|
On July 20 2009 06:05 Aegraen wrote: Whats up with all the low count post WC3 fanboys? I know I can't be the only one seeing a trend here.
Why does it matter if they are low post and posting about WC3 though? As long as the posts are good it's fine, because the thread features of the worlds best WC3 player
|
Egg-rean you should go back to watching AOE :D. I doubt your Iamgrunt can compete to this level anyway :D.
Seriously though,
This is a competition between Moon and Nada, that's it. Not about fucking war3 vs sc or mbs vs outdated grouping or even about 250 apm vs 350 apm.
He who spends time playing, thinking , reacting will win it. I'm glad Skyze is there to bring about some valid points (and frozenarbiter too), these guys are the top of their level in their respective games, how they shift to a new one is based on individual capability far more than the games they are currently playing.
I hope this is a good show and neither Moon nor Nada pwn the other out (that's a fail fail situation).
|
-_- thanks Kage lol
I just feel like anyone who hasnt played war3 enough, really understands how difficult it is. Sure, it looks like its a "newb game" that anyone can pick up, but theres so much mental strategy involved, more than the basic SC mindset of "expand, stop his expos, kill his army".. Creeping adds such a different dimension to the game, it makes it very unique and not at all comparible to SC.
I spent 4 years on SC, then played war3 when it first came out for the first 3 years of it (playing on some semi-pro teams, eGe.Canada and The-Feared) and then I came back to BW last year again. Its not like I've only played war3 and havent touched sc, while I never really got to a far level in bw (esp as a solo player, i did 2v2s only til this past year) I understand what the differences is between SC and War3, and something that is not obvious to most people is that it takes DIFFERENT skillsets, not "more or less"..
|
lol at the guy who keeps saying Iamgrunt will do good. He was good at aoe3 (a game i played for 3 years) but sc is soo much harder. I don't anticipate him to be very good at sc2 when its released.
I don't care who wins this moon vs Nada I just want a good match(s) that I can watch
|
Overall WC3 is a better game
|
imho this will show us will sc2 be more like sc1 or wc3 oriented
|
United States2822 Posts
On July 21 2009 07:04 IceCube wrote: imho this will show us will sc2 be more like sc1 or wc3 oriented I disagree completely. It will show us which one of those players is better at adapting to a new video game. In almost every single interview or player account, they've said that SC2 really feels like SC1.
|
On July 21 2009 07:10 scintilliaSD wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2009 07:04 IceCube wrote: imho this will show us will sc2 be more like sc1 or wc3 oriented I disagree completely. It will show us which one of those players is better at adapting to a new video game. In almost every single interview or player account, they've said that SC2 really feels like SC1.
Yep. Not a single person who's played SC2 has compared it to War3's style of game play.
|
On July 21 2009 07:04 IceCube wrote: imho this will show us will sc2 be more like sc1 or wc3 oriented It won't. Your honest opinion has actually been stated many times in the thread already, and by now most of us have come to the rational conclusion that who wins will prove absolutely nothing.
We already know all of the ins and outs - the similarities between SC2 and the two older games. Moon might have an edge with unit production mechanics since he's been using MBS his entire pro career. Nada might have an edge with superior understanding of SC, like when to expand, harass, turtle, push, pull back, etc.
But the fact is that SC2 is a game completely different than what either of them are used to, so it might as well just be proving adaptability. Maybe one of the players is better at adapting to a new environment. Maybe one of them will let their ego get in the way, and throw away the whole set. Maybe one will have really bad gas and thus be unable to concentrate.
Over all, this is meant to be a fun exhibition match, not a competition. It's supposed to JOIN the two communities, not get them scowling at eachother. Embrace your WC3 brethren, for we will soon be sharing the same BNET.
|
On July 21 2009 06:58 ixion wrote: Overall WC3 is a better game
ok.
|
Marshall Islands104 Posts
Looking forward to seeing NaDa and Moon playing!
Here are my points (not adding to the fire)
#1 Blizzard is extremely skilled at making games and has a great team on SC2. #2 Blizzard's SC2 team keeps saying they are trying to keep it different than WC3. #3 Most likely, SC2 and WC3 will be very, very different, in my opinion.
WC3 vs SC2 players? Why not give both the benefit of the doubt and then find out when the game launches?
But yes, the Moon vs. NaDa game should be epic!
|
i remember moon beating savior in sc2 at won of the BWI's but.... sc pros > wc3 pros at sc2 i guess so logic fails in this case... or atleast your logic
|
On July 21 2009 03:13 blade55555 wrote:lol at the guy who keeps saying Iamgrunt will do good. He was good at aoe3 (a game i played for 3 years) but sc is soo much harder. I don't anticipate him to be very good at sc2 when its released. I don't care who wins this moon vs Nada I just want a good match(s) that I can watch 
He was one of the best in AoK/AoC and AoE III. He won WCG2001 and 2007 (He only entered into 3). He trained with Koven in AoC arguably the best Age of player ever. AoC was as competitive in its hey-day as SC. I think he would do very good in SC2 (He is Korean also).
Yes, I agree SC is a lot harder than AoE III, AoC though is comparable.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 21 2009 08:54 starPride wrote: i remember moon beating savior in sc2 at won of the BWI's but.... sc pros > wc3 pros at sc2 i guess so logic fails in this case... or atleast your logic Pride, they did not play eachother - they were in the same video, but not the same game. (for the record I have no idea who will win between Moon and NaDa)
|
On July 21 2009 09:00 Aegraen wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2009 03:13 blade55555 wrote:lol at the guy who keeps saying Iamgrunt will do good. He was good at aoe3 (a game i played for 3 years) but sc is soo much harder. I don't anticipate him to be very good at sc2 when its released. I don't care who wins this moon vs Nada I just want a good match(s) that I can watch  He was one of the best in AoK/AoC and AoE III. He won WCG2001 and 2007 (He only entered into 3). He trained with Koven in AoC arguably the best Age of player ever. AoC was as competitive in its hey-day as SC. I think he would do very good in SC2 (He is Korean also). Yes, I agree SC is a lot harder than AoE III, AoC though is comparable.
...lol?
|
On July 21 2009 09:51 Goshawk. wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2009 09:00 Aegraen wrote:On July 21 2009 03:13 blade55555 wrote:lol at the guy who keeps saying Iamgrunt will do good. He was good at aoe3 (a game i played for 3 years) but sc is soo much harder. I don't anticipate him to be very good at sc2 when its released. I don't care who wins this moon vs Nada I just want a good match(s) that I can watch  He was one of the best in AoK/AoC and AoE III. He won WCG2001 and 2007 (He only entered into 3). He trained with Koven in AoC arguably the best Age of player ever. AoC was as competitive in its hey-day as SC. I think he would do very good in SC2 (He is Korean also). Yes, I agree SC is a lot harder than AoE III, AoC though is comparable. ...lol?
the answer is yes
|
Ye moon will rock apparently he was a good terran player back in the day
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 21 2009 11:29 SiDX wrote: Ye moon will rock apparently he was a good terran player back in the day Pretty sure he plays zerg in starcraft? At least I remember Testie saying Moon's zerg was very good -.-
And he's commented he thinks Zerg in SC2 are the most like Night Elves in how they play, I think.
|
SCL is reporting from their 'sources' that the SC2 matches will most likely not be broadcast. If so, that's really disappointing.. Anyone else have any more information?
|
On July 21 2009 13:45 FrozenArbiter wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2009 11:29 SiDX wrote: Ye moon will rock apparently he was a good terran player back in the day Pretty sure he plays zerg in starcraft? At least I remember Testie saying Moon's zerg was very good -.- And he's commented he thinks Zerg in SC2 are the most like Night Elves in how they play, I think. In an interview he said he wanted to play Zerg.
|
|
|
|
|
|