Well, my good Canadian lad.
That. Will. Not. Stand!
| Forum Index > The Shopkeeper′s Inn |
|
Alaric
France45622 Posts
March 29 2016 22:02 GMT
#22521
Well, my good Canadian lad. That. Will. Not. Stand! | ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12084 Posts
March 29 2016 22:06 GMT
#22522
On March 30 2016 06:52 Eppa! wrote: Show nested quote + On March 30 2016 06:47 Lord Tolkien wrote: When I meant hilariously over-proportioned, I mean in other ways. Mostly below the belt. **cough** There's a slight difference between characters like Tryndamere or Kratos or Tycho (or the original, Dukem Nukem) to the typical cases of oversexualized females in video games: those designs tend to appeal, more-so to the "alpha male fantasy" of generally heterosexual straight males of the video game demographic than for any sex appeal. Taste is pretty personal and calling over sexuallized men in video games a male power fantasy isn't a good argument. While I would generally agree, all of these characters stem from the old Duke Nukem trope and design, which with any familiarity with the series (and its descent into self-parodying its take on women and the character as the ultimate "stud") would basically highlight the design as an impossibly idealized "heterosexual straight man" who gets all the ladies. It is entirely likely that women and some gay men will find it attractive, but that's the root of the character design and general inspiration for all of these characters. Even, in the case of Kratos, the same descent into self-parody (because seriously, the plot of GOWII and III turned the series into a parody of the interesting story-line and character depth of the first) On March 30 2016 07:02 TheYango wrote: Show nested quote + On March 30 2016 06:00 Lord Tolkien wrote: The complaint seemed mostly to be focused on the pose not being a good fit for the character and tends towards the overall problem with the video game (or at least, the AAA industry) in homogenously blending female characterizations together through sexualization. This argument would be more convincing if there weren't far greater instances of "not a good fit for the character" in past instances of sexualized Blizzard heroines that managed to fly under the radar. The Warcraft and Starcraft mythos are chock-full of sexualized female character designs. Why is this only a problem now in a relatively minor instance? Hell, I'd argue the total shift in Kerrigan's character going from BW to SC2's plot was "not a good fit for the character". There's been greater effort among the gaming industry to be inclusive new minority audiences, and in general the growth of the industry is now found among aforementioned audience (predominantly women, whom were largely left out at the time of the WC3 and SC1/2 series). One of the overarching design goal of Overwatch was to create a diverse and inclusive cast of characters for all people, which is why the issue now arises. The WC series and SC series were designed with a primarily heterosexual, male audience in mind (which was the standard for video gaming at the time and for much of the decades since they separated video games into the toy section for boys). | ||
|
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
March 29 2016 22:11 GMT
#22523
| ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
March 29 2016 22:12 GMT
#22524
That's not to say that the overall cause of gender equality is bad, it's very good. Just think in this instance it's less about the greater good and more the usual internet bandwagon. edit: I also don't understand your SC2/BW argument. Are you saying that the original BW had vastly superior female writing because it was targeted solely at heterosexual males but the new story was targeted at a broader audience so they destroyed a strong female lead? | ||
|
Eppa!
Sweden4641 Posts
March 29 2016 22:16 GMT
#22525
| ||
|
Seuss
United States10536 Posts
March 29 2016 22:16 GMT
#22526
On March 30 2016 07:11 TheYango wrote: You're going to have a hard time convincing me that a competitive team shooter is targeted at a more diverse casual audience than WoW or Hearthstone which both have more egregious instances of this. When I play Overwatch with my EJ peeps close to half of them are girls. *shrug* Edit: This sort of topic has been done to death in regards to movies, television, sports, STEM, and other nonsense. If you walk into things with a "currently only white males between the ages of 10 and 27 like this, therefore nobody else can or will ever like this" you're going to perpetuate that dynamic unnecessarily. | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
March 29 2016 22:18 GMT
#22527
On March 30 2016 07:16 Seuss wrote: Show nested quote + On March 30 2016 07:11 TheYango wrote: You're going to have a hard time convincing me that a competitive team shooter is targeted at a more diverse casual audience than WoW or Hearthstone which both have more egregious instances of this. When I play Overwatch with my EJ peeps close to half of them are girls. *shrug* Hey buddy | ||
|
TheHumanSensation
Canada1210 Posts
March 29 2016 22:18 GMT
#22528
On March 30 2016 07:11 TheYango wrote: You're going to have a hard time convincing me that a competitive team shooter is targeted at a more diverse casual audience than WoW or Hearthstone which both have more egregious instances of this. The key component here is understanding that blizzard doesn't really know what they're doing. It's not that they can't design characters or games etc., but rather that a few of their employees are probably vaguely familiar with "SJW narratives" without actually being very engaged in social justice work themselves. This causes their end product to be a weird botched amalgamation of [what it was originally going to be] + [Blizzard's collective interpretation of social justice ideas]. Then their explanations for their actions are also weird and inconsistent because they don't really understand why they did what they did. This is really, really common, and isn't a pattern exclusive to blizzard or video games specifically. | ||
|
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
March 29 2016 22:23 GMT
#22529
On March 30 2016 07:18 TheHumanSensation wrote: The key component here is understanding that blizzard doesn't really know what they're doing. We have a winner. | ||
|
Skitter
United States899 Posts
March 29 2016 22:24 GMT
#22530
| ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12084 Posts
March 29 2016 22:30 GMT
#22531
On March 30 2016 07:11 TheYango wrote: You're going to have a hard time convincing me that a competitive team shooter is targeted at a more diverse casual audience than WoW or Hearthstone which both have more egregious instances of this. iunno, anything that isn't a strategy game seems casual to me :twitchmeme:. More seriously, WoW was designed waaaay back when, before inclusion became an issue and a focus for the industry. Mass Effect 2 wasn't published until..2010? Skyrim, 2011? That's generally where the discussion about female and LGBT inclusion in the gaming industry actually started to take off. WoW was, what...2004? Starcraft 2 released in 2010, but anounced in 2007 (and Blizzard has notoriously long development times). In regards to Hearthstone, online CCGs weren't a very popular genre until it's release, and I'm not sure if they actually expected it to blow up as it did. It's certainly casual as far as card games go, but card games aren't necessarily easy if you don't have experience in them or the genre itself, and beyond that, the Card Game community was a comparatively small group when they started work on it. OTOH, FPSes are an extraordinarily popular genre in the West (particularly the US), and also has an absolutely notorious record (from console FPSes) for having a highly sexist (or at least immature) crowd. With that in mind, I don't find it hard to believe that Blizzard focused extra attention on trying to make it a much more inclusive and well-designed (character-wise) game than their previous titles, especially given the development of Overwatch was probably started around the time inclusivity became a serious issue in the industry. Hence, an actually superb (from what I can see) and diverse set of character designs. @ Numy: I believe it was a male who posted that initial complaint. Either way, though. | ||
|
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
March 29 2016 22:34 GMT
#22532
On March 30 2016 07:30 Lord Tolkien wrote: OTOH, FPSes are an extraordinarily popular genre in the West (particularly the US), and also has an absolutely notorious record (from console FPSes) for having a highly sexist (or at least immature) crowd. And the CCG community doesn't? Fucking please. | ||
|
AlterKot
Poland7525 Posts
March 29 2016 22:37 GMT
#22533
| ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12084 Posts
March 29 2016 22:50 GMT
#22534
On March 30 2016 07:34 TheYango wrote: Show nested quote + On March 30 2016 07:30 Lord Tolkien wrote: OTOH, FPSes are an extraordinarily popular genre in the West (particularly the US), and also has an absolutely notorious record (from console FPSes) for having a highly sexist (or at least immature) crowd. And the CCG community doesn't? Fucking please. It did spawn Reynad, so I'm not disagreeing. That being said, the relative size of the two genres (and how relatively well-known they were as cesspools) are entirely different, as well as CCGs being primarily mechanics driven (with quite a number of HS's art appropriated from outside Blizzard, and retouched) and there being, comparatively little need for aesthetic character design involved due to previous WC games establishing most of the designs already (Jaina and Valeera are, well, busty females because of previous lore, comics, video games, etc.). OW, by contrast, is a new series/IP, so they have the opportunity to start fresh, and they've clearly focused a LOT of design resources on it. On March 30 2016 07:37 AlterKot wrote: My personal theory is that people at Blizzard were internally arguing about this and at first someone convinced someone else to put that pose in the game, but then the other person used the feedback as proof that he was right about this pose not fitting the character. My theory is that the pose was added because they were trying to fill out cosmetics for full release and just got lazy and copied it from some other character. Fear the Kennen reskins. | ||
|
Crusnik
United States5378 Posts
March 29 2016 22:51 GMT
#22535
On March 30 2016 06:10 Numy wrote: Aesthetics over practicality is hardly a female only thing. Why practicality is even an issue eludes me. If the game isn't trying to mirror reality then it doesn't need to adhere to anything it doesn't want to. That's how fantasy works. The author gets to decide the rules of their universe. Sure boob armour is dumb but I don't mind it in certain settings. It's the same as those huge baddass armour you see on male characters to me. They both dumb but both have their place in certain stories. I just think people are going crazy over silly things. Main issue I have with games/movies is how they don't know how to make a strong female character without making her just a man. Really rare that you find a strong female character that shows femininity. Yuri Ha Zahard would like a word sir. | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
March 29 2016 22:55 GMT
#22536
| ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12084 Posts
March 29 2016 22:56 GMT
#22537
On March 30 2016 07:55 jcarlsoniv wrote: I'm amazed that the constant stream of solicitation mail I get from credit card companies doesn't violate some sort of predatory law. My phone remains a constant source of "would you like a home security system?" calls, even though I don't own a home and, no, I would not like to remain on your call list (why do you keep calling despite removing me from your list?!?!). | ||
|
Alaric
France45622 Posts
March 29 2016 23:05 GMT
#22538
If she was a gay male character there wouldn't be much difference in characterisation, since her obsession is played for laughs more than character development. | ||
|
red_
United States8474 Posts
March 29 2016 23:08 GMT
#22539
On March 30 2016 07:56 Lord Tolkien wrote: Show nested quote + On March 30 2016 07:55 jcarlsoniv wrote: I'm amazed that the constant stream of solicitation mail I get from credit card companies doesn't violate some sort of predatory law. My phone remains a constant source of "would you like a home security system?" calls, even though I don't own a home and, no, I would not like to remain on your call list (why do you keep calling despite removing me from your list?!?!). Do Not Call lists are very strict legally, unfortunately there is (supposed to be) a statement they have to read to you first to confirm that you want to get put on it that most people hang up or interrupt before it gets finished, so you don't get placed on. It's stupid, yes, and I'm sure there are shady places that are bending the rule as well. Source: worked part-time in a call center for a bit when I was in school. | ||
|
Scip
Czech Republic11293 Posts
March 29 2016 23:11 GMT
#22540
On March 30 2016 07:51 Crusnik wrote: Show nested quote + On March 30 2016 06:10 Numy wrote: Aesthetics over practicality is hardly a female only thing. Why practicality is even an issue eludes me. If the game isn't trying to mirror reality then it doesn't need to adhere to anything it doesn't want to. That's how fantasy works. The author gets to decide the rules of their universe. Sure boob armour is dumb but I don't mind it in certain settings. It's the same as those huge baddass armour you see on male characters to me. They both dumb but both have their place in certain stories. I just think people are going crazy over silly things. Main issue I have with games/movies is how they don't know how to make a strong female character without making her just a man. Really rare that you find a strong female character that shows femininity. Yuri Ha Zahard would like a word sir. What are her feminine traits, an obsession with a baby faced teenage boy? The best part about having a known personality, I can just come in here and remind you that somewhere, Scip has an opinion regarding butts in videogames, and you know what it is without me having to spell it out. Also, to continue on the important topic, DAMN TOWER OF GOD it's about to get fucking good mark my words in 3 weeks... t.t | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Super Smash Bros Other Games
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends |
|
SOOP
soO vs FanTaSy
WardiTV Weekly
Replay Cast
Monday Night Weeklies
PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
GSL
Patches Events
Replay Cast
KCM Race Survival
[ Show More ] RSL Revival
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
|
|
|