|
On March 12 2016 13:18 Gahlo wrote: You know, this Go thing is generally interesting, but I feel I would be a lot more interested if I knew what the hell was going on as far as game mechanics. the pieces go on the empty intersections, black first then white. the goal is to surround more open intersections than the other guy. in an even game white gets an extra few points and a half for going second.
|
On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things.
Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously
edit - nvm
|
|
|
On March 12 2016 13:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things. Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously https://www.youtube.com/c/usgoweb/live
This is a lot more high level strategy talk, but doesn't start until 9pm PST
|
On March 12 2016 13:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things. Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously edit - nvm
Can you expand on what you mean by Go strategy? It's not that easy to explain all the possibilities that the players can choose from. I think when listening to commentary, you have to try to focus on the idea behind the moves rather than the moves directly. It's a lot about what move accomplishes whatever idea they want in the most efficient way possible. Then you try to figure out how to do it while also keeping the initiative throughout the whole board.
|
On March 12 2016 14:06 ketchup wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 13:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things. Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously edit - nvm Can you expand on what you mean by Go strategy? It's not that easy to explain all the possibilities that the players can choose from. I think when listening to commentary, you have to try to focus on the idea behind the moves rather than the moves directly. It's a lot about what move accomplishes whatever idea they want in the most efficient way possible. Then you try to figure out how to do it while also keeping the initiative throughout the whole board.
Yeah, when I tuned in they were talking about some of the history and other stuff, but in retrospect it was a silly question.
|
On March 12 2016 14:07 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 14:06 ketchup wrote:On March 12 2016 13:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things. Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously edit - nvm Can you expand on what you mean by Go strategy? It's not that easy to explain all the possibilities that the players can choose from. I think when listening to commentary, you have to try to focus on the idea behind the moves rather than the moves directly. It's a lot about what move accomplishes whatever idea they want in the most efficient way possible. Then you try to figure out how to do it while also keeping the initiative throughout the whole board. Yeah, when I tuned in they were talking about some of the history and other stuff, but in retrospect it was a silly question. Majority of it is the 9p guy playing through potential variations ^^
Having watched a lot of chess broadcasts, they're actually doing a really really good job of keeping it both interesting but also understandable. This is a pretty slick setup by google
I watched a little of the "higher level" stream with the korean dude yesterday, but the combination of poorer quality the guy not speaking very clearly (and not really knowing enough to understand most of what they said anyway) made it a bit meh
edit: oh cool, the advanced stream is much better today. Actual understandable commentary and good quality :o
|
On March 12 2016 14:24 killerdog wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 14:07 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 14:06 ketchup wrote:On March 12 2016 13:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things. Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously edit - nvm Can you expand on what you mean by Go strategy? It's not that easy to explain all the possibilities that the players can choose from. I think when listening to commentary, you have to try to focus on the idea behind the moves rather than the moves directly. It's a lot about what move accomplishes whatever idea they want in the most efficient way possible. Then you try to figure out how to do it while also keeping the initiative throughout the whole board. Yeah, when I tuned in they were talking about some of the history and other stuff, but in retrospect it was a silly question. Majority of it is the 9p guy playing through potential variations ^^ Having watched a lot of chess broadcasts, they're actually doing a really really good job of keeping it both interesting but also understandable. This is a pretty slick setup by google I watched a little of the "higher level" stream with the korean dude yesterday, but the combination of poorer quality the guy not speaking very clearly (and not really knowing enough to understand most of what they said anyway) made it a bit meh
It seems like the stream today is much better since the two commentators are actually in the same place.
|
On March 12 2016 14:27 ketchup wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 14:24 killerdog wrote:On March 12 2016 14:07 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 14:06 ketchup wrote:On March 12 2016 13:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things. Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously edit - nvm Can you expand on what you mean by Go strategy? It's not that easy to explain all the possibilities that the players can choose from. I think when listening to commentary, you have to try to focus on the idea behind the moves rather than the moves directly. It's a lot about what move accomplishes whatever idea they want in the most efficient way possible. Then you try to figure out how to do it while also keeping the initiative throughout the whole board. Yeah, when I tuned in they were talking about some of the history and other stuff, but in retrospect it was a silly question. Majority of it is the 9p guy playing through potential variations ^^ Having watched a lot of chess broadcasts, they're actually doing a really really good job of keeping it both interesting but also understandable. This is a pretty slick setup by google I watched a little of the "higher level" stream with the korean dude yesterday, but the combination of poorer quality the guy not speaking very clearly (and not really knowing enough to understand most of what they said anyway) made it a bit meh It seems like the stream today is much better since the two commentators are actually in the same place. The only thing cooler would be having a visual representation of what AlphaGo's thinking process.
also AGA stream is now on, and the new commentator has much better English, and way cuter.
|
|
|
On March 12 2016 14:33 wei2coolman wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 14:27 ketchup wrote:On March 12 2016 14:24 killerdog wrote:On March 12 2016 14:07 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 14:06 ketchup wrote:On March 12 2016 13:33 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 12 2016 12:50 ketchup wrote: Stream is on for those interested enough to watch. Just commentary about how AlphaGo works right now, so it's interesting learning about how it does things. Will they talk at all about Go strategy? I haven't seen the previous two, so I'm sure they talk about it at least a bit previously edit - nvm Can you expand on what you mean by Go strategy? It's not that easy to explain all the possibilities that the players can choose from. I think when listening to commentary, you have to try to focus on the idea behind the moves rather than the moves directly. It's a lot about what move accomplishes whatever idea they want in the most efficient way possible. Then you try to figure out how to do it while also keeping the initiative throughout the whole board. Yeah, when I tuned in they were talking about some of the history and other stuff, but in retrospect it was a silly question. Majority of it is the 9p guy playing through potential variations ^^ Having watched a lot of chess broadcasts, they're actually doing a really really good job of keeping it both interesting but also understandable. This is a pretty slick setup by google I watched a little of the "higher level" stream with the korean dude yesterday, but the combination of poorer quality the guy not speaking very clearly (and not really knowing enough to understand most of what they said anyway) made it a bit meh It seems like the stream today is much better since the two commentators are actually in the same place. The only thing cooler would be having a visual representation of what AlphaGo's thinking process. also AGA stream is now on, and the new commentator has much better English, and way cuter.
I don't think they could release that easily right now. I think it would be cool to just see AlphaGo actively give it's internal percent chance of winning. Some of the articles mentioned that the developers watching have that info.
|
On March 12 2016 14:38 killerdog wrote: ok AGA stream is awesome Yeah, the commentators actually have emotions regarding the game. Redmond is too emotionally void.
I wonder if quantum computing increase in potential computational output would make such program almost obsolete with just pure brute force calculation?
|
On March 12 2016 14:49 wei2coolman wrote:Yeah, the commentators actually have emotions regarding the game. Redmond is too emotionally void. I wonder if quantum computing increase in potential computational output would make such program almost obsolete with just pure brute force calculation? It feels like he's also been coached to be super super safe. He literally has the eyes of the western world on GO through him.
The AGA stream really is way more entertaining though
|
AlphaGo is so efficient/strong. Lee Se Dol can't take the initiative at all, even though he is trying really hard. The longer this goes on, the harder it gets since end game seems impossible to win against AlphaGo.
|
On March 12 2016 15:03 ketchup wrote: AlphaGo is so efficient/strong. Lee Se Dol can't take the initiative at all, even though he is trying really hard I think it's so interesting when the commentators can't find mistakes from sedol's play, but AlphaGo just in control.
I think it's hard to characterize how hard AlphaGo is controlling the game, because it's designed to play by win percentage, not by win amount. So if given an game state where it's 80% chance of winning, but by 40 points, vs 90% chance by 5 points. It'll choose the 90% chance every time.
|
On March 12 2016 15:09 wei2coolman wrote:Show nested quote +On March 12 2016 15:03 ketchup wrote: AlphaGo is so efficient/strong. Lee Se Dol can't take the initiative at all, even though he is trying really hard I think it's so interesting when the commentators can't find mistakes from sedol's play, but AlphaGo just in control. I think it's hard to characterize how hard AlphaGo is controlling the game, because it's designed to play by win percentage, not by win amount. So if given an game state where it's 80% chance of winning, but by 40 points, vs 90% chance by 5 points. It'll choose the 90% chance every time.
I dont know. I think there has to be more time put into analyzing the game before you can call any move a mistake. They probably won't use that term in the broadcast unless it's some form of obvious blunder. It will be interesting to see how this game progresses. Hopefully I don't fall asleep before it ends.
|
United States15536 Posts
DARKEST DUNGEON COMPLETE!
Damn, those were some interesting final runs.
Anyone else finished that thing?
|
I'm not sure to be more disturbed by AlphaGo completely dominating Lee Sedol, or 4chan already drawing AlphaGo waifu.
|
Somehow Alphago just seems stronger with each game it plays :o
|
Tried watching that Google stream.
No clue what they're saying.
|
|
|
|
|
|