[T] Hajime no Ippo Maifa - Page 32

On May 02 2015 08:22 Holyflare wrote:


oh right yeh i forgot ls

On April 29 2015 17:51 Jean Valjean wrote:


I may be overreacting here so I'm hoping someone actually gives enough shits to step in and comment. This single read erodes whatever town lean I had on LS based off of Holyflare's point regarding Lightningstrike's reaction to rsoultin giving up.

I'm going to break it down.


I'm not Bats.


Good, my case on Breshke was a strong one.


No I haven't. Unless meh means something entirely different where LS comes from. I have been open to challenges about my reads, I have actively presented information and ideas to the thread, including multiple opinions about players backed up by analysis or explanation of why I think what I think. At best it's insulting that he thinks my game has been meh, at worst it simply means he has no idea and "meh" is an easy word to throw in there when talking about a no name player.


No I haven't been bad. Yes we don't know if my #1 scumread backed by a strong case is mafia, but we do know that my #2 scumread, also backed by a very strong and factually correct case was mafia. I ended up voting on the correct wagon because of precisely this, I am willing to compromise and my intentions were clear through my posts all throughout day 1. Again, at best this is insulting, and at worst he's just throwing it out there because he hasn't read a single word I've said.


If we ignore the fact that I am not batsnacks, even if I was what the hell would this sentence have to do with his read on me? Why does this matter? Let's pretend LS hadn't written anything about bats because obviously anything written about bats is both irrelevant to the case at hand and doesn't apply to me, being not bats.

So what's left of LS's read on me? I'll post it again.



Why not just straight up admit he hasn't read me instead of posting that is clearly lying on his part. Both of the statement (meh and bad) can be proven to be false by reading my filter, yet he posts them anyway. The following are the possible reasons for posting what he posted in his list:

#1: He wants to antagonize me to try to get me to respond and get a read on me.

#2: He wants to antagonize me because he's a massive dick

#3: He hasn't read anything I've said but felt like he needed to have an opinion on me.

I see no indication that #1 is true because he threw out a bunch of other "meh" reads in his list. I cannot comment on all of those simply because I don't have the in-depth analysis of everyone involved to be qualified to speak about it. Maybe LS is just an asshole of a player, but I haven't gotten that feeling from his posting so that leaves me to conclude the correct conclusion is #3.

In which case he is mafia because he is making up reads.

I'm voting LS.

On May 02 2015 08:34 sicklucker wrote:
im too bored to follow this game.

So Jean Valjean should have two checks and we should know who their on. If someone didnt go and look at his reads on the player below him on the list you probably should.

On May 02 2015 08:49 The Shining wrote:
I know but it still pertains to me, as I was literally just thinking about how Breshkes role, like LS/Obi/Chez/IJ's roles, don't necessarily give me anything alignment indicative.

GP though. And to answer you about my joke earlier, let's just hope it is Vivax so I can stalk someone tonight. Good thing is, they can't rb both RSo and myself tonight so something good should come out of next night phase.

On May 02 2015 22:00 indignant wrote:

No, I would rather he just says it directly.

On May 02 2015 22:05 indignant wrote:

Why even bother thinking about him? It is clear who we lynch today and it is clear that he has been severely damaged regardless of alignment. Scum will kill him very soon if he is town.

On May 02 2015 22:17 indignant wrote:

I am still catching up which is more interesting than talking about HF. If you want me to comment on him tell me what your problem is. If it is that he called you 3p then I can't help you. That's not alignment indicative.