|
On May 26 2014 08:33 Integra wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:32 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. " just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014." This is such weird logic. One person making a breakthrough in technology does not mean people have become smarter. It had to be allot of people, not just one. An entire industry had to be created in the first place in order to support such creation.
Nowhere near enough people that would make up for automating fields of work. It's a drop in the ocean. There is no logical way to support a theory that does not mean a increase in unemployment rates with the increasing populations, nor that people would get better education with increasing populations and decreasing resources.
I'll leave the last word to anyone else cause I need my beauty sleep. Nite!
|
On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going.
|
On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going.
So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable.
|
|
|
On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems.
|
On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Unless you want to be controlled by the machines
|
On May 26 2014 08:47 Otolia wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote: [quote] By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Unless you want to be controlled by the machines  SkyNet? Guess you don't need administrators then, or even humans, lol.
|
On May 26 2014 08:32 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:27 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 08:23 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 08:12 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. I don't believe in that at all. We had a high unemployment since 1980 - back them computers were worthless, the best computer we had were less efficient than the last iphone. It's true that technologies play a role, but saying it is computers that are responsible of the current unemployment is a gross exageration. On May 26 2014 07:59 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 07:33 Nyxisto wrote: @Acertos:
Yes, getting rid of the Euro may be the easier than reshaping the economy (towards more industry/better paying high-tech jobs), and better for the broad population than driving the wages down(which would be another, but admittedly asshole-ish way), but the problem with getting rid of the Euro would be :
chaos, because who the hell knows what will happen to the European economies if the Eurozone implodes, and more importantly a weaker currency would drive the living standard down as well. People are importing stuff for a reason. The overvalued currency that the Euro may be for France is also helpful on the consumer side of things. Having a weaker currency would mean that they're automatically more competitive but also more expensive imports and travelling.
Also for political reasons alone a breakup of the currency union would be really bad. Why should the European countries grow together if there's no reason?
I never said getting rid of the euro, I am the advocate of a devaluation of the euro and even if the majority of exchanges of European countries are made inside the EU it would still have a positive effect on exports of France, Italy and Spain. And even more, I think that the EU should be protectionist fortress the US feared it would be. A united EU is the biggest economy of the world and I believe that our market is indispensable so instead of suffering social dumping and fiscal dumping from other countries (which doesn't necessarily mean trashing the European fiscal paradises), imo we should and we could without economically bad sanctions, impose direct and indirect protectionist measures to countries like China with their cheap, low quality/safety, made by people working in horrible conditions products, or countries like the US with their standardized food (which is mostly unhealthy btw with GMOs and hormones), standardized films and music, or countries like South Arabia, that can do whatever they want just because they have oil or other natural resources. You see the power of Europe would be limitless if it was more united and nationalistic, if there was more coordination, our dependence on fossil energy would be greatly reduced, our geopolitical power would be 10 times what it is now, our economy could be even more self sustainable etc... It would not work tho. How do you devaluate the euro ? Some economists proposed that the BCE print euro and buy US debt treasure bond, it could work in the short time, but the fact is that the euro zone is too competitive, has a global excedent of its commercial balance, lower the exchange rate in that situation is really hard. The goal isn t a permanent devaluation or something of the sort but temporary mean to get Europe major economies that are the UK, France, Spain, Italy, Greece, back on track and to let them have more manoverability to reshape their economy. I'm no economist but devaluating the Euro will only have an effect on trade with countries that use other currencies. The fact that there's no option for devaluation for the countries within the EU is what WhiteDog is criticizing. You can't devaluate a currency against itself, that makes no sense. But the problem stays that you cannot put that many different economies in the same currency zone. You're gonna hate me for this, but why not some kind of Hartz reform for France? Cut the wages for 10 years and get the economy back on track during that time. Why not make the economies more similar instead of going back to different currencies? And why would Germany be the model for all the european economies ? In fact, Germany is the worst model in terms of growth : even with the euro (that clearly benefit Germany) its growth in the last 15 years is below France (not to mention its natural growth, something really important for the european's future, or even inequalities and poverty, exploding since the reform). Plus there are cultural matter that plays a lot in the grand picture, cultural matter that you cannot really change (saving rate, consumption habit, etc.). The only solution is the end of euro, a federal government, or some kind of taxation on commercial imbalance (with a redistribution from excedentary to deficitary states).
I don't think the 'German model' is optimal by any means. But although I personally don't like what has happened here over the last 10 years economically, at least it's somewhat working. Cultural habits aren't unchangeable I think, that's a really soft argument.
Social transfer Eurozone wide is something I wouldn't even be opposed against, but that's something you can't possibly sell to the average German/North European voter. And if we're already that far we could as well just make it the United states of Europe ; )
I think the EU has brought us all a great deal of mobility, cultural exchange and peace. I don't want to see this change and nationalism resurface, I think giving the currency up right now would completely wreck the EU.
|
On May 26 2014 08:46 Integra wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote: [quote] By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems.
Still doesnt make any sense. When we become more productive every guy working in those branches monitors machines that produce a big amount of goods.So when you have everybody working in that branche you have a even bigger number of goods. So then everyone buys 10computers 50cars and 50iphones?
If you increase the efficiency then you get more goods, goods that nobody can buy.
|
On May 26 2014 08:49 Sokrates wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:46 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:09 Zaros wrote: [quote]
ignoring the fact that new areas of work will be created and the scale of current work increased. The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems. Still doesnt make any sense. When we become more productive every guy working in those branches monitors machines that produce a big amount of goods.So when you have everybody working in that branche you have a even bigger number of goods. So then everyone buys 10computers 50cars and 50iphones? If you increase the efficiency then you get more goods, goods that nobody can buy. You do realize that IT is a service which covers allot more than just giving the retail industry the service of automating production. it has other functions as well, even in the production sector.
|
On May 26 2014 08:48 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 08:23 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 08:12 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. I don't believe in that at all. We had a high unemployment since 1980 - back them computers were worthless, the best computer we had were less efficient than the last iphone. It's true that technologies play a role, but saying it is computers that are responsible of the current unemployment is a gross exageration. On May 26 2014 07:59 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 07:33 Nyxisto wrote: @Acertos:
Yes, getting rid of the Euro may be the easier than reshaping the economy (towards more industry/better paying high-tech jobs), and better for the broad population than driving the wages down(which would be another, but admittedly asshole-ish way), but the problem with getting rid of the Euro would be :
chaos, because who the hell knows what will happen to the European economies if the Eurozone implodes, and more importantly a weaker currency would drive the living standard down as well. People are importing stuff for a reason. The overvalued currency that the Euro may be for France is also helpful on the consumer side of things. Having a weaker currency would mean that they're automatically more competitive but also more expensive imports and travelling.
Also for political reasons alone a breakup of the currency union would be really bad. Why should the European countries grow together if there's no reason?
I never said getting rid of the euro, I am the advocate of a devaluation of the euro and even if the majority of exchanges of European countries are made inside the EU it would still have a positive effect on exports of France, Italy and Spain. And even more, I think that the EU should be protectionist fortress the US feared it would be. A united EU is the biggest economy of the world and I believe that our market is indispensable so instead of suffering social dumping and fiscal dumping from other countries (which doesn't necessarily mean trashing the European fiscal paradises), imo we should and we could without economically bad sanctions, impose direct and indirect protectionist measures to countries like China with their cheap, low quality/safety, made by people working in horrible conditions products, or countries like the US with their standardized food (which is mostly unhealthy btw with GMOs and hormones), standardized films and music, or countries like South Arabia, that can do whatever they want just because they have oil or other natural resources. You see the power of Europe would be limitless if it was more united and nationalistic, if there was more coordination, our dependence on fossil energy would be greatly reduced, our geopolitical power would be 10 times what it is now, our economy could be even more self sustainable etc... It would not work tho. How do you devaluate the euro ? Some economists proposed that the BCE print euro and buy US debt treasure bond, it could work in the short time, but the fact is that the euro zone is too competitive, has a global excedent of its commercial balance, lower the exchange rate in that situation is really hard. The goal isn t a permanent devaluation or something of the sort but temporary mean to get Europe major economies that are the UK, France, Spain, Italy, Greece, back on track and to let them have more manoverability to reshape their economy. I'm no economist but devaluating the Euro will only have an effect on trade with countries that use other currencies. The fact that there's no option for devaluation for the countries within the EU is what WhiteDog is criticizing. You can't devaluate a currency against itself, that makes no sense. But the problem stays that you cannot put that many different economies in the same currency zone. You're gonna hate me for this, but why not some kind of Hartz reform for France? Cut the wages for 10 years and get the economy back on track during that time. Why not make the economies more similar instead of going back to different currencies? And why would Germany be the model for all the european economies ? In fact, Germany is the worst model in terms of growth : even with the euro (that clearly benefit Germany) its growth in the last 15 years is below France (not to mention its natural growth, something really important for the european's future, or even inequalities and poverty, exploding since the reform). Plus there are cultural matter that plays a lot in the grand picture, cultural matter that you cannot really change (saving rate, consumption habit, etc.). The only solution is the end of euro, a federal government, or some kind of taxation on commercial imbalance (with a redistribution from excedentary to deficitary states). I don't think the 'German model' is optimal by any means. But although I personally don't like what has happened here over the last 10 years economically, at least it's somewhat working. Cultural habits aren't unchangeable I think, that's a really soft argument. Social transfer Eurozone wide is something I wouldn't even be opposed against, but that's something you can't possibly sell to the average German/North European voter. And if we're already that far we could as well just make it the United states of Europe ; ) I think the EU has brought us all a great deal of mobility, cultural exchange and peace. I don't want to see this change and nationalism resurface, I think giving the currency up right now would completely wreck the EU. I don't believe the german model is working, even "somewhat". It is like a neomercantilist ideology, it is working for you, and only for you, and in the short run. It is not a strategy that you can globalize at the european level, and it is already responsible of our lack of growth and our inability to get out of the crisis. About the last part of your post, I personally feel european, and maybe we could push for a more political europe, with an european military or civic service for exemple, or more cultural interactions, a unification of education and school program, and things like that, but thinking the europe like a giant market and believing that the autoregulated market will bring us peace is a flawed plan imo.
|
On May 26 2014 08:58 Integra wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:49 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:46 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:11 nkr wrote: [quote]
The majority of new work created is for people who can afford an education. The unemployment figures aren't as much of an issue for these people to begin with. By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems. Still doesnt make any sense. When we become more productive every guy working in those branches monitors machines that produce a big amount of goods.So when you have everybody working in that branche you have a even bigger number of goods. So then everyone buys 10computers 50cars and 50iphones? If you increase the efficiency then you get more goods, goods that nobody can buy. You do realize that IT is a service which covers allot more than just giving the retail industry the service of automating production. it has other functions as well, even in the production sector.
Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones.
So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts.
|
On May 26 2014 08:58 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:48 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 08:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 08:23 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 08:12 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. I don't believe in that at all. We had a high unemployment since 1980 - back them computers were worthless, the best computer we had were less efficient than the last iphone. It's true that technologies play a role, but saying it is computers that are responsible of the current unemployment is a gross exageration. On May 26 2014 07:59 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 07:33 Nyxisto wrote: @Acertos:
Yes, getting rid of the Euro may be the easier than reshaping the economy (towards more industry/better paying high-tech jobs), and better for the broad population than driving the wages down(which would be another, but admittedly asshole-ish way), but the problem with getting rid of the Euro would be :
chaos, because who the hell knows what will happen to the European economies if the Eurozone implodes, and more importantly a weaker currency would drive the living standard down as well. People are importing stuff for a reason. The overvalued currency that the Euro may be for France is also helpful on the consumer side of things. Having a weaker currency would mean that they're automatically more competitive but also more expensive imports and travelling.
Also for political reasons alone a breakup of the currency union would be really bad. Why should the European countries grow together if there's no reason?
I never said getting rid of the euro, I am the advocate of a devaluation of the euro and even if the majority of exchanges of European countries are made inside the EU it would still have a positive effect on exports of France, Italy and Spain. And even more, I think that the EU should be protectionist fortress the US feared it would be. A united EU is the biggest economy of the world and I believe that our market is indispensable so instead of suffering social dumping and fiscal dumping from other countries (which doesn't necessarily mean trashing the European fiscal paradises), imo we should and we could without economically bad sanctions, impose direct and indirect protectionist measures to countries like China with their cheap, low quality/safety, made by people working in horrible conditions products, or countries like the US with their standardized food (which is mostly unhealthy btw with GMOs and hormones), standardized films and music, or countries like South Arabia, that can do whatever they want just because they have oil or other natural resources. You see the power of Europe would be limitless if it was more united and nationalistic, if there was more coordination, our dependence on fossil energy would be greatly reduced, our geopolitical power would be 10 times what it is now, our economy could be even more self sustainable etc... It would not work tho. How do you devaluate the euro ? Some economists proposed that the BCE print euro and buy US debt treasure bond, it could work in the short time, but the fact is that the euro zone is too competitive, has a global excedent of its commercial balance, lower the exchange rate in that situation is really hard. The goal isn t a permanent devaluation or something of the sort but temporary mean to get Europe major economies that are the UK, France, Spain, Italy, Greece, back on track and to let them have more manoverability to reshape their economy. I'm no economist but devaluating the Euro will only have an effect on trade with countries that use other currencies. The fact that there's no option for devaluation for the countries within the EU is what WhiteDog is criticizing. You can't devaluate a currency against itself, that makes no sense. But the problem stays that you cannot put that many different economies in the same currency zone. You're gonna hate me for this, but why not some kind of Hartz reform for France? Cut the wages for 10 years and get the economy back on track during that time. Why not make the economies more similar instead of going back to different currencies? And why would Germany be the model for all the european economies ? In fact, Germany is the worst model in terms of growth : even with the euro (that clearly benefit Germany) its growth in the last 15 years is below France (not to mention its natural growth, something really important for the european's future, or even inequalities and poverty, exploding since the reform). Plus there are cultural matter that plays a lot in the grand picture, cultural matter that you cannot really change (saving rate, consumption habit, etc.). The only solution is the end of euro, a federal government, or some kind of taxation on commercial imbalance (with a redistribution from excedentary to deficitary states). I don't think the 'German model' is optimal by any means. But although I personally don't like what has happened here over the last 10 years economically, at least it's somewhat working. Cultural habits aren't unchangeable I think, that's a really soft argument. Social transfer Eurozone wide is something I wouldn't even be opposed against, but that's something you can't possibly sell to the average German/North European voter. And if we're already that far we could as well just make it the United states of Europe ; ) I think the EU has brought us all a great deal of mobility, cultural exchange and peace. I don't want to see this change and nationalism resurface, I think giving the currency up right now would completely wreck the EU. I don't believe the german model is working, even "somewhat". It is like a neomercantilist ideology, it is working for you, and only for you, and in the short run. It is not a strategy that you can globalize at the european level, and it is already responsible of our lack of growth and our inability to get out of the crisis. Well our trade surplus is already sinking and imports are growing reasonable fast now, so lets at least wait and see how it pans out in one or two years. Also 'neomercantilism' would be huge exaggeration. Median household income is still reasonable high here and we're not going to create some colonies anytime soon. You're painting things way worse than they are.
|
On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:58 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:49 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:46 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: [quote] By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:16 Integra wrote: By 2080 the Majority of the people will have an education which qualifies them. You cannot compare the average education level of a 2014 average person and someone from 2080, its obvious they will be allot smarter. Just the fact that most of the jobs will be run by computers proves this. Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems. Still doesnt make any sense. When we become more productive every guy working in those branches monitors machines that produce a big amount of goods.So when you have everybody working in that branche you have a even bigger number of goods. So then everyone buys 10computers 50cars and 50iphones? If you increase the efficiency then you get more goods, goods that nobody can buy. You do realize that IT is a service which covers allot more than just giving the retail industry the service of automating production. it has other functions as well, even in the production sector. Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones. So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. I'll give you two examples: Business intelligence In order to get a overview of a complex organization, to find trends and to being able to measure success the company obtains vast amount of information which it tries to serialize into something tangible. For example it could try to gather information from others competitors and increase their competition. Another example would be to simplify decision-making so that the decisions that are made would come faster and be more reliable. A third example would be to automate the process of creating reports and other financial tools which the company uses.
Information and Communication Since work becomes more globalized the security and ability to communicate becomes more important than ever and allot of work has to be done in order for this to work. For example a web portal could be built by a bunch of programmers where people could communicate by forums or create their own newsgroups along with various security measures so only a selected people could access it.
None of these examples actually increases the amount of gods being made.
|
On May 26 2014 09:12 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 08:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:48 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 08:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 08:23 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 08:12 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 08:08 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:[...]but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. By 2080, 80% of the current work positions will be automated and replaced by computers. The idea that employment is going to improve in the future is a lie. It won't. Current solutions to this issue aren't enough. I don't believe in that at all. We had a high unemployment since 1980 - back them computers were worthless, the best computer we had were less efficient than the last iphone. It's true that technologies play a role, but saying it is computers that are responsible of the current unemployment is a gross exageration. On May 26 2014 07:59 Acertos wrote:On May 26 2014 07:33 Nyxisto wrote: @Acertos:
Yes, getting rid of the Euro may be the easier than reshaping the economy (towards more industry/better paying high-tech jobs), and better for the broad population than driving the wages down(which would be another, but admittedly asshole-ish way), but the problem with getting rid of the Euro would be :
chaos, because who the hell knows what will happen to the European economies if the Eurozone implodes, and more importantly a weaker currency would drive the living standard down as well. People are importing stuff for a reason. The overvalued currency that the Euro may be for France is also helpful on the consumer side of things. Having a weaker currency would mean that they're automatically more competitive but also more expensive imports and travelling.
Also for political reasons alone a breakup of the currency union would be really bad. Why should the European countries grow together if there's no reason?
I never said getting rid of the euro, I am the advocate of a devaluation of the euro and even if the majority of exchanges of European countries are made inside the EU it would still have a positive effect on exports of France, Italy and Spain. And even more, I think that the EU should be protectionist fortress the US feared it would be. A united EU is the biggest economy of the world and I believe that our market is indispensable so instead of suffering social dumping and fiscal dumping from other countries (which doesn't necessarily mean trashing the European fiscal paradises), imo we should and we could without economically bad sanctions, impose direct and indirect protectionist measures to countries like China with their cheap, low quality/safety, made by people working in horrible conditions products, or countries like the US with their standardized food (which is mostly unhealthy btw with GMOs and hormones), standardized films and music, or countries like South Arabia, that can do whatever they want just because they have oil or other natural resources. You see the power of Europe would be limitless if it was more united and nationalistic, if there was more coordination, our dependence on fossil energy would be greatly reduced, our geopolitical power would be 10 times what it is now, our economy could be even more self sustainable etc... It would not work tho. How do you devaluate the euro ? Some economists proposed that the BCE print euro and buy US debt treasure bond, it could work in the short time, but the fact is that the euro zone is too competitive, has a global excedent of its commercial balance, lower the exchange rate in that situation is really hard. The goal isn t a permanent devaluation or something of the sort but temporary mean to get Europe major economies that are the UK, France, Spain, Italy, Greece, back on track and to let them have more manoverability to reshape their economy. I'm no economist but devaluating the Euro will only have an effect on trade with countries that use other currencies. The fact that there's no option for devaluation for the countries within the EU is what WhiteDog is criticizing. You can't devaluate a currency against itself, that makes no sense. But the problem stays that you cannot put that many different economies in the same currency zone. You're gonna hate me for this, but why not some kind of Hartz reform for France? Cut the wages for 10 years and get the economy back on track during that time. Why not make the economies more similar instead of going back to different currencies? And why would Germany be the model for all the european economies ? In fact, Germany is the worst model in terms of growth : even with the euro (that clearly benefit Germany) its growth in the last 15 years is below France (not to mention its natural growth, something really important for the european's future, or even inequalities and poverty, exploding since the reform). Plus there are cultural matter that plays a lot in the grand picture, cultural matter that you cannot really change (saving rate, consumption habit, etc.). The only solution is the end of euro, a federal government, or some kind of taxation on commercial imbalance (with a redistribution from excedentary to deficitary states). I don't think the 'German model' is optimal by any means. But although I personally don't like what has happened here over the last 10 years economically, at least it's somewhat working. Cultural habits aren't unchangeable I think, that's a really soft argument. Social transfer Eurozone wide is something I wouldn't even be opposed against, but that's something you can't possibly sell to the average German/North European voter. And if we're already that far we could as well just make it the United states of Europe ; ) I think the EU has brought us all a great deal of mobility, cultural exchange and peace. I don't want to see this change and nationalism resurface, I think giving the currency up right now would completely wreck the EU. I don't believe the german model is working, even "somewhat". It is like a neomercantilist ideology, it is working for you, and only for you, and in the short run. It is not a strategy that you can globalize at the european level, and it is already responsible of our lack of growth and our inability to get out of the crisis. Well our trade surplus is already sinking and imports are growing reasonable fast now, so lets at least wait and see how it pans out in one or two years. Also 'neomercantilism' would be huge exaggeration. Median household income is still reasonable high here and we're not going to create some colonies anytime soon. You're painting things way worse than they are. No, no I'm not. Here's the euro zone current account.
![[image loading]](https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-GwshwEiooT0/U4KJMbhUdZI/AAAAAAAAAHs/JFFDfAYlWcU/w426-h264/ssss.jpg)
Here is another in english with 2014 datas (the line is the trend), for Germany's commercial balance (so minus capital account)
![[image loading]](http://www.tradingeconomics.com/charts/germany-balance-of-trade.png?s=grtbale&d1=20000101&d2=20141231&trend=1) Still far from the commercial balance that Germany had prior to the euro... By the way, the commercial balance getting better in most eurozone country aside from France is related to a clear degradation of importation : they've gotten so poor that their commercial balance came to equilibrium due to a lack of consumption. Way to go, fix problems through impoverishment.
|
On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:
Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones.
So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. Hint: A lot of people won't be working in a productive field !
|
On May 26 2014 09:26 Otolia wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:
Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones.
So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. Hint: A lot of people won't be working in a productive field !
On May 26 2014 09:17 Integra wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:58 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:49 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:46 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:20 nkr wrote: [quote]
What do you base this on? With an increasing population and a decrease in resources, you will not have a more educated population. if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014. Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths. On May 26 2014 08:22 Sokrates wrote: [quote]
Yes everyone can become a theoretical physicist or a highlevel engineer. You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems. Still doesnt make any sense. When we become more productive every guy working in those branches monitors machines that produce a big amount of goods.So when you have everybody working in that branche you have a even bigger number of goods. So then everyone buys 10computers 50cars and 50iphones? If you increase the efficiency then you get more goods, goods that nobody can buy. You do realize that IT is a service which covers allot more than just giving the retail industry the service of automating production. it has other functions as well, even in the production sector. Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones. So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. I'll give you two examples: Business intelligenceIn order to get a overview of a complex organization, to find trends and to being able to measure success the company obtains vast amount of information which it tries to serialize into something tangible. For example it could try to gather information from others competitors and increase their competition. Another example would be to simplify decision-making so that the decisions that are made would come faster and be more reliable. A third example would be to automate the process of creating reports and other financial tools which the company uses. Information and CommunicationSince work becomes more globalized the security and ability to communicate becomes more important than ever and allot of work has to be done in order for this to work. For example a web portal could be built by a bunch of programmers where people could communicate by forums or create their own newsgroups along with various security measures so only a selected people could access it. None of these examples actually increases the amount of gods being made.
So if you replace 40m peoples job with machines 40m of them will work in business intelligence and security. Seems legit. You both do not understand that the amount of people needed for such tasks is VERY limited and it is certainly not arbitrarily expandable.
Other than security it is indirectly all about making better, cheaper and more demanded goods. So my point is still valid.
But if you want discuss that we should make a seperate thread.
|
On May 26 2014 09:33 Sokrates wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 09:26 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:
Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones.
So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. Hint: A lot of people won't be working in a productive field ! Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 09:17 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:58 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:49 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:46 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:27 Integra wrote: [quote] if the majority of the work has been replaced by computers someone has to have done it, namely humans. The only reason why we cannot do it now is because we don't have the understanding on how to replace the jobs or how to maintain the vast networks to make such a automated system to work just the fact by itself that it would actually be doable is in self proof that people in the 2080 would have to be allot smarter than the people in 2014.
Most likely the low workers would be administrators and maintenance people for the systems while the higher elite would be the architects who put it all together and at the very top would be the ones who invented and improved the methodology behind these systematical behemoths.
[quote] You don't need a education in engineering or any sort of math to be working with computers. So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with... Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems. Still doesnt make any sense. When we become more productive every guy working in those branches monitors machines that produce a big amount of goods.So when you have everybody working in that branche you have a even bigger number of goods. So then everyone buys 10computers 50cars and 50iphones? If you increase the efficiency then you get more goods, goods that nobody can buy. You do realize that IT is a service which covers allot more than just giving the retail industry the service of automating production. it has other functions as well, even in the production sector. Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones. So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. I'll give you two examples: Business intelligenceIn order to get a overview of a complex organization, to find trends and to being able to measure success the company obtains vast amount of information which it tries to serialize into something tangible. For example it could try to gather information from others competitors and increase their competition. Another example would be to simplify decision-making so that the decisions that are made would come faster and be more reliable. A third example would be to automate the process of creating reports and other financial tools which the company uses. Information and CommunicationSince work becomes more globalized the security and ability to communicate becomes more important than ever and allot of work has to be done in order for this to work. For example a web portal could be built by a bunch of programmers where people could communicate by forums or create their own newsgroups along with various security measures so only a selected people could access it. None of these examples actually increases the amount of gods being made. So if you replace 40m peoples job with machines 40m of them will work in business intelligence and security. Seems legit. It was just two examples, there are tons of them really, point is that IT is a service and the automation in production is just a fraction of what IT actually does. For some odd reason you believe that IT equals automation when IT in actuality equals services.
|
Regarding the productivity talk, we had paradigm changes in productivity basically every 20 years for the last two centuries. Given the fact how productivity went up in the industrial and agricultural sector we should all be unemployed by now. What instead happened was that people just made new jobs that resulted in the increase of the service sector. If jobs are going to go away in the future we'll just invent new jobs.
|
On May 26 2014 09:36 Integra wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 09:33 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 09:26 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:
Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones.
So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. Hint: A lot of people won't be working in a productive field ! On May 26 2014 09:17 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 09:04 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:58 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:49 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:46 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:42 Sokrates wrote:On May 26 2014 08:39 Integra wrote:On May 26 2014 08:37 Sokrates wrote: [quote]
So then what are they doing with the computers? 80% of the population is working with computers doing what? Administrating themselves?I wonder what is the point in having computers to begin with...
Point of having computers is to automate, point of having administrators is to make sure the system keeps going. So 80% of the population becomes an administrator. Sounds reasonable. Actually it is considering any current workforce working in IT and management mostly do administrative work, even people with key positions like leading and architecture who are suppose to lead people and create new systems still spends allot of their time administrating the systems. Still doesnt make any sense. When we become more productive every guy working in those branches monitors machines that produce a big amount of goods.So when you have everybody working in that branche you have a even bigger number of goods. So then everyone buys 10computers 50cars and 50iphones? If you increase the efficiency then you get more goods, goods that nobody can buy. You do realize that IT is a service which covers allot more than just giving the retail industry the service of automating production. it has other functions as well, even in the production sector. Yes i know this but there is still a LIMIT of how much people can work in these areas. The branch certainly doesnt expand to infinity. You do not get the whole picture. If machines are there to increase productivity no matter if robots or computers you get MORE GOODS. So these goods have to be bought and i cant use 10cars or 50 phones. So then again tell me where 80% of the population will work which doesnt increase the amount of goods to ridicolous amounts. I'll give you two examples: Business intelligenceIn order to get a overview of a complex organization, to find trends and to being able to measure success the company obtains vast amount of information which it tries to serialize into something tangible. For example it could try to gather information from others competitors and increase their competition. Another example would be to simplify decision-making so that the decisions that are made would come faster and be more reliable. A third example would be to automate the process of creating reports and other financial tools which the company uses. Information and CommunicationSince work becomes more globalized the security and ability to communicate becomes more important than ever and allot of work has to be done in order for this to work. For example a web portal could be built by a bunch of programmers where people could communicate by forums or create their own newsgroups along with various security measures so only a selected people could access it. None of these examples actually increases the amount of gods being made. So if you replace 40m peoples job with machines 40m of them will work in business intelligence and security. Seems legit. It was just two examples, there are tons of them really, point is that IT is a service and the automation in production is just a fraction of what IT actually does. For some odd reason you believe that IT equals automation when IT in actuality equals services.
SERVICES FOR WHAT??? You are rotating in something that doesnt make sense because it is too abstract for you and therefore you think you can fit in a infinite amount of people.
So what does IT do? How do i personally increase my standard of living with IT services.In the end there has to be a product.
On May 26 2014 09:39 Nyxisto wrote: Regarding the productivity talk, we had paradigm changes in productivity basically every 20 years for the last two centuries. Given the fact how productivity went up in the industrial and agricultural sector we should all be unemployed by now. What instead happened was that people just made new jobs that resulted in the increase of the service sector. If jobs are going to go away in the future we'll just invent new jobs.
That cycles you are talking about will eventually end. They are not infinite and in reality it becomes more specialized for very talented people.
You can already see that in the US a lot of people running around with useless degrees because there is only a certain amount of jobs available. And they will hire the best person. It is like a pyramid, large bottom, thin end. And we are removing the bottom layers, but that doesnt mean that the end will get thicker as we please it.
|
|
|
|
|
|