On November 06 2015 12:10 Lord Tolkien wrote:+ Show Spoiler +Well, it's about time I addressed it, and since the full copy is out, why not now. To disclaim, I haven't bothered to read the full text of the agreement; I just don't feel like sitting down to read 6000+ pages of technical details. Seriously. But let's break TPP down into several manageable sections. 1) What is TPP, 2) Why is TPP significant, 3) what are the main criticisms of the agreement, 4) What is the expected impact of the agreement? I also suppose 5) What do I think about it, but that will likely be a negligible portion of this. So first, what is TPP? Well, it, in short, it's a comprehensive multilateral free trade agreement (with a wide array of regulatory, framework, currency, and capital implications) that aims to liberalize and free up the trade barriers on Pan-Pacific trade. Last I checked, 12 nations were party to the negotiations and had agreed to the terms, and another 5 had expressed interest (notable nations who are not in either category were China and India). Now, breaking it down, there are several unique components to this (which I will focus on because really, 6000+ pages of shit, and I'm not going to try and figure out all the individual taxes/tariffs they abolish; USTR says it's over 18,000, and I don't feel like bothering to fact-check it). The two most prominent is that it's the first multilateral agreement to establish a common standard for copyright/IP (which is where a number of criticisms stem from), and the second is it includes investor-state dispute settlement mechanisms, that is, provides a legal avenue for investors and companies to seek compensation for lost profits from government actions. Both of these are controversial (the latter despite having been an established part of international public law since NAFTA), the former because of the standards they adopt, and the latter because the continued debate of the degree to which ISDS mechanisms limit the ability and space of governments to manage public goods (healthcare, environment/resource management, etc.). ~~~~ Now, TPP has been the topic of trade analysts for years now, and for good reason. The last major attempt at an agreement on international trade was the WTO's Doha Development Rounds from 2001-2008, which broke down after irreconcilable disputes over agricultural subsidies demanded by developing economies (the leaders of that push are all part of the BRICS currently). The elimination thereof the United States and the EU, particularly France, was adamant against. Since the collapse of Doha, there hasn't been another major multilateral push for trade liberalization on the international stage (with the Eurozone debt crisis continuing to forestall any motion towards further consolidation). The two other major multilateral economic initiatives relevant today are the BRICS Group and the New Development Bank, and the Silk Road Initiative (which is mostly a China thing). Most of these efforts are predominantly financing and investment, and focused instead on development as opposed to trade policy. So in effect, I can't stress how monumental TPP has the potential to revive international trade policy, which has largely languished after the collapse of Doha. Beyond it's comprehensive scope (aiming to resolve IP/Copyright And, of course, it's also singular in the scope of it's intended outcomes; many formerly sacred cows have been killed in the making of this agreement. Japan for instance has eased up on MANY of their previously politically-impervious trade barriers to agricultural produce (the agricultural sector in Japan having a wide, though fading, degree of power in Japanese politics, which had previously allowed them to uphold stringent barriers and regulations on foreign agricultural produce). On a political level, it's the first major effort of the United States to reassert regional leadership in the Pacific Rim (being one of the major steps of the US geostrategic pivot away from Europe towards East Asia), and a fairly crucial one. As China seeks to pour hundreds of billions into developing the Silk Road Economic Belt and Maritime Silk Road (primarily to benefit the Chinese economy, but nonetheless), TPP is a suitably important and comprehensive alternate (though, given they focus on two different economic domains, fairly non-conflicting). ~~~ Now overall, the criticisms of TPP fall under one of several categories. 1) Intellectual Property Rights and Copyright and the Internet, 2) The effect of Copyright enforcement on Medical Costs (in non-US states), 3) Effect on Employment Income Inequality, and 4) Effect on the Environment. There was of course the criticism that the negotiations were being held in secret, but that's honestly a stupid and inane critique of standard diplomatic practice, so I will mostly ignore it. The first two criticisms stem, from the IP/Copyright harmonization clauses, aimed at standardizing IP/Copyright law and enforcement across all TPP nations. These clauses are aimed at bringing TPP nations up to current US copyright law (which is very stringent in it's enforcement). I believe there's also a clause which allows companies to essentially issue a DMCA to ISPs if they see infringing content and search results. That is the crux of what the internet freedom advocates are arguing about; current US copyright/IP law generally favors the copyright/patent holder. + Show Spoiler +The other issue is the issue of patent and copyright extension, at current US legal standards, for pharmaceutical companies in non-US countries, mostly in regards to the creation of generic alternates. The main criticism is that by adopting TPP, non-US companies will have to tighten up on generic drug production, and pay "innovator" price for newly developed medicines (which generally tends to be markedly higher than generics). This ultimately factors into healthcare prices in TPP countries, and can negatively effect medical access in emerging economies. The third critique stems mostly from the standard criticism of free trade agreements (that FTAs negatively affect employment and wage levels). Overall, I've touched upon this before, but this is, first, generally not the case, though there is certainly the possibility of short-term labor disruptions and potentially painful economic readjustment (see the effect of NAFTA on Mexican corn farmers). The fourth critique is again, similar to other criticisms of FTAs, but, more uniquely, of the investor-state dispute settlement mechanism. The argument is that companies will use this to challenge government environmental policies, or other regulatory mechanisms. NatGeo has actually put out an extremely well-done article on the environmental issues of TPP, see below, but TPP has included a number of safeguards clauses with the environment in mind, and has amended the arbitration process to more readily dismiss potential frivolous cases; the question is, as always, enforcement. http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2015/11/151105-TPP-free-trade-wildlife-trafficking-conservation-cites/~~~ I'm pretty tired at this point, so I'll be succinct. Now, what will be the overall impact? In general, TPP aims at improving international trade for small/medium-sized businesses, which is where most of it's economic gain will be found (as with all FTAs, the net economic benefit of TPP will undoubtedly be positive, in terms of GDP and "job creation"). Large corporations will have mostly already circumvented these trade barriers (by establishing foreign subsidiaries), though they will also still benefit. There is the possibility of short term labor market and economic disruptions (and there are always winners and losers in these types of deals), but overall, it's an economic positive. On the environment, it's unclear whether TPP can improve environmental regulation and enforcement. Despite the safeguards, the issue is again enforcing the treaty, and is thus a difficult topic to address. I find the proposed scenario of oil companies suing states for setting up emission standards patently ridiculous. IP/Copyright: yeah, US copyright laws are craptastic and in need of updating. However, the argument that it greatly impacts internet freedom is...dubious to me. Because I live in the United States and use the internet frequently. US IP/copyright laws are not impossible to live with, and just require some navigation. The potential impact on medical and pharmaceutical costs is however something I find to be an entirely valid concern. It is likely that there are a number of provisions in the 6000+ page morass that will attempt to address the issue, but as of now, I will refrain from commenting. I overall view TPP as a highly positive and strategic trade agreement, with some issues that may need to be addressed overall. As an American, I find very little issues with it, as it impacts me. For non-Americans, I would consider reading it further, though I will note that SIGNING a treaty is not the same as RATIFYING a treaty. It's a crucial distinction that a number of the anti-TPP advocacy groups seem to be missing. Ratification may take years in some countries. My personal issues with it are here as well. I believe there's a clause that requires ISP's to give up a clients identity tied to an ip address if there's "reasonable suspicion" of copyright infringement at that address. They then define reasonable suspicion as just the claimant saying "yo we think it's there," no warrant or anything required.
That's massively enabling the lawsuit trolls who completely fuck up peoples lives by "buying" representation rights from media groups, then just stalking trackers and sending "pay us $5000 in costs or we sue for $100000" and sending out hundreds of those letters a day. It's basically nigerian scammer level stuff except people can't afford to ignore it, and most people are too scared to realise they're full of shit, or too poor to afford to actually fight the claim.
This change would make that so ridiculously easy that I fear it would just start happening everywhere.
Not to mention how irritating it would be if youtube level DMCA claims applied to the entire internet.
|