|
Okay 1800 pts Terran here. I just registered because this post sums up quite well the tvz matchup atm and I wanted to give my opinion.
I had a very good winning rate against Z before this patch - things have changed (not saying this is bad tho ;-P)
It is very true that harassing has become very hard, in fact it was even before patch because most Z learned what to do to be generally safe against anything you'd throw at them. (Unless you cheesed hard but that's gambling not a safe way to win). Now with this patch it's even harder.
The only thing that - in my opinion - still works is blue flame hellion drop with a viking before medivacs to clean up scouting overlords. But it's dangerous, if you don't kill 10+ drones, you're behind.
So basically since I can't stop 14hatch I started to 14-15cc. It works! Like in bw you will be able to defend the zergling rush with a wall and usually the zerg player won't even try. Problem is that it is very less effective compared to bw. I won few games by playing like that. Zerg either made a big push (with banelings to kill wall) that I wasn't prepared for or just took a 3rd quickly and when I was ready to go out he would have a far better army than me.
Harassing mid-late game (with dropships) is hard if the Z has a decent amount of mutas because good Z players have vision all around the map with overlords+creep tumors and dropships are now slower . Harassing with hellions is kinda the same, he'll see you coming and will build 2 spine crawlers at each expansion.
So what's the solution?
I think terrans have 3 ways differents ways of playing that are still good.
1) Just play standard, whatever build you used, do the same, but try to expand quickly. Stay on 2 bases macro-up and try to scout what the Z is doing. Prepare a mass marines/tanks/medivacs timing push and before pushing focus ALL your attention on your army. Your micro will decide who wins this game. Scan to reveal hidden banelings and to spot where the Z army is. Siege up a few tanks - move on - siege - unsiege - repeat and spread your marines. When you're near the Z base it will all come down to micro, whatever army he has, if your marines are all in the same spot and caught by banelings or fungal, it's over. Spreading your marines is very important !! Using multiple control groups is the best way to do this.
2) Abusing close positions. This work on maps like metalopolis or lost temple when you get close positions. Zerg has few answer to a slow push with tanks/bunkers/turrets, just crawl your way to his base while scouting for drops and hidden expansions.
3) Abusing small maps. On small maps zergs have a limited number of expansions. If you siege up and take expansions slowly and camp well with radar turrets Z can't do much. Just go out with 3-3 mech at the end and/or mass +3 marauders if he's massing ultras.
So what happens if you're cross positions on big maps? Well I'll let you guess :p Good luck!
Btw I have a 1000 pts Z account too and will start playing it again to see what weaknesses can be exploited in Z play, i'm sure there are things I haven't found out yet but atm I find the mu difficult for T.
|
I would think someone trying to be taken seriously and then saying things like "almost impossible and not really effective" as a complete categorization of an entire opening would warrant some kind of account warning
|
On October 18 2010 05:19 Flatha wrote:Show nested quote + I'm just saying, if you don't wall with your rax you instalose to a banelingbust, and you want to make the reactor on the rax to save time, making it on the factory is just a waste of a minute.
Instead of just saying vague things lie that, could you give an actual example of how to hide your tech better while still being moderately well defended vs a bust?
You're trying too hard to pick apart at the specifics when I'm speaking in generalities. I am intentionally trying not to make absolute statements on how Terran should be played, where the buildings should go, whether you should put a factory at the front of the base or not because scenarios change and individual matches play out differently. If a zerg player sees a ramp wall-off with just a barracks with an addon and a supply depot, does that NECESSARILY dictate that the zerg player will use a baneling bust? No. It's possible, but its not a guarantee. At the same time, the Terran player must also be wary of the front vulnerability and perhaps should be scouting more actively for a possible banling bust. Or maybe its going to be a 5RR! Exactly because of these variability in what could happen I'm not making absolute statements. ALL I am saying is that perhaps Terran players should give more consideration "to making that decision of whether to make your tech opening easier to scout or not by the zerg opponent." Take that statement and apply it as you will, it's really food for thought and I'm going to reiterate that I'm not making absolute statements of what Terran players should do.
You can go ahead and make that decision but everytime I do that the Zerg player just swarms me with lings and banelings, often even off one base. Not having done a walloff has just robbed you of the best way to deal with that.
Also, a Z seeing your front open is more valuable scouting information than seeing whatever it is that you may be building up front. Because then he can just rely on the above.
|
There's a third option between not completing your wall with a depot, and not walling off at all.
It involves your other buildings....
|
i'm a 1700 terran and i had many problems in tvz already before the patch. but i'm trying to harass with ghosts drops at the moment. a queen needs 4 snipes to get killed and optionally u can spend the snipes (25 mana) on drones, which also kills them immediately. the funny part in this strategy: easily killing the queen means no anti air; no anti air allows u to add 2-3 vikings and kill his overlords, while u expand and transition into thors/marauder/medevac or something u prefer.
replay
|
On October 18 2010 07:12 Geo.Rion wrote: plus you dont even mention hellion drops, the best harass option.
I actually did...
- Early helion harass: 2 queens at the ramp and a spinecrawler at the natural-mineral line is enough to shut this down completely . Helion drops will die against roaches because of their range.
|
As zerg player my worst nightmare is still blue flame hellion + thor push around 15-20 minutes or early thor pushes with scv's/mules on auto repair. Roach range helps but the priority targeting is still a broken mechanic that makes killing the scvs verrryy difficult.
|
I love how the OP complains that his 1-unit-combo doesn't work anymore.
It's like;
"If I try my 1 unit rush, he'll have 3 different units + static defence that destroys my 'army'".
You mention reapers, banshees, marines, hellions....how about a combination?
|
all the terrans in this thread make me really believe how terran is such a gimmick as a race -.-, straight up play can win you just as many games as cheesy all ins and rushes.
|
On October 18 2010 21:05 mikell wrote: all the terrans in this thread make me really believe how terran is such a gimmick as a race -.-, straight up play can win you just as many games as cheesy all ins and rushes. Actually most people are discussing ways to harass a zerg, not all-in. Letting a good zerg drone heavily is not an option as you will fall behind, and calling the terran race a gimmick because of it is just ignorant.
|
~1500 diamond terran
I either open 2rax FE -> MMM or 1 base MMM and transition into ghosts. Micro your MMM ball to pull marines behind banelings. Once he gets infestors, use ghosts to EMP them before they get off too much fungal (one or two shouldnt be the end of the world). Run upgrades on your bio. Don't let him be on too much more income than you without harassing because with this build, maintaining close to equal economies is necessary.
For example: (Not a fantastic replay but it gives some idea of what to do) http://www.sc2replayed.com/replays/92497-1v1-terran-zerg-metalopolis
|
okay today i found out , after patch i havent win a single game vs Zergs. please dont say that "ALL" zergs suddenly gained huge amount of skill to counter terran as hell .8/10 faced zerg and lost all of it. and lol seems they are getting better and better in new stuff after patch wich im SURE there is amount of hidden buffs as blizzard always does that. anyways i feel Terran is close to unplayable vs zerg , mach roach has no counter and if u go rauder you ruined your chance to defence/counter mutas , i tried blue hellion drop that is said on top wich worked quiet good and killed nice amount of SCVs but since they are on 2 base , actually it doesnt hurt their econ to throw them below you and still they will overrun. btw i was 15th on diamond now im 43 wich should thank to zerg. i even tryed to invent a new build vs blings with changing Vikings into groundmode and move them ahead of marines that works prefect, but roaches eat that so only works with muta/ling/bling.would be happy to see some new things up that can actualy makes it playable against zergs at least for nubs like me? >.<
|
So to the Terrans/Zergs suggesting the 1 rax FE strat.... has anyone actually done this successfully without getting completely dominated by the zerg in the mid or late game by being overrun with superior zerg economy ? If so I'd love a replay because I just can't seem to make it work.
I think the whole reason TvZ is so harass oriented is simply due to the fact that if you don't do something to disturb the drone pump/mass expo zerg machine, you're just going to get rolled over. Playing a "straight up" game that doesnt involve some form of eco harass early on is suicide.
|
ok, so im still in bronze rank 7 (ffs, i cant get out of bronze, work to much at cant play enough..) anyway... the few games i have played after the patch i have only lost 1. again this is prob im playing other bronze noobs!! But you all seem to be in dimond and fuking pro, where as im not, how ever no1 is going air?! hellions, FE, banshee + marines still pulled off a banshee rush with 1 hellion to start...
is air not a good idea then (in higher levles of play?)
|
To be honest it is actually starting to feel a little like Zerg may be safer than he needs to be in the midgame, though this could just be a result of so much practice against it. Terran has no effective way to remove mutas from play other than a dedicated push that forces them to defend, so Zerg's air dominance is a given in the midgame.
One thing to consider, though, is that with 15 CC or something similar, you do force Zerg into a fast third base or an extreme sacrifice for an attack (he already cut drones to fast expand, now is NOT a good time to pressure for him). You can scout that attack and defend it with good building placement--worst comes to worst you can lift and hold the ramp while using extra MULEs, so that you still get a big economic benefit.
Assuming there's no attack to bunker down against, you're either in a favorable situation (2 base to 2) or still even but going to fall dangerously behind soon (he expands again). In that case, hellions will be stronger than if you left things 2 base to 1, but in return, mutas are stronger when they come. Hellions will come earlier though. Does the relatively thin spread of units favor Zerg or Terran more when Terran is harassing? Instinct says Terran because of stronger defenses but I could be wrong. I know that from the Zerg perspective, each side taking the extra base early on extends the window where I have to make a lot of drones to be even on income by a significant amount.
Terrans also aren't usually at the level where they attack more than one place at a time or bait forces for a strike team to do more. Against most players, this is enough to do exponentially more damage, and is really in line with how Brood War's bionic TvZ played out. Not saying it's a final solution because it still has to be cost-effective, but I think even if Zerg plays well it will slow him down more. One or two hellions with preigniter over at another base can do absurd amounts of damage if Zerg isn't able to take his eyes off a big skirmish (which he also needs to micro heavily).
Finally, I think that the Terran Big Push hasn't been really worked on that much, because it wasn't really needed nearly as much before when harassment would often kill and going past two bases for Terran was rare. (Remember all those games on Lost Temple where Terran's whole game plan was a drop? And that hasn't really been changed much, either.) The timing of upgrades and the push itself should be explored more before ruling out Terran's viability in the late game.
|
I do Marine Raven and snipe every single creep tumor I can. Then I slow push with Marine and Auto Turrets. I do some sort of FE(1 rax or 2 rax with late gas) so I can get on 4 gas. Then I tech as fast as I can to 2 Starports, build medivacs until Raven energy and durable materials comes in and then do non-stop raven production. I think that if you are really frugal, you might be able to get 3 starports and pop out a stream of medivacs. You don't need an armory very quickly because you have 4 upgrades from the E-Bay you need to get. Get +2 Armor to buildings then the +1 Range to base defense.
The main goal of this is to contain the Zerg to a smaller amount of bases and then trade minerals(marines) for gas(everything that zerg has that is actually scary). You do this by killing the creep tumors with your raven detection and then laying down large fields of auto turrets up to their natural creep to constrict their movement. You also park your large marine army outside so the Zerg is hesitant to counter. Zerg then has 3 options: 1) Zerg can try a frontal assault to break out. 2) Zerg counters with Mutas to force you to back off. 3) Zerg starves to death.
If the Zerg tries a frontal assault then you try and initiate a favorable trade with your static defenses. If you get HSM up before Zerg attacks, then you can HSM their units if you are good at that sort of thing. Otherwise, throw as many auto turrets down as possible. A PDD may help if they hydras but that is 4 turrets that zerg isn't getting hit by. Without creep Banelings are not particularly scary and Roach/Hydra are hard pressed to give chase. The main thing you have to watch out for in this case is Mutas or corruptors killing all your Ravens. Of paramount importance with this build is keeping your Ravens alive because they are units with energy and can reach a critical mass where they can carpet the map with auto turret death. So focus on keeping them alive. I usually go get ship plating for my ravens as well. This also allows for a possible BC transition if you get frisky. You should be able to support quite a few Rax with all the minerals you get so unless you lose terribly the marines can be replenished quite quickly.
In the second case, if they have enough muta to pose a serious threat then just attack. The Z ground army will not be up to snuff and you can throw enough auto turrets down to pave the way for your marines to kill everything else. T will win most base trades and upgraded Turrets are fairly decent.
In the Third case, where the Zerg just sits, you just keep throwing down auto turrets all the way into Z's base. This picks away at zerg's unit count and you will eventually have so many ravens that you will be able to non-stop turret and win the game.
|
On October 17 2010 23:51 Baguette wrote: Maruaders still rape everything Zerg has except Lings and Hydras. Instead of making 10 Thors and A-moving in the Zerg's base, you actually have to scout and try hard now. How amazing is that?
And mutas. And infestors.
Oh hay marauders are bad against literally 80% of any good zerg's army.
WOW who would have thought
|
Isn't zerg earlygame still really weak regardless of the buffs? Why don't you just FE? It's not like there's much zerg can do about it. You either can goad him into attacking you or forcing him to get a third base which makes your harassment waaay easier.
At least this is the way I've always felt. I always feel completely impotent to punish a FE.
|
On October 17 2010 23:30 Dente wrote: - Early helion harass: 2 queens at the ramp and a spinecrawler at the natural-mineral line is enough to shut this down completely . Helion drops will die against roaches because of their range. ?
putting two queens on the ramp? really how many zergs are going to just two queens and a spine chilling at the ramp?
|
Zerg has been soo used to having a hard time to defend this whole time, but still learned to play and learned how to play it's race effectively despite the difficulties. Now that's easier, zerg's practice is really paying off.
|
|
|
|
|
|