|
On November 06 2015 01:53 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 01:50 Seuss wrote: Delaying flight until the end of the latest expansion was, I think, a fantastic move by Blizzard. It wasn't enough on its own to bring that "WoW" feeling (as you put it) back, but it was a step in that direction.
Not all of the streamlining has had unfortunate side effects, and some of the streamlining that did was arguable a net positive regardless. The problem is that once it's all added up you have a game that's wasting a feature that really separates it from most of its competition, the wholeness of its world, and at the same time is arguably as/less social than LoL solo queue.
That's probably the most complicated design problem in gaming history though. How do you make an MMO's world meaningful and its players feel emergently compelled to engage in social activity while also streamlining the game so it doesn't require a ridiculous time investment. I loved a lot of the streamlining they did. Each time they added some new features I'd be like "sweet this is going to make things so much easier". Then in a few months you just don't feel attached to the game anymore. The social aspect of multiplayer games is so interesting. It's both the things we hate and yet need. We love the idea of it being streamlined to be easier but at the same time doing that too much results us no longer feeling attachment to the game. It's just truly fascinating problem and we actually have a history we can look at with regards to these things. I wish they'd maybe did some more data capturing while it was going on to figure it out.
What kinds of things would you have liked to see, data-wise? How could community interaction be quantified?
First thing that comes to mind is count of public messages (Trade, LFG, etc.) - I'm sure it's GREATLY diminished since the advent of the streamlining functions.
|
I never played WoW, but travel in vanilla Maplestory was a pain. You had to wait 30 minutes for a stupid airship, fly on the airship for 15 minutes (where coincidentally one of the strongest monsters in the game would spawn to troll you) to move from one continent to the other.
Oh, and that shit was expensive too.
|
On November 06 2015 01:58 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 01:53 Numy wrote:On November 06 2015 01:50 Seuss wrote: Delaying flight until the end of the latest expansion was, I think, a fantastic move by Blizzard. It wasn't enough on its own to bring that "WoW" feeling (as you put it) back, but it was a step in that direction.
Not all of the streamlining has had unfortunate side effects, and some of the streamlining that did was arguable a net positive regardless. The problem is that once it's all added up you have a game that's wasting a feature that really separates it from most of its competition, the wholeness of its world, and at the same time is arguably as/less social than LoL solo queue.
That's probably the most complicated design problem in gaming history though. How do you make an MMO's world meaningful and its players feel emergently compelled to engage in social activity while also streamlining the game so it doesn't require a ridiculous time investment. I loved a lot of the streamlining they did. Each time they added some new features I'd be like "sweet this is going to make things so much easier". Then in a few months you just don't feel attached to the game anymore. The social aspect of multiplayer games is so interesting. It's both the things we hate and yet need. We love the idea of it being streamlined to be easier but at the same time doing that too much results us no longer feeling attachment to the game. It's just truly fascinating problem and we actually have a history we can look at with regards to these things. I wish they'd maybe did some more data capturing while it was going on to figure it out. What kinds of things would you have liked to see, data-wise? How could community interaction be quantified? First thing that comes to mind is count of public messages (Trade, LFG, etc.) - I'm sure it's GREATLY diminished since the advent of the streamlining functions.
stuff like how active the channels were, how active people were talking to each other outside of guild, on average how long did people spend not actively doing anything (queueing/fighting) in the game, how many new players did people interact with and how many new relationships were retained from this meeting etc. Stuff like that I think can be both super interesting or super boring lol
|
On November 06 2015 02:05 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 01:58 jcarlsoniv wrote:On November 06 2015 01:53 Numy wrote:On November 06 2015 01:50 Seuss wrote: Delaying flight until the end of the latest expansion was, I think, a fantastic move by Blizzard. It wasn't enough on its own to bring that "WoW" feeling (as you put it) back, but it was a step in that direction.
Not all of the streamlining has had unfortunate side effects, and some of the streamlining that did was arguable a net positive regardless. The problem is that once it's all added up you have a game that's wasting a feature that really separates it from most of its competition, the wholeness of its world, and at the same time is arguably as/less social than LoL solo queue.
That's probably the most complicated design problem in gaming history though. How do you make an MMO's world meaningful and its players feel emergently compelled to engage in social activity while also streamlining the game so it doesn't require a ridiculous time investment. I loved a lot of the streamlining they did. Each time they added some new features I'd be like "sweet this is going to make things so much easier". Then in a few months you just don't feel attached to the game anymore. The social aspect of multiplayer games is so interesting. It's both the things we hate and yet need. We love the idea of it being streamlined to be easier but at the same time doing that too much results us no longer feeling attachment to the game. It's just truly fascinating problem and we actually have a history we can look at with regards to these things. I wish they'd maybe did some more data capturing while it was going on to figure it out. What kinds of things would you have liked to see, data-wise? How could community interaction be quantified? First thing that comes to mind is count of public messages (Trade, LFG, etc.) - I'm sure it's GREATLY diminished since the advent of the streamlining functions. stuff like how active the channels were, how active people were talking to each other outside of guild, on average how long did people spend not actively doing anything (queueing/fighting) in the game, how many new players did people interact with and how many new relationships were retained from this meeting etc. Stuff like that I think can be both super interesting or super boring lol
I think the thing I'd be most interested in seeing would be how that kind of stuff would be captured in the back end. And I agree with all of those data points being potentially interesting. But all of the analysis in the world still relies on figuring out the issue that Seuss pointed out - how do you make sure people are engaged in the world without making things too onerous?
|
On November 06 2015 02:01 ticklishmusic wrote: I never played WoW, but travel in vanilla Maplestory was a pain. You had to wait 30 minutes for a stupid airship, fly on the airship for 15 minutes (where coincidentally one of the strongest monsters in the game would spawn to troll you) to move from one continent to the other.
Oh, and that shit was expensive too. honestly, playing vanilla maplestory was a pain. i remember it taking weeks to get to like level 20
|
tolk im getting more nervous about the TPP and need that recap! ive been patient! the major points surrounding net neutrality/anonymity concern me and the parts about trade confuse me.
|
On November 06 2015 02:25 ComaDose wrote: tolk im getting more nervous about the TPP and need that recap! ive been patient! the major points surrounding net neutrality/anonymity concern me and the parts about trade confuse me.
It seems like everyone is getting nervous about TPP, especially the internet/copyright stuff. I mean I'll be owned by China soon so it's not that big a deal for me but if it disrupts content production it'll be sad.
|
On November 06 2015 00:24 phyvo wrote:So Monte roped me in to playing Vanilla WoW on a private server with him. It got me thinking and I decided to check out the first few levels of current WoW since it's free anyway and I haven't played since the launch of Cataclysm. I started laughing when mobs that just yesterday I had been fighting for 15 seconds each went down in two key presses. Random NPCs teleporting me around for the sake of convenience. Druids running around in cat form before level 20. It actually being nearly impossible to die from you pulling more aggro than you intended. Everything super streamlined so that you can get as many dings as possible in a short amount of time. I don't know what to think, honestly, it's like two different universes. Show nested quote +On November 05 2015 23:16 Ketara wrote: Isn't the preseason on the PBE?
Why do we have two threads for the same thing. Someone thought the changes were big enough to merit their own thread. Can't let the PBE thread have actual traffic, the world might explode! The preseason changes were announced before PBE was updated.
|
On November 06 2015 03:16 Ansibled wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 00:24 phyvo wrote:So Monte roped me in to playing Vanilla WoW on a private server with him. It got me thinking and I decided to check out the first few levels of current WoW since it's free anyway and I haven't played since the launch of Cataclysm. I started laughing when mobs that just yesterday I had been fighting for 15 seconds each went down in two key presses. Random NPCs teleporting me around for the sake of convenience. Druids running around in cat form before level 20. It actually being nearly impossible to die from you pulling more aggro than you intended. Everything super streamlined so that you can get as many dings as possible in a short amount of time. I don't know what to think, honestly, it's like two different universes. On November 05 2015 23:16 Ketara wrote: Isn't the preseason on the PBE?
Why do we have two threads for the same thing. Someone thought the changes were big enough to merit their own thread. Can't let the PBE thread have actual traffic, the world might explode! The preseason changes were announced before PBE was updated. Not to mention that ever since 5.20 the PBE has been minor touches here and there with nothing excited. =\
On November 06 2015 00:55 Requizen wrote: lol is everyone suddenly getting the WoW itch again? Nope. The only thing that could have brought me back to WoW was demon hunters and they came out an expansion too late. I'm not buying 2 expansions so I can play a demon hunter on a game I'd struggle to afford the sub for.
|
On November 06 2015 02:07 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 02:05 Numy wrote:On November 06 2015 01:58 jcarlsoniv wrote:On November 06 2015 01:53 Numy wrote:On November 06 2015 01:50 Seuss wrote: Delaying flight until the end of the latest expansion was, I think, a fantastic move by Blizzard. It wasn't enough on its own to bring that "WoW" feeling (as you put it) back, but it was a step in that direction.
Not all of the streamlining has had unfortunate side effects, and some of the streamlining that did was arguable a net positive regardless. The problem is that once it's all added up you have a game that's wasting a feature that really separates it from most of its competition, the wholeness of its world, and at the same time is arguably as/less social than LoL solo queue.
That's probably the most complicated design problem in gaming history though. How do you make an MMO's world meaningful and its players feel emergently compelled to engage in social activity while also streamlining the game so it doesn't require a ridiculous time investment. I loved a lot of the streamlining they did. Each time they added some new features I'd be like "sweet this is going to make things so much easier". Then in a few months you just don't feel attached to the game anymore. The social aspect of multiplayer games is so interesting. It's both the things we hate and yet need. We love the idea of it being streamlined to be easier but at the same time doing that too much results us no longer feeling attachment to the game. It's just truly fascinating problem and we actually have a history we can look at with regards to these things. I wish they'd maybe did some more data capturing while it was going on to figure it out. What kinds of things would you have liked to see, data-wise? How could community interaction be quantified? First thing that comes to mind is count of public messages (Trade, LFG, etc.) - I'm sure it's GREATLY diminished since the advent of the streamlining functions. stuff like how active the channels were, how active people were talking to each other outside of guild, on average how long did people spend not actively doing anything (queueing/fighting) in the game, how many new players did people interact with and how many new relationships were retained from this meeting etc. Stuff like that I think can be both super interesting or super boring lol I think the thing I'd be most interested in seeing would be how that kind of stuff would be captured in the back end. And I agree with all of those data points being potentially interesting. But all of the analysis in the world still relies on figuring out the issue that Seuss pointed out - how do you make sure people are engaged in the world without making things too onerous?
Stated another way, you want your players to form social connections in the game and to hang out in the game to maintain those connections. The problem is that the former is primarily accomplished through adversity (e.g. tough quests/dungeons, having to form dungeon groups manually etc.) and the latter primarily through grinds (i.e. if everyone is online all the time because they're grinding then the game is the place to hang out because that's where everyone already is).
If you want to quantify community interaction the most important data points are those which indicate when a player formed a bond and those which indicate when the bond broke or petered out.
|
On November 06 2015 03:41 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 03:16 Ansibled wrote:On November 06 2015 00:24 phyvo wrote:So Monte roped me in to playing Vanilla WoW on a private server with him. It got me thinking and I decided to check out the first few levels of current WoW since it's free anyway and I haven't played since the launch of Cataclysm. I started laughing when mobs that just yesterday I had been fighting for 15 seconds each went down in two key presses. Random NPCs teleporting me around for the sake of convenience. Druids running around in cat form before level 20. It actually being nearly impossible to die from you pulling more aggro than you intended. Everything super streamlined so that you can get as many dings as possible in a short amount of time. I don't know what to think, honestly, it's like two different universes. On November 05 2015 23:16 Ketara wrote: Isn't the preseason on the PBE?
Why do we have two threads for the same thing. Someone thought the changes were big enough to merit their own thread. Can't let the PBE thread have actual traffic, the world might explode! The preseason changes were announced before PBE was updated. Not to mention that ever since 5.20 the PBE has been minor touches here and there with nothing excited. =\ Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 00:55 Requizen wrote: lol is everyone suddenly getting the WoW itch again? Nope. The only thing that could have brought me back to WoW was demon hunters and they came out an expansion too late. I'm not buying 2 expansions so I can play a demon hunter on a game I'd struggle to afford the sub for. you cant actually struggle to pay $30 a month can you? i bought $11 smokes $12 lunch and $8 5 pack of dvds today at lunch....
rereading made me realize i sounded insensitive but i ment a dollar a day is less than a coffee kinda thing.
i swear guys im not an asshole
|
|
|
On November 06 2015 04:30 ComaDose wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 03:41 Gahlo wrote:On November 06 2015 03:16 Ansibled wrote:On November 06 2015 00:24 phyvo wrote:So Monte roped me in to playing Vanilla WoW on a private server with him. It got me thinking and I decided to check out the first few levels of current WoW since it's free anyway and I haven't played since the launch of Cataclysm. I started laughing when mobs that just yesterday I had been fighting for 15 seconds each went down in two key presses. Random NPCs teleporting me around for the sake of convenience. Druids running around in cat form before level 20. It actually being nearly impossible to die from you pulling more aggro than you intended. Everything super streamlined so that you can get as many dings as possible in a short amount of time. I don't know what to think, honestly, it's like two different universes. On November 05 2015 23:16 Ketara wrote: Isn't the preseason on the PBE?
Why do we have two threads for the same thing. Someone thought the changes were big enough to merit their own thread. Can't let the PBE thread have actual traffic, the world might explode! The preseason changes were announced before PBE was updated. Not to mention that ever since 5.20 the PBE has been minor touches here and there with nothing excited. =\ On November 06 2015 00:55 Requizen wrote: lol is everyone suddenly getting the WoW itch again? Nope. The only thing that could have brought me back to WoW was demon hunters and they came out an expansion too late. I'm not buying 2 expansions so I can play a demon hunter on a game I'd struggle to afford the sub for. you cant actually struggle to pay $30 a month can you? i bought $11 smokes $12 lunch and $8 5 pack of dvds today at lunch.... rereading made me realize i sounded insensitive but i ment a dollar a day is less than a coffee kinda thing. i swear guys im not an asshole Lol coma. Gahlo seems to be on the employement struggle bus IIRC.
More importantly why are you buying smokes.
|
I have enough gold to play WoW for free for the next 4 years, possibly more. It depends on whether Blizzard continues goldflation in Legion or if they manage to curb it. I suspect that WoWToken prices will briefly rise as players resub, before plummeting as players sell tokens in order to get gold for shiny things in Legion. So long as Blizzard doesn't make class halls Garrisons 2: The Regarrisoning gold deflation might even be a thing.
|
On November 06 2015 04:42 mordek wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 04:30 ComaDose wrote:On November 06 2015 03:41 Gahlo wrote:On November 06 2015 03:16 Ansibled wrote:On November 06 2015 00:24 phyvo wrote:So Monte roped me in to playing Vanilla WoW on a private server with him. It got me thinking and I decided to check out the first few levels of current WoW since it's free anyway and I haven't played since the launch of Cataclysm. I started laughing when mobs that just yesterday I had been fighting for 15 seconds each went down in two key presses. Random NPCs teleporting me around for the sake of convenience. Druids running around in cat form before level 20. It actually being nearly impossible to die from you pulling more aggro than you intended. Everything super streamlined so that you can get as many dings as possible in a short amount of time. I don't know what to think, honestly, it's like two different universes. On November 05 2015 23:16 Ketara wrote: Isn't the preseason on the PBE?
Why do we have two threads for the same thing. Someone thought the changes were big enough to merit their own thread. Can't let the PBE thread have actual traffic, the world might explode! The preseason changes were announced before PBE was updated. Not to mention that ever since 5.20 the PBE has been minor touches here and there with nothing excited. =\ On November 06 2015 00:55 Requizen wrote: lol is everyone suddenly getting the WoW itch again? Nope. The only thing that could have brought me back to WoW was demon hunters and they came out an expansion too late. I'm not buying 2 expansions so I can play a demon hunter on a game I'd struggle to afford the sub for. you cant actually struggle to pay $30 a month can you? i bought $11 smokes $12 lunch and $8 5 pack of dvds today at lunch.... rereading made me realize i sounded insensitive but i ment a dollar a day is less than a coffee kinda thing. i swear guys im not an asshole Lol coma. Gahlo seems to be on the employement struggle bus IIRC. More importantly why are you buying smokes. okay well now i feel worse for busting a job hunters balls.
and because im addicted and it makes me feel good curves my appetite, releases endorphins, gives me a break from work, im in the habbit, i enjoy the taste, i socialize with other smokers, and they say i have little appreciation for self preservation.
can i have some gold monte?
|
I'm not a bank, I'm a Montebank.
|
On November 06 2015 04:50 Seuss wrote: I'm not a bank, I'm a Montebank. omg is that where you got your name from?! how slow am i?!
also.... *undoes button* im sure we can work something out where i can earn some gold
|
On November 06 2015 04:30 ComaDose wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 03:41 Gahlo wrote:On November 06 2015 03:16 Ansibled wrote:On November 06 2015 00:24 phyvo wrote:So Monte roped me in to playing Vanilla WoW on a private server with him. It got me thinking and I decided to check out the first few levels of current WoW since it's free anyway and I haven't played since the launch of Cataclysm. I started laughing when mobs that just yesterday I had been fighting for 15 seconds each went down in two key presses. Random NPCs teleporting me around for the sake of convenience. Druids running around in cat form before level 20. It actually being nearly impossible to die from you pulling more aggro than you intended. Everything super streamlined so that you can get as many dings as possible in a short amount of time. I don't know what to think, honestly, it's like two different universes. On November 05 2015 23:16 Ketara wrote: Isn't the preseason on the PBE?
Why do we have two threads for the same thing. Someone thought the changes were big enough to merit their own thread. Can't let the PBE thread have actual traffic, the world might explode! The preseason changes were announced before PBE was updated. Not to mention that ever since 5.20 the PBE has been minor touches here and there with nothing excited. =\ On November 06 2015 00:55 Requizen wrote: lol is everyone suddenly getting the WoW itch again? Nope. The only thing that could have brought me back to WoW was demon hunters and they came out an expansion too late. I'm not buying 2 expansions so I can play a demon hunter on a game I'd struggle to afford the sub for. you cant actually struggle to pay $30 a month can you? i bought $11 smokes $12 lunch and $8 5 pack of dvds today at lunch.... rereading made me realize i sounded insensitive but i ment a dollar a day is less than a coffee kinda thing. i swear guys im not an asshole I haven't had a real job in close to 2 years now. Currently I work for my parents doing repair/renovation on a couple of their properties in exchange for rent, enough money to pay my bills, gas, and the government standard food estimation for a single person. Anything I want to buy funwise comes out of eating money. WoW is not worth even more PB&J when I can play TOR, an mmo I like better, for free.
|
No, Montegomery is just a pseudonym I've been using since I started playing LoL. It just happens to lend itself to lots of fun puns.
|
On November 06 2015 05:01 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2015 04:30 ComaDose wrote:On November 06 2015 03:41 Gahlo wrote:On November 06 2015 03:16 Ansibled wrote:On November 06 2015 00:24 phyvo wrote:So Monte roped me in to playing Vanilla WoW on a private server with him. It got me thinking and I decided to check out the first few levels of current WoW since it's free anyway and I haven't played since the launch of Cataclysm. I started laughing when mobs that just yesterday I had been fighting for 15 seconds each went down in two key presses. Random NPCs teleporting me around for the sake of convenience. Druids running around in cat form before level 20. It actually being nearly impossible to die from you pulling more aggro than you intended. Everything super streamlined so that you can get as many dings as possible in a short amount of time. I don't know what to think, honestly, it's like two different universes. On November 05 2015 23:16 Ketara wrote: Isn't the preseason on the PBE?
Why do we have two threads for the same thing. Someone thought the changes were big enough to merit their own thread. Can't let the PBE thread have actual traffic, the world might explode! The preseason changes were announced before PBE was updated. Not to mention that ever since 5.20 the PBE has been minor touches here and there with nothing excited. =\ On November 06 2015 00:55 Requizen wrote: lol is everyone suddenly getting the WoW itch again? Nope. The only thing that could have brought me back to WoW was demon hunters and they came out an expansion too late. I'm not buying 2 expansions so I can play a demon hunter on a game I'd struggle to afford the sub for. you cant actually struggle to pay $30 a month can you? i bought $11 smokes $12 lunch and $8 5 pack of dvds today at lunch.... rereading made me realize i sounded insensitive but i ment a dollar a day is less than a coffee kinda thing. i swear guys im not an asshole I haven't had a real job in close to 2 years now. Currently I work for my parents doing repair/renovation on a couple of their properties in exchange for rent, enough money to pay my bills, gas, and the government standard food estimation for a single person. Anything I want to buy funwise comes out of eating money. WoW is not worth even more PB&J when I can play TOR, an mmo I like better, for free.
To be fair, PB&J is delicious
|
|
|
|
|
|