|
@marv: Does that mean I don't get an answer?
I don't think your reason for townreading Apathy is good - him giving up his smurf easily means almost nothing when other players already said they figured out who he was (I think from that anime picture)? Anyway he is likely to be town IMO, but more because his d1 felt pretty good and bunnies' play feels pretty scummy to me.
|
@marv You seem to think BH is scummy for not leading town. As someone many people expected to lead town, why have you done so little to lead town today? Why are you dismissing me instead of trying to convince me if I am voting for someone you think is town?
|
|
On August 31 2014 01:42 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2014 01:40 Amiko wrote: @marv You seem to think BH is scummy for not leading town. As someone many people expected to lead town, why have you done so little to lead town today? Why are you dismissing me instead of trying to convince me if I am voting for someone you think is town? I've not stated or even insinuated that once.
On August 31 2014 01:34 marvellosity wrote: we're what, 4.5h from deadline? and BH has done nothing, and he's not leading the votes.
|
@Wave Because if I poke him he answers my question whether he intends to be a jerk or not.
Maybe he is still voting Blazinghand partly because BH has done so little, but that couldn't have been his reason when the day started (because BH hadn't done nothign yet)
Since he's said he doesn't feel that BH is scummy for not leading town, it indicates to me his reasoning is that he still townreads batsnacks, or feels that Blazinghand's low activity is scummier than batsnacks' activity. Imo batsnacks' last few posts don't look that good to me so he feels scummier.
|
@marv What do you think of the content batsnacks actually posted? Have you considered it or are you just set on voting Blazinghand because of his non-activity?
If you can convince me batsnacks' last few posts are better than I thought I'm open to moving to Blazinghand.
|
Btw let's just point out the irony: Marv is able to be a dick and not answer questions because it is his "meta" that he will ignore your questions. Marv wants to vote Blazinghand because he doesn't want Blazinghand to be able to get away with not playing the game.
Btw this is not indicative to me of an alignment. More indicative of personality >:D
|
On August 31 2014 01:57 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2014 01:51 Amiko wrote: @marv What do you think of the content batsnacks actually posted? Have you considered it or are you just set on voting Blazinghand because of his non-activity?
If you can convince me batsnacks' last few posts are better than I thought I'm open to moving to Blazinghand. Show nested quote +On August 31 2014 01:55 Not really holyflare wrote:On August 31 2014 01:51 Amiko wrote: @marv What do you think of the content batsnacks actually posted? Have you considered it or are you just set on voting Blazinghand because of his non-activity?
If you can convince me batsnacks' last few posts are better than I thought I'm open to moving to Blazinghand. Also, if someone can convince me that bat's listpost is far from scummy, I might be willing to switch to BH. Ugh I hate when people do this. It looks really scummy, like you're hoping that somebody makes an excuse for you to vote a towny (not that BH is necessarily). [
Yeah I understand that, but if marv is going to try to lead town at the end of D1 I'd like to think he's actually read one of the few posts from batsnacks that has substance.
|
|
@Wave LOL The prologue of that book even takes place in California
|
|
On August 31 2014 02:41 batsnacks wrote: @amiko
If you don't understand why me, and others, voted BH then I won't be able to explain it to you. Sorry.
Bunnies has been in the past more conversational as scum and less analytical.
I voted BH at the beginning of the day because I thought ritoky and me were the towniest d1. I kept voting BH because there was no reason to switch.
I'm fine with your explanation on Blazinghand.
It seems to me that bunnies has been fairly conversational and not very analytical (sort of the reverse of what you are describing) - can you flesh that out a little bit?
|
Back in thread should be here through deadline.
@Blazinghand: Can you share your read on WaveofShadow? I'm interested in this because he seemed more persuaded by the pregame-ingame inconsistency with your cell ordering.
|
On August 31 2014 04:58 ritoky wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2014 04:49 Blazinghand wrote:On August 31 2014 04:44 Damdred wrote: BH, if you would I left a few questions for you in my filter that you have not gotten to yet. Could you look over them and answer some of the things you haven't answered yet for me?
Also BH any other reads on the other cells yet? Sure, I'll respond. Besides the 27nb read I'm still working. I'm focusing on they next two cells. blazeit420mlgnoscopehand, i don't really find anything particularly damning per se about you. however, i have a couple concerns: and this is also in regards to what you said about bunnies vote earlier. when there was a wagon on you, a great many people had still not voted in the thread, and were holding their votes waiting. then suddenly a counterpush comes onto bats, and a whole lot of people throw their votes down in the opposite direction. yet the reasoning behind the counterpush doesn't seem strong enough to garner all these votes in my eyes. so my concern is that a couple mafia were waiting to see if they had to nail you in your coffin or if something could happen to shove it the other way. this is exactly what happened to meapak last cell game and surprisingly enough it was led by holyflare who seems to be a prime contributor to this one. can you please ease these concerns of mine?
This was something I was thinking about earlier, but I felt like more people would have jumped onto Blazinghand following the me pointing out the inconsistency pre-game and in-game if that was the case.
|
(Not because it's super strong evidence, but because it seems like it could be strong evidence or a good excuse to vote without much thought)
|
@ritoky: I think my only question is whether you know who NRHF or your mom is- I know NRHF but don't know your mom, so was curious if that played into your reads
|
also Batsnacks is voting BH now and lilwade put his vote into the voting thread
|
|
GG It's possible ritoky's scum but Blazinghand seems much more likely to me. (Regardless of alignment I think ritoky played pretty well this game, gj whatever you are)
|
My impression is that bunnies is the scum in this cell but I'll take a look later tonight and try to make more of a case out of it.
@Lilwade Can you talk about professor apathy?
|
|
|
|