Mafia in the Himalayas - Page 9

On June 28 2015 11:04 Damdred wrote:
Well don't just think because x disagrees I must be wrong, it very well could be I'm not giving it enough weight.

One thing to consider when looking at the night kills is was this person trying to solve the game.

Ij some regards it points to an experienced scum maybe hf maybe not. The team took out some people who were legitimately trying to solve the game.

So I mean there are some things going for hf being scum, buy I also think that the weird mig claim. The masons surviving unscathed for so long, especially when RS is a good player and the d1 lynch is towards hf being town.

On June 28 2015 11:39 Damdred wrote:
RS has decent reads and tries to figure the game out.

oneg why did you vote for GB in the situation?

LS why did you vote for GB yesterday? Especially when rmconfirmed town RS pushed against it?

On June 29 2015 10:13 Holyflare wrote:
talk to me about this ls crap you keep saying then, link the posts with tmi and explain why it's tmi

On June 29 2015 11:31 Holyflare wrote:


well did he make that post before or after mig flipped? Also, i'm not sure how it's tmi? It's fucking retarded yeh but that doesn't make it tmi

On June 30 2015 12:36 ruXxar wrote:
If it was up to me I'd lynch them both today.
I lean slightly more towards onegu for total lack of rational thought process.
Like he makes some weird ass statements I don't understand at all.
Like saying you have TMI.
Saying you claimed red.
Saying he voted on gb because he wanted to consolidate.
Tunneling you all game for no fucking reason, just because he has a personal vendetta against you?
Then when you are actually green checked he makes up hilariously unlikely scenarios to fit his world.
Not one solid read out of that guy and afk all game?

Fuck that, I'm done.

On June 30 2015 13:53 NydusHerMain wrote:
Yeah I'm sorry... I honestly just don't trust my reads that much because I was totally okay with all the mislynches so far because I thought they were scum... so I'm just trying to find some associative read >.> ...

On June 30 2015 13:57 NydusHerMain wrote:


Have you read the thread? O.o

On June 30 2015 06:58 ruXxar wrote:


I also agree with nydus point here.

Right now the absolutely easiest mislynch is Onegu(imo).
If I was mafia and onegu was town I would make her my #1 target right now and push her very hard.

This is sort of a dilemma because he actually does appear really scummy and I don't agree with the way he plays or the logic he uses.

However, since no one else seems to be shitting down onegu's throat, it makes me more inclined to believe he's actually mafia(why wouldn't mafia be all over a target that is such an easy mislynch?!)

In my last game I got fooled by the "too obvious to be scum" idea in that I felt a certain person made such obviously scummy moves that no one would make it so obvious that they are scum.

It burned me in the end when it turned out the person was scum all along and I hard defended him as town.
I learned from this and at this point "too scummy to be scum" is not a valid excuse for me to not push someone.

On June 30 2015 03:10 Damdred wrote:
Its a really tough game honestly, I'm like 99.9% sure that LS is town in this situation and I sort of hope hes scum just so I can be proud of him changing his meta in a way I didn't think he could.

FId is confirmed town

I know i'm town obviously.

This leaves me in a world where all I have to do is find town in Onegu, Shockey, HF, NHM and Rux. There are two towns and three mafia in this group.

Content wise HF could look ok, red check withstanding I still want some more of his thoughts around the GB lynch.

Oneg has 0 real content voted with his mafia read in lynching GB which was headed by confirmed mafia mig.

Shockey is sort of weird.

Rux could of carried a shot and got blocked or been shot, he seem to be trying to solve the game though that is true, but isn't really evolving his reads in a way.

Its a sort of a hard game at thi sjuncture though

On June 29 2015 05:35 ShoCkeyy wrote:
Problem is, I can't explain it, my only thought is that Onegu knew LS is mafia because they're on the same team and he knew he would just waste votes on him from the get go but that's complete theory at this point. I said it's possible, but I've definitely have been scum reading LS the whole game. And now that we're this far into the game and reading through GB's filter and LS's filter it just makes sense to me. I want to see everyone else's thoughts though.

What are your thoughts on what I brought up against LS and his reaction to it?