|
On March 25 2016 23:44 mordek wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2016 23:28 Scip wrote: Damn, looks like kdog is getting cuxed. :3 don't think he can even play for a draw now.
For those who don't know, killerdog is the Adam Blatchley kid. So black is up a pawn, I'm bad, but why did kdog offer the rook trade? Isn't black looking to simplify or is the pawn up not that big a deal at this point? I am bad at chess answer: It forces the knight to retreat which reduces the queen pressure on 2H?
|
Oh I meant, considering you need to keep some particular CMC cards in the top, do you use the divining top during upkeep to manipulate your draw, then rearrange it if needed depending on what your opponent casts/may cast?
This card is pretty cool. Easy to kill, but unless you're fighting a fast deck (which vampires and werewolves are I guess) it can end up having a strong effect, and the 4 attack makes you not want to ignore it. Also I thought green wasn't supposed to draw easily? This is pretty darn strong if you can bait madness cards using discard effects, or tricks by playing aggro.
(I don't know if this counterspell is good, but the flavour is hilarious.)
|
Generally during upkeep so that you don't draw what you need to keep on top but it's not like there's some hard rule of "this is when you top"
|
On March 26 2016 00:33 Eppa! wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2016 23:44 mordek wrote:On March 25 2016 23:28 Scip wrote: Damn, looks like kdog is getting cuxed. :3 don't think he can even play for a draw now.
For those who don't know, killerdog is the Adam Blatchley kid. So black is up a pawn, I'm bad, but why did kdog offer the rook trade? Isn't black looking to simplify or is the pawn up not that big a deal at this point? I am bad at chess answer: It forces the knight to retreat which reduces the queen pressure on 2H? I guess it forces him to move a pawn so his king doesn't get trapped. Just caught up on the rest of the moves. I think congrats on the draw?
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
Wow, I didn't expect kdog to be able to make a draw out of that. I guess I'm bad at chess too :p
|
On March 26 2016 00:37 Alaric wrote:Oh I meant, considering you need to keep some particular CMC cards in the top, do you use the divining top during upkeep to manipulate your draw, then rearrange it if needed depending on what your opponent casts/may cast? This card is pretty cool. Easy to kill, but unless you're fighting a fast deck (which vampires and werewolves are I guess) it can end up having a strong effect, and the 4 attack makes you not want to ignore it. Also I thought green wasn't supposed to draw easily? This is pretty darn strong if you can bait madness cards using discard effects, or tricks by playing aggro. (I don't know if this counterspell is good, but the flavour is hilarious.)
How to Counterbalance Top by Cixah:
This card combo is more oppressive than the Russians under Stalin. It basically says "Hey did your deck need to reliably cast 1 drop spells? Well you can't, ever, for the rest of the game. Because not only am I playing a reusable counter, I still have force of will. Not to mention other good spells at 2 and 3 like Remand and Repeal."
So now that you have a general idea how awesome this card combo is. It's really versatile because like you said you can filter draws and spend a mana at any point to manipulate the top of your deck. You basically have access to any of the top 3 cards of your deck to cast because reasons. But most of the time yes, you use your upkeep to top so that you can manipulate your draw because its important as fuck.
|
Going through the spoilers atm...Super Convoke has caught my eye. + Show Spoiler +
Like...with Eldrazi Scions that's nuts----each gives two mana.
Also, sad zambie is sad. This you, 6ah? + Show Spoiler +
I think this kind of flavour is what BFZ block was really missing. Love the silliness and seriousness where appropriate. My favourite will forever be Zoidberg Zombie though + Show Spoiler +
|
On March 26 2016 01:18 Cixah wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2016 00:37 Alaric wrote:Oh I meant, considering you need to keep some particular CMC cards in the top, do you use the divining top during upkeep to manipulate your draw, then rearrange it if needed depending on what your opponent casts/may cast? This card is pretty cool. Easy to kill, but unless you're fighting a fast deck (which vampires and werewolves are I guess) it can end up having a strong effect, and the 4 attack makes you not want to ignore it. Also I thought green wasn't supposed to draw easily? This is pretty darn strong if you can bait madness cards using discard effects, or tricks by playing aggro. (I don't know if this counterspell is good, but the flavour is hilarious.) How to Counterbalance Top by Cixah: This card combo is more oppressive than the Russians under Stalin. It basically says "Hey did your deck need to reliably cast 1 drop spells? Well you can't, ever, for the rest of the game. Because not only am I playing a reusable counter, I still have force of will. Not to mention other good spells at 2 and 3 like Remand and Repeal." So now that you have a general idea how awesome this card combo is. It's really versatile because like you said you can filter draws and spend a mana at any point to manipulate the top of your deck. You basically have access to any of the top 3 cards of your deck to cast because reasons. But most of the time yes, you use your upkeep to top so that you can manipulate your draw because its important as fuck.
Miracles doesn't run Remand/Repeal, they way too shit for Legacy. 3 mana cost is generally Entreat/Council's and creatures if you running them, it's actually one of the harder slots to deal with. Miracles isn't even the defacto deck in Legacy, it's just that it's the cheapest control deck on MODO so it's popular.
Vintage shops is the real prison man. Who needs to bother with top when you can just stop anyone playing spells turn 1.
|
On March 26 2016 01:47 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2016 01:18 Cixah wrote:On March 26 2016 00:37 Alaric wrote:Oh I meant, considering you need to keep some particular CMC cards in the top, do you use the divining top during upkeep to manipulate your draw, then rearrange it if needed depending on what your opponent casts/may cast? This card is pretty cool. Easy to kill, but unless you're fighting a fast deck (which vampires and werewolves are I guess) it can end up having a strong effect, and the 4 attack makes you not want to ignore it. Also I thought green wasn't supposed to draw easily? This is pretty darn strong if you can bait madness cards using discard effects, or tricks by playing aggro. (I don't know if this counterspell is good, but the flavour is hilarious.) How to Counterbalance Top by Cixah: This card combo is more oppressive than the Russians under Stalin. It basically says "Hey did your deck need to reliably cast 1 drop spells? Well you can't, ever, for the rest of the game. Because not only am I playing a reusable counter, I still have force of will. Not to mention other good spells at 2 and 3 like Remand and Repeal." So now that you have a general idea how awesome this card combo is. It's really versatile because like you said you can filter draws and spend a mana at any point to manipulate the top of your deck. You basically have access to any of the top 3 cards of your deck to cast because reasons. But most of the time yes, you use your upkeep to top so that you can manipulate your draw because its important as fuck. Miracles doesn't run Remand/Repeal, they way too shit for Legacy. 3 mana cost is generally Entreat/Council's and creatures if you running them, it's actually one of the harder slots to deal with. Miracles isn't even the defacto deck in Legacy, it's just that it's the cheapest control deck on MODO so it's popular. Vintage shops is the real prison man. Who needs to bother with top when you can just stop anyone playing spells turn 1. lol you've gone from 'I just started MTG and wat is this' to 'neckbeard who's been playing the game for 20 years' rl quick with your eternal bias
|
On March 26 2016 01:50 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2016 01:47 Numy wrote:On March 26 2016 01:18 Cixah wrote:On March 26 2016 00:37 Alaric wrote:Oh I meant, considering you need to keep some particular CMC cards in the top, do you use the divining top during upkeep to manipulate your draw, then rearrange it if needed depending on what your opponent casts/may cast? This card is pretty cool. Easy to kill, but unless you're fighting a fast deck (which vampires and werewolves are I guess) it can end up having a strong effect, and the 4 attack makes you not want to ignore it. Also I thought green wasn't supposed to draw easily? This is pretty darn strong if you can bait madness cards using discard effects, or tricks by playing aggro. (I don't know if this counterspell is good, but the flavour is hilarious.) How to Counterbalance Top by Cixah: This card combo is more oppressive than the Russians under Stalin. It basically says "Hey did your deck need to reliably cast 1 drop spells? Well you can't, ever, for the rest of the game. Because not only am I playing a reusable counter, I still have force of will. Not to mention other good spells at 2 and 3 like Remand and Repeal." So now that you have a general idea how awesome this card combo is. It's really versatile because like you said you can filter draws and spend a mana at any point to manipulate the top of your deck. You basically have access to any of the top 3 cards of your deck to cast because reasons. But most of the time yes, you use your upkeep to top so that you can manipulate your draw because its important as fuck. Miracles doesn't run Remand/Repeal, they way too shit for Legacy. 3 mana cost is generally Entreat/Council's and creatures if you running them, it's actually one of the harder slots to deal with. Miracles isn't even the defacto deck in Legacy, it's just that it's the cheapest control deck on MODO so it's popular. Vintage shops is the real prison man. Who needs to bother with top when you can just stop anyone playing spells turn 1. lol you've gone from 'I just started MTG and wat is this' to 'neckbeard who's been playing the game for 20 years' rl quick with your eternal bias
I watched so much eternal man, more than standard at least. When you bored and have hours to kill then strolling through youtube vids are fun. Playing games is just too much effort.Top is banned in modern anyway so counterbalance isn't a thing there.
Just got so bored of this standard so quickly.
|
United States47024 Posts
Cixah just mentioned Remand/Repeal because he still has PTSD from Counter-Top being in Extended.
|
On March 26 2016 01:53 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2016 01:50 WaveofShadow wrote:On March 26 2016 01:47 Numy wrote:On March 26 2016 01:18 Cixah wrote:On March 26 2016 00:37 Alaric wrote:Oh I meant, considering you need to keep some particular CMC cards in the top, do you use the divining top during upkeep to manipulate your draw, then rearrange it if needed depending on what your opponent casts/may cast? This card is pretty cool. Easy to kill, but unless you're fighting a fast deck (which vampires and werewolves are I guess) it can end up having a strong effect, and the 4 attack makes you not want to ignore it. Also I thought green wasn't supposed to draw easily? This is pretty darn strong if you can bait madness cards using discard effects, or tricks by playing aggro. (I don't know if this counterspell is good, but the flavour is hilarious.) How to Counterbalance Top by Cixah: This card combo is more oppressive than the Russians under Stalin. It basically says "Hey did your deck need to reliably cast 1 drop spells? Well you can't, ever, for the rest of the game. Because not only am I playing a reusable counter, I still have force of will. Not to mention other good spells at 2 and 3 like Remand and Repeal." So now that you have a general idea how awesome this card combo is. It's really versatile because like you said you can filter draws and spend a mana at any point to manipulate the top of your deck. You basically have access to any of the top 3 cards of your deck to cast because reasons. But most of the time yes, you use your upkeep to top so that you can manipulate your draw because its important as fuck. Miracles doesn't run Remand/Repeal, they way too shit for Legacy. 3 mana cost is generally Entreat/Council's and creatures if you running them, it's actually one of the harder slots to deal with. Miracles isn't even the defacto deck in Legacy, it's just that it's the cheapest control deck on MODO so it's popular. Vintage shops is the real prison man. Who needs to bother with top when you can just stop anyone playing spells turn 1. lol you've gone from 'I just started MTG and wat is this' to 'neckbeard who's been playing the game for 20 years' rl quick with your eternal bias I watched so much eternal man, more than standard at least. When you bored and have hours to kill then strolling through youtube vids are fun. Playing games is just too much effort.Top is banned in modern anyway so counterbalance isn't a thing there. Just got so bored of this standard so quickly. But that's why limited is funnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
|
You can't do any degen shit in limited though. It's just two people slapping each other. Maybe other limited formats allowed more degen shit though. I mean I don't really do much degen but it's nice seeing degen and having the option of degen.
|
I'd say the Russians under Stalin were oppressed rather. 
What I meant Cixah is that if you draw and need some stuff in your top cards to trigger counterbalance, then you're likely to choose your draw between 1-2 cards of the top 3 (to keep the important ones), so while you're manipulating the top of your library a lot, it's actually very different from, say, replacing your draw phase with "Scry 3, then draw a card", right?
Writing down quick opinions on full spoiler for limited, because I know I'm super bad so I want to get that out of the way before more competent people put theirs : + Show Spoiler +Apart from bombs, W and U look like the weakest colours to me, with G the best, probably followed by R.
Spirits have flying, some have flash, and you can very easily produce tokens? But their stats are really bad, so I guess the idea's to survive using tapping and lifegain, while dropping clues, until you can start cracking them and retake the game with card advantage? It looks to me that against all the high attack/trample in G and R, people wouldn't hesitate to attack into spirits and force a race. I'm probably underestimating the strength of exiling some humans to create flying tokens though (especially with the GW cards that care about stuff dying). I'd have to look again for how much removal is actually available. Hope against hope, Bound by moonsilver, Puncturing light all look pretty good actually.
Zombies don't look great either (more because of U than B which seems to have more tools) but I'm pretty sure I'm underestimating how wide they can go, or how strong built-in recursion (especially on flyers) is. Plus if you open bombs there's generic recursion too. Is it "threaten reanimation so your opponent doesn't attack for fear of double blocks, until your board is wide enough and, with a pump spell or two, you start attacking"? At least B is packed with removal, and madness enablers (hello Murderous Compulsion, kill an attacker if you have an enabler). Shamble Back looks... quite good? 2/2 for B that isn't even tapped, unless your opponent is playing tokens it looks really good to slow down Delirium, get rid of recursive threats, etc.
Vampires are pretty diluted. Their good cards are good, but there's a bunch of mediocre to bad commons too. Red's ability to pump them or give them double-strike/first-strike/trample when they're already pretty aggressive looks dangerous though. Inner Struggle and Dissenssion in the Ranks look like really really powerful removal, and can open the way. Magmatic Chasm sets up an alpha strike. In the right deck, creatures like Pyre Hound are probably extremely good, and it's a common. Stensia Masquerade looks like a bomb, it's so strong if you have a low curve and a couple flyers/tricks to force bad blocks. In B in general, Dead Weight looks like a good anti-aggro card though, and better in general than it'd be in BFZ block with its 2/3s.
I think in the end Werewolves look like the strongest archetype at first glance. They've got good stats, sometimes even untapped (a bunch of 3/3s for 3), the same offensive tools i mentioned for R, and G provides ways to use your mana via clues, and clue synergy, a bunch of wolf synergies and tokens, and Cryptolith Rites is bonkers. That's going to constructed. Howlpack resurgence for aggressiveness, Crawling sensation with cards like Groundskeeper for tokens at uncommon, the 0/4 Fungus that becomes 3/4 for 2 with Delirium looks really powerful, and there's a bunch of ramp and fixing between the Dryad, the Cultivator, etc. Plus it looks like WotC moved away from "fight" to "deal damage equal to its power" which makes G removal at least decent, and often cheap for its potential. G also has access to a bunch of card selection (delirium traverse, its vessel, etc.), and I believe the only enchantment removal (barring "non-land permanent" destruction/exile which is often costly) in a set which appears to have really powerful enchantments.
I'm a removal junky and GB doesn't have a tribe which is a shame, but G looks the best colour by a notch to me, making werewolves, and potentially humans if the "stall and grow" plan (fungus, tokens, clue synergy and lifegain) is workable, the tribes I'm most looking forward too. Can't wait to be wrong.
|
|
|
Maybe, but you're our potato.
|
On March 26 2016 01:53 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2016 01:50 WaveofShadow wrote:On March 26 2016 01:47 Numy wrote:On March 26 2016 01:18 Cixah wrote:On March 26 2016 00:37 Alaric wrote:Oh I meant, considering you need to keep some particular CMC cards in the top, do you use the divining top during upkeep to manipulate your draw, then rearrange it if needed depending on what your opponent casts/may cast? This card is pretty cool. Easy to kill, but unless you're fighting a fast deck (which vampires and werewolves are I guess) it can end up having a strong effect, and the 4 attack makes you not want to ignore it. Also I thought green wasn't supposed to draw easily? This is pretty darn strong if you can bait madness cards using discard effects, or tricks by playing aggro. (I don't know if this counterspell is good, but the flavour is hilarious.) How to Counterbalance Top by Cixah: This card combo is more oppressive than the Russians under Stalin. It basically says "Hey did your deck need to reliably cast 1 drop spells? Well you can't, ever, for the rest of the game. Because not only am I playing a reusable counter, I still have force of will. Not to mention other good spells at 2 and 3 like Remand and Repeal." So now that you have a general idea how awesome this card combo is. It's really versatile because like you said you can filter draws and spend a mana at any point to manipulate the top of your deck. You basically have access to any of the top 3 cards of your deck to cast because reasons. But most of the time yes, you use your upkeep to top so that you can manipulate your draw because its important as fuck. Miracles doesn't run Remand/Repeal, they way too shit for Legacy. 3 mana cost is generally Entreat/Council's and creatures if you running them, it's actually one of the harder slots to deal with. Miracles isn't even the defacto deck in Legacy, it's just that it's the cheapest control deck on MODO so it's popular. Vintage shops is the real prison man. Who needs to bother with top when you can just stop anyone playing spells turn 1. lol you've gone from 'I just started MTG and wat is this' to 'neckbeard who's been playing the game for 20 years' rl quick with your eternal bias I watched so much eternal man, more than standard at least. When you bored and have hours to kill then strolling through youtube vids are fun. Playing games is just too much effort.Top is banned in modern anyway so counterbalance isn't a thing there. Just got so bored of this standard so quickly.
I still play them because I like the cards. I think some lists have moved to more relevant threats like stoneforge and batterskull/jitte but its been a minute since put the cards together. As for vintage I don't really see many of the counter top lists their either because everyone is playing some kind of storm variant right now due to dark petition being printed.
|
On March 26 2016 02:05 killerdog wrote: I'm a fucking potato
I think you could have won that game? But you played to not lose and succeeded so good job.
Edit:phone double post op.
|
On March 26 2016 02:00 Numy wrote: You can't do any degen shit in limited though. It's just two people slapping each other. Maybe other limited formats allowed more degen shit though. I mean I don't really do much degen but it's nice seeing degen and having the option of degen. Screw degenerate shit. It's all well and good when you see it for the first time and go 'Wow that's pretty cool,' but when you have to play against it over and over and you weren't even the one to come up with the coolness of it, I don't understand the appeal.
The skill of deckbuilding on the fly/having everyone on potentially equal footing/having different games/matchups every time really appeals to me over constructed formats where if you play enough all the games tend to run together.
|
On March 26 2016 02:11 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2016 02:00 Numy wrote: You can't do any degen shit in limited though. It's just two people slapping each other. Maybe other limited formats allowed more degen shit though. I mean I don't really do much degen but it's nice seeing degen and having the option of degen. Screw degenerate shit. It's all well and good when you see it for the first time and go 'Wow that's pretty cool,' but when you have to play against it over and over and you weren't even the one to come up with the coolness of it, I don't understand the appeal. The skill of deckbuilding on the fly/having everyone on potentially equal footing/having different games/matchups every time really appeals to me over constructed formats where if you play enough all the games tend to run together.
Equal footing isn't fun in magic, you can lose when things are equal. I'd rather just do degenerate shit.
|
|
|
|
|
|