Jean: rsoul does have a point though in the fact that "clean" doesn't generally mean that your posts are perfect, but rather that they're overly constructed and careful instead of genuine.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 15:25 GMT

#2743

On April 30 2015 00:11 Jean Valjean wrote:

Show nested quote +

At the time I wasn't around to post anything that was of much value and I just got annoyed at that post by rsoultin.

Regarding your suggestion that maybe he's just bad, I still don't quite get why he would in that case say something that's wrong. Even bad players are capable of just pointing out things that are factually correct. I just think it's weird that he wouldn't simply admit to not having a clue if he didn't. Why is he trying to make it look like he has put more effort into the game than he has? That's what is bothering me.

Maybe I was overreacting and I should just stick to Vivax. There really does exist a reason for Vivax being mafia as I explained in my post about his read against me.

Show nested quote +

Sure but why wouldn't I post in a constructed manner? I think my posts are extremely easy to read and help people process my thoughts in a straightforward manner. Why would I immediately post every thought that comes to me like a blathering monkey instead of presenting the things I have to say in a pleasant and constructed manner?

It's not like using paragraphs makes me mafia, is it?

I hope the "blathering monkey" doesn't refer to me

In any case, I was mostly pointing out that your response to being called "clean" was based on a false assumption. With that out of the way, yeah, it doesn't really make you scum. Each has their own playstyle. Generally though it's not a good sign if someone makes huge posts with lots of text and little conclusions... You do at least have conclusions, it's just that your style is somewhat detached from the thread and as such can give the impression of not caring too much. Personally I have a hard time townreading you and if you're town, you could maybe focus on A) giving your input on relevant discussion topics B) finding genuinely new / useful stuff that nobody else noticed yet. You've been kind of doing B, but it's been... more like explaining why you'd think some way, not pushing your opinion to make others change their mind or to get feedback.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 15:27 GMT

#2744

Damdred hasn't really done much that I can remember. What's going for him is his vote on sandroba but I hope he does something else too.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 16:20 GMT

#2767

On April 30 2015 00:35 indignant wrote:
I swear I did not read Xatalos post before I answered.

Such a parrot

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 16:21 GMT

#2768

I hope HF at least submits the fight thing.

It's a bit sad since he promised to promote the fight but we'll see.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 17:57 GMT

#2861

You'll hang for punching me

##Unvote
##Vote FecalFeast

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 18:08 GMT

#2865

Hm yeah he did look like he thought he had catched The Shining or something.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 20:37 GMT

#2978

Honestly it's just too unlikely for FF to be town IMO. And if he was, we'd still have to explain the actions through some other means. Occam's razor.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 29 2015 20:40 GMT

#2983

Nah, lynch FF. Everything just fits if he's scum. Something like a wandering miller also sounds exactly like a scum fakeclaim IMO.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 30 2015 11:45 GMT

#3308

Hence to fight and conquer in all your battles is not supreme excellence; supreme excellence consists in breaking the enemy's resistance without fighting.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 30 2015 11:48 GMT

#3309

Votestealing roles are indeed more Mafia-oriented so that's not looking so good... It's a bit baffling why he would claim here though.

I'd like to hear the "specific reason" he mentioned to me before he gets lynched or something though

It might even clear him.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 30 2015 11:49 GMT

#3310

On April 30 2015 17:53 Breshke wrote:

Show nested quote +

3p survivor claim

Surprised indignant didn't jump on this :D

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

April 30 2015 11:50 GMT

#3311

On April 30 2015 17:54 marvellosity wrote:
I would say, given sand flipped with vote-altering powers, if LS were mafia, that's a lot of vote-altering powers mafia has its disposal

This is true too... Then again, it's probably not OP considering that there are a ton of town roles.