On November 05 2014 05:18 LightningStrike wrote:
Fine I will tell you my role since I going to get lynched anyway I am a Town Detective so if you lynch me oh well gl finding them without direct help.

"town detective" don't claim my role bro

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 04 2014 20:23 GMT

#562

bats do you really believe his claim, i don't.

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

November 04 2014 20:24 GMT

#563

On November 05 2014 05:21 Breshke wrote:

Show nested quote +

"town detective" don't claim my role bro

Is this a real claim or just saying he's fakeclaiming?

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

November 04 2014 20:24 GMT

#564

On October 25 2014 05:52 Blazinghand wrote:

Sample PMs:

Show nested quote +

I don't see a detective.

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

November 04 2014 20:24 GMT

#565

why does he claim detective when the roles are cop/watcher/doctor

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

November 04 2014 20:25 GMT

#566

On November 05 2014 05:24 Fecalfeast wrote:

Show nested quote +

Is this a real claim or just saying he's fakeclaiming?

I doing a real claim that other guy is falsecaliming.

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

November 04 2014 20:26 GMT

#567

On November 05 2014 05:24 Fecalfeast wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't see a detective.

I got the pm from BH and he gave me Town Detective which is Cop o nthe OP list of roles.

Serejai

6007 Posts

November 04 2014 20:26 GMT

#568

But you claimed a role that isn't even in this game.

KelsierSC

United Kingdom10443 Posts

November 04 2014 20:26 GMT

#569

btw LS I am the real detective so if you really think you have been townier than me we can try to 1v1

or if you are truly town then just resend and we can move on

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

November 04 2014 20:26 GMT

#570

On November 05 2014 04:26 Serejai wrote:

Show nested quote +

On November 05 2014 04:18 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

On November 05 2014 04:00 Serejai wrote:

On November 05 2014 03:46 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
##Vote: Serejai

That vote and the rationale doesn't sit well at all with me. Explain yourself, please.

Lol, the rationale doesn't sit well? That's a very scummy thing to say. I know I'm town, and I don't know what cricket is. Therefore, if the lynch is going to be me or cricket... why would I let myself stay in the hot seat?

I don't think cricket is scum, but I know that I'm not; so if it's him or me, I'll choose him.

I thought you were town but this post of yours is scummy as shit.

Alright look if you're town, let me break this down for you. This:

On November 05 2014 03:58 Serejai wrote:
My vote would still be on Elvis if I had a choice, but I do not; it doesn't seem like anyone else is willing to commit to him.

I would be willing to change my vote to Immaterial as well, and here's why:

Is really scummy. If you keep your vote on Cricketer, and he gets enough votes to be lynched, and if you turn out to be right and he's actually town, you're helping scum win. That's one more wasted lynch for the town and one less person to eliminate for the mafia. You don't follow bandwagons either. That's what scum does because other people make misguided cases and then scummers can put nails in the coffin.

Now here you have a case on Immaterial. But after all that evidence that you dug up on him and you being convinced he's scum (which is what I'm getting from reading that post, you don't even vote for the guy. Why not? The rest of us will commit to him if and only if you deliver some sort of evidence that says "This guy is definitely the scum, and these guys who you're all voting for right now are town, or at least less scummy than Immaterial".

For example I'm voting for you because you have way too many scumreads, are doing the most scum-beneficial things possible right now, and the people who you're voting for doesn't equate to the people who you think are scum. In other words, to answer your question, you're letting yourself stay in the hot seat right now.

So here's what I want you to do, if you're town:

1. There are three scum in the game. Give me the three who you think are the most scummy in this game. If you're really unsure about a third, you can do an alternate fourth.
2. Tell me why those three are the scummiest players in the game.
3 (optional but recommended). Before you post, play devil's advocate. Think about these players being town, and try to justify their actions. Use this to refine your final judgment.
4. Pick the scummiest of the bunch and vote for them.

You list four things, and I've already done them all.

1) I've stated my scumlist numerous times in this thread (Elvis, Fecal, bat, kush / Immaterial), and all that resulted from it was all four of them voting to lynch me.
2) I've stated why I think all of them are scum, and this resulted in my scumlist tunneling me.

Elvis did a reactionary vote just like you. The reason I picked you over him is that you call everyone scum and Elvis's posts have slightly more substance. You also kinda dug your hole on that one.

4) I've picked the scummiest of my scumlist (Elvis) and voted for them, which resulted in everyone getting scum reads on me because apparently Elvis is confirmed town.

It doesn't seem like you're in danger with the LS wagon. Also wtf the LS wagon. That said, I want you to try and make the best case you can for Elvis being town. Might not do a lot to your end goals, but it'll probably make your points a lot more weighty considering you looked at both sides of the coin. Right now it just looks like you're yelling at everyone who tries to oppose you on the thinnest strands of evidence, although I somewhat did like your case on Imma. It seemed more thought out, although it's got a long way to go.

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

November 04 2014 20:26 GMT

#571

On November 05 2014 05:25 LightningStrike wrote:

Show nested quote +

I doing a real claim that other guy is falsecaliming.

The only issue is that you claimed a role that doesn't exist. You already said you are new to mafia so I assume you're not using another site's terminology so what gives?

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

November 04 2014 20:27 GMT

#572

Do I have to copy and paste the pm of my role from BlazingHand?

batsnacks

United States4466 Posts

November 04 2014 20:28 GMT

#573

KSC you are brave. Good luck my friend.

##vote: LightningStroke

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

November 04 2014 20:28 GMT

#574

On November 05 2014 05:26 KelsierSC wrote:
btw LS I am the real detective so if you really think you have been townier than me we can try to 1v1

or if you are truly town then just resend and we can move on

Sucks having to counterclaim D1. Hope we have a doctor.