Certainly not Oats (no role) or Hopeless (he talked a lot about seeing his action etc.). Or you (you were going to protect him after all). Or me or LSB. I guess Palmar/prplhz/gumshoe could be potential targets. Or then he just didn't RB anyone.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:44 GMT

#2424

Hmm, I guess gumshoe is the most likely option. If he became a Super-Vet-PGO with immunity to RB, then it would also explain the night actions. That's already stretching the limits of realism though.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:45 GMT

#2425

gumshoe, are you fifth-dimensional planar dragon? Are you?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:48 GMT

#2428

LSB, you didn't read the part where it was confirmed that you're essentially a vanilla at this point.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:48 GMT

#2429

"I'm going to assume that the mafia role PM tells you if you are "Goon, GF, or Roleblocker" and then you can select an additional ability off of that."

Was this straight from the ScumQT?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:52 GMT

#2432

Hmm, dunno why scum LSB would claim that gumshoe is town though. It's the only realistic other option for today :/

Who would you propose then LSB?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:53 GMT

#2435

On March 10 2014 07:52 Artanis[Xp] wrote:

Show nested quote +

Gumshoe getting +1 vest and a PGO ability would fit with the role of veteran and it's two defensive abilities, versus another offensive ability for palmar plus some ability for him to prevent a hit on gumshoe (why would he do that?), or him busdriving. Tell me, how does a busdriving assassin make any sense?!

This needs a Paint picture. Badly.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:56 GMT

#2437

Dunno. This game seems to hardly make any sense. I guess there's something huge we're missing... But I somehow can't picture how gumshoe could be scum with his Veteran role.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 22:59 GMT

#2440

On March 10 2014 07:56 LSB wrote:

Show nested quote +

Lynching prphz or Palmar.

[image blocked]

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:02 GMT

#2442

I doubt that prplhz or Palmar would suddenly gain a bus driver ability in addition to their KP. Pretty much the only role where it really makes sense is if it replaces one of the (for Mafia) useless JOAT powers.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:04 GMT

#2444

On March 10 2014 08:01 Artanis[Xp] wrote:

Show nested quote +

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:06 GMT

#2446

LSB, what do you think of lynching gumshoe?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:18 GMT

#2456

I'm trying to wrap my head around if this a good WIFOM plan by LSB or if he's simply town. There are several things that point to town:

1) Clear belief that I would return green if I checked him
2) Unwillingness to lynch the easiest possible mislynch
3) Wrong assumptions about how the Mafia roles would work

I have to admit that LSB is doing a good job of playing innocent if he's scum.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:22 GMT

#2459

On March 10 2014 08:18 LSB wrote:

Show nested quote +

So you assume three things for Gumshoe to be mafia.

1) Marv RBed Gumshoe - Most likely
2) Gumshoe has extra Lives / immune to night KP - on top of vet, really?
3) Gumshoe has a PGO ability that only targets the first person that visits him at night - Okay this is just getting silly

For anyone else to be mafia, they would need a bus drive ability. Just one assumption.

I do agree that this is a far-fetched theory. But it's also quite far-fetched that Palmar or prplhz would receive a bus driving ability on top of their already powerful KP roles.... And they're also otherwise towny. That would really just leave you.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:28 GMT

#2461

On March 10 2014 08:20 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
We lynch Gumshoe today.
Fin.

I'd say LSB deserves to live more than gumshoe for now in any case. Clearly gumshoe isn't going to bring anything new to the table, but at least LSB is doing stuff (and also appearing pretty towny in some ways). While I still think that LSB is the most likely to have a bus driving ability, we lose nothing by lynching gumshoe (and it's not impossible for the PGO theory to be true).

##Unvote
##Vote gumshoe

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:31 GMT

#2462

Btw didn't notice this before. Much reasoning, such ninja

On March 10 2014 03:56 gumshoe wrote:
##Vote:Lsb

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:32 GMT

#2466

You're conceding?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:33 GMT

#2467

On March 10 2014 08:32 Xatalos wrote:
You're conceding?

@gumshoe

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

March 09 2014 23:34 GMT

#2468

On March 10 2014 08:31 gumshoe wrote:
Alright, honestly I don't think much more could be expected of me this game XD god speed town, god save the jail keeper.

This just felt a LOT like scum giving up.