EPTall of icedraco's reps, but not the other...three?
D Ranks Allkill Teamleague - Page 41
| Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
|
Birdie
New Zealand4438 Posts
I'll ask again in our Skype group for them. | ||
|
L_Master
United States8017 Posts
| ||
|
chrisolo
Germany2609 Posts
| ||
|
Hyeon
Korea (South)462 Posts
i'm going home 2-3 hrs later, will give you replay. | ||
|
pebble444
Italy2502 Posts
See you on the battlefield GG NO RE | ||
|
L_Master
United States8017 Posts
I will be casting this in 45 minutes. sB v TAKK + Courage v MannerHatch | ||
|
L_Master
United States8017 Posts
| ||
|
L_Master
United States8017 Posts
+ Show Spoiler [sB v TAKK] + | ||
|
CityShuffle
France57 Posts
On December 11 2012 08:42 L_Master wrote: + Show Spoiler + I'll cast it alongside the sB/TAKK reps in that case. + Show Spoiler [Liquipedia Question] + Looking at the standings in liquipedia propechy_ was credited with 4 wins. This is actually something I can see going either way on the one hand he didn't have the opportunity to play those games and thus lost the opportunity to go 4-0. At the same time...he didn't play, and therefore win, those games. We have no idea if he would have won or lost had games actually been played. While this is a little less of an issue for the league itself (unless people are really concerned about things like MVP), the big issue would be that it is very likely Birdie will pull many of the results from liquipedia for his Glicko rankings...and it really would make no sense to include walkover wins as part of a ranking system. + Show Spoiler [Liquipedia Question] + Unless i missed something, the current stats of prophecy_ dont involve the w/o of his team, he won 4-0(week1), then 1-1(week2) ,then a win against redaxis(week5), yes after this last win his team got a w/o but he didnt receive any win for thoses game, his stat show 6-1, which are the game he played) So i dont really see why he should be awarded of thoses w/o win ? his team get the points. My pov about this w/o is that w/o is a team win, not a personal win, Same for Flo in my team, got a w/o against takk after his first win against redaxis, why award him 4win ?. And well, as for this league, competition is fun to some (alot?) of us i guess, win/loss is what make the game enjoyable, so basically MVP is still a cute thing to cheer up for, maybe some team want they ace to get the MVP by let them play everygame, actually we didnt, but still, its fun to see a ranking between player !. Sorry for my bad english, i just wanted to share my thought. dont see offense anywhere also. | ||
Nagisama
Canada4481 Posts
On December 12 2012 22:31 CityShuffle wrote: + Show Spoiler [Liquipedia Question] + Unless i missed something, the current stats of prophecy_ dont involve the w/o of his team, he won 4-0(week1), then 1-1(week2) ,then a win against redaxis(week5), yes after this last win his team got a w/o but he didnt receive any win for thoses game, his stat show 6-1, which are the game he played) So i dont really see why he should be awarded of thoses w/o win ? his team get the points. My pov about this w/o is that w/o is a team win, not a personal win, Same for Flo in my team, got a w/o against takk after his first win against redaxis, why award him 4win ?. And well, as for this league, competition is fun to some (alot?) of us i guess, win/loss is what make the game enjoyable, so basically MVP is still a cute thing to cheer up for, maybe some team want they ace to get the MVP by let them play everygame, actually we didnt, but still, its fun to see a ranking between player !. Sorry for my bad english, i just wanted to share my thought. dont see offense anywhere also. Walkovers aren't counted in the individual ranking standings. They're just there for formatting. Also, for Birdie's ranking, I think he takes into account who the person plays, so he'll have to look through the results of each week anyways. Although, if he wants the spreadsheet of all the players standings instead of just the top 10, I have them. | ||
|
ninini
Sweden1204 Posts
On December 13 2012 00:01 Nagisama wrote: Walkovers aren't counted in the individual ranking standings. They're just there for formatting. Also, for Birdie's ranking, I think he takes into account who the person plays, so he'll have to look through the results of each week anyways. Although, if he wants the spreadsheet of all the players standings instead of just the top 10, I have them. The ranking looks accurate, atleast now. Didn't prophecy all-kill some team? That's why he has so many wins. I have a suggestion about the ranking though, in that you change it to be based on the difference between wins and losses. So basically: 4-0 is better than 5-2. And if they have the same win/loss difference, you either go by most wins or the least losses. This is not a big deal, but I think that system would be more accurate in terms of determining who the strong players are. | ||
|
Nagisama
Canada4481 Posts
On December 13 2012 17:22 ninini wrote: The ranking looks accurate, atleast now. Didn't prophecy all-kill some team? That's why he has so many wins. I have a suggestion about the ranking though, in that you change it to be based on the difference between wins and losses. So basically: 4-0 is better than 5-2. And if they have the same win/loss difference, you either go by most wins or the least losses. This is not a big deal, but I think that system would be more accurate in terms of determining who the strong players are. I'll try something like this for next week after results are in. | ||
|
Yokipi
United States6 Posts
I have not talked to RedAxis, the captain, about this, though, so whatever he suggests would be the final say; this is just from my perspective since our last two weeks were WOs. I and others should be completely available again starting the following week however. | ||
|
SynC[gm]
United States3127 Posts
On December 14 2012 05:51 Yokipi wrote: Team Freedom might need some help or a rescheduling for this week. This is the third consecutive Saturday that I will not be able to attend, and because a lot of us attend school, it seems that finals week hits roughly at around the same period and causes a massive drop in attendance. I have not talked to RedAxis, the captain, about this, though, so whatever he suggests would be the final say; this is just from my perspective since our last two weeks were WOs. I and others should be completely available again starting the following week however. I don't like how rescheduling might mess up the results for other teams, and we'll be postponing someone else's time for our good... The last week will be a good time for all of us to play! | ||
|
EchOne
United States2906 Posts
| ||
|
SlowBullets
United States839 Posts
| ||
|
pebble444
Italy2502 Posts
On December 14 2012 08:34 SlowBullets wrote: Sun Kan is the ACE of this league, lol and ACE is the Samsung KHAN ^^ | ||
|
Nagisama
Canada4481 Posts
| ||
|
SynC[gm]
United States3127 Posts
ACE's Zergs have gone 14-3, that's amazing... | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
| ||
| ||
