I put my save Slam as soon as he claimed obs. Actually I accidentally put it on Marv while I wanted to put it on Slam, but I managed to realize and change it at the very last minute. I would not be able to save rsoultin during n2 because I am unable to change the roach bait ability.

I did absorb KP because mafia KP was put on me n1.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:22 GMT

#1316

It's fine. If you want to try to make a big play you can fake-claim a red check on another scum read first to test reactions.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:24 GMT

#1319

Like giving out the red check straight away allowed us to:
- Townread SL (due to interactions that followed)
- Discuss plans for the next day, which led us to auto.

Also we already had 1 mafia down, so that kind of environment makes it pretty hard for mafia. Rough game for them. =/

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:26 GMT

#1324

On January 30 2015 11:24 rsoultin wrote:
yeah...

my biggest challenge was not being town kp night 1 @.@ everyone i'd played with before was all rsoul is scuuuum lol

I had you as scum early on, but then I noticed you were playing another game in which your filter looked similar (but role not revealed). As soon as you flipped town in that game I was pretty set on calling you town. Then you claimed cop with a red, which made it even easier to call you town.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:34 GMT

#1328

On January 30 2015 11:30 rsoultin wrote:

Show nested quote +

what was it about my posting that read scummy?

the other players I was talking about know i'm pretty active, which I wasn't early this game...I just figured that was the main reason for the reads

I think it was something along the lines of your post not contributing much and I couldn't really find a townie mindset behind it. Felt like you were hiding I guess. Can't really remember specifics, I usually do a lot of gut reads.

Same for mderg, his comment on palmar's plan early on was actually exceptionally scummy, but I was happy letting the day go along and see if he was going to be useful (towns can do scummy things too). He wasn't, so he was probably scum.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:37 GMT

#1329

Mafia KP was put on me and Palmar, which I think is rather questionable. You're never winning CC wars over the long term, so it's better to go after observers and let rest of town get suspicious of people leading the game, especially after losing a team mate d1. The double KP from Obi on two town (which was discussed in public) was an excellent way to add to that fire.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:38 GMT

#1331

Also Immortal is the coolest town role and is always going to get picked in top 3. Like it's essentially an upgraded VT.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:40 GMT

#1333

On January 30 2015 11:38 rsoultin wrote:

Show nested quote +

Honestly, between trying to figure out a way around scum!DP being townread by geript in MYLO in my other game and the sheer amount of insanity between the roles and picks and plans, I was just lost lol. And started focusing on the basics. Making reads.

Everyone else wanted to talk about roles and mechanics pretty much, though @.@ I've never played one of these before and also have no clue what protoss is. it was a fun challenge? lol

First game as well for PyP, pretty fun imo. Very hard to balance, though. I feel like mafia need a good plan for role picking.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:44 GMT

#1335

On January 30 2015 11:33 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
TBH I made up most of the rules on the spot. If you PM'd me about some technicality or other, I'd just pull an answer out of my ass.

No other rigging took place tho. I think LS generated the only one true random shot, and then everything else clocked in at 100%.

Thanks for hosting, Sent! Pretty cool roles & game. Sorry for spamming your inbox with questions. :D

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:46 GMT

#1337

On January 30 2015 11:39 IAmRobik wrote:
It's very disheartening to enter a scum chat and see marv's name knowing that he just tried his hardest in a scum game and he's never gonna replicate that effort this game

Yeah I realized it pretty quickly. Being mafia in a long game is fucking exhausting.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:48 GMT

#1338

On January 30 2015 11:25 Onegu wrote:
@. SL it was a drunk storm. If I could have changed it I would have. I most likely would have either stormed marv as he was afk or into the lurkers which would have been 3-7 spots. Sorry I was drunk didn't mean to be terrible.

I think I would've called for an mderg storm. It would've been awesome. Better luck next time, I guess!

Also, don't play mafia when you're drunk. Unless you're mafia.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:49 GMT

#1340

Not easy (co-)hosting a game like this, I would imagine.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:51 GMT

#1342

Immortal

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

January 30 2015 02:55 GMT

#1348

From top of my head:

Palmar: Warp Prism
Superbia: Immortal
Obi: Colossus
Robik: Probe
rsoultin: Phoenix
FF: Probe (probably tried to pick Immortal)
mderg: Oracle
SL: Probe (tried to pick Immortal)
Milkman: Carrier
Oats: Probe (not sure what he tried to pick)
Onegu: HT
Marv: DT
Slam: Obs