However I do believe that the EU is infringing to much on nations. It should limit itself to economic concerns and stop trying to dictate everything of its member states.
The European Parliament election thread - Page 11
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Gorsameth
Netherlands22710 Posts
However I do believe that the EU is infringing to much on nations. It should limit itself to economic concerns and stop trying to dictate everything of its member states. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On May 26 2014 03:50 Gorsameth wrote: Economically the EU does more good then harm, anyone thinking they will be better off by leaving now is ignoring reality. However I do believe that the EU is infringing to much on nations. It should limit itself to economic concerns and stop trying to dictate everything of its member states. Do you have proof of that (for france)? I'm ready to discuss it, show me. | ||
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
On May 26 2014 03:49 sharkie wrote: Switzerland and Norway are doing just fine without the European project, no? Firstly these countries are hardly comparable to 60 or 80 million people economies like France or Germany, secondly these countries are part of the Schengen Area as well and to say they aren't part of the European project is highly exaggerated. What are you talking about ? Can you give me source that the european project actually helped the condition of the french workers ? of the french middle class ? I'm not an oracle so I can't tell you how a world would look without the European Union, but I doubt very much that isolated national states would've done so much better. The financial crisis would've happened anyway, with or without European Union. | ||
|
TTBest
Germany74 Posts
However, the French seem to see the FN as the best method to show their anger against the established partys. But why allying to the racists? If you want to protest, vote far left, at least, those guys care about peace in Europe... | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On May 26 2014 03:54 Nyxisto wrote: Firstly these countries are hardly comparable to 60 or 80 million people economies like France or Germany, secondly these countries are part of the Schengen Area as well and to say they aren't part of the European project is highly exaggerated. I'm not an oracle so I can't tell you how a world would look without the European Union, but I doubt very much that isolated national states would've done so much better. The financial crisis would've happened anyway, with or without European Union. Here i'll give you another perspective on the subject Euroland and the World Economy is a collection of works that examines the role that Europe currently plays, as well as the contribution it could make as a future global economic player. Professor Terzi recently stated, “Ordinary discussions of global growth prospects often begin with blaming the U.S. for its excessive external deficit and China for its artificially low currency and the consequent massive flow of exports to the West. While these two players are blamed for sending the global economy astray, little attention is being paid to the role of European economies.” However, he believes there is a problem in Europe, as well, stating, “ I do not subscribe to the influential view that claims that the euro area, or Euroland, provides a template of economic policy and contributes to limiting those U.S.-Asia imbalances. Instead, I believe that Euroland is as much if not more ‘guilty’ than the United States.” This lack of attention led Professor Terzi and his former colleague Jörg Bibow to ask a small group of invited scholars to explore with them the role of the euro area in contributing to issues that concern the world economy. Professor Terzi explained, “The 3-day workshop in Lugano, Switzerland was a rare moment of scientific dialogue and constructive criticism, and all working papers deserved to be collected and published at the highest level.” Palgrave Macmillan agreed, leading to a 311-page volume that compellingly questions, from a variety of angles, many popular beliefs about the road to virtues of Euroland. The final message of the book is that if Euroland aims to play a greater global role, on a par with the U.S., it should accept its new responsibility for global growth, becoming an engine of the world economy. However, this will not happen without a substantial change, and a greater unity of intent, in macroeconomic policy-making. http://www.fus.edu/academics/faculty/faculty-publications/books/andrea-terzi Also South Korea is 50million people and a world economy. On May 26 2014 03:57 TTBest wrote: I'm living for 9 months now in France, having both nationalities (german/french) and I feel deeply ashamed for the French people. They simply do not understand what it means to vote FN - Protectionism, an agressive rhetoric on the international stage instead of peaceful cooperation, being allied with the real racists (who definitely exist in this party) and finally, a regression towards nationalism. However, the French seem to see the FN as the best method to show their anger against the established partys. But why allying to the racists? If you want to protest, vote far left, at least, those guys care about peace in Europe... If you were born in France you'd know why they don't vote far left. The communist party had 25-30% forty years ago, but they tarnished themselves in defending the URSS. The far left is dead. I know I'm one of the last that still vote for them. | ||
|
GL999et1000
France229 Posts
But this is the result of bad politics led by the current government, the previous one, and even the previous of the previous one. France is paying the lack of reforms that should have been taken many years ago. Now with the debt, the socialist government is lost in the doubt, hesitating between a rigor politic (refused by a large part of the left) and a socialist politic based on taxes which he is paying at elections. Each time there are economic problems, people always blame the minorities. Currently prime minister Manuel Valls who is a socialist, the UMP party (french right) and the FN party (french extreme right) are blaming roms which are... 15-20 000 in France. I voted for UDI (french party of the center which has realized 10%), in my opinion the less demagogic out of all. | ||
|
AA.spoon
Belgium331 Posts
On May 26 2014 03:49 sharkie wrote: Switzerland and Norway are doing just fine without the European project, no? Switzerland is very rich because of their extensive banking system. Norway is very rich because they have a lot of oil. The small size of these countries and their resources (oil, banks) advantages them enormously. They still have plenty of trade/free movement agreements with the EU. Furthermore, plenty of Norwegian laws are made in Brussels: As a member of the European Economic Area (EEA), Norway has to apply Euro-laws over whose drafting it has had no say. In conclusion, they do fine because of their size and resources, but still cooperate a lot in research, trade and military matters with the EU. | ||
|
Makro
France16890 Posts
The socialist are down. The awakening will be extremely harsh. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On May 26 2014 04:01 GL999et1000 wrote: I am so ashamed of my country. But this is the result of bad politics led by the current government, the previous one, and even the previous of the previous one. France is paying the lack of reforms that should have been taken many years ago. Now with the debt, the socialist government is lost in the doubt, hesitating between a rigor politic (refused by a large part of the left) and a socialist politic based on taxes which he is paying at elections. Reform really ? We reformed everything, the entire country changed, our laws too, almost everyday, and the situation is getting worse. | ||
|
SpikeStarcraft
Germany2095 Posts
On May 26 2014 03:27 radiatoren wrote: In Denmark the exitpoll shows 23 % for DPP, which is below expectation, but it still makes it the largest party. Among the rest I am satisfied that we seem to get a very broad representation with 7 different parties making it and making it with enough margin for it to be pretty much certain. In the far more uncertain area The Greens surprise a lot by seemingly taking 12 % and 2 candidates, which is the same as last election (considering they had a complete meltdown less than half a year ago that would be a small sensation). man, this european parlament is so fucking confusing and chaotic. So many different alliances with hundreds of parties across different countries. Most of the parties you've never heard of. I made an effort today to learn about the top 10 alliances but there are still a lot of big ones like Europe of Freedom and Democracy which is apparently big in denmark with DDP. I see why the US has a 2 party system. Makes stuff sooo much easier. Its such a mess. And you dont get educated about the parliament at all. I mean its partly because it has almost no power at all. Many of the executives in the EU have nothing to do with the ones you vote for. Like Van Rompuy and Barroso. European Council, European Comission, its such a mess. There's no real eu government party and no real opposition. Its like a politician aristocracy. I really tried to make sense of this farce, but theres no way the average citizen understands how the EU works. I dont get it either, to be honest. If you want to move forward with the United States of Europe this mess needs to be cleaned up. | ||
|
Sokrates
738 Posts
On May 26 2014 03:50 Gorsameth wrote: Economically the EU does more good then harm, anyone thinking they will be better off by leaving now is ignoring reality. However I do believe that the EU is infringing to much on nations. It should limit itself to economic concerns and stop trying to dictate everything of its member states. "Economically", by that you mean big cooperations that make more profit. The benefits of being in the EU doesnt reach the general population, it only helps rich people to put it blunt. Mass immigration only helps big cooperations aswell because they get cheap workers. | ||
|
Douillos
France3195 Posts
On May 26 2014 03:46 WhiteDog wrote: What are you talking about ? Can you give me source that the european project actually helped the condition of the french workers ? of the french middle class ? A quick example is that without the PAC, there would not be any form of agriculture left in France. I can't believe how many people are actually trying to defend the FN party. Numerous cases of racism have been reported in new towns won by this Party after the municipal elections. And when I read people saying it's a "socialist & patriotic party" , I really feel sad to live in France (FYI I'm irish but grew up her). Everytime a party member opens his mouth, it's to bring the debate back to the eternal "immigrants are the problem, they steal our jobs and take advantage of our healthcare". For fucks sake, they were able to spend a large part of the presidential debate on the problem of halal food in schools. The FN party is an extremist, racist party, and they only thing that makes it worse is that their political program is a crock of shit, filled with ideas that wouldnt have even worked 50 years ago. The real thing is that most people in France just don't give a fuck enough to lose 2 hours to go and vote on a sunday afternoon, probably spent most of it watching Rolland Garros. Participation 45% = 25% FN, nothing else. That party is a joke and I firmly believe that you have to be brainwashed and/or mentally challenge to actually believe that they could be anything else than trouble for France as an industrial & economically competitive country. I just hope people here will wake the fuck and go vote next time. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On May 26 2014 04:13 Douillos wrote: A quick example is that without the PAC, there would not be any form of agriculture left in France. I can't believe how many people are actually trying to defend the FN party. Numerous cases of racism have been reported in new towns won by this Party after the municipal elections. And when I read people saying it's a "socialist & patriotic party" , I really feel sad to live in France (FYI I'm irish but grew up her). Everytime a party member opens his mouth, it's to bring the debate back to the eternal "immigrants are the problem, they steal our jobs and take advantage of our healthcare". For fucks sake, they were able to spend a large part of the presidential debate on the problem of halal food in schools. The FN party is an extremist, racist party, and they only thing that makes it worse is that their political program is a crock of shit, filled with ideas that wouldnt have even worked 50 years ago. The real thing is that most people in France just don't give a fuck enough to lose 2 hours to go and vote on a sunday afternoon, probably spent most of it watching Rolland Garros. Participation 45% = 25% FN, nothing else. That party is a joke and I firmly believe that you have to be brainwashed and/or mentally challenge to actually believe that they could be anything else than trouble for France as an industrial & economically competitive country. I just hope people here will wake the fuck and go vote next time. Seriously ? Do you know anything about protectionism ? So France can't protect its agriculture now ? | ||
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
On May 26 2014 04:12 Sokrates wrote: "Economically", by that you mean big cooperations that make more profit. The benefits of being in the EU doesnt reach the general population, it only helps rich people to put it blunt. Mass immigration only helps big cooperations aswell because they get cheap workers. I don't know what mass immigration is supposed to be, besides a populist buzzword, but research has proven that almost all Western nations are profiting from immigration. If you think immigrants only help rich people then please take a loot who works in our nursing homes and hospitals. | ||
|
Spaylz
Japan1743 Posts
The left is losing all popularity, and I doubt Hollande will even bother running for a second term. The right is in shambles, who will represent the UMP in 2017? The only option I see is Fillon, as I don't think Copé will make it. The far left doesn't have a chance, and neither does the center. The trend has been growing for a solid decade now, but the FN is finally gaining a lot of ground, and this is their first really major step toward the presidency in 2017. Luckily, I will be living abroad again by then... My fellow Frenchmen are right, to vote FN is largely to vote out of anger and protest, but it is a lousy solution. Anyone who has glanced at Marine Le Pen's program for the presidential elections in 2012 knows she will be no better than the others. Some of her ideas are truly moronic - then again, Hollande had his fair share of stupid notions too. Time will tell. The people were appalled when Jean-Marie Le Pen made it to the second round in 2002 (even though they made it happen) and voted for Chirac in masses, but in 2017 voters might not turn around. 57% of abstention is pretty scary. | ||
|
Sokrates
738 Posts
On May 26 2014 04:15 Nyxisto wrote: I don't know what mass immigration is supposed to be, besides a populist buzzword, but research has proven that almost all Western nations are profiting from immigration. If you think immigrants only help rich people then please take a loot who works in our nursing homes and hospitals. So there are no "native" people that would do the job? If not raise their wages they are badly paid anyway. And that western nations profit from unregulated immigration is a lie,there are statistics that show immigration costs more than it helps. Not even mentioning all the other problems immigration causes, esp. when a debate of integrating them is always shut down by certain people. http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/478076/We-were-wrong-we-are-sorry-Senior-Labour-MP-Sadiq-Khan-pens-open-letter-to-Ukip-voters | ||
|
mahrgell
Germany3943 Posts
On May 26 2014 04:21 Sokrates wrote: So there are no "native" people that would do the job? If not raise their wages. And that western nations profit from unregulated immigration is a lie,there are statistics that show immigration costs more than it hels. http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/478076/We-were-wrong-we-are-sorry-Senior-Labour-MP-Sadiq-Khan-pens-open-letter-to-Ukip-voters Unregulated immigration? There is no unregulated immigration to the EU. Nowadays the EU is often more strict with it's immigration rules then the US... | ||
|
Spaylz
Japan1743 Posts
If you look at most of the "stable" countries (e.g. Canada or, a more extreme and somewhat ridiculous example, the US), they have strict and selective immigration policies. France has got to be the only country in the world where selective immigration is directly associated to racism for some reason. There is nothing wrong with wanting to have productive people in your country. If you move to a foreign country, you should be able to guarantee that you can actively contribute to its society and economy. In France, most people don't think like that and are far too quick to assimilate selective immigration as outright racism. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
| ||
|
Douillos
France3195 Posts
On May 26 2014 04:15 WhiteDog wrote: Seriously ? Do you know anything about protectionism ? So France can't protect its agriculture now ? Sure, but at what price? What do you think the response of countries you are importing food from is going to be when you tax goods coming in to the country? Well, I'll tell you, they are going to do the same thing on the products you are exporting to them. And what does that mean? That means exportations going down, French companies being even less competitive, jobs disapearing etc. We are no longer in a world where you can just decide to start imposing protectionist measure without facing massive retaliation So what do we do? North korean style, Red Khmer maybe? The FN is from another century, it's just a response to the fears of many who have no idea how shit works nowadays and that the only way is to protect ourselves from the "invaders". A more powerful Europe is the best way to protect our quality of life and I'm really disappointed that people don't get that. | ||
| ||
