|
wow I may actually try this with my friend We have been playing random shit lately like: LOTR TCG, game of thrones risk, starcraft risk, game of thrones card game, and this seems to fit right up that alley.
|
On March 31 2016 23:32 ComaDose wrote:wow I may actually try this with my friend  We have been playing random shit lately like: LOTR TCG, game of thrones risk, starcraft risk, game of thrones card game, and this seems to fit right up that alley.
someone create something in cockatrice or whatever magic shit you guys use and I'd play this
|
On March 31 2016 23:40 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 31 2016 23:32 ComaDose wrote:wow I may actually try this with my friend  We have been playing random shit lately like: LOTR TCG, game of thrones risk, starcraft risk, game of thrones card game, and this seems to fit right up that alley. someone create something in cockatrice or whatever magic shit you guys use and I'd play this This seems like a fun idea actually. Not sure how to convert those image files into something usable by cockatrice. Mebbe I'll look into it.
Edit: Google was my friend. http://www.magicmultiverse.net/cardsets/358 Looks like an older version though than the one Gahlo linked but I'm sure it's still good.
Dunno where Yangers has been lately but he's pretty good with cockatrice...Numy I think you are as well? Want to help set this up?
Edit x2: Wow look at how many of these there are. Coma if this is something you're really interested in without getting into MTG itself this appears to be the place. http://www.magicmultiverse.net/cardsets
|
wow some of those seem really cool! yeah I remember the basics of how to play magic from when I used to mess around with my friends and our jank decks in middle school so it would be fun to try these things even tho I have no motivation or desire to invest in the "real" game.
|
I'm not a fan just because they balanced that out of creating 25 one-ofs for each deck, basically. When you look at the card individually I'm sure it looks flavorful, but I don't really feel it in a deck... save maybe for Zerg because they're going to shit "zergling" tokens either way. Power level seems strange too with cards I'd have expected to cost 1 more for Z.
|
United States47024 Posts
I'd rather draft them in a Cube instead of playing them as-is anyway.
EDIT: Man there are some huge flavor fails here. Mutalisk is just asking to have "Whenever <this> deals combat damage to a creature, it deals 1 damage to each of up to 2 other target creatures." How does the ETB discard fit at all?
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
|
They said it's for the "harass" aspect, so I guess reducing the opponent's ressources when they come into play is supposed to fit the "hit-and-run" idea.
I find the constant face-turning of Terran cards super clunky though. Sure, in a way it fits the setup time of transforming units and spider mines, but forcing you to go facedown and paying a bunch of mana every time is weird, and iirc the whole "give a permanent a bonus then change it into something else" doesn't work (came up during a draft when a guy with a Kor Skyclimber had a Deceiver of Forms in play, in response to the trigger he paid to give flying to the Skyclimber, but apparently becoming the revealed creature "erases" these transient bonuses).
I think it'd fit Zerg more, as the burrow mechanic, and I don't like the Lurker at all for example. On the other hand I guess it's the least wordy version of the Spider Mine. I'd have seen it as an artifact that deals X damage between target attacking creatures without flying when you sac it, but their version is more or less the same (for setup time you could have it enter play tapped, require its ability to tap on top of the cost and sac, and give it flash, but it gets wordy).
Or just make the siege tank a 3/4 with "when ~ attacks, you may pay X. If you do, it gains +3/-3 and trample [or menace] until end of turn, it doesn't untap during your next untap step" to figure that it has huge damage and AoE in siege mode but gets much more vulnerable. Maybe offer to pay Y during your untap step to untap it (but it gets super wordy). You may do away with the tap/untap clause I guess, since the "when ~ attacks" part makes sure you commit to the siege mode to begin with. Also synergy with defensive matrix to defend it this way.
|
United States47024 Posts
They should just be Innistrad-style flip cards, tbh. They don't make any sense as Morphs.
I get WHY they used Morph (had some cloaking units and needed sufficient number of them for the "hidden" aspect to be meaningful) but really, the gameplay of flip cards just fits much better.
|
LLL - "Hey look at this cool adaptation"
Yango - "Nah it's stupid."
|
They also said they didn't use Innistrad-style double-faced cards because they're much harder to proxy for testing and stuff. C'mon Yango, there's a lot of things I disagree with in their design, but if you don't read the fine print that won't help you. 
Elusive Tormentor-style card for the Ghost's nuclear strike! Actually, just giving them Skulk and an activated ability to make them hexproof (which figures the cloaking better I think) would probably fit the stealth aspect better. But then they'd synergise too well with the combat tricks and other instant buffs I guess. Still better power-wise than what they went for. D:
|
United States47024 Posts
Bunker is another huge flavor fail here. They could easily have gone for the "infantry gets inside and attacks from it" mechanic--something like:
"When Bunker enters the battlefield, exile target Soldier creature you control until Bunker leaves the battlefield.
Bunker's power is equal to the exiled creature's power."
Bunker being a 0/5 with no interaction with infantry doesn't make any sense.
On April 01 2016 02:09 Alaric wrote: They also said they didn't use Innistrad-style double-faced cards because they're much harder too proxy for testing and stuff. Oh I read that, I just don't think that's a valid excuse when Cockatrice exists.
And yes, Elusive Tormentor was exactly what I was thinking of for cloaking units.
|
Bunker as a way to wall off your base, then getting salvaged once you don't need it anymore and because it blocks the ramp. Remember they're mostly using SC2's flavour and usage over Broodwar (which is part of what I disagree with).
Your take on the bunker fits W a lot better with the exile/blink mechanic too. The way they try to justify the SCV annoys me a bit. "It gives 3 mana, it synergises with Morph and Salvage!" Well, no, because you paid 2 mana to activate that ability anyway, so it's just slight ramp.
|
United States47024 Posts
Also, if they REALLY cared so much about how easy cards are to proxy, it's still not an excuse for not using flip cards, because Kamigawa-style flip cards also exist.
|
Didn't they say a lot of the choices ended up sacrificing flavour for playability?
Sure they could have made every unit identical to sc2 stats, but it probably wouldn't be that fun to play, and they claim to have made an actual enjoyable game. Maybe give it a try before discarding it :p
|
United States47024 Posts
On April 01 2016 02:24 killerdog wrote: Didn't they say a lot of the choices ended up sacrificing flavour for playability? I totally dismiss the idea that flavor has to be sacrificed for playability. The sets with the best flavor pretty much have always tended to play well, and the ones that ostensibly sacrifice one for the other actually just end up being shit at both.
|
So where does Kamigawa end up on that scale?
|
United States47024 Posts
Great flavor, plays well in Limited aside from the fact that Jitte exists.
Gets a bad rep from Standard but it was pretty much impossible for a Standard rotation containing Mirrodin block to not suck.
|
On April 01 2016 02:45 TheYango wrote: Great flavor, plays well in Limited aside from the fact that Jitte exists.
Gets a bad rep from Standard but it was pretty much impossible for a Standard rotation containing Mirrodin block to not suck.
Kamigawa/rav1 block was pretty great. I loved dying to all the top deck burn spells and hands of honor/demise.
Edit: don't forget intruder alarm/forbidden orchard/fireball decks!
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
You guys should download miitomo on the app store and add me.
|
|
|
|
|
|