|
On November 17 2015 00:56 AsmodeusXI wrote: My biggest issue with the HotS campaign was that it felt more Terran than Zerg. Kerrigan was human as all get out the whole time, even back in Queen of Blades mode. I wished that the Swarm had felt more hive-like, more alien, but a single protagonist is probably easier to write for and likely easier for an audience to understand (if I'm thinking from Blizz's perspective). But the singular nature of Kerrigan made her feel very much human, which felt... weird. And unfortunate. Abathur was the most "swarm-y" part of the campaign... and he was the upgrade side-character.
I felt more Zerg-y during the SC1/BW campaigns, but admittedly that could be rose-tinted goggles.
Also, "Primal Zerg." Shit directly contradicts the backstory in the original SC1 manual, which I read more times than I'd like to admit.
But hey, Protoss is my favorite anyways, so I'm sure I'll enjoy LotV when I get around to it no matter what. What's odd is that in the Marine Field Manual, they still talk about the original planets and species of the various Zerg strains (Slothien -> Hydralisk, space faring Gargantis -> Overlords), and nothing I saw about Primal Zerg.
Maybe there are/were more worlds of Primal Zerg than just Zerus, and the strains that we saw there (Mutalisk, Zergling, etc) were part of the Primal Zerg biology before Amon corrupted the Overmind. In fact, HotS seems to indicate that Swarm Hosts were a strain that the Primal Zerg evolved/assimilated and the Swarm adapted them.
So, while there was no reason for the Primal Zerg to really exist other than give a reason for Kerrigan to become Zerg again but not corrupted, it does sorta make sense within their own lore.
|
United States15536 Posts
I was always under the impression that the "original" Zerg were just the larva, and that the Overmind was the Xel'naga's apex creation. By using the adaptability of the Prime Zerg (read: squishy super bugs), the Overmind could start creating the perfect swarm. In that version of the "canon", the Primal Zerg don't really fit.
But again, I'm going off really old memories at this point. Your explanation makes sense, it just doesn't jive with the version I recall. And CURSE YOU PLOT HOLES!!!!
|
On November 17 2015 01:39 AsmodeusXI wrote: I was always under the impression that the "original" Zerg were just the larva, and that the Overmind was the Xel'naga's apex creation. By using the adaptability of the Prime Zerg (read: squishy super bugs), the Overmind could start creating the perfect swarm. In that version of the "canon", the Primal Zerg don't really fit.
But again, I'm going off really old memories at this point. Your explanation makes sense, it just doesn't jive with the version I recall. And CURSE YOU PLOT HOLES!!!!
Are they still plot holes when they retroactively change the story?
|
I don't think it's a change at all. It was clear that we never had the full history prior to HotS, so any adding felt fine as long as it didn't invalidate the facts we already had.
|
On November 17 2015 01:43 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 17 2015 01:39 AsmodeusXI wrote: I was always under the impression that the "original" Zerg were just the larva, and that the Overmind was the Xel'naga's apex creation. By using the adaptability of the Prime Zerg (read: squishy super bugs), the Overmind could start creating the perfect swarm. In that version of the "canon", the Primal Zerg don't really fit.
But again, I'm going off really old memories at this point. Your explanation makes sense, it just doesn't jive with the version I recall. And CURSE YOU PLOT HOLES!!!! Are they still plot holes when they retroactively change the story?
Maybe not. We could probably use a new term to describe what's going on.
A word for when a story is clearly supposed to be canon and follow from previous canon, but in fact refutes/rewrites the previous canon.
I propose lorelol.
On November 17 2015 01:59 Requizen wrote: I don't think it's a change at all. It was clear that we never had the full history prior to HotS, so any adding felt fine as long as it didn't invalidate the facts we already had.
In this case it isn't as bad as the original lorelol. Original SC lore actually does have the zerg assimilating other species before the creation of the Overmind, so Primal Zerg aren't impossible. It does seem forced though, just not as forced.
|
On November 17 2015 00:32 AsmodeusXI wrote: As little as I think of the SC2 storyline, I definitely wanted to play LotV's campaign at some point just for funsies.
So what I can't figure out is WHY I CAN'T STOP MYSELF FROM CLICKING SPOILER TAGS.
It's a compulsion. And I can't stop. wwwhhhhyyyyyyyyyyy
Spoiler tags are pretty much "click me" buttons for me.
On November 17 2015 00:50 Requizen wrote:It definitely felt like there was a different team working on the epilogue than was working on the campaigns. So in my mind it went something like this: WoL was a smallish scale. Raynor was trying to get revenge on Kerrigan/save her and make a stand against the Dominion. In the Starcraft universe, at least, that's a relatively small scale, one man's mission. HotS went on a bigger scale. Kerrigan's personal vendetta was bringing the Zerg to heel and taking down Mengsk. Rather than Jim's little rebellion with his fleet, she used the Swarm to attack an entire goverment. LotV went even bigger. It's about saving the soul of the Protoss, and the entire Protoss race is involved in one way or another, and rather than the bad guy just being an evil leader, it's the equivalent to a fallen god. But, it works in the story because of the way the Psychic stuff works in Starcraft. I feel like they just tried to even top that in the epilogue, and it went too big and fell apart because the scope went from a standard Sci Fi universe (a fairly well done standard Sci Fi universe) to something that felt like it came out of a JRPG. I'm just going to choose to not let 3 final missions spoil the other ~60 for me, personally. I also found this thing, which is SC1 done in SC2. While I still have my SC1 and BW discs, I'm kind of excited to play through the story again with the nice new graphics. Of course, it still has all the old cinematics and VOs, so the nostalgia factor is still there.
It's kinda like Gurren Lagan (sp?). That was a great anime.
|
United States15536 Posts
On November 17 2015 02:02 Seuss wrote:Show nested quote +On November 17 2015 01:43 Numy wrote:On November 17 2015 01:39 AsmodeusXI wrote: I was always under the impression that the "original" Zerg were just the larva, and that the Overmind was the Xel'naga's apex creation. By using the adaptability of the Prime Zerg (read: squishy super bugs), the Overmind could start creating the perfect swarm. In that version of the "canon", the Primal Zerg don't really fit.
But again, I'm going off really old memories at this point. Your explanation makes sense, it just doesn't jive with the version I recall. And CURSE YOU PLOT HOLES!!!! Are they still plot holes when they retroactively change the story? Maybe not. We could probably use a new term to describe what's going on. A word for when a story is clearly supposed to be canon and follow from previous canon, but in fact refutes/rewrites the previous canon. I propose lorelol. Show nested quote +On November 17 2015 01:59 Requizen wrote: I don't think it's a change at all. It was clear that we never had the full history prior to HotS, so any adding felt fine as long as it didn't invalidate the facts we already had. In this case it isn't as bad as the original lorelol. Original SC lore actually does have the zerg assimilating other species before the creation of the Overmind, so Primal Zerg aren't impossible. It does seem forced though, just not as forced.
Touche. Shows how good MY memory is.
|
Haha I love how no one in the WoW-verse talks about the sudden inclusion of space travel, and then the complete ignoring of it immediately afterwards.
|
On November 17 2015 02:13 AsmodeusXI wrote:Show nested quote +On November 17 2015 02:02 Seuss wrote:On November 17 2015 01:43 Numy wrote:On November 17 2015 01:39 AsmodeusXI wrote: I was always under the impression that the "original" Zerg were just the larva, and that the Overmind was the Xel'naga's apex creation. By using the adaptability of the Prime Zerg (read: squishy super bugs), the Overmind could start creating the perfect swarm. In that version of the "canon", the Primal Zerg don't really fit.
But again, I'm going off really old memories at this point. Your explanation makes sense, it just doesn't jive with the version I recall. And CURSE YOU PLOT HOLES!!!! Are they still plot holes when they retroactively change the story? Maybe not. We could probably use a new term to describe what's going on. A word for when a story is clearly supposed to be canon and follow from previous canon, but in fact refutes/rewrites the previous canon. I propose lorelol. On November 17 2015 01:59 Requizen wrote: I don't think it's a change at all. It was clear that we never had the full history prior to HotS, so any adding felt fine as long as it didn't invalidate the facts we already had. In this case it isn't as bad as the original lorelol. Original SC lore actually does have the zerg assimilating other species before the creation of the Overmind, so Primal Zerg aren't impossible. It does seem forced though, just not as forced. Touche. Shows how good MY memory is.
I looked it up, so don't feel bad for not remembering something clearly from 17 years ago.
The impression you, myself, and others had that there wasn't room in canon for Primal Zerg is telling. While there was technically space for the Primal Zerg in lore, the way the previous lore was written implicitly made it seem impossible. The working assumption was that all Zerg on Zerus were brought within the Overmind's control, and Primal Zerg defy that assumption even if the old lore was never explicit on that point.
On November 17 2015 02:17 Requizen wrote: Haha I love how no one in the WoW-verse talks about the sudden inclusion of space travel, and then the complete ignoring of it immediately afterwards.
It's all wrapped up in lorelol. We prefer to gloss over that moment in WoW History as much as possible.
|
Meh, Primal Zerg don't bother me overly much. We didn't know everything there was to know about an alien race and made assumptions. Though I'm not one to get wrapped up in little details of a story or retcons as long as it's not egregious.
|
I thought all of WoW History is lorelol and if they ever make War4 it'll decide to disregard the lorelol completely.
|
Yo TL, help a nerd out. What's the best freeware alternative to MATLAB?
I want a personal copy for at home... but damn that is expensive. Anyone used python (x, y), octave, sage, or freemat?
|
On November 17 2015 02:59 iCanada wrote: Yo TL, help a nerd out. What's the best freeware alternative to MATLAB?
I want a personal copy for at home... but damn that is expensive. Anyone used python (x, y), octave, sage, or freemat?
What are you using it for? We used Scilab as an alternate for Engineering stuff.
|
Can't you just pirate it? I did that cuz for some reason the uni only let us use it on their pcs.
|
MATLAB is pretty secure from what I remember
|
On November 17 2015 02:59 iCanada wrote: Yo TL, help a nerd out. What's the best freeware alternative to MATLAB?
I want a personal copy for at home... but damn that is expensive. Anyone used python (x, y), octave, sage, or freemat? Octave. Or pirate it, it's all over the place.
|
On November 17 2015 02:59 iCanada wrote: Yo TL, help a nerd out. What's the best freeware alternative to MATLAB?
I want a personal copy for at home... but damn that is expensive. Anyone used python (x, y), octave, sage, or freemat?
Man, I feel you. I'd love to have access to Lumira and Tableau for personal use instead of trial editions.
|
On November 17 2015 04:30 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On November 17 2015 02:59 iCanada wrote: Yo TL, help a nerd out. What's the best freeware alternative to MATLAB?
I want a personal copy for at home... but damn that is expensive. Anyone used python (x, y), octave, sage, or freemat? Man, I feel you. I'd love to have access to Lumira and Tableau for personal use instead of trial editions. I use Tableau Public a lot. Love it. Not as extensible as the paid edition, but neat enough.
|
Tableau is kinda overrated IMO. It's like a shitty hybrid between Excel and Lumira. Lumira has great data viz but a kinda crappy interface, Excel has a great interface (or I'm just more familiar with it) and meh data viz.
|
On November 17 2015 04:40 ticklishmusic wrote: Tableau is kinda overrated IMO. It's like a shitty hybrid between Excel and Lumira. Lumira has great data viz but a kinda crappy interface, Excel has a great interface (or I'm just more familiar with it) and meh data viz.
I have very little experience with Tableau - we're an SAP shop, so we're familiarizing most with Lumira (which integrates with our Universes very easily). From my limited experience of messing with the Tableau trial, Lumira seems much more user friendly but has less depth (in capability) than Tableau. Lumira also has the added benefits of being able to do data cleansing within the tool rather than having to do it on the data set.
This presents its own set of interesting issues - there's no audit log of what's been changed in the Lumira data set, so it becomes a question of data integrity and security. Also, Lumira is a 64-bit only client.
None of our customers have been onboarded onto Lumira yet, but it's something we're trying to get going. It's more or less on my plate, but it's not something I can work on when other shit keeps getting thrown my way instead. I think it's a very cool product, and customer higher-ups are all like "gimme dem visualizations", but I'm mostly operating in the dark.
edit - we're also working on Geotagging stuff. We've purchased licenses for CMaps (Centigon), which soon has Lumira integration. Supposedly it's supposed to be working now, but the export link doesn't seem to be functioning properly. *shrug* the CEO of Centigon is gonna be here later this week to meet with me/one of our devs to teach us.
|
|
|
|
|
|