IV Titanic Mafia: It Has Been a Privilege - Page 56

On July 24 2014 20:19 GlowingBear wrote:


I actually think this is his town play. But I'm considering his meta, though.
And you? What's your opinion?

On July 24 2014 20:27 batsnacks wrote:


Yeah I'm more than a little tired of playing with people who just call each other idiots all game. It makes me want to troll those people, but I'm trying to behave. You can try again day 2 assuming you get the chance.

On July 24 2014 20:22 GlowingBear wrote:


I see a damdred wagon without a damdred case. What is the argument for lynching him? If there is not a single discussion, I think the chances aren't big.

@Xatalos: what do you think of lynching koshi?

On July 24 2014 20:29 Xatalos wrote:


The argument is that he set up for voting me without any kind of commitment, didn't pursue that line of thought and has generally stayed almost invisible in the discussion while making a somehow passable amount of posts.

I think Koshi is acting stupid but it's not reason enough lynch him. He should be easier to read on D2+.

On July 24 2014 20:26 Vivax wrote:
Xata how can you feel CR's push seems genuine it gives me a different impression.
If it were a push on me based on his reasons I wouldn't be as chill as you are.



The reason is simple. His posts read like he cares, he posted a case on Xatalos without according followup, he promised stuff he didn't deilver, he doesn't post much at all.

People like him are more likely to be scum over people like VA who openly look bad instead of hiding behind townie sounding posts.

On July 24 2014 20:34 Xatalos wrote:


I think it was the way he responded to my questions or something. It felt like he genuinely had a thought process behind his push and it wasn't just a fake push.

On July 24 2014 20:27 Koshi wrote:



Why do they look good if you have 0 clues on them.

On July 24 2014 20:31 Vivax wrote:


What would be an acceptable reason for you to scumread Koshi then, acting stupid not D1, but D2?

On July 24 2014 20:29 Xatalos wrote:


The argument is that he set up for voting me without any kind of commitment, didn't pursue that line of thought and has generally stayed almost invisible in the discussion while making a somehow passable amount of posts.

I think Koshi is acting stupid but it's not reason enough lynch him. He should be easier to read on D2+.

On July 24 2014 20:40 Xatalos wrote:


I have a terrible history of reading Koshi so I'll just quote a guideline I received from a player with better success reading him:

"Koshi I think is really easy to read, he becomes really obvious town some time on Night 1 or Day 2 if he is town. e.g. in ## mafia I thought he was suspicious on day 1 but mid day 2 he was easily my strongest townread. he bleeds his thought process into the thread. it's really transparent, you just gotta read and put yourself in his shoes."

On July 24 2014 20:37 Xatalos wrote:


Not looking that good or bad is better than just looking bad. I didn't have any real issues with any of those votes besides the vote from batsnacks.

On July 24 2014 09:57 batsnacks wrote:
I'm going to sheep CR because I liked the case. Better than any case I could have made.

##Vote: xatalos

Someone ask me questions I feel scummy. But make sure they're nice questions or I'll probably just ignore them.

On July 24 2014 20:37 Koshi wrote:
##unvote
##vote Chopin Listzs

I got to have my vote on this guy as well. Also highhh chance on scum.

On July 24 2014 20:43 Koshi wrote:


You say the case from CR is pretty genuine, why can't batsnacks not believe in the case?

and tbh, that CR case on you looked pretty good. I mean, the joke in the start was enough to vote you if Vivax wasn't so damn scummy the entire game.

On July 23 2014 17:23 Koshi wrote:
I wonder if people really think that Xatalos made that post and was serious about it. Silly guys.

Anyhoezels. Only 3 scummers. If you think scum makes a entrance post like Xatalos in this game as scum I don't know what to say... Unless you can proof he is going for the too scummy to be scum tactic. And I think Xatalos can't do that.


So Xatalos confirmed town.

I mean, the joke in the start was enough to vote you

On July 24 2014 20:37 Vivax wrote:


Go into detail if you can. Show us your thought process while you quote one of the posts that made you get that idea. It's your head on the line so it's in your best interest, and also in mine to find out what you are.

On July 24 2014 09:00 Chairman Ray wrote:


I already said this before, but there's an associative tell between you and Koshi which I can't ignore. Doesn't do much good before you flip.