|
On May 26 2014 06:47 Big J wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:41 SoSexy wrote:On May 26 2014 06:40 Anvil666 wrote: Ahm I thought we're debating the European Elections here, not ideology? Preliminary results here:
211 Seats EPP (conservatives), 193 S&D (social democrats), 74 ALDE (liberal), 58 Greens/EFA (greens), 47 GUE/NGL (lefts), 39 ECR (right-wing), 33 EFD (more right-wing), 56 Others
The two are closely entwined, my friend. Yeah but he is right. The results of some neonazis like le pen hardly matter for the EU. That's basically a national protest, but those parties are actually quite tiny in sum and dont even add together as they have a hard time to even form a common european faction. What actually matters is that Juncker has 211 seats behind him and but only 18more than Schulz and that they now have to form coalitions. As far as I understand it, It is not entirely clear if Orban's party and Forza Italia stay with EPP, as both have drifted away from the faction's stances a lot. So it might be that the 211 seats reduce a bit when they start forming the parliament's groups.
|
On May 26 2014 06:45 Douillos wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:33 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:29 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:23 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:18 ACrow wrote:On May 26 2014 06:05 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:04 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:03 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:01 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 05:36 WhiteDog wrote: [quote] Ok I will elaborate a little.
The FN is a nationalist party at core. During Le Pen's era, that nationalism was also backed up by some kind of racism and xenophobia and they were, with that, for economic liberalism (Le Pen wanted to be the french Reagan).
But, with Marine Le Pen's (the daughter), the FN "smartly" took most of the critics coming from the non institutionalised far left and made it their own. They took Sapir's and Lordon's critics toward the europe (far left economists) to a point were those economists had to defend themselves from being from the FN ! In the same vein, they actually defend France's social security, they defend the retirement at 60, they push for an increase in the minimum wage, they repeat non stop that they are "against liberalism and globalization". They put themselves as the only opposition to what is judged (rightfully I might say) to be the core reason of our social problems. [quote] Competitivity is a microeconomic term (at the level of firms). From a macroeconomic perspective, you can change the competitivity of a nation in a few seconds (with the exchange rate of your money or with law). China and Germany are competitive because they have underevaluated currency, we are not because we have an over evaluated currency and because we have a social security that push our labor cost high.
Basically, the state have the tools to make an entire nation competitive, because it is the state that makes the rules that permit the exchange. Protectionism is one of those tools (how do you think EDF is now one of the biggest energy firm in the world ? because we protected it during the firty glorious). Wow, so you really think the reason France could "easily" become competitive again, by devaluating the currency? And then how would you import the materials needed to assemble? Yes easily, the problem is the price in terms of purchasing power and living condition for the french. Purchasing anything else than French made products would be a problem. Yes. But that's not a bad thing for unemployment tho, it would force our internal production to propose substitutions. That's working really well for North Korea. .. Not. With our modern level of globalization, there are no such easy solutions as just devaluing your currency and try to go autarkic to make everything magically alright. That's way too simplistic an approach. North Korea ? What are you talking about ? That's not a simplistic approach, that's basic economy since the XVIIIth century. It's like when I talk about inflation and people respond that the weimar hyperinflation was bad... There is a difference in scale in here. Protectionism is used by ALL countries in the world, through laws and various negotiations at different level. The Europe is one of the least protective place on earth (even our tariff is lower than most, at 1.6ish % if I recall, and we use protective less laws than others). The United State, intelligently, protect some specific branch of their economy to permit them from taking off. I'm am not talking about secluding ourself from others, just intelligent localized protectionism, like Friedrich List or Stuart Mill theorized. One day, Germany will wake up and understand that its dogmatism will cause its downfall (I give them 5 to 10 years). I don't care, if they don't bring us with them. Only powerful countries can negotiate properly. The EU could negotiate on equal grounds. European countries individually would get laughed at when they would try to set their terms. And that last sentence of yours... Man you FN boys & girls know how to make fools of yourselves. I'm not FN, but I don't really care. France is the fifth economic power and you think we have no bargaining power... I'll let Krugman respond to the rest : Most discussion about the possibility of secular stagnation has focused on US data, partly because most of the new secular stagnationists are American, partly because the data are easier to work with. But as Izabella Kaminska and James Mackintosh point out, the euro area seems closer to Japanification than the US. So are there structural changes in Europe that arguably will lead to persistently lower demand unless offset by policy? Indeed there are. Start with demography: a falling rate of growth in the working-age population leads, other things equal, to lower investment as a share of GDP, because there is less need to equip workers with new factories, office buildings, houses, etc. And if we look at working-age population for the US, the euro area (EA), and Japan we see that Europe is now where Japan was around 1998, when I and other Japan worriers started talking in earnest about liquidity traps: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman2/051714krugman2-blog480.png) Add to this the end of ever-increasing leverage. In the US we focus on how ever-growing household debt was a major source of demand before 2008, which won’t come back; in Europe much the same was going on, but it also makes sense to focus on a different measure, large capital flows to peripheral countries, which won’t come back even if the woes of austerity abate. And these flows were a big part of overall European demand before the crisis: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman3/051714krugman3-blog480.png) So with a shrinking working-age population and without the boost to demand caused by the capital-flow bubble, Europe is extremely likely to have a significantly lower natural real rate of interest heading forward than it had in the past. This in turn suggests that it’s a really really bad idea to let inflation drift down, whether or not it turns into outright deflation. That was like what, 10 years ago? In any case, Imagine how better France (and other european countries) are off when they work together. It's inevitable, sooner or later Europe will be a federal institution and we will gain a lot from that. Of course the transition that started over 50 years ago is hard and the 2008 crisis hit Europe more than other places, but it's worth it. As an immigrant in France (I'm Irish Canadian, arrived here at 5 years old), a person who really is fond of the French culture and way of life, I just can't understand what the fuck is going on in this country... And When I meet French expats through my job (I travel all around Europe on a weekly basis), they feel the same way...
I believe France is still the fifth economic power in the world. A quick Google search tells you that, at least as of 2012-13, it is still the case.
Nonetheless, most of France's problems come from the mentality of us Frenchmen. It's sad to admit, but it's true. Our country has many problems, one of which being the cost of employment, which is setting back the job market and then some. About ten years ago, Dominique de Villepin tried to solve that with the CPE, and miserably failed due to the massive uprisings in opposition to his idea, which really wasn't stupid at all.
Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
The immigration problems have already been discussed in the thread, and come back to the same notion: Frenchmen alienating immigrants for not being "trueborn" French. That is a gross generalization of how us Frenchmen think, but it's relevant enough to be true and to be a problem. Again, it's more complicated, but after having lived abroad and having seen the mentality of mostly Canadians and a bit of Americans, I have to stand disgusted by our way of thinking. I'm likely biased though.
|
|
|
On May 26 2014 06:38 SoSexy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:33 Duvon wrote:On May 26 2014 06:16 Yuljan wrote:On May 26 2014 06:05 SoSexy wrote:On May 26 2014 06:00 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 05:45 SoSexy wrote: So many haters in this thread. There's a reason parties like FN win, and it is to blame on years of 'politically correct' policies (mainly by the Left) that went WAY too far in the name of multiculturalism. this is exactly the kind of attitude I am talking about, and it will get us in big trouble over the next decades on this continent. No matter how the economy is going to do. How the fuck can you live in the 21st century and claim that multiculturalism is a bad thing. The only reason this forum exists is that people from very different cultures don't give a crap about that and do great stuff together. Multiculturalism PER SE is not a bad thing. It is bad when every critics towards it is rejected in name of the principle itself. The problem of the next century won't be me, it will be radical islam which is already rooted in our societies in the name of mutual respect and comprehension. But don't you dare criticize it, you bigot racist... Same here Multiculturalism isnt too bad, but only if the right cultures are invited. Radical muslims and roma do not fit into our society. We already have hundreds of "german" youths going to fight for islam in Syria. This will only get worse... The right in Germany is ridicilous though, I will probably emigrate myself and leave you to your multicultural (till the muslims make up the majority) paradise. Using the same reasoning, I could say that you don't fit in my society, get out. Also, any kind of categorizing is problematic, as it focuses on a label and not on the people. Add in segregation and integration and meh, it's a fishy soup to try to navigate, so much so that left-wings haven't gotten any farther than adding the ingredients and hoping it doesn't burn when you don't stir it. Somebody needs to find that spoon. I believe that a french fits in France, an italian in Italy, etc. Bad people will be everywhere and the government has to deal with it, but if in addition to that we start to take in people who are against women's right, against homosexuals, who endorse genital mutilation, then they don't fit. If I come to Sweden to teach at university, pay my rent, taxes, services etc would you accept me? If I come to Sweden and have free money from the government, have my wife go around in a burqa, would you accept me?
I find it interesting that you think people in burqa take free money from governments.
|
On May 26 2014 06:45 Douillos wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:33 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:29 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:23 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:18 ACrow wrote:On May 26 2014 06:05 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:04 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:03 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:01 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 05:36 WhiteDog wrote: [quote] Ok I will elaborate a little.
The FN is a nationalist party at core. During Le Pen's era, that nationalism was also backed up by some kind of racism and xenophobia and they were, with that, for economic liberalism (Le Pen wanted to be the french Reagan).
But, with Marine Le Pen's (the daughter), the FN "smartly" took most of the critics coming from the non institutionalised far left and made it their own. They took Sapir's and Lordon's critics toward the europe (far left economists) to a point were those economists had to defend themselves from being from the FN ! In the same vein, they actually defend France's social security, they defend the retirement at 60, they push for an increase in the minimum wage, they repeat non stop that they are "against liberalism and globalization". They put themselves as the only opposition to what is judged (rightfully I might say) to be the core reason of our social problems. [quote] Competitivity is a microeconomic term (at the level of firms). From a macroeconomic perspective, you can change the competitivity of a nation in a few seconds (with the exchange rate of your money or with law). China and Germany are competitive because they have underevaluated currency, we are not because we have an over evaluated currency and because we have a social security that push our labor cost high.
Basically, the state have the tools to make an entire nation competitive, because it is the state that makes the rules that permit the exchange. Protectionism is one of those tools (how do you think EDF is now one of the biggest energy firm in the world ? because we protected it during the firty glorious). Wow, so you really think the reason France could "easily" become competitive again, by devaluating the currency? And then how would you import the materials needed to assemble? Yes easily, the problem is the price in terms of purchasing power and living condition for the french. Purchasing anything else than French made products would be a problem. Yes. But that's not a bad thing for unemployment tho, it would force our internal production to propose substitutions. That's working really well for North Korea. .. Not. With our modern level of globalization, there are no such easy solutions as just devaluing your currency and try to go autarkic to make everything magically alright. That's way too simplistic an approach. North Korea ? What are you talking about ? That's not a simplistic approach, that's basic economy since the XVIIIth century. It's like when I talk about inflation and people respond that the weimar hyperinflation was bad... There is a difference in scale in here. Protectionism is used by ALL countries in the world, through laws and various negotiations at different level. The Europe is one of the least protective place on earth (even our tariff is lower than most, at 1.6ish % if I recall, and we use protective less laws than others). The United State, intelligently, protect some specific branch of their economy to permit them from taking off. I'm am not talking about secluding ourself from others, just intelligent localized protectionism, like Friedrich List or Stuart Mill theorized. One day, Germany will wake up and understand that its dogmatism will cause its downfall (I give them 5 to 10 years). I don't care, if they don't bring us with them. Only powerful countries can negotiate properly. The EU could negotiate on equal grounds. European countries individually would get laughed at when they would try to set their terms. And that last sentence of yours... Man you FN boys & girls know how to make fools of yourselves. I'm not FN, but I don't really care. France is the fifth economic power and you think we have no bargaining power... I'll let Krugman respond to the rest : Most discussion about the possibility of secular stagnation has focused on US data, partly because most of the new secular stagnationists are American, partly because the data are easier to work with. But as Izabella Kaminska and James Mackintosh point out, the euro area seems closer to Japanification than the US. So are there structural changes in Europe that arguably will lead to persistently lower demand unless offset by policy? Indeed there are. Start with demography: a falling rate of growth in the working-age population leads, other things equal, to lower investment as a share of GDP, because there is less need to equip workers with new factories, office buildings, houses, etc. And if we look at working-age population for the US, the euro area (EA), and Japan we see that Europe is now where Japan was around 1998, when I and other Japan worriers started talking in earnest about liquidity traps: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman2/051714krugman2-blog480.png) Add to this the end of ever-increasing leverage. In the US we focus on how ever-growing household debt was a major source of demand before 2008, which won’t come back; in Europe much the same was going on, but it also makes sense to focus on a different measure, large capital flows to peripheral countries, which won’t come back even if the woes of austerity abate. And these flows were a big part of overall European demand before the crisis: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman3/051714krugman3-blog480.png) So with a shrinking working-age population and without the boost to demand caused by the capital-flow bubble, Europe is extremely likely to have a significantly lower natural real rate of interest heading forward than it had in the past. This in turn suggests that it’s a really really bad idea to let inflation drift down, whether or not it turns into outright deflation. That was like what, 10 years ago? In any case, Imagine how better France (and other european countries) are off when they work together. It's inevitable, sooner or later Europe will be a federal institution and we will gain a lot from that. Of course the transition that started over 50 years ago is hard and the 2008 crisis hit Europe more than other places, but the it's worth it. As an immigrant in France (I'm Irish Canadian, arrived here at 5 years old), a person who really is fond of the French culture and way of life, I just can't understand what the fuck is going on in this country... And When I meet French expats through my job (I travel all around Europe on a weekly basis), they feel the same way... And you think I am against federalism ? You really think I'm pro FN ? lol
The problem is, I think with my head while you let your heart talk. A federalism needs institutions that can execute macroeconomic policies and fiscal transfert at the european level. Those do not exist or are deficient, that's it. You defend an idea, the idea of europe, and it's a good thing, but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need.
|
On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Truth is monetary policies are already hitting their limit everywhere. Printing some shiny new money is not going to do anything, not in the long term. It reminds of the Friedman joke.
"A friend of mine was taking a class by Milton Friedman at the U of Chicago, and after a late night studying fell asleep in class. This sent Friedman into a little tizzy and he came over and pounded on the table, demanding an answer to a question he had just posed to the class, my friend, shaken but now awake said " I'm sorry Professor, I missed the question but the answer is increase the money supply."
edit: also what's up with the crazy Muslim hate, what did they do to you?
|
On May 26 2014 06:54 nkr wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:38 SoSexy wrote:On May 26 2014 06:33 Duvon wrote:On May 26 2014 06:16 Yuljan wrote:On May 26 2014 06:05 SoSexy wrote:On May 26 2014 06:00 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 05:45 SoSexy wrote: So many haters in this thread. There's a reason parties like FN win, and it is to blame on years of 'politically correct' policies (mainly by the Left) that went WAY too far in the name of multiculturalism. this is exactly the kind of attitude I am talking about, and it will get us in big trouble over the next decades on this continent. No matter how the economy is going to do. How the fuck can you live in the 21st century and claim that multiculturalism is a bad thing. The only reason this forum exists is that people from very different cultures don't give a crap about that and do great stuff together. Multiculturalism PER SE is not a bad thing. It is bad when every critics towards it is rejected in name of the principle itself. The problem of the next century won't be me, it will be radical islam which is already rooted in our societies in the name of mutual respect and comprehension. But don't you dare criticize it, you bigot racist... Same here Multiculturalism isnt too bad, but only if the right cultures are invited. Radical muslims and roma do not fit into our society. We already have hundreds of "german" youths going to fight for islam in Syria. This will only get worse... The right in Germany is ridicilous though, I will probably emigrate myself and leave you to your multicultural (till the muslims make up the majority) paradise. Using the same reasoning, I could say that you don't fit in my society, get out. Also, any kind of categorizing is problematic, as it focuses on a label and not on the people. Add in segregation and integration and meh, it's a fishy soup to try to navigate, so much so that left-wings haven't gotten any farther than adding the ingredients and hoping it doesn't burn when you don't stir it. Somebody needs to find that spoon. I believe that a french fits in France, an italian in Italy, etc. Bad people will be everywhere and the government has to deal with it, but if in addition to that we start to take in people who are against women's right, against homosexuals, who endorse genital mutilation, then they don't fit. If I come to Sweden to teach at university, pay my rent, taxes, services etc would you accept me? If I come to Sweden and have free money from the government, have my wife go around in a burqa, would you accept me? I find it interesting that you think people in burqa take free money from governments.
They do my friend, they do. In Sweden too.
|
On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth.
On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
Truth is monetary policies are already hitting their limit everywhere. Printing some shiny new money is not going to do anything, not in the long term. It reminds of the Friedman joke. "A friend of mine was taking a class by Milton Friedman at the U of Chicago, and after a late night studying fell asleep in class. This sent Friedman into a little tizzy and he came over and pounded on the table, demanding an answer to a question he had just posed to the class, my friend, shaken but now awake said " I'm sorry Professor, I missed the question but the answer is increase the money supply." Do you understand that is what the BCE is doing ? Keynes was against this idea (increasing money supply) because he had a qualitative theory of money supply unlike Friedman.
|
On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going.
|
On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ?
|
On May 26 2014 07:01 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ?
Isn't that the whole issue? I've read everywhere that you shouldn't be trying to cut back in times of crisis, but you should be investing and reworking the system.
|
On May 26 2014 07:03 Spaylz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 07:01 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ? Isn't that the whole issue? I've read everywhere that you shouldn't be trying to cut back in times of crisis, but you should be investing and reworking the system. Yes and no, without fiscal institutions, investing right now in europe would only increase Germany's GDP, because there is a deep problem of demand in germany. It is more complicated, it is just a shit situation.
|
Comparing with the previous prediction:
1 more seat for EPP (conservatives), 8 less seats for S&D (social democrats), 3 more seats for ALDE (liberal), 3 more seats for Greens/EFA (greens), 2 more seats for GUE/NGL (lefts), 1 less seat for ECR (right-wing), 3 left seats for EFD (more right-wing),
I think it is a bit early still to predict that.
|
On May 26 2014 07:01 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ?
It's simple : we cut on people's pensions, remove minimum wage, simplify work contracts, fire everyone in hospitals/schools... and when we're as f*cked as Greece and finally competitive, we watch other countries do the same to get some jobs back. Also, we can brag about how our richest "national" companies are making billions-euros-tax-free profit.
|
On May 26 2014 07:05 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 07:03 Spaylz wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ? Isn't that the whole issue? I've read everywhere that you shouldn't be trying to cut back in times of crisis, but you should be investing and reworking the system. Yes and no, without fiscal institutions, investing right now in europe would only increase Germany's GDP, because there is a deep problem of demand in germany. It is more complicated, it is just a shit situation.
EU = working for German hegemony?
|
On May 26 2014 07:06 VyingsP wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 07:01 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ? It's simple : we cut on people's pensions, remove minimum wage, simplify work contracts, fire everyone in hospitals/schools... and when we're as f*cked as Greece and finally competitive, we watch other countries do the same to get some jobs back. Also, we can brag about how our richest "national" companies are making billions-euros-tax-free profit. Yes, exactly, that's the european dream we should all vote for.
|
On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:45 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:33 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:29 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:23 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:18 ACrow wrote:On May 26 2014 06:05 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:04 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:03 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:01 Douillos wrote: [quote]
Wow, so you really think the reason France could "easily" become competitive again, by devaluating the currency? And then how would you import the materials needed to assemble? Yes easily, the problem is the price in terms of purchasing power and living condition for the french. Purchasing anything else than French made products would be a problem. Yes. But that's not a bad thing for unemployment tho, it would force our internal production to propose substitutions. That's working really well for North Korea. .. Not. With our modern level of globalization, there are no such easy solutions as just devaluing your currency and try to go autarkic to make everything magically alright. That's way too simplistic an approach. North Korea ? What are you talking about ? That's not a simplistic approach, that's basic economy since the XVIIIth century. It's like when I talk about inflation and people respond that the weimar hyperinflation was bad... There is a difference in scale in here. Protectionism is used by ALL countries in the world, through laws and various negotiations at different level. The Europe is one of the least protective place on earth (even our tariff is lower than most, at 1.6ish % if I recall, and we use protective less laws than others). The United State, intelligently, protect some specific branch of their economy to permit them from taking off. I'm am not talking about secluding ourself from others, just intelligent localized protectionism, like Friedrich List or Stuart Mill theorized. One day, Germany will wake up and understand that its dogmatism will cause its downfall (I give them 5 to 10 years). I don't care, if they don't bring us with them. Only powerful countries can negotiate properly. The EU could negotiate on equal grounds. European countries individually would get laughed at when they would try to set their terms. And that last sentence of yours... Man you FN boys & girls know how to make fools of yourselves. I'm not FN, but I don't really care. France is the fifth economic power and you think we have no bargaining power... I'll let Krugman respond to the rest : Most discussion about the possibility of secular stagnation has focused on US data, partly because most of the new secular stagnationists are American, partly because the data are easier to work with. But as Izabella Kaminska and James Mackintosh point out, the euro area seems closer to Japanification than the US. So are there structural changes in Europe that arguably will lead to persistently lower demand unless offset by policy? Indeed there are. Start with demography: a falling rate of growth in the working-age population leads, other things equal, to lower investment as a share of GDP, because there is less need to equip workers with new factories, office buildings, houses, etc. And if we look at working-age population for the US, the euro area (EA), and Japan we see that Europe is now where Japan was around 1998, when I and other Japan worriers started talking in earnest about liquidity traps: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman2/051714krugman2-blog480.png) Add to this the end of ever-increasing leverage. In the US we focus on how ever-growing household debt was a major source of demand before 2008, which won’t come back; in Europe much the same was going on, but it also makes sense to focus on a different measure, large capital flows to peripheral countries, which won’t come back even if the woes of austerity abate. And these flows were a big part of overall European demand before the crisis: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman3/051714krugman3-blog480.png) So with a shrinking working-age population and without the boost to demand caused by the capital-flow bubble, Europe is extremely likely to have a significantly lower natural real rate of interest heading forward than it had in the past. This in turn suggests that it’s a really really bad idea to let inflation drift down, whether or not it turns into outright deflation. That was like what, 10 years ago? In any case, Imagine how better France (and other european countries) are off when they work together. It's inevitable, sooner or later Europe will be a federal institution and we will gain a lot from that. Of course the transition that started over 50 years ago is hard and the 2008 crisis hit Europe more than other places, but the it's worth it. As an immigrant in France (I'm Irish Canadian, arrived here at 5 years old), a person who really is fond of the French culture and way of life, I just can't understand what the fuck is going on in this country... And When I meet French expats through my job (I travel all around Europe on a weekly basis), they feel the same way... And you think I am against federalism ? You really think I'm pro FN ? lol The problem is, I think with my head while you let your heart talk. A federalism needs institutions that can execute macroeconomic policies and fiscal transfert at the european level. Those do not exist or are deficient, that's it. You defend an idea, the idea of europe, and it's a good thing, but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need.
Trust me that it is not my only heart speaking when I defend the idea of a united Europe. History & economics are both in favor of a Supra-national instution; but I agree with you, Today's europe is not working like it should... It's just that voting simply against it is defintily not the solution...
|
On May 26 2014 07:09 Douillos wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:45 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:33 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:29 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:23 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:18 ACrow wrote:On May 26 2014 06:05 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:04 Douillos wrote:On May 26 2014 06:03 WhiteDog wrote: [quote] Yes easily, the problem is the price in terms of purchasing power and living condition for the french. Purchasing anything else than French made products would be a problem. Yes. But that's not a bad thing for unemployment tho, it would force our internal production to propose substitutions. That's working really well for North Korea. .. Not. With our modern level of globalization, there are no such easy solutions as just devaluing your currency and try to go autarkic to make everything magically alright. That's way too simplistic an approach. North Korea ? What are you talking about ? That's not a simplistic approach, that's basic economy since the XVIIIth century. It's like when I talk about inflation and people respond that the weimar hyperinflation was bad... There is a difference in scale in here. Protectionism is used by ALL countries in the world, through laws and various negotiations at different level. The Europe is one of the least protective place on earth (even our tariff is lower than most, at 1.6ish % if I recall, and we use protective less laws than others). The United State, intelligently, protect some specific branch of their economy to permit them from taking off. I'm am not talking about secluding ourself from others, just intelligent localized protectionism, like Friedrich List or Stuart Mill theorized. One day, Germany will wake up and understand that its dogmatism will cause its downfall (I give them 5 to 10 years). I don't care, if they don't bring us with them. Only powerful countries can negotiate properly. The EU could negotiate on equal grounds. European countries individually would get laughed at when they would try to set their terms. And that last sentence of yours... Man you FN boys & girls know how to make fools of yourselves. I'm not FN, but I don't really care. France is the fifth economic power and you think we have no bargaining power... I'll let Krugman respond to the rest : Most discussion about the possibility of secular stagnation has focused on US data, partly because most of the new secular stagnationists are American, partly because the data are easier to work with. But as Izabella Kaminska and James Mackintosh point out, the euro area seems closer to Japanification than the US. So are there structural changes in Europe that arguably will lead to persistently lower demand unless offset by policy? Indeed there are. Start with demography: a falling rate of growth in the working-age population leads, other things equal, to lower investment as a share of GDP, because there is less need to equip workers with new factories, office buildings, houses, etc. And if we look at working-age population for the US, the euro area (EA), and Japan we see that Europe is now where Japan was around 1998, when I and other Japan worriers started talking in earnest about liquidity traps: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman2/051714krugman2-blog480.png) Add to this the end of ever-increasing leverage. In the US we focus on how ever-growing household debt was a major source of demand before 2008, which won’t come back; in Europe much the same was going on, but it also makes sense to focus on a different measure, large capital flows to peripheral countries, which won’t come back even if the woes of austerity abate. And these flows were a big part of overall European demand before the crisis: ![[image loading]](http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2014/05/17/opinion/051714krugman3/051714krugman3-blog480.png) So with a shrinking working-age population and without the boost to demand caused by the capital-flow bubble, Europe is extremely likely to have a significantly lower natural real rate of interest heading forward than it had in the past. This in turn suggests that it’s a really really bad idea to let inflation drift down, whether or not it turns into outright deflation. That was like what, 10 years ago? In any case, Imagine how better France (and other european countries) are off when they work together. It's inevitable, sooner or later Europe will be a federal institution and we will gain a lot from that. Of course the transition that started over 50 years ago is hard and the 2008 crisis hit Europe more than other places, but the it's worth it. As an immigrant in France (I'm Irish Canadian, arrived here at 5 years old), a person who really is fond of the French culture and way of life, I just can't understand what the fuck is going on in this country... And When I meet French expats through my job (I travel all around Europe on a weekly basis), they feel the same way... And you think I am against federalism ? You really think I'm pro FN ? lol The problem is, I think with my head while you let your heart talk. A federalism needs institutions that can execute macroeconomic policies and fiscal transfert at the european level. Those do not exist or are deficient, that's it. You defend an idea, the idea of europe, and it's a good thing, but please look at reality : unemployment, inequalities, poverty, growth. That's the kind of thing people need. Trust me that it is not my only heart speaking when I defend the idea of a united Europe. History & economics are both in favor of a Supra-national instution; but I agree with you, Today's europe is not working like it should... But voting simply against it is defintily not the solution... I didn't vote against it, I voted for an internationalist party, how much more pro european can you get ? I'm just saying it is rational to vote against considering it is flawed and might not be in a situation were you can reform it.
|
On May 26 2014 07:05 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 07:03 Spaylz wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ? Isn't that the whole issue? I've read everywhere that you shouldn't be trying to cut back in times of crisis, but you should be investing and reworking the system. Yes and no, without fiscal institutions, investing right now in europe would only increase Germany's GDP, because there is a deep problem of demand in germany. It is more complicated, it is just a shit situation.
Didn't you say that you thought making the job market less "secure", facilitating firing procedures and removing minimum wage is dumb and false? Or were you referring to something else (e.g. printing/not printing money).
|
On May 26 2014 07:11 Spaylz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 07:05 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 07:03 Spaylz wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 07:01 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:58 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 06:56 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 06:53 Spaylz wrote: Again, look at Canada or even Germany, which I believe has no minimum wage? Jobs aren't as "secure" and it is easier to fire people, which is much less crippling and makes for a better job market. It's more complicated than that of course, but long story short: being an employer in France is expensive (and on a side note, also requires a shitload of paperwork).
I didn't dare to bring that up first because I feared I would cause WhiteDog's head to explode : ( Because it is false and dumb ? German don't understand their exportations are made at the cost of european's present growth and their own natural growth. Everyone understands that, but what needs to happen is that Germany needs to buy more (which is starting to happen right now) but it also means that our neighbouring countries need to sell more stuff. You gotta get that industry going. And how can we while we are supposed to restrict our investment ? lol How can we when inflation is at 0 % and growth at 1% ? Isn't that the whole issue? I've read everywhere that you shouldn't be trying to cut back in times of crisis, but you should be investing and reworking the system. Yes and no, without fiscal institutions, investing right now in europe would only increase Germany's GDP, because there is a deep problem of demand in germany. It is more complicated, it is just a shit situation. Didn't you say that you thought making the job market less "secure", facilitating firing procedures and removing minimum wage is dumb and false? Or were you referring to something else (e.g. printing/not printing money). Both those things are dumb. I don't believe an increase in money supply leads to an increase in consumption when the demand for money is null or almost null. And reforming the job market has happened in Greece, Spain, France (yes, we've been pushing for reform since 10 years and we have a very flexible market now, believe it or not, with quite a lot of ways to fire people, and more determined contract than indetermined one) Portugal, and it failed.
What we need are real policies : invest (and protect) specific branch (energy, transportation, internet, etc.) while we push for an inflation (to lower the debt burden) by directly giving money from the central bank to the states (monetising the debt it's called, but it is forbidden in the current europe). In addition to that, we need to push for some real reform at the european level, forcing all countries to reach an equilibrium in their commercial balance within the euro zone, either by destroying the euro (which is the wrong move) or by using some other kind of tactics (like Keynes' proposal to tax countries with positive commercial balance). But it's completly utopic.
|
|
|
|
|
|