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2017 06:39 Grackaroni wrote:
This is going to sound pretty stupid but I could see teammates wanting to jump on scum Palmar as a distancing maneuver at the start of the day when there's little chance that votes would stay on him for the rest of the day. This is such a dumb post by grack. Literally means nothing and literally makes no conclusions
I don't think that was a conclusion, just a fairly obvious observation that, should Palmar flip scum, there's a good chance we'll find a partner on that early vote wagon.
|
I'm still waiting on a Pheonix Wright-esque dramatic turnaround from Oats.
|
On December 14 2017 05:26 Arya321 wrote:
Also when did Kmatt vote Oats? I know he said he wouldn't mind him dying but that was earlier.
Just recently, since I had to vote something or get modkilled
|
|
|
So Oats initially voted for Palmar, then jumped to Conversion at the end when it was apparent he was getting lynched. How many layers deep of WIFOM are we gonna go?
|
Kind of silly to claim that now. You're just asking to get shot before you can reveal anything.
|
On December 14 2017 07:11 Palmar wrote:
I claim cop.
100% hardclaim.
Real talk tho: why? The only winning scenario here is for Mafia to let you live, you scan and find another scum, and live to reveal+lynch that target.
|
That...actually kind of works unless mafia choose to shoot neither of you. Then we have to do a 50/50 lynch.
|
On December 14 2017 08:16 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On December 14 2017 08:10 Kmatt wrote:
That...actually kind of works unless mafia choose to shoot neither of you. Then we have to do a 50/50 lynch. ???
If someone other than you or Palmar get shot, then we still have to lynch the liar.
|
I claim VT, because that's apparently the cool thing to do now.
|
|
|
On December 14 2017 08:44 VisceraEyes wrote:
So tomorrow the lynch is between Koshi/Palmar/Holyflare. All doctors are on me and the cops are going to be left open for the mafia to kill because we have something better than the cop.
We have me.
I don't think we lynch Koshi either way unless there's yet another CC. As it stands either Koshi or the actual cop between HF/Palmar is getting shot. If/when the cop dies we lynch the other.
|
This game devolved into nonsense pretty quickly. At least I don't have to think too hard about tomorrow's votes.
|
I'm still keeping up but probably can't post much for the next 8hrs or so.
|
Hot dog! I figured Grack would be a default lynch by virtue of being so afk, but what a hit! At this point I think the safest course of action is to lynch Palmar. If he's red we win, and if he's really a cop then Forumite is on the chopping block. Only other option would be if he was a VT claiming for who knows what reason (I've seen this unfortunately). Or is it possible to have four scum players?
|
Also I'm betting Eversince was the Vig.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
