|
For lack of better term, since i have no idea what it's called... Anyway, there's that common technique where you run troops like zerglings or zealots through enemy forces, then have them attack so they don't have to spend time going around each other and stoofa...
I know it works well in many situations, and I do it all the time. The thing I don't get it why and when this technique actually works. I mean, you obviously don't do it when you have zerglings, they have zealots, and you have equal numbers (actually, you can't do a whole lot in those situations)... Do you only do it when you're stronger? Outnumber? When they fire slower? When you're melee and they're ranged?...
Just wondering. Any help would be appreciated .
|
Well..you pretty much answered the question yourself. You do it when melee-melee if you have a large number of weaker units and your opponent has fewer strong units..ling-lots, ling-firebat--lot-ultra;) vs ranged its very important to have as many units as possible attack at once..so if you're going to engage at all you better flank or 'weave'.
|
Norway10161 Posts
e.g when you attack those 15 marines with medic support with you puny 8-muta force .. those 30 lings are gonna wreck major havoc because you "weaved" them while your mutas died. GG rines.
|
when u 'weave' them, more units can attack a unit at once
for an example, when a rine is attacked on 4 sides by 4 lings, he'll die in the time it takes a ling to attack
once the lings are amongst the rines, rines start popping one by one and as their numbers grow smaller, they die faster
|
So more or less, I guess it's the obvious answer... do it when you won't lose all your troops trying to get in (ie lings vs zeals in equal ratio)...
But when you consider it, why is this better than, say, flanking from multiple directions, then? In that case you take less damage while running, surround them, and attack ASAP... I'm assuming it has to do with simply striking hard and fast so a player can't react, but I'm a bit uncertain... Sorry if this is all a stupid question. Just trying to figure it all out since I use it all the time but I really don't even know why... only that it helps
|
I have a different question, but I'll post it here since I don't want to start a whole new topic for something like this and this is a tactics thread that's already been drained:
If say your forces reside somewhere fairly distant from your base, and your opponents forces that are about the same as yours, or maybe a little smaller than yours, attack you, but you were not planning to have a confrontation at that moment, will you retreat, or face your enemy? For some reasons I now think it's almost always wiser to retreat when your enemy is making a move with his force against you - he planned it and you didn't, so you'd like to schedule your fights on your own. Right?
|
United States37500 Posts
This comes down to basic, rapid decision making. Depending on who your opponent is and how confidant you are in your micro, that should help you decide if you ought to fight or flee.
And as always, if you are facing a competent opponent, regardless if he does have a slightly smaller force than yours, he is initiating a battle because he has some reason to believe he can win. More weight for you to be cautious.
|
It depends on the situation, terrain, positioning, etc (like, if he's about to storm into your base, you probably don't want to leave...). That's all obvious, though.
Assuming it's just your average open-field, nothing-important-around battle, there's several factors. First, who's going to win? Check the numbers, unit types, etc. Also remember any army travelling a distance will be less effective on engaging unless they organize (rally) first. Also, anyone already in a position will tend to have an advantage as it's easier to hold a position than take it (usually). On the other paw, chances are they planned it.
If you can easily defeat them, do so, obviously. If you are about equal, look at how organized they are, how organized you are (as in, good positioning), and consider how likely that were to have planned this well. Remember the risk for surprises as you're playing their game if you engage. If you believe you have better positioning, and it's unlikely they'll do anything unexpected, by all means, engage, do some damage, then either finish them or retreat once they start getting into an organized formation.
If you are not organized, etc, then retreat. If you think they planned it, or already know more than you do, then pull back at first.
In general, if you have the choice, do whatever your opponent doesn't expect. Play on your own terms. However, it's mostly analyzing whether or not your opponent made a bad decision to attack (plus the risk of some trap).
|
Common sense but good points. "do whatever your opponent doesn't expect" made me rethink my tactics. I get drawn into battle too much - almost always when my enemy attacks, I say "Ok, buddy, let's rock"
|
On December 17 2002 22:54 Majicou wrote: So more or less, I guess it's the obvious answer... do it when you won't lose all your troops trying to get in (ie lings vs zeals in equal ratio)... But when you consider it, why is this better than, say, flanking from multiple directions, then? In that case you take less damage while running, surround them, and attack ASAP... I'm assuming it has to do with simply striking hard and fast so a player can't react, but I'm a bit uncertain... Sorry if this is all a stupid question. Just trying to figure it all out since I use it all the time but I really don't even know why... only that it helps 
The reason you'd use this instead of flanking is because you have a smaller, more tactical force of Zealots and Goons (or whatever), trying to run through a big Tank/Vulture/Depot set up. You can't really flank the Tanks and what not as well, since your force isn't big enough to deal with them all at once. But you can make small hits and wear him down by attrition, and hope that he has some bad placements somewhere, and eventually you'll just break through and keep throwing down elsewhere.
|
Well, I guess what confuses me is that at first, you're supposed to use this when you outnumber them. Now you do it because you don't... Ack, so confusing :-)
Oh, and MPXMX... glad my crazy common sense ways were somewhat useful for once . Actually, I was more or less quoting Sun Tzu, but ah well. I can feel useful for a while!
|
Sun Tzu is incredible! My point is simply that this maneuver can take a smaller force and make it more useful than if you were to spread it too far out and just be crushed by divide and conquer.
|
Hehe. Sun Tzu does rule . Guy's a bloody genius. Who would have thought a 25 page tiny manual for the elite in ancient China would still be arguably the best strategic war analaysis in the world.
Anyhoo... the funny part about that maneuver is you actually equally DIVIDE your own troops equally amoung the enemy, although if you outnumber them, you will outnumber them in each of the 'minibattles' that occur... Ah well, LOL. Sorry, guess this is just turning out to be my stupid curiousity about why this technique works at all since I just can't figure it out. You apparently take hits without dealing damage at first. You divide your own forces. You allow the enemy to surround you within their ranks... The only advantages I can really see is that they can't move, your troops don't run into each other much, and the attack is sudden, meaning less warning with the big under attack thingy. These don't seem that wonderful comparatively, but who knows... Yet, somehow it all works.
|
its good against tanks/vultures because your zealots takes the hits from the tanks instead of being held up by the vultures, and they drag the mines with them which means all your goons get within range without getting attacked and usually some of your zealots survive and attack the tanks. it works mainly because the ai allways attacks the closest threat and because the tanks will do splash damage to each other when the zealots are close.
|
Good point Zorglub. I was talking more generally but the technique is very powerful to help out in those tank pushes. It also spreads out splash since you engage multiple tanks instead of having zealots stumble over each other trying to get to one tank while all the rest shoot at the lovely little Protoss cluster.
|
Majicou, if someone hasnt mentioned it already. First off its flanking. Also when you run past zealots and theyre around the zealots, and they attack thats called CF(Collapse Formation). The reason you do that is to increase the aggregate rate of attack. 1v1 Ling gets owned bad but if more lings are surrounding zealots its harder to micro them out and back into battle.
|
Makes sense. And thanks for telling me the term. "weaving" is such a lousy-sounding word for it . Thanks Fozzy!
|
|
|
say ur zerg, p rushes you. you kill his first zeal. he can no longer stay anywhere near you. so he starts to run his 2 zeals. you have, say, 9 lings left.
now if you just hit attack move the lings will get in a conga line and only attack one at a time every 10 seconds.
if you move past then attack all lings or close to all will attack.
this takes advantage of the fact that p cannot fight and MUST run. if he chooses to fight he still loses his zeals and u lose near 0 lings.
of course once he meets up with the other 2 zeals the whole process starts over again. u run, he chases, you kill weak zeals, he runs and all over again till one of u is back in your base.
|
On December 19 2002 04:45 Casper... wrote: say ur zerg, p rushes you. you kill his first zeal. he can no longer stay anywhere near you. so he starts to run his 2 zeals. you have, say, 9 lings left.
now if you just hit attack move the lings will get in a conga line and only attack one at a time every 10 seconds.
if you move past then attack all lings or close to all will attack.
this takes advantage of the fact that p cannot fight and MUST run. if he chooses to fight he still loses his zeals and u lose near 0 lings.
of course once he meets up with the other 2 zeals the whole process starts over again. u run, he chases, you kill weak zeals, he runs and all over again till one of u is back in your base.
Well, I'm understanding more. I understand why and when you do this. I use it constantly and I consider it fundamental for chasing junk with zerglings. I just didn't know HOW it worked in the first place since it seemed counter-intuitive. Still does to some extent. But anyhoo, I sort of got the idea... mostly. Thanks though
|
|
|
|
|
|