|
On March 11 2016 01:39 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 01:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I think I'll be impressed when a computer can program other computers. You're almost as bad as those people on the Nightly Show who said to Bill Nye "why do I care that there's water on Mars" What's bad about people not caring about information that doesn't affect their lives in any way?
|
On March 11 2016 01:48 nafta wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 01:39 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 11 2016 01:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I think I'll be impressed when a computer can program other computers. You're almost as bad as those people on the Nightly Show who said to Bill Nye "why do I care that there's water on Mars" What's bad about people not caring about information that doesn't affect their lives in any way?
There's a difference between not being interested and thinking it's not important or a big deal.
|
On March 11 2016 01:48 nafta wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 01:39 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 11 2016 01:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I think I'll be impressed when a computer can program other computers. You're almost as bad as those people on the Nightly Show who said to Bill Nye "why do I care that there's water on Mars" What's bad about people not caring about information that doesn't affect their lives in any way? you wont say that when the robot overlords take over the world and play go better than us after the last dan has fallen
|
28104 Posts
Technically Ke Jie is #1 right now, but Lee Sedol has been around for longer which is probably why he got the opportunity (Ke Jie is like 8-2 against Sedol in the past 1-2 years IIRC).
Also, everyone watch the fuck out one day the robits will be the true overlords of our beloved esports!
|
On March 11 2016 01:39 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 01:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I think I'll be impressed when a computer can program other computers. You're almost as bad as those people on the Nightly Show who said to Bill Nye "why do I care that there's water on Mars" Soniv plz
Edit: Alright I'll be more specific. Yes, I get that it's showcasing an advancement in technology in terms of how computers solve tasks/programming/whatever, but the advancement is so minute and they are constantly being one-upped so frequently it loses relevance to someone like me who is not highly invested in the industry in any way shape or form. No, I don't think it is a 'big deal,' and I'm not sure why this specific event assures me that it must be so. What is particularly groundbreaking about it?
Finding (liquid) water on Mars has potential world-changing implications and I don't think it's a fair comparison in the slightest.
Oh and let me also say this. The problem with the Nightly Show interview is they were trying to turn the ignorance into a joke that simply wasn't funny and not embracing parts of interview that should have been left to Bill Nye to get a point across properly. Saying something like 'and why should I care if there is water on Mars' is a completely legitimate question if straight context is provided---this allows the interviewee to expand and explain at his leisure, but the atmosphere created was instead one of mockery and sardonic ignorance.
|
On March 11 2016 01:58 TheEmulator wrote:Technically Ke Jie is #1 right now, but Lee Sedol has been around for longer which is probably why he got the opportunity (Ke Jie is like 8-2 against Sedol in the past 1-2 years IIRC). Also, everyone watch the fuck out one day the robits will be the true overlords of our beloved esports! Pretty sure that will never happen because the people who watch for the actual gameplay almost don't exist :D
|
On March 11 2016 01:59 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 01:39 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 11 2016 01:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I think I'll be impressed when a computer can program other computers. You're almost as bad as those people on the Nightly Show who said to Bill Nye "why do I care that there's water on Mars" Soniv plz Edit: Alright I'll be more specific. Yes, I get that it's showcasing an advancement in technology in terms of how computers solve tasks/programming/whatever, but the advancement is so minute and they are constantly being one-upped so frequently it loses relevance to someone like me who is not highly invested in the industry in any way shape or form. No, I don't think it is a 'big deal,' and I'm not sure why this specific event assures me that it must be so. What is particularly groundbreaking about it? Finding (liquid) water on Mars has potential world-changing implications and I don't think it's a fair comparison in the slightest.
Problem solving from a computer standpoint is a complex... problem. Depending on how many potential options and solutions, solving for a specific problem can take incredible amounts of time or processing power. This is why encryption works - finding the "key" for the lock would take an unreasonably large amount of time for even the strongest computers.
+ Show Spoiler [Soothing Sorting Algorithms] +
Why is this a big deal? DeepMind is not doing that kind of brute force problem solving in order to win at Go, which has a huge and constantly evolving number of possible iterations based on board state and plays made. DeepMind is dynamically evaluating these variables and, most importantly, learning as it goes through more and more iterations.
So yes, while this particular instance is somewhat niche, it's indicative of the tech becoming stronger and growing in potential. To suggest that it doesn't have world-changing implications is just downright wrong.
|
On March 11 2016 02:24 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 01:59 WaveofShadow wrote:On March 11 2016 01:39 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 11 2016 01:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I think I'll be impressed when a computer can program other computers. You're almost as bad as those people on the Nightly Show who said to Bill Nye "why do I care that there's water on Mars" Soniv plz Edit: Alright I'll be more specific. Yes, I get that it's showcasing an advancement in technology in terms of how computers solve tasks/programming/whatever, but the advancement is so minute and they are constantly being one-upped so frequently it loses relevance to someone like me who is not highly invested in the industry in any way shape or form. No, I don't think it is a 'big deal,' and I'm not sure why this specific event assures me that it must be so. What is particularly groundbreaking about it? Finding (liquid) water on Mars has potential world-changing implications and I don't think it's a fair comparison in the slightest. Problem solving from a computer standpoint is a complex... problem. Depending on how many potential options and solutions, solving for a specific problem can take incredible amounts of time or processing power. This is why encryption works - finding the "key" for the lock would take an unreasonably large amount of time for even the strongest computers. + Show Spoiler [Soothing Sorting Algorithms] +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kPRA0W1kECg Why is this a big deal? DeepMind is not doing that kind of brute force problem solving in order to win at Go, which has a huge and constantly evolving number of possible iterations based on board state and plays made. DeepMind is dynamically evaluating these variables and, most importantly, learning as it goes through more and more iterations. So yes, while this particular instance is somewhat niche, it's indicative of the tech becoming stronger and growing in potential. To suggest that it doesn't have world-changing implications is just downright wrong. And is this first time in recent years a computer has been able to do anything of this magnitude? The answer is no, this is simply the first time it has been showcased in a (pseudo-)popular arena. (Hell and even then, not really. There was always Watson which was similar in many ways.)
What I'm saying is this particular instance of technology itself, niche or not, does not have world-changing implications on its own. The growth and development of the technology does and obviously will change things immensely. It's a slowly evolving process.
A landmark discovery is not a slow process.
|
Technically, metaprograming is a thing.
Crap, forgot to refresh.
|
Like, this sort of thing is pretty sensationalist, along the same veins as when newspapers talk about 'New cure for AIDS/Cancer/etc found!'
In reality the implications of whatever research done have potential but they are many years removed from actual real-life application and may never even see the light of day after more iteration.
|
On March 11 2016 01:58 TheEmulator wrote:Technically Ke Jie is #1 right now, but Lee Sedol has been around for longer which is probably why he got the opportunity (Ke Jie is like 8-2 against Sedol in the past 1-2 years IIRC). Also, everyone watch the fuck out one day the robits will be the true overlords of our beloved esports! Pretty much any fighting game or any game where reaction speed is a limiter bots could dominate. This also includes FPS games.
Brute force problem solving is used a lot already? Isn't that the whole point of super computers which have been used for a shit ton of stuff.
|
Czech Republic11293 Posts
On March 11 2016 02:35 Eppa! wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 01:58 TheEmulator wrote:Technically Ke Jie is #1 right now, but Lee Sedol has been around for longer which is probably why he got the opportunity (Ke Jie is like 8-2 against Sedol in the past 1-2 years IIRC). Also, everyone watch the fuck out one day the robits will be the true overlords of our beloved esports! Pretty much any fighting game or any game where reaction speed is a limiter bots could dominate. This also includes FPS games. Or blink stalker allins.
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
programs already can program other programs or even themselves.
|
That's what metaprogramming is.
|
Kasparov v Deep Blue was vastly different. Fun fact: in one of the games, Deep Blue made a mistake, and Kasparov got shaken because he thought Deep Blue had seen something he didn't. Kasparov could have won, but ended up drawing that instead. That may have rattled him enough to lose the series as well.
|
On March 11 2016 02:44 ticklishmusic wrote: Kasparov v Deep Blue was vastly different. Fun fact: in one of the games, Deep Blue made a mistake, and Kasparov got shaken because he thought Deep Blue had seen something he didn't. Kasparov could have won, but ended up drawing that instead. That may have rattled him enough to lose the series as well. Beaten by a computer with mind games. Somehow that's even worse, right?
|
On March 11 2016 02:44 ticklishmusic wrote: Kasparov v Deep Blue was vastly different. Fun fact: in one of the games, Deep Blue made a mistake, and Kasparov got shaken because he thought Deep Blue had seen something he didn't. Kasparov could have won, but ended up drawing that instead. That may have rattled him enough to lose the series as well.
The opposite phenomenon of losing to a worse player cuz they did something so stupid it worked
|
On March 11 2016 02:48 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 02:44 ticklishmusic wrote: Kasparov v Deep Blue was vastly different. Fun fact: in one of the games, Deep Blue made a mistake, and Kasparov got shaken because he thought Deep Blue had seen something he didn't. Kasparov could have won, but ended up drawing that instead. That may have rattled him enough to lose the series as well. The opposite phenomenon of losing to a worse player cuz they did something so stupid it worked IT'S LIKE WHEN YOU LOSE TO ME AT SG
|
i didn't know kasparov was chinese
|
On March 11 2016 02:53 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On March 11 2016 02:48 jcarlsoniv wrote:On March 11 2016 02:44 ticklishmusic wrote: Kasparov v Deep Blue was vastly different. Fun fact: in one of the games, Deep Blue made a mistake, and Kasparov got shaken because he thought Deep Blue had seen something he didn't. Kasparov could have won, but ended up drawing that instead. That may have rattled him enough to lose the series as well. The opposite phenomenon of losing to a worse player cuz they did something so stupid it worked IT'S LIKE WHEN YOU LOSE TO ME AT SG
No, that's you failing to understand that even if moon and I are better, it doesn't mean we will win 100% of the time. Execution errors still happen.
|
|
|
|
|
|