Well you obviously think they are scummy, sans the super. Don't avoid the question. Why are chrom/umasi scummier than other dudes like superfluous / lurkers?

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 13 2013 18:30 GMT

#491

I think Gotard is mafia

His first post is a giant list that accomplishes next to nothing and provides little original. Lists are generally an easy way to feign contribution while doing jack.

+ Show Spoiler +

On July 13 2013 19:53 Gotard wrote:
Hello! After some lurking (jk I was sleeping) i'd like to share my thoughts:

1) hzflank - cold, calculated. Null read.
2) StiMaDDict - bad town. It would be too easy if he's mafia.
3) Chromatically - I think he's pushing stim too hard (he's agressive in general) but at the same time it's good for town to see some bandwagons going
4) jrkirby - confuses me a little.But he has a similar view on StiMaDDict as i do.

Show nested quote +

5) Koshi - inexperienced or lurking hard.
6) Xzavier - one good post

Show nested quote +

No wait, that one was good. Need to see some more activity from him to have a read. I don't agree that lynching lurker is better than no lynch (9v3 > 8v3)

7) Rainbows - A lot of posts with minimum impact seems more townie than mafia.

Show nested quote +

wtf?

8) Nightcat99 - lurking newbie.
9) Umasi - Very aggressive same as last game I played with him (He was town).
11) Hurricane Sponge - biggest town read. Really liked this post.
12) Superfluous - Town vibe.
13) cloud-9 - US timezone and 0 posts.

He also seems apprehensive about making decisions. In the following he notes that he is "confused. . . not sure of anything", as if he doesn't want to take responsibility for his scum reads. His jokes (see below and above) are also punctuated with (jk) like he really doesn't want to be taken seriously. "Just incase you guys were wondering, that's a joke post" -MLuneth, scum.

On July 13 2013 20:12 Gotard wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 13 2013 19:57 Chromatically wrote:
Gotard, who do you want to lynch?

Easy question. Umasi and Xzavier!!! (jk)

I'm really confused because my biggest (biggest doesn't mean that i'm really sure of anything) scum reads don't think that Stim is mafia. Maybe they don't want to vote on him because they know that this is too easy and don't want to jump on him that early.

Show nested quote +
On July 13 2013 19:57 Chromatically wrote:
Why don't you think that Stim is scum?

He looks like a bad town not like mafia.

The rest of Gotard's filter is calling Stim not mafia. He's obviously bad town guise and not mafia.. he knows?

Anyway, Gotard has a low post count, does lists, and seems nervous about things when he really shouldn't be if town. I think he's scum. Discuss.

##Vote: Gotard

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 13 2013 19:20 GMT

#497

Consider Gotard, he is mafia. Fairly inactive and scummy. Good lynch.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 13 2013 20:18 GMT

#518

Super sounds so scummy, or like he plays on epicmafia.com too much.

In either case we do need 7 votes to lynch today. if its a nl, imma be pissed.

We need to consolidate a few candidates that we can choose from. I say Gotard Jlirby and super

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 13 2013 20:26 GMT

#521

half a day left and a lot havent posted or barely have :/ just keep it in mind. the inactives at least

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 13 2013 20:36 GMT

#525

Gotard, would you like some syrup with your waffle?

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 13 2013 22:45 GMT

#561

Gotard still scummy guise

..

whenever i get home ill revote cus u guys dont wanna kill him.

im feeling jrkirby is the better lynch, I'll case it later.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 17:57 GMT

#628

So I've done some analysis of the voting patterns of the moment. JrKirby is in grave danger... why isn't he voting Super?

That strikes me as odd. Scum would do it to stay alive. Town would do it to stay alive. Anyone have some insight as to motivation (with the exception of 'he thinks Gotard is scum and not Super') because I can't justify it from either alignments perspective.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 18:06 GMT

#632

I think Gotard is scum and is trying to lynch Jrkirby instead of Super, his scumbuddy :p dem pre-flip associations. So bad, but so tempting.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 18:16 GMT

#636

On July 15 2013 03:15 StiMaDDict wrote:
@Rainbow: Explain your unvote on Gotard please. Has your scumread on him changed or do you feel as if you need to change your vote due to majority voting system.

I think he's scum. Just not the scum we're lynching today.

Since he's voting JrKirby, I feel like Super is the better lynch.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 18:28 GMT

#641

On July 15 2013 03:19 Chromatically wrote:

Show nested quote +

You're voting purely based on preflip associations, which you just said were bad?

Both dudes on the block are scummy, Super just has less redeeming qualities.Pre-flip associations are bad. Very bad. Though as a mortal, I do bad things all the time.

The problem I'm facing is figuring out which wagon is scum. My town reads are all over these two guys (and if my town reads are scum, GJ dudes, fuck these bad townies). Super just makes big paragraphs and has a ton of excuses blah blah blah. I have no qualms with lynching either of these guys, I may as well spin around and play pin-the-tail-on-the-scum at this point.

Hurray for Day 1's, the only reason I'm rather 'meh' as town is because I have no information from the start. As scum I know all the things and am never wrong because my objective is to kill town. Fun Fact: I love playing scum :p

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 19:27 GMT

#678

Super calling jrkirby probably town...

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 19:38 GMT

#684

everyone thinks the guys on trial are scummy... except for theirbcounterwagons. dafaq is going on.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 19:52 GMT

#686

Super. If you're town and think jrlirby is town, then youbknowbthe lynch is probably between townies.

Who is most suspect in this case?

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 20:02 GMT

#690

My gut says super.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 20:07 GMT

#695

Not really. I phone post 90% of the time so it's hard to sit down and make a case of it.

I feel like either of them could be scum. Super just toqnreads everyone when as town you should be suspect of everyone

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 20:13 GMT

#700

On July 15 2013 05:07 Rainbows wrote:
Not really. I phone post 90% of the time so it's hard to sit down and make a case of it.

I feel like either of them could be scum. Super just toqnreads everyone when as town you should be suspect of everyone

I lied this describes Gotard better.

My votes on super but I really dont care who's lynched between the two. #Scummylogic

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 20:20 GMT

#702

I think gotard is scum, nobody listened tho.

kirby and super could be anything.

Rainbows

Germany1217 Posts

July 14 2013 20:35 GMT

#713

OKAY IM WITH CHROM LYNCH KIRBY YOLO

Lol.

Rainbows