I also don't like how you say that people are looking for someone to lynch and that I'm not helping myself right now. It seems that you are trying to make me want to stop posting for a while...

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 30 2013 17:49 GMT

#244

E00e I'm curious what you think of the game so far as the only thing you have mentioned (directed towards anyway) is that you "agree with the scummy things about cakeman". Other than that you are acting similarly to what OWB did before and I also called him out.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 30 2013 19:10 GMT

#259

So far E00e's only statements about other players has been:
"Jonnys' accusations seem forced and I dont feel bad about Vanesco"
"I agree with the scummy things about cakeman"
"Jonny's and July's posts seem off because they are inconsistent"

There has been no logic and reasoning to anything he has said so far and I also would like to hear why he has the reads he has. It seems like all of his statements are just an "insert name here" statement and can be said about almost anyone.

@nyxnyxnyx
On page 10 is the timer, voting ends as of 1 day and 4 hours from this post

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 30 2013 20:47 GMT

#264

E00e has posted right before July asked him to explain and then went quiet for a bit. I later ask for E00e to explain his accusations and again he goes quiet for a long time. Since he's not willing to talk maybe having more pressure on him will make him. Along with that, as explained in one of my previous posts, he has not given any actual information and as such he is reading scummy to me.

##Vote: E00e

I also want to remind people that OdinOfPergo is the only one that hasn't posted anything.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 30 2013 22:35 GMT

#270

@E00e
I will not say if I agree with you or not since you give no reasoning. I may or may not agree on some people, but I may disagree with the specific accusation you are giving. If you are town I would recommend giving more reasoning for your reads (even if they are obvious to you), but if you are scum then I don't mind if you remain quiet since it will be an easy lynch. Your only "kinda" accusation is on a maybe one of the first 5 posts of the game. So are you telling me all you have from this game are from only the first page of posts and have nothing else from the rest of the game? Well since my jumping to conclusion is correct then I guess it was the correct move, is it not?

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 00:11 GMT

#281

I would like to hear from Storr if he is around. He has been fairly quiet this in his reads. Storr said he would "explain more on cake latter". He has also only mentioned no read on people or town reads on them. I'm curious just what type of reads he has and any scum reads he may have since almost everybody has posted something at this point.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 01:19 GMT

#292

@Balla
I do not like your vote at the moment you made it. It's like you are saying you will look into it but vote before doing so, as if it doesn't matter if storr has posted something useful or not.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 01:24 GMT

#293

@JonnyLaw
I am at the moment just waiting until poofter shows up again. I would rather wait for him to respond before giving an opinion I have on him.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 01:44 GMT

#297

Balla you mentioned before that you are holding off your reads because of lurkers. Now that most of us have said something, may I ask what reads you have, especially since you keep asking people on their opinions on others. It seems to me like you should have some info that could be useful to town since we are starting to get into early votes.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 02:08 GMT

#299

Ok, I understand where your reads are coming from kinda. May I ask for your opinion on E00e or have you just forgotten about him atm?

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 02:28 GMT

#301

I will be afk for roughly 3-4 hours

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 06:45 GMT

#371

So I am now back and should be for a bit over an hour until I go to bed.

Currently I am still waiting on E00e. I think we all agreed to lynch lurkers and he has been called out three times. First by July, no response. Then later by me, no response. Suddenly I vote him, and guess what a response. What has he done since, nada. All of the "reads" he has said he have either been: "i agree with", "i disagree with", or questions. At least on storr there is some activity by him when town wants him to talk, but E00e was called out and has gone back into hiding. I would rather lynch E00e at this point before lynching storr.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 06:59 GMT

#381

What are peoples opinions on E00e? He has done nothing to this game, has hidden from accusations, and is a lurker. It seems like everytime he is brought up people just forget about him.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 07:44 GMT

#385

Alright I'm heading off to bed. Should be back on in 6ish hours.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 13:36 GMT

#395

Even tho E00e has now at least spoken up I still don't like many points he has given. I still don't like how E00e has avoided answer questions that me and July asked UNTIL he was voted on, then he decided to respond. Obviously I would have expected you to respond, which is why since asking you didn't work I had voted.

Also you never explain any of your reads apart from saying something along the lines of "it was discussed already so I don't have to". You mention July and Jonny are inconsistent with no reasoning which just looks like you are trying to throw the blame on somebody else. You even mention that you are leaving your reasonings off the table. As a town I don't understand how not giving town any insight or reads you have on another player is actually helping.

In your latest few posts you don't talk about anything specific again and harp on maybe how Odin came into the game very aggressively. Only point thats valid is that some of his postings have been distracting but after maybe the first few, its mostly all about the game. I still haven't seen you come up with any of your own original reads with any actual evidence or they have been very weak at best.

Overall, at this point the most two scummy people seem to be E00e/July. E00e's response now is much better than what July has brought to the game. All July has done is ask questions, try to attack me on something he misread and not backing off when I (and others I think) explain it. He has also given no reads and has been lurking. He has contributed nothing of use for town to the game. To me I would say July is a stronger vote than E00e at this point, but if town decides that E00e is the best lynch, I would have no problem with that.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 13:40 GMT

#396

July also mentions he doesn't want to dig his own grave when Balla wants him to talk more. It also doesn't really matter if Balla is mafia or town, because any post he makes both townies and mafia will see, no matter who is mafia. So not responding to Balla when he asks for more is very suspicious to me. He also mentions that he would rather keep them precise and to the point when I don't recall a single post being just that.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 15:30 GMT

#399

Unfortunately I have to go afk again but will be back 2-ish hours before voting ends.

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 22:22 GMT

#561

Ok, I am back now.

Before leaving I had my vote on E00e. Not that I don't think he is scummy but like I mentioned before, July was seeming more scummy to me. The reason why I think July is a good day 1 lynch is because he has not really given the town anything useful and his last few posts are basically screaming "I give up, I don't want to play anymore". How I see it is that best case scenario he is scum, worst case scenario we get rid of a useless town who has mostly useless posts which only creates distractions for other players to use to their advantage.

Apart from this the three players that seem like we can get a majority lynch on are E00e, July, or Odin. All 3 in my opinion would be good lynches but my largest scum read (on these 3) to smallest would be:
July
E00e
Odin

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 22:25 GMT

#562

Because of my reasons above and it currently seems like most of the town have voted on July I will also change my vote. I will still be around till the end of voting so if anybody has anything about these 3 players or a very big argument (that they think is a MUCH better lynch) then I will change my vote accordingly.

##Vote: July617

Vanesco

United States105 Posts

October 31 2013 22:36 GMT

#568

The problem July is that your argument is "don't kill me cause I'm town" and then you will probably lose the game without me. Also, usually with mafia setup's town is allowed to have 1 miss lynch, which is why I am not too worried yet if the lynch turns up town because even then, the interactions done with that player can help give reads on others. You have done nothing to convince me that you are town. The fact that many people are on the July vote might make you look more town, however as I have mentioned before, getting rid of dead weight, especially with 1 miss lynch allowed, is not the worst thing that town could end up doing.

Prev 1 2 3 Next All

Please or register to reply.

Live Events Refresh