Seems really odd to me that you completely ignored my constant pleas not to let a no lynch happen then go throw away your vote for nothing when I said 99999999x that was a terrible idea.

I mean Mattchew was even more stubborn but he ended up listening to reason. You just completely ignored it. I told you there was no realistic chance BM was ever going to get lynched.

There's a possibility of you just being really thickheaded Town but yeah, I do need to read the thread again. Katina looks much worse anyways ATM.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

March 16 2012 03:39 GMT

#1122

Medics should pick out of me, Palmar, Mattchew, DrH to protect. Fairly confident all of them are Town.

gumshoe

Canada3602 Posts

March 16 2012 03:54 GMT

#1123

On March 16 2012 12:34 Curu wrote:
Seems really odd to me that you completely ignored my constant pleas not to let a no lynch happen then go throw away your vote for nothing when I said 99999999x that was a terrible idea.

I mean Mattchew was even more stubborn but he ended up listening to reason. You just completely ignored it. I told you there was no realistic chance BM was ever going to get lynched.

There's a possibility of you just being really thickheaded Town but yeah, I do need to read the thread again. Katina looks much worse anyways ATM.

I made my vote in a rush, I also went into this game thinking scum WOULDN'T play a flashy game so I crossed kurumi off as just stupid, look at my past few games, I have in fact had bad experiences with scummy lurkers. I am pleasantly surprised that kurumi was scum and a touch regretful that I was unable to contribute to his lynch. but at the time I voted for the guy I thought to be the most scummy and I don't regret that decision, If you had listened to me and hosted a bm lynch we would had the same outcome, besides isn't a last second switch just as scummy as not switching? It seems like your just getting on my case because I didn't agree with you and frankly up until kurumi was lynched I wasn't sure you were town either. Please don't abuse your current momentum and statues as confirmed townie to lynch an active and for the most part contributing player just because you didn't see eye to eye with him.

jaybrundage

United States3921 Posts

March 16 2012 03:54 GMT

#1124

Im confused why people think palmar is town. He caused two townie deaths. Are we really going to say that Palmar is town all of a sudden. This makes zero sense at all. Also Katina is hella scummy. We should lynch her tommorow

gumshoe

Canada3602 Posts

March 16 2012 03:55 GMT

#1125

On March 16 2012 12:54 jaybrundage wrote:
Im confused why people think palmar is town. He caused two townie deaths. Are we really going to say that Palmar is town all of a sudden. This makes zero sense at all. Also Katina is hella scummy. We should lynch her tommorow

Please consider lynching bm -_- or at least give me a good reason not to.

gumshoe

Canada3602 Posts

March 16 2012 03:56 GMT

#1126

Palmar has done alot of stuff behind the scenes I'm guessing, plus he's lynched two of our weakest townies node and jackal, effectively removing them from discussion that can now be used to find actual scum. He seems pretty town to me.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

March 16 2012 04:01 GMT

#1127

Bill Murray/jaybrundage/Katina/EchelonTee

any questions?

Palmar proved his roleclaim was legit, thinking he's scum is just stupid at this point.

gumshoe

Canada3602 Posts

March 16 2012 04:03 GMT

#1128

On March 16 2012 13:01 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Bill Murray/jaybrundage/Katina/EchelonTee

any questions?

Palmar proved his roleclaim was legit, thinking he's scum is just stupid at this point.

Wait so your ok with bm?

Anyways I'm going to bed, vig, if your out there please please please shoot bm.

night night.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

March 16 2012 04:06 GMT

#1129

Yeah, I'm fine with BM. I think BM is more likely scum at this point. I'm not sure if Kurumi was a bus or if it was really just stupid town providing the resistance. If BM flips town it's pretty safe to assume BM and other random lurker votes were an attempt to save him.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

March 16 2012 04:08 GMT

#1130

Palmar is completely legit. No reason for him to give up Kurumi like that, I was suspicious of him when he wouldn't tell me who his "mystery informant" was but he went and posted it in the thread shortly after.

Palmar also cleared out Townies that were going to hurt Town far more than help them. Yeah they were Townies but we had no way to tell and clearing them out without wasting lynches was definitely more helpful.

EchelonTee

United States5239 Posts

March 16 2012 04:18 GMT

#1131

On March 16 2012 13:01 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Bill Murray/jaybrundage/Katina/EchelonTee

any questions?

Palmar proved his roleclaim was legit, thinking he's scum is just stupid at this point.

I really, really dislike people going around claiming "X/Y/Z" is confirmed town. I thought Palmar's strengths as town were his transparency and his case building. In this game he's been completely non-transparent about his cases, which has consisted of:

1. Node is trash (I agreed)
2. Jackal I don't like you/you should've shot and potentially caused 2 townie deaths (rly bad case)
3. uhh err ninja vote Kurumi before deadline (wat).

Seriously Curu, "Palmar had no reason to give up Kurumi"? If Palmar was scum he HAD to vote out Kurumi at that point. If jackal flips green and Palmar hasn't produced any reds, he would've been instantly voted off the island, no question. Now he gains a lot of townie cred even though he didn't at all push the Kurumi lynch along." Palmar either A. stumbled into that lynch(town) or B. calculated move to gain cred(red).

@gumshoe he's not saying BM is good, he's saying that we're all bad for not voting Kurumi. which I am.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

March 16 2012 04:28 GMT

#1132

Echelon, Palmar started the case on Kurumi. Read the Skype convo I posted, he basically told me about his informant's claim, I point out that his informant is probably Mafia, Palmar outs Kurumi's name into the thread. Without Palmar's info this lynch doesn't happen today.

He has been playing a bit odd but get off him. He is not worthy of any suspicion at this point.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

March 16 2012 04:34 GMT

#1133

How is Palmar not confirmed when he proved his role

Mr. Wiggles

Canada5894 Posts

March 16 2012 04:38 GMT

#1134

Palmar, how did you go from:

On March 14 2012 23:51 Palmar wrote:
I hate playing roles, but fuck it. Jackal is likely telling the truth, I have additional information to back up his claim.

To:

On March 15 2012 23:02 Palmar wrote:
##Lynch: Jackal58

Looking through your posts, you flip-flop on three different people, and then do this seemingly out of the blue. What made you decide to switch to Jackal?

Mr. Wiggles

Canada5894 Posts

March 16 2012 04:38 GMT

#1135

On March 16 2012 13:34 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
How is Palmar not confirmed when he proved his role

What role?

EchelonTee

United States5239 Posts

March 16 2012 04:39 GMT

#1136

On March 16 2012 13:28 Curu wrote:
Echelon, Palmar started the case on Kurumi. Read the Skype convo I posted, he basically told me about his informant's claim, I point out that his informant is probably Mafia, Palmar outs Kurumi's name into the thread. Without Palmar's info this lynch doesn't happen today.

He has been playing a bit odd but get off him. He is not worthy of any suspicion at this point.

fine. ur intense sheeping is just wtf, though

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

March 16 2012 04:46 GMT

#1137

that was me wiggles

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

March 16 2012 04:46 GMT

#1138

On March 16 2012 13:38 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

Show nested quote +

What role?

King, I think it was

jaybrundage

United States3921 Posts

March 16 2012 04:49 GMT

#1139

Doc I started the Kurumi lynch are you kidding me?

At this point i should be confirmed town. I was the first to try to lynch kurumi.

ROfl if you think im scum im dont knwo what to say