Witchcraft Mini Mafia II - Page 7

On November 07 2013 04:42 Sn0_Man wrote:
Im around but I'm (as you can see) not posting much atm. This game is disheartening considering I'm somehow "scummy" and pointing out things that others do when I consider them scummy somehow is an excuse for OO to be an insulting asshole.

I dont know what the hell we are gonna do about cephiro, but he's playing much more town-aligned than last game (may have to do with him having a weird ass role last game). Lynching him doesn't seem smart atm.

ET seems pretty town not sure why people wish to lynch him.

Rayn is playing very different but afaik its different from anything he's done before as scum or town and I'm OK with his train of thought. Not his conclusions but he feels reasonably town too.

Umasi/Vanesco/HzFlank are all pretty null, i have no kinda "ins" to read these guys so far. Onegu kinda fits this category too, but I'd rather lynch him than the others I think.

Syl I don't like. Mostly because him and OO have hard-buddied. Not that I'd expect them to do that as scum, but they haven't even been a little bit suspicious of each other despite said buddying. Generally somebody attempting to buddy me makes me very suspicious (at least when I feel like I'm obvtown). Syl's scumgames often include real effort at the start with long, very "effort-y" posts put in at fairly regular intervals so I'm gonna keep my eye on him. Then again i've Mislynched Syl for dumb shit too. He's on the scum side of null, along with OO.

WoS is hard for me this game. Half the time he sounds like he's thinking the game and obvtown. Then the other half his posts just rub me the wrong way. I've played a fair few games with (always rolls town) WoS and something feels off, dunno. Don't think we lynch him soon either but I can't just give him the townread I've given others (ET/Thrawn etc).

Thats like everybody relevant I think.

I'm willing to discuss stuff with ppl but I'm currently 100% unwilling to interact with OO due to how he's played so far. My scumread on him hinges on his mindset towards the game: All he cares about is people's perception of him and that they see him as conftown. He doesn't actually care to play well, just to appear good. My unwillingness to interact with him is completely separate from that, though it probably clouds my vision somewhat.

On November 07 2013 05:01 thrawn2112 wrote:
oh we're posting our reads way before the deadline? me next!

WoS is town and I don't feel the need to explain why.

hzflank is town and deserves a medal for displaying great courage and valor while under fire.

Vanesco is a townie dude, he really seems to care about his arguments and making people answer his questions.

Ceph... seems town. I can't sense any dishonesty coming from that guy. However, out of all my reads this is the one I'm the most apprehensive about.

Sn0 imo is pretty obviously town but I can understand why people think he's not. I don't think he'd appear as comfortable posting as he does if this were his first real scum game.

ET.. I would have called him town without hesitation at the end of D1 for being one of the few who were around at deadline and actually discussed things instead of dropping off their vote at the last minute. However I'm kinda pissed that he's gone silent since the lynch. He is mostly town in my mind but he needs to return in full force asap

rayn.. jesus idk... I think I change my mind about him more often than I do about any other player. WoS you will hate this, but ironically you are the one who makes me go from ":scum" to "who knows" on rayn for now, because of that comment you made about how I should already know that town rayn is kinda crazy. I'm gonna take a pass on this one and not even give you guys a read because it'd probably be a bs read and very likely to change very soon.

umasi, I must have a mental block on this guy because I can never remember anything he posts. I have him as town in my notes but I can't remember the feeling I got that made me write that, so I'm gonna call him null


OO is scum dandelion from BEMMII. I am going to park my vote on this guy for D2 until he decides to actually explain his reads instead of writing "fake" cases.

Syl scum? Maybe. Actually, probably. Mainly by process of elimination, but also because of the inordinate amount of sad faces he posts. I shoulda lynched him instead of gumshoe after changing my mind about hzflank.

Soooooo I only have 2 people picked for scum, which means that my reads are probably horribly fucked up.

OH FUCK I skipped Onegu, he must be 3rd scum. Case closed. (Actually I AM leaning scum on him right now for reasons I gave a few posts ago)

On November 07 2013 05:07 Sn0_Man wrote:
Did u read hogwarts WoS?

On November 07 2013 05:12 thrawn2112 wrote:
I know what you're saying. But one of the main reasons I was initially suspicious of rayn was because of what I perceived to be a crazy and insane fixation on ET. Once you reminded me that he can do that as town, which he has done to me, I could no longer think he's scum because of that tunnel. There have been times where I was sure of him being scum and times where I was sure of the opposite, which is why for now I am refusing to give my read on rayn until I come to a decision I'm more confident about.

On November 07 2013 05:17 thrawn2112 wrote:


Then go read a few pages starting from here. Everything he does leads up to a bigass case which ended up being "fake." Throughout the ordeal he was being purposefully antagonistic. Whenever someone tries to argue with OO in this game he responds by puffing up his chest and acting like he's above it all. How is that not exactly like scum dandel? he may have more "content" but I can't give him credit for that because it all ended up being for nothing anyways.

On November 07 2013 11:07 thrawn2112 wrote:
oh fuck WoS you are probably gonna be pretty pissed

On November 07 2013 11:16 thrawn2112 wrote:


I'm gonna have to bail on that rayn-train lol

On November 07 2013 13:18 Onegu wrote:



I think they are both scum.... I just pointed that out.... I am ok with either lynch.

On November 07 2013 13:24 thrawn2112 wrote:


yeah I know. but forget about ET and rayn for now because this vote onegu just made is crazy. I looked through his filter and he never talks to or about rayn as if he thinks he's mafia. Onegu never implies that he thinks rayn is scum until just now, and the only reasoning was because maybe scum rayn was trying to save scum hzflank? This is after Onegu start throwing out quotes to show that hzflank is scum... why wouldn't he just vote for hz? The answer... as much as you hate to admit it, imo is because rayn is town and onegu thinks that's an easier mislynch.

On November 07 2013 13:28 thrawn2112 wrote:


Do you remember that quote rayn provided?

On November 07 2013 14:03 thrawn2112 wrote:


yeah, I think what he's doing is backtracking, but if you believe him then he's not backtracking. he claimed to have been developing suspicions about rayn earlier, he just didn't point them out. we have to accept that on faith because there is nothing in his filter to prove to us on way or the other if he ever thought rayn was mafia

so the two choices are:

1) believe that he did think rayn was scum before now, except he didn't say anything about it and chose to talk about other stuff instead
2) he's scum and playing terribly

On November 07 2013 14:05 Onegu wrote:



Wait where did I say I thought rayn was scum earlier? The first time was when I saw his BS reason for makeing me look bad, hell I voted dor him to be blue before this.