Carnival Cruise Mafia - Page 7

On May 18 2013 05:54 Blazinghand wrote:
for the record hiropro is a hideously bad lynch. he's not scum just a bad player. prplhz' is making this shit case against kush and opting out of the discussion and yall are just letting it slide for some reason. vote prplhz

On May 18 2013 07:15 Blazinghand wrote:


ok so there's two big things about prplhz, but only one that I consider seriously a thing I'm lynching him for.

First, and this is the important one, prplhz is pushing a lynch on kush that he MUST know is bad. he has stated repeatedly that he thinks kush is objectively scummy, but refuses to give a complete meta read on him. If presented with evidence that kush is ALWAYS objectively scummy, reasonably you'd back off, make a meta read, claim a red check, or state you want to lynch him for policy reasons. If you don't do any of these, you haven't actually demonstrated that kush is scum and not town. If you're not interested in doing any of these, then you are not interested in finding out if kush is scum or not.

Basically, prplhz wants to lynch kush. Why? Well, prplhz claims it's because he thinks kush is scummy, but it's completely clear that nothing kush is doing this game is scummier than normal kush play. Prplhz says "well, he's more self-focused this game!" but doesn't give the evidence to show this as a legitimate meta read. He doesn't even say he wants to policy lynch kush. Why is he voting kush? Because he doesn't want to take part in the serious discourse/wagons (OO, WoS, and for some reason VE and HiroPro) and by voting kush he looks like he's doing something.

It's completely clear what's going on here-- prplhz is opting out of the town discourse by voting kush.