EPTLiquidmania Qualifier #3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
| ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
@iamperfectcion: Could you be more specific about no lynch - mafia holding the shot (ie: does it mean that mafia is forced to hit inmedialtely after a no lynch?) Thank you. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
| ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
| ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 20 2017 22:07 Damdred wrote: we are lnyching someone today no matter what I agree about lynching someone today, but I am not really sure it´s imperative. Can you please elaborate? On February 20 2017 22:15 Damdred wrote: So will we be friends this game rayn? Also I really dislike Molongo comment, it sort of pushes two anti-town sentiments (in this case) at the same time and both things he probably should know better than to do. And its not really commital at the same time, think its a bad post. First, my username is Malongo. Second, how is my proposal anti-town? While my post may not be commital (with wich I concur) I wonder what do you mean by "a bad post". Maybe you could enlight me with a good post full of content for a start. On February 20 2017 22:11 raynpelikoneet wrote: Ebwop: oh well, yes YOU would. But it doesnt make any sense to propose a random lynch where you exclude yourself. :p It makes all the sense to me actually :p. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 20 2017 23:57 Damdred wrote: Obviously the answer is probably not. That in no way is defensive? You just described someone answering a question. I am not overreacting or twisting your point, I never said Mal did overact in fact he hasn't been back in the thread since that post. LIke this is a non point totally I am actively reading, it`s just that it takes me more to make me readable to you guys. I have no offence if you want to ignore me, however I felt you stretched out the answer about the no lynching. Again, while I agree that it is desirable to lynch someone I think it`s not 100% imperative for day 1. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 20 2017 23:45 Damdred wrote: Oh you meant this one, i thought he was talking about elaborating on a different point. Meh, this is just softball stuff you lynch to get information and figure out why people are pushing what they are. Not lynching lets mafia pick off the strong towns without town getting information on who they scum read But the information we have day 1 is the weakest of all, if anything I am trying to get townie reads, not mafia reads. Maybe it could be smarter to lynch based activity wise instead? | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 00:25 sicklucker wrote: if I decide its more like a 50% chance. STATS I believe you. So, if it was your power to lynch someone today who dies? | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 00:23 Damdred wrote: Well genrally speaking yeah the info d1 is the weakest but the motives are interesting. Nothing is set in stone so you get to see how people react what they push what wagons they hop on. Its a great time to really start looking at motivations behind things, I think we lynch scum slightly higher percent than random lynches here so there is that to. Even on day 1 with 0 info (and assuming no claims whatsoever)? I feel perplexed and beg to differ. Not too sure because I reallly haven`t read all the last games and I am going with my gut here but I doubt 1/4 games lynch red day 1. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 00:31 sicklucker wrote: well the great thing about getting a high percentage is not randomly picking someone after I have read 10 posts and posted nothing but bullshit Yeah i get the point. But you fail to give an answer regardless of the %. Let me help you: IF I had the power to decide today`s lynch so far I would lynch ryan. Reason? well he appeared as active recently and Damdred had a soft town read on him and everything was pretty normal until he decided that he can just dissapear and make like the convo Damdred/Koshi never happened. Whatever, he just dodged any reference (I am inclined to believe Damdred and Koshi are both town btw) and came up with a post about you. So as light as it seems i`d be lynching ryan so far. Now you, what do you think so far? Who would you lynch? | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 01:36 Vivax wrote: Do you think the Koshi + Damdred has mafia in it ? Read my post bolded it for you. Or why would rayn be mafia for treating it as all town? Not really, we could be all townies I think we all thought the same at that time. Didn't really look to me like he abandoned something there, he just drew a conclusion you might not agree with. Oh yes he did. Look at his last post/next post. On February 20 2017 23:20 raynpelikoneet wrote: All the four of us can be town for now. On February 21 2017 00:41 raynpelikoneet wrote: I feel like sicklucker is tryharding wrong. Wich completely ignores anything in Koshis/Damdred argument (wich is very interesting as well). All that being said, you and Fecalfeast are completely ignoring my question (I originaly asked luckluster btw) wich is way more important than ryan`s behavior: IF you had the choice and the power who would you lynch? Forget about me trying to make a case about ryan and answer the question. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 02:51 Vivax wrote: Malongo I don't understand why it makes rayn of all people scummy when he doesn't keep posting around a conversation that most people think is town on town. What do you think a town rayn should do there, since you think he did it as mafia? Really? | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
M: hello V-F-S V-F-S: hi there M: look, I think an interesting way to start things going is if you answer Who would you lynch first f it was in your power? (insert here sicklucker quote about high %) V-F-S: but Malongo, there is not enough posts (and we want that %) M: Yes I know, but let`s work with what we have for now. As for me I would lynch ryan because he dodged some argument and whatnot. V-F-S: But Malongo, how can you possible think he is mafia. I don`t understand your reasoning. M: Hey I gave you my reason. I am not really making a case against ryan, I am answering the same question that I`d like you to answer, I am more interested in your answer, and I think the town will benefit greatly. V-F-S: But Malongo, how could ever pinpoint ryan as mafia, how should he act in the case he is not mafia. M: Would you answer the question please, moron? | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 03:30 Vivax wrote: I already gave you my early reads, but I don't see why I should say that I want to lynch one of them already. If at the end of the day they didn't change, then I will want to. You are totally blowing the rayn thing out of proportion as a reaction to being pressured, in my opinion. Except the fact that I am not blowing anything, in fact you could just answer the original question without trying to "pressure" back. Way to piss me of regardless. Next time say just say that you don`t want to answer. By the way I never wrote to lynch one of them necessarily. I made a simple hypothetical question that you seem to fail to understand. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 04:34 Vivax wrote: My original intention wasn't exactly to pressure you, just to ask why what you said made rayn mafia, but given the way you reacted, I got the feeling that you felt pressured. Is this rayn not chiming in more on Damdred + Koshi still as important as it looked like back then? It is for me, if it was my privilege to chose a lynch target. Even more considering he has failed to make anything out of the game so far. I don`t get your "totally normal" picture out of him. I mean rayn posted "All the four of us can be town for now." then Koshi proceded to take the eyes out of Damdred and his attitude, wich even garanted a lynch vote. Ryan proceded to make like nothing happens and kept the "all townies nothing else to post" posture. Then again this is not a game of individual choices, thats why my hypothetical question has no value if you don`t answer, while it retains at least the discussion active if you do. Last but not least I don`t really like the fact that you are making me look like I am tunneling to lynch ryan and called me blowing things out of a question that you refuse to answer yourself. Even more putting words on me "just to ask why what you said made rayn mafia" <- I never did. So what about you, do you think it`s imperative a lynch today like Damdred, and if so what is the best way to approach it? What about al the convo that Koshi had on Damdred, does it look to you that we are all for townies for now (Damd, Koshi, ryan and me)? @Koshi what`s the reason to vote Fecalfeast? I really don`t like his reasoning to vote you but why did you suddenly change your vote? | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 04:10 Fecalfeast wrote: Personally malingo i think asking people who they would lynch less than 24hours into day 1 when there are hardly any posts that can be considered alignment indicative is less constructive than questioning your reasoning for wanting to lynch rayn So proposing an hypothetical question that I agree to answer myself first and other players refuse to is less constructive than questioning my own answer to said question. Do you see the logic flaw here don`t you? Your answer was pretty terrible too, but not alignment indicative, sadly. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 01:20 Vivax wrote: Koshi + Damdred can be town for now. SL for some reason talks bad about himself and already seems to be on the defensive when he starts posting. Malongo feels very generic with his posts as Koshi pointed out, I don't think we need to talk about policy with this playerlist. These would be my early guesses, rest is still nullish. Hiiiiii rayn I failed to find the post were Koshi talked about me being generic. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 05:14 Vivax wrote: What am I refusing to answer Malongo? IF you had the power to lynch someone who would you? On February 21 2017 05:25 Fecalfeast wrote: I gave as serious an answer as I deemed appropriate, given that there's hardly.anything to base a hypothetical lynch on. Palmar MVP so far though But you agree that we are having a lynch an the same basis anyways? Why not to try to take it serious then? And leave Palmar alone is just a butterly. | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 06:03 Vivax wrote: You are obtuse cause you don't see that he tried to misrep me saying I refused to answer something when the answer was in my filter I still don`t see what your answer was. The only thing I get from you is "I posted my reads wah, wah". Whatever. On February 21 2017 05:56 Fecalfeast wrote: I require more content to produce meaningful reads on my own and nobody has made a compelling argument as to why someone should be lynched. For those reasons it seems silly at its foundation to discuss a hypothetical lynch, at least from my perpective. I will, however, ask you: have the posts since you chose rayn as your hypothetical lynch changed your mind at all? Do you think anything other than rayn's handling of a discussion is alignment indicative? But the only real way to produce real content when you have nothing to work is discussing a lynch or not? Not so silly then. I don`t know about ryan. He seems to be interested in lynching sicklucker now. At this point in the day we are starting to cast the votes so there is not much point in hypothetical questions. On February 21 2017 06:05 Fecalfeast wrote: Are you saying I'm not acute? You actually reminded me. Molongo why was I geouped up with vivax and sicklucker saying there aren't enough posts when i never said that until after? I just put you all together at that time because you didn`t answer anything and started questioning my own answer (except sicklucker who was the starting point). | ||
|
Malongo
Chile3479 Posts
On February 21 2017 12:29 sicklucker wrote: and to Malongo. I believe I already answered that q if you read between the lines. I said dandred was suspicious. Its just not that overly important or a reliable read so I didnt feel a need to spam it. and it certainly wont hold up through day 1 lynch on its own You never said that, you wrote "Damdred is too politically correct" or something in those lines, wich I read as "Damdred is a nerd". | ||
| ||
