Can you explain why? This is how I see it:

Storr is scum: d1 he fools me, probably gets a misslynch. d2 I probably get a scumread on him and want to kill him.
Storr is town: d1 gets a pass, d2 I probably read him as town this day and rest of all days to come.

Worst case scenario we trade 1 townie for 1 scum, best case scenario I don't waste my time reading someone who is town on d1 and increase chances of hitting scum overall.

Keep in mind, this all is if I have no read on Storr d1, and I currently think he's likely town (I don't see any of his scum play).

Just give your opinion if you really think I'm doing something wrong here and let's move on. I'm not lynching storr today, end of story.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 25 2014 23:03 GMT

#411

On September 26 2014 08:02 SkyDragon wrote:
Seer is welcome to spy on me, I have nothing to hide.

???

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 25 2014 23:04 GMT

#412

What is this WIFOM garbage.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 25 2014 23:04 GMT

#413

On September 26 2014 07:57 Killing wrote:
All you need to win this game is a town circle of 7 (including yourself).

Killing
Storr
Superbia
HF
Haru
Hopeless

I personally think that's a strong town circle. Basically just need 1 more and game is easy rares especially since seer will probably come out with red or green on someone scummy tommorow. I really wanna hear reads from obi and bat.

How are you reading hopeless town?

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 25 2014 23:25 GMT

#420

All right, fair enough. Going to read bats massive wall now. Still waiting on Sky.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 00:01 GMT

#450

Sky is there an inverse relation between how scummy you read people and how much you want to push them? Like it's either that or it's you trying to prove to me that you're definitely not scum with hopeless and bats after I insinuated that you're scum with them. I suggest that you might be scum with hopeless and bats and next thing I know they're on your scum list and you're pushing on bats. I don't even know how to interpret what you're doing.

Bats, I like the energy you're putting into the read on GB, but I don't know how to feel about it. It feels like the meat of your read just seems like a gutread you're trying to justify and put it into words (like the third person read) and it feels a little awkward. I'm not sold on your read (feels like GB is just pushing), but I'm reading you town because of it. (Also the reads part was pretty funny)

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 00:10 GMT

#453

On September 26 2014 09:04 batsnacks wrote:
@Superbia the GB thing is a gut read. It's not a gut read I'm taking lightly though. I'm serious about everything I said.

Yeah that's fine. I might look it over again tomorrow, but for now I'll stay tentative since GB is still active. I really liked the palmar-vote read you posted afterwards, though.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 00:15 GMT

#456

On September 26 2014 09:12 SkyDragon wrote:
@Superbia - What you said is a non-issue to me. Storr was most suspicious to me anyway, and ObiWan became suspicious once Storr said that he's probably Town. I added Hopeless as third most suspicious before your comment about my read on Hopeless so it doesn't mean anything. I was going to call out Bats once Storr said to push someone but then he decided to make an appearance so I didn't have to.

So who do you think is most likely scum at this point? Storr or Bats?

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 00:16 GMT

#458

On September 26 2014 09:15 batsnacks wrote:
I'm going to be upset if GB and skydragon are both mafia but it's not looking good for them.

Why would this upset you?

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 00:20 GMT

#463

On September 26 2014 09:19 SkyDragon wrote:
I would say Bats at this stage. Storr just doesn't seem as suspicious to me anymore.

Why? Your main read on Storr was that he was aggressive (correct me if I'm wrong here), which he still very much is.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 01:07 GMT

#500

On September 26 2014 10:03 Fecalfeast wrote:

Show nested quote +

Come on man, spill the beans. You have to have some half-baked reads

Rofl, regardless of alignment, FF is entertaining.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 01:11 GMT

#502

Sky just disregard the whole meta game thing and keep playing. Has your opinion changed on Bats?

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 01:36 GMT

#508

I'm off for now. I'll evaluate the game tomorrow and see where my vote goes. Storr, I'll also read your wall tomorrow.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

September 26 2014 15:18 GMT

#658

This is currently my world:

Town:
StorrZerg - I've explained it before and the read is still the same. A thousand bonus townpoints for backing off on SkyDragon. Storr is going to stay in my towncircle unless something changes d2+.

Null (but special):
batsnacks - His push on GB read town to me. But then he pushes on Sky which is really fucking easy at that point in time. He does instantly back off as soon as Storr does. This might just be scum trying to buddy up by sheeping Storr, which would mean that Sky is town. As such, I'm ready to put bats on my scum list if Sky flips town (which means I'm decently happy to lynch Sky today).

Palmar - Palmar trying to take charge of town is scaring the shit out of me. Where was this Palmar last game? What changed? I like his Hopeless push, it's someone who I've felt might be scummy as well. But ugh. Does anyone have any information on Palmar's scumplay with links and shit? Because at this rate I'm never going to have a good read on him unless we lynch hopeless and he flips scum, which I'm not convinced about at this point in time.

Palmar, what is your opinion on FF? Have you read what I've said about him? If so, what do you think?

Scum:
Fecalfeast - Read still the same, he hasn't done anything significant since I've given this read except go on Sky, which seems like a very fucking easy lynch/push at that point. The fact that no one else has pinged you out for this is also really weird. Scum should be on your fucking ass for this shit, but no one is. You're scum.

SkyDragon (leaning) - You've been given some space, I'm expecting you to use this space before the EoD to come up with some good content. Failure to do so means I lynch you.

Hopeless (leaning) - Palmar has given a decent push on hopeless already. His filter feels devoid of any kind of proactivity. Why are you fine with sitting back and just giving comments? Fucking do something (see below). I would also really like to see you start a push on someone. I'd prefer lynching FF and Sky (if he keeps lurking) over hopeless right now, but I think we have a somewhat decent shot of hitting scum here if we want to go down this path.

At this point I would like a town/scum circle/list from the following people before EoD:
- Hopeless1der
- Glowingbear
- ObiWanShinobi
- HaruRH
- FecalFeast
- Batsnacks
- justanothertownie
- StorrZerg

##Vote: FecalFeast