|
On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more. 1. I think that plan was too hasty. 2. I also saw citi.zen as the better target because of the sketchiness of his claim. 3. This could be true he hasn't had a great counterplan. 4. None of us have been on the right side of a vote yet since we've yet to bag a red.
|
On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more.
A lot of people can fit that category.
1. He found flaws in your plan which I was not comfortable with your plan as well. Don't make it a personal offense.
2. BC INITIATED THE SOUTH LYNCH! Otherwise no one or only a few of us would of voted for him! He wanted Citizen for info, citizen lied and that screwed things up.
3. The whole town has been in a flame war and FoS on everyone. Seriously you are just going to pick BC over everyone else who has spammed, flamed, and FoS randomly by 10x?
4. Uh everyone has. I believe BC's only mistake was changing his vote from South.
Either case that is also the town's fault. The town should of stayed with South. BC said Cit was a good lynch for info but still claimed South would give us a red.
So once again, please give me some decent valid reasoning. From my stand point I would say he has only done a few wrong moves and has only brought suspicion on him, but not enough to make any claims.
Though if you look at what other people say about BC and how it doesn't make sense one bit, such as all these role claims about him and weird ass stories.
Doesn't it seem obvious that mafia are trying to take advantage of this scenario? Even South is trying to vote for Cob. Wouldn't he try to at least let his mafia member live for one more night?
This whole crap about Cob is fishy even the stories about him defending South which he didn't is BS!.
So please once again give me information that would make me want to vote for BC. Otherwise he has done no worse then any other townie in this game.
|
Oh...and Why is nobody questioning why only one person died? Or was that medic protection planned? Vet get hit....No question with that?
|
On July 26 2010 15:50 BrownBear wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:47 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote:On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. Not bothering with the rest of your post, but this is demonstrably false. Anyone can go back and read my vote list at the bottom of Page 132 and see that you either have a very poor memory or are lying. Day 1: He votes for Pandain. I believe Pandain is green, thus I believe him to be voting for the wrong person for the wrong reasons. Day 2: He votes for Amber[light]. Again, a person who i believe is green. Again, wrong side of a vote. Day 3: He votes for citi.zen. Very wrong side of a vote. Your point was?
Do you know how voting works? BC's votes Day 1 and 2 weren't on any side; they didn't even matter. The only one that's on the wrong side is Day 3, which by definition isn't every day.
Since you seem to know the "wrong side" for each day of lynching, please enlighten us: what was the Right Side?
|
On July 26 2010 15:50 BloodyC0bbler wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more. Your roleclaim plan was flamed by more than me, don't try to finger me on that. South was analyzed and pulled out by me? then I went for a person who turned out to be lying and whos plan lost tons of credibilty for it. Surprise, surprise, I was wrong about his alignment, but correct on his plan being riddled with issues. Sparking town discussion? I have been doing so since I got back from work, hell, i started the discussion on citizen's plan that till then everyone was like "YEA LETS AUTO TRUST 100%" and the guy was lying. As for wrong side of vote so far? Citizen flipped liar. Amberlight has not flipped period, nor has pandain, and look pandain has turned out to be a liar as well. Dude, if you want to analyze and finger me to death, care to well not blatantly lie?
You need to calm down and stop lying. citi.zen did not flip liar, he flipped mouthpiece. HUGE difference.
Mouthpiece does NOT equal liar. Mouthpiece is a legit strategy designed to protect blue roles. Stop calling it a lying strategy.
My roleclaim plan was flamed by more than you, but you were the most vocal from my perspective. You also have personally attacked me many times, which I don't like. Stop doing that.
And regarding citi.zen's plan? That was a legit plan he had with zeks. Both are confirmed town. Your "sparking town discussion" fucked that up. If that's not red play, I don't know what is.
See, at this point, you'd really better hope you flip red. If you flip red, I'll accept all of your play as good mafia play. If you don't I really will just have no respect for you as a player anymore, because your town play this game has been absolutely atrocious.
|
On July 26 2010 15:27 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: Before day ends we need to figure out what claims we have had and so on.
Can someone in / understanding this "town circle" thing make a chart visualizing this?
I'm serious. It can be ms paint or whatever I just think it would help. I have just caught up on thread.
And it's a shitstorm.
Ignore what I said about doing analysis. This is much bigger.
Everybody, if you have been wondering who the mystery man in Pandain's post (Mr. ???) is, wonder no more. It is I.
And now, I can say that Pandain has been lying to me.
On July 26 2010 15:23 Pandain wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:21 Divinek wrote:On July 26 2010 15:14 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: #vote SouthRawrea #vote Pandain I'm just going to start with who I know for 100% sure has lying. Hasn't worked well so far but I don't give a fuck. my logical trail takes me down the same path, ill likely end up on a liar as well for my other vote because if you're town for fuck sakes dont openly lie to the town, at least in such a stupid and poor manner Just to clear it up, I did NOT lie to town. I lied only to Youngmini because we were going to let him into the circle but had to be sure he wasn't GF(since he had checked green.). I did NOT lie to the town or jeopardize it, until Youngmini reaveled it, probably with good intentions :/. It was ???,Subversion, and I's secret expirement. If I still lived, than youngmini wasn't GF and we would let him in our group. That's the extent of my lie, to youngmini for one day. The pms with Subversion I posted verify this. With a full game's worth of PMs from both Pandain and Subversion, I can show you that this "secret experiment" was not anything planned between the three of us. In fact, Pandain went at it on his own, and did not consult Subversion or myself.
You may ask, how am I confirmed? I started PMing Subversion sometime after the first night, when I realized he had soft claimed blue in thread. Through PMs, he told me he was a Detective, and that his first check had been youngminii but he was suspicious that youngminii was Godfather. Disregarding that, I asked him to check me Night 2 so that we could have a fully confirmed circle (and as a test to see if he would get my role), but after a while he decided to check Amber[LighT] instead, as already said earlier in the thread.
Regarding Pandain, and how he comes into this: during Day 2, Subversion was on the line to be lynched, and I pulled Pandain off of him because I still believed that Subversion was Detective. Yes, it is a risk, but the plan was calculated. If Subversion had died during Night 2, then Pandain would have been outed as Mafia infiltration. Sacrificing one Detective for Mafia is always worth it, especially in this format, and that was my failsafe.
However, Subversion lived through the night, so I began to think Pandain was more legitimate. After all, the rules of the game (even stickied in the Mafia threads) say to kill blues as you find them if you are Mafia, and Subversion was still alive. However, at this point Subversion was too afraid still to tell youngminii AND Amber[LighT], since he feared both of them could be the Godfather. Not wanting him to out himself too early, I thought it would be best for him, myself, and Pandain to stay quiet, and to wait out the day.
Then citi.zen's plan came in, and this is where things started going awry. I do not have much time per day to dedicate to Mafia, especially with guests this weekend, and so I returned to my computer with a message from Pandain saying that he had told youngminii that he was Detective and that youngminii would be the mouth. Apparently, he had not consulted Subversion about this and when I talked to Subversion later that day he was very distressed and expressed his doubts. I, too, secretly began to have them, but they were still unfounded: Pandain seems to post impulsively, so I chalked his latest scheme up to that.
citi.zen saw through this, of course, and then the thread went to shit with massive claims. Ah, before I forget, Pandain also wanted me to help him call for a mass roleclaim to Tricode, who wouldn't have been confirmed at that point due to conflicting calls over town kill power roles.
And so we have it here. Mafia killed Subversion, and I had a PM from Pandain telling me that the "other Detective" was going to check Subversion tonight, but to "keep Subversion from thinking that, and to just play it cool and to have him check Misder/lakrismamma.
And here we are now.
Town, I am going to bed soon, but if you want a roster of PMs, just call for them. I can provide them with rapidity that begets falseness, and I invite you to scrutinize them all.
What am I saying with this post? Pandain is Mafia? No, simply that he lied, and "took initiative" and tried to implement his circle. It still is awfully suspicious the way things turned out, but one thing's for sure: if we're lynching all liars, Pandain has some stuff to explain.
Edited hanging bold tag.
|
Damn it, hanging bold tag...
|
On July 26 2010 15:49 SiNiquity wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:46 ~OpZ~ wrote: Hey BC, plz post your PM's with South and Rastaban. Please copy and paste them, not type them. Thanks in advance. Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:02 BloodyC0bbler wrote:On July 26 2010 14:51 SiNiquity wrote: Also BC, while you're here. Do you deny PMing Rasta and South? You probably only have minutes left at this rate. That I do. I could name you the players I have pm'd and they would most likely confirm that they have had some form of messages with me.
Divinek, Tree.hugger, Infundibulum in that order.
I will also note that they pm'd me first. Aside from those three I have actually not pm'd anyone at all this game. Even to respond to really annoying messages.
|
On July 26 2010 15:50 BloodyC0bbler wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more. Your roleclaim plan was flamed by more than me, don't try to finger me on that. South was analyzed and pulled out by me? then I went for a person who turned out to be lying and whos plan lost tons of credibilty for it. Surprise, surprise, I was wrong about his alignment, but correct on his plan being riddled with issues. Sparking town discussion? I have been doing so since I got back from work, hell, i started the discussion on citizen's plan that till then everyone was like "YEA LETS AUTO TRUST 100%" and the guy was lying. As for wrong side of vote so far? Citizen flipped liar. Amberlight has not flipped period, nor has pandain, and look pandain has turned out to be a liar as well. Dude, if you want to analyze and finger me to death, care to well not blatantly lie? Details of citizens plan became apparent on his death. Do you not understand that? Their were reasons he lied. But you're right. We should lynch zeks anyway JUST BECAUSE he has a bomb on you/south kill 4 people (lynch zeks/someone else, BC/South/someone else if bomb moves), 3 mafia or, 2 mafia and 1 possible mafia, and lose a hatter that's used both bombs....
|
On July 26 2010 15:53 ~OpZ~ wrote: Oh...and Why is nobody questioning why only one person died? Or was that medic protection planned? Vet get hit....No question with that?
I assumed the "circle" was taking care of it -_- being town is so boring at times
Also, it could be Mafia really wanted Subversion dead and figured with the circle in place medic protection had him covered, so they doubled up on him.
|
I am getting out of the thread now, because I'm worried I'm becoming too emotionally invested in it.
I'm going to cool off for tonight, read it tomorrow, and make sure I'm voting for the right reasons, not the emotional/wrong ones.
That's the best you're getting, BC. Whatever decision I make tomorrow, I'm making it because I believe it's the best decision for the town. So don't bitch about it when it happens.
|
+ Show Spoiler +On July 26 2010 15:54 Protactinium wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:27 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: Before day ends we need to figure out what claims we have had and so on.
Can someone in / understanding this "town circle" thing make a chart visualizing this?
I'm serious. It can be ms paint or whatever I just think it would help. I have just caught up on thread. And it's a shitstorm. Ignore what I said about doing analysis. This is much bigger. [b]Everybody, if you have been wondering who the mystery man in Pandain's post (Mr. ???) is, wonder no more. It is I. And now, I can say that Pandain has been lying to me. Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:23 Pandain wrote:On July 26 2010 15:21 Divinek wrote:On July 26 2010 15:14 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: #vote SouthRawrea #vote Pandain I'm just going to start with who I know for 100% sure has lying. Hasn't worked well so far but I don't give a fuck. my logical trail takes me down the same path, ill likely end up on a liar as well for my other vote because if you're town for fuck sakes dont openly lie to the town, at least in such a stupid and poor manner Just to clear it up, I did NOT lie to town. I lied only to Youngmini because we were going to let him into the circle but had to be sure he wasn't GF(since he had checked green.). I did NOT lie to the town or jeopardize it, until Youngmini reaveled it, probably with good intentions :/. It was ???,Subversion, and I's secret expirement. If I still lived, than youngmini wasn't GF and we would let him in our group. That's the extent of my lie, to youngmini for one day. The pms with Subversion I posted verify this. With a full game's worth of PMs from both Pandain and Subversion, I can show you that this "secret experiment" was not anything planned between the three of us. In fact, Pandain went at it on his own, and did not consult Subversion or myself. You may ask, how am I confirmed? I started PMing Subversion sometime after the first night, when I realized he had soft claimed blue in thread. Through PMs, he told me he was a Detective, and that his first check had been youngminii but he was suspicious that youngminii was Godfather. Disregarding that, I asked him to check me Night 2 so that we could have a fully confirmed circle (and as a test to see if he would get my role), but after a while he decided to check Amber[LighT] instead, as already said earlier in the thread. Regarding Pandain, and how he comes into this: during Day 2, Subversion was on the line to be lynched, and I pulled Pandain off of him because I still believed that Subversion was Detective. Yes, it is a risk, but the plan was calculated. If Subversion had died during Night 2, then Pandain would have been outed as Mafia infiltration. Sacrificing one Detective for Mafia is always worth it, especially in this format, and that was my failsafe. However, Subversion lived through the night, so I began to think Pandain was more legitimate. After all, the rules of the game (even stickied in the Mafia threads) say to kill blues as you find them if you are Mafia, and Subversion was still alive. However, at this point Subversion was too afraid still to tell youngminii AND Amber[LighT], since he feared both of them could be the Godfather. Not wanting him to out himself too early, I thought it would be best for him, myself, and Pandain to stay quiet, and to wait out the day. Then citi.zen's plan came in, and this is where things started going awry. I do not have much time per day to dedicate to Mafia, especially with guests this weekend, and so I returned to my computer with a message from Pandain saying that he had told youngminii that he was Detective and that youngminii would be the mouth. Apparently, he had not consulted Subversion about this and when I talked to Subversion later that day he was very distressed and expressed his doubts. I, too, secretly began to have them, but they were still unfounded: Pandain seems to post impulsively, so I chalked his latest scheme up to that. citi.zen saw through this, of course, and then the thread went to shit with massive claims. Ah, before I forget, Pandain also wanted me to help him call for a mass roleclaim to Tricode, who wouldn't have been confirmed at that point due to conflicting calls over town kill power roles. And so we have it here. Mafia killed Subversion, and I had a PM from Pandain telling me that the "other Detective" was going to check Subversion tonight, but to "keep Subversion from thinking that, and to just play it cool and to have him check Misder/lakrismamma. And here we are now. Town, I am going to bed soon, but if you want a roster of PMs, just call for them. I can provide them with rapidity that begets falseness, and I invite you to scrutinize them all. What am I saying with this post? Pandain is Mafia? No, simply that he lied, and "took initiative" and tried to implement his circle. It still is awfully suspicious the way things turned out, but one thing's for sure: if we're lynching all liars, Pandain has some stuff to explain.
why in the name in ALL THAT IS FUCKING JUST IN THE WORLD did he tell you he was a dt without checking you first
|
On July 26 2010 15:54 BrownBear wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:50 BloodyC0bbler wrote:On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more. Your roleclaim plan was flamed by more than me, don't try to finger me on that. South was analyzed and pulled out by me? then I went for a person who turned out to be lying and whos plan lost tons of credibilty for it. Surprise, surprise, I was wrong about his alignment, but correct on his plan being riddled with issues. Sparking town discussion? I have been doing so since I got back from work, hell, i started the discussion on citizen's plan that till then everyone was like "YEA LETS AUTO TRUST 100%" and the guy was lying. As for wrong side of vote so far? Citizen flipped liar. Amberlight has not flipped period, nor has pandain, and look pandain has turned out to be a liar as well. Dude, if you want to analyze and finger me to death, care to well not blatantly lie? You need to calm down and stop lying. citi.zen did not flip liar, he flipped mouthpiece. HUGE difference. Mouthpiece does NOT equal liar. Mouthpiece is a legit strategy designed to protect blue roles. Stop calling it a lying strategy. My roleclaim plan was flamed by more than you, but you were the most vocal from my perspective. You also have personally attacked me many times, which I don't like. Stop doing that. And regarding citi.zen's plan? That was a legit plan he had with zeks. Both are confirmed town. Your "sparking town discussion" fucked that up. If that's not red play, I don't know what is. See, at this point, you'd really better hope you flip red. If you flip red, I'll accept all of your play as good mafia play. If you don't I really will just have no respect for you as a player anymore, because your town play this game has been absolutely atrocious.
No, he blatently lied about being hatter. He refused to even address criticism to his plan, and tried his best to not have discussion. Him lying about his role means he flipped as a liar. His townie role means dick as it didn't instant prove SR was red, it means someone in his group had to be verified instead.
Someone lying about role, refusing to talk about his plan in detail, refusing to answer criticism is actually the key features of someone playing anti town. If it was perfect he would have addressed these points.
Also with a legit dt actually dead, and zeks still alive with a "claimed dt circle" of a liar, He's not confirmed. HE is likely legit, but not confirmed. I don't get where you find these random reasons to confirm people without real evidence to do so. I'm sorry you didn't see the problems with it, I am sorry that you believe that citizen was incapable of being lied to, I am sorry that you trust things in mafia so black and white when the game is shades of grey.
|
On July 26 2010 15:54 Protactinium wrote:
With a full game's worth of PMs from both Pandain and Subversion, I can show you that this "secret experiment" was not anything planned between the three of us. In fact, Pandain went at it on his own, and did not consult Subversion or myself.
I'll repost this pm. Btw is there a way to like show it in pm format?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: To: youngminii [ Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Secret Date: 7/23/10 15:42 Okay, I'm making a risk. I know it could lead to my death but w/e, I trust you. I think your too active to be GF.
I'm the DT.
Amber and you are both townies.
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
which 1?
can u post me the PM ----------------------------------------- Original Message:
pmed him now. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: That's a good plan, lets do that.
I'll tell u all the checks, so u wont even rly be lying either.
I wonder, if we shouldn't try the same thing with Amber? ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Actually I have a plan. I could reveal to him I'm the DT. Then I will die if he's GF, and then you can come out and bust him. I really think that's a good plan. Since your the only one(besides proct) that I can trust, what do you think.
I clearly did tell Subversion You were probably awol, as you do alot cause of your guests.
It's true that sometimes I have to make decisions fast because out of us 3 I was the most active. For example, when youngmini wanted to pm citizen I couldn't just say no. I delayed for like 7 minutes after I pmed you guys and had to make a decision.
Checking my pms for other stuff.
|
On July 26 2010 16:01 BloodyC0bbler wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:54 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:50 BloodyC0bbler wrote:On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more. Your roleclaim plan was flamed by more than me, don't try to finger me on that. South was analyzed and pulled out by me? then I went for a person who turned out to be lying and whos plan lost tons of credibilty for it. Surprise, surprise, I was wrong about his alignment, but correct on his plan being riddled with issues. Sparking town discussion? I have been doing so since I got back from work, hell, i started the discussion on citizen's plan that till then everyone was like "YEA LETS AUTO TRUST 100%" and the guy was lying. As for wrong side of vote so far? Citizen flipped liar. Amberlight has not flipped period, nor has pandain, and look pandain has turned out to be a liar as well. Dude, if you want to analyze and finger me to death, care to well not blatantly lie? You need to calm down and stop lying. citi.zen did not flip liar, he flipped mouthpiece. HUGE difference. Mouthpiece does NOT equal liar. Mouthpiece is a legit strategy designed to protect blue roles. Stop calling it a lying strategy. My roleclaim plan was flamed by more than you, but you were the most vocal from my perspective. You also have personally attacked me many times, which I don't like. Stop doing that. And regarding citi.zen's plan? That was a legit plan he had with zeks. Both are confirmed town. Your "sparking town discussion" fucked that up. If that's not red play, I don't know what is. See, at this point, you'd really better hope you flip red. If you flip red, I'll accept all of your play as good mafia play. If you don't I really will just have no respect for you as a player anymore, because your town play this game has been absolutely atrocious. No, he blatently lied about being hatter. He refused to even address criticism to his plan, and tried his best to not have discussion. Him lying about his role means he flipped as a liar. His townie role means dick as it didn't instant prove SR was red, it means someone in his group had to be verified instead. Someone lying about role, refusing to talk about his plan in detail, refusing to answer criticism is actually the key features of someone playing anti town. If it was perfect he would have addressed these points. Also with a legit dt actually dead, and zeks still alive with a "claimed dt circle" of a liar, He's not confirmed. HE is likely legit, but not confirmed. I don't get where you find these random reasons to confirm people without real evidence to do so. I'm sorry you didn't see the problems with it, I am sorry that you believe that citizen was incapable of being lied to, I am sorry that you trust things in mafia so black and white when the game is shades of grey.
See above post. I'm out. Night! :D
|
Actually, I'm just going to put out PMs here now. I apologize for any repeats, since Pandain tended to send sometimes two or three from the same PM-thread before I could respond to the first one, so I tried to consolidate.
Subversion's suspicion PM: + Show Spoiler +From: Subversion [ 799 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: citi.zen's plan. Date: 7/24/10 19:51 just feel like im losing control of the situation here. he's a bit impulsive, and i'd rather make the decisions myself than have to keep going thru him. also may seem suspicious later on.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: It was kind of weird that he did so... on his own as well. That could have potentially owned you if you had done so at the same time...
If you are going to do so, at least wait the time period okay? We might still have a counter-claim. If I were citi.zen and red, trading one red is worth getting two Detectives, since then the town has no way to find Mafia, right? Even so, I think it's too risky. What's wrong with using Pandain anyway, beyond the "convolution" factor. ----------------------------------------- Original Message:
----------------------------------------- Original Message: What do you think of it?
There are a few holes...
Not bad at all.
Some things I need to explain.
I checked young and he was townie. But the problem is him ORR amber COULD be GF. So pandain and I had this plan. pandain pm'd young and told him HE was the DT and had checked him. now we wait and see if pandain dies next, then we know young is scum.
But now with citizen's plan, pandain has PM'd citizen saying he is the DT. He did this without waiting for a response from me, he's a bit of a loose cannon like that, keeps making decisions without my approval.
anyway, i told him now that we need to tell citizen and the other DT that I am in fact the real DT, or else it gets way too convoluted, and obviously explain the plan about young.
this may be risky, but he keeps taking decisions into his own hands now, and i dont like that. I don't want to have to do everything through him anymore.
PMs with Pandain (apologies for messiness): + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: O GOD IM SORRY Date: 7/25/10 13:59
I'll try ----------------------------------------- Original Message: An excellent one. I would definitely recommend it!
----------------------------------------- Original Message: was that a good movie
----------------------------------------- Original Message: And I quote from the movie Inception: "Will you take a leap of faith?"
You've got your chance.
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
trust me this time
----------------------------------------- Original Message: ...Pandain, you do realize that if there is Mafia in the other circle you effectively just killed both DTs if the suicide bomber decides he wants his 72 virgins.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: dt is prob going to check sub. We should not let sub know anything though. Act if normal, try to get him to check misder/lakris.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Sigh, why do you do these things. It's okay, have Subversion check him tonight to verify him. Though why did you give the name up without confirmation? If Subversion dies tonight, then we know something's up...
----------------------------------------- Original Message: I told zeks whos in our circle along with dt.
I'm afraid I fadoodled this up.
So I either gave us a chance, or fadoodled us up
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Just keep your cool, and don't out Subversion. He seems to have gone AWOL, but I'll talk to him when he gets around to the night.
As for the check, I'm not sure still. Be back later.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Youngmini revealed me. What a badunkadunk
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Alright, but don't give into him either. Just keep it in case he decides to try to out you. Besides, we have the trump card that you are not really the DT, and he is safe either way.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Im not going to post the pm chain yet. Especially at this time. we'll talk about it together later.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: He thinks. Still, what kind of threat is that... Anti-town behavior, no matter what he "thinks."
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
No he knows(thinks) I false claimed. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: What's wrong with this kid. He thinks you're DT and is pressuring you to reveal that you are DT, and that you'll be killed during the night? Post the whole PM chain. This is ridiculous. If you were DT and listened, and they killed SouthRawrea who is Hatter, it's good for them. If you don't, he "reveals" to Mafia who the DT is, and they kill him. BAD for town either way.
Post the PM chain. I will be back after deadline; guests are beckoning. Good luck.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: I told him youngmini was safe, part of my dt role. And that is the PM. From "Anyway yeah..." to "In this claim."
I respond:"Haha I'm the DT. I think you have too much trust in citizen and his "DT." I mean, now that I think about it, why would citizen risk the whole town on a plan that could potentially give this unconfirmed DT all the info mafia needed. "
To which he then responds. "Okay then, you better hope you're right. If you're red, the best way to go about this is to lynch SouthRawr because I'll be revealing you tonight (before mafia get their night kills by the way, so that's not a way out).
If you're DT and citi.zen really is red, then we're all dandy. But if you're DT and citi.zen is not red (I don't see why this would happen), you're still going to be revealed tonight."
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Post that PM you got from him. I don't understand; even if he's going to throw you under the bus why is he implicating Amber[LighT]? Something's not right with youngminii--for the better part of the day he's been saying "lynch southrawrea since if he's bomber he'll have bomb on chaoser" but he's also saying that southrawrea is red. I got a two minute reprieve, and haven't read thread, but this is a bad threat to make.
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
Anyway yeah I'm telling you right now to vote for SouthRawr (and tell amber[light] to). If you don't, I am going to publicly tell everyone who you are at night and that you false claimed DT (assuming citi.zen is green/blue).
Yes, this is a threat. Yes, I will tell everyone that you are claiming DT. Yes, I will include amber[light] in this claim.
THAT is from Youngmini. Dont know how he figured out. Hope you've been following thread, theres been so much happening. + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: URGENT URGENT URGENT Date: 7/25/10 09:19
yeah, if he tries to i'll just be like "Im not dt" ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Alright, but don't give into him either. Just keep it in case he decides to try to out you. Besides, we have the trump card that you are not really the DT, and he is safe either way.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Im not going to post the pm chain yet. Especially at this time. we'll talk about it together later.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: He thinks. Still, what kind of threat is that... Anti-town behavior, no matter what he "thinks."
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
No he knows(thinks) I false claimed. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: What's wrong with this kid. He thinks you're DT and is pressuring you to reveal that you are DT, and that you'll be killed during the night? Post the whole PM chain. This is ridiculous. If you were DT and listened, and they killed SouthRawrea who is Hatter, it's good for them. If you don't, he "reveals" to Mafia who the DT is, and they kill him. BAD for town either way.
Post the PM chain. I will be back after deadline; guests are beckoning. Good luck.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: I told him youngmini was safe, part of my dt role. And that is the PM. From "Anyway yeah..." to "In this claim."
I respond:"Haha I'm the DT. I think you have too much trust in citizen and his "DT." I mean, now that I think about it, why would citizen risk the whole town on a plan that could potentially give this unconfirmed DT all the info mafia needed. "
To which he then responds. "Okay then, you better hope you're right. If you're red, the best way to go about this is to lynch SouthRawr because I'll be revealing you tonight (before mafia get their night kills by the way, so that's not a way out).
If you're DT and citi.zen really is red, then we're all dandy. But if you're DT and citi.zen is not red (I don't see why this would happen), you're still going to be revealed tonight."
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Post that PM you got from him. I don't understand; even if he's going to throw you under the bus why is he implicating Amber[LighT]? Something's not right with youngminii--for the better part of the day he's been saying "lynch southrawrea since if he's bomber he'll have bomb on chaoser" but he's also saying that southrawrea is red. I got a two minute reprieve, and haven't read thread, but this is a bad threat to make.
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
Anyway yeah I'm telling you right now to vote for SouthRawr (and tell amber[light] to). If you don't, I am going to publicly tell everyone who you are at night and that you false claimed DT (assuming citi.zen is green/blue).
Yes, this is a threat. Yes, I will tell everyone that you are claiming DT. Yes, I will include amber[light] in this claim.
THAT is from Youngmini. Dont know how he figured out. Hope you've been following thread, theres been so much happening. + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: What...the...Fadoodle Date: 7/25/10 07:30 This is Pm between me and zeks Mesends video of "somebody watching me" Him:If you are what I think you are you're on a path of being LVP.
*word slip*
Me:Least valuable player?
hehe
Him:You better not be DT.
If you are its obvious you haven't checked me. Or you'd understand everything.
ME:Way to make everything so mysterious
Him: Hope you got that
Now here I am saying... What the fadoodle? + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: Also: Date: 7/25/10 06:59 I'm voting for Citizen now.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Consolidating. This is true; I don't think Mafia would jump out to help their leader unless he was in deep shit. Maybe citi.zen isn't there and they're all panicking now?
If citi.zen is Hatter and dies, then he'll get Mafia. We'll get information from that since right now we all seem to be evenly divided, so we can go pick up supporters. And if SouthRawrea is Mafia as well, we definitely destroy him tomorrow with our double lynch. That's a guarantee right there of getting one Mafia right? And we should be able to get more based on DT checks. One thing I just thought of is if citi.zen is Mafia and we don't kill him, we are risking our DTs tonight, and if one of them dies then it's bad for us.
I think they're being convinced themselves... no reason overextending at this point. I'm going to wait for citi.zen to defend though before becoming too biased. American justice is supposed to be impartial, right, and the defendant should always be allowed to speak.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: True.At the same time, will that negate his plan? It had holes anyway but it had potential
Don't forget in that plan it's possible we'll only get one mafia if a mafia fake claims DT to a "trusted rep"
Do you want to try to convince the others yet? Get tree hugger to help for more momentum?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: I trust him. Besides, at this point both are potential Hatters right? citi.zen will have both his bombs placed, and SouthRawrea only has one. citi.zen, being astute (if he really is hatter) will have bombs on at least one Mafia, while SouthRawrea being new is more likely to kill town. I think it's actually win-win for us if we lynch citi.zen: we'll probably off a Mafia, and if citi.zen is Mafia then we can control SouthRawrea's bombs to make them more useful, then have him lynched next day once he gets both.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Citizen has been far more active and contributive than south. And yeah, chaoser and young are probably not on the same team lol, they hate each other too much. Than replace young with sinquity. Hehe.
South does seem more genuine, that is for sure. Just for that, maybe I should trust him. He's SO believable. Maybe he's good actor? though he is new
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Will respond to all here. Your list seems sound; I don't know about Subversion though since I still believe him. If he's faking we'll know. Notice that bumatlarge jumped out to defend citi.zen early but then disappeared again? zeks is also randomly suspicious, I agree he might be Mafia. Good call on that earlier by the way. I would totally have ignored him. youngminii is pushing very hard for Chaoser... you still believe them both to be Mafia? Of course, it could be a ploy.
I'd rather save SouthRawrea. He has been active and has provided his defense, and seems more genuine. citi.zen hasn't even shown his face since attacking SouthRawrea's counterclaim. Instead, there's a slew of random people defending him... and why?
zeks could be Mafia, and if we catch citi.zen we catch him. I'm still very confused about all this though; not 100% on anything. Mafia is too perplexing, sometimes.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Also: If we want to save south we need to act now. Lynching south does give us info though. Alot of info. Do you think it would be worth it just to lynch him for that? + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: URGENT URGENT URGENT Date: 7/25/10 08:57
Anyway yeah I'm telling you right now to vote for SouthRawr (and tell amber[light] to). If you don't, I am going to publicly tell everyone who you are at night and that you false claimed DT (assuming citi.zen is green/blue).
Yes, this is a threat. Yes, I will tell everyone that you are claiming DT. Yes, I will include amber[light] in this claim.
THAT is from Youngmini. Dont know how he figured out. Hope you've been following thread, theres been so much happening. + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: Citizens' plan Date: 7/25/10 06:32 arghhhhh zeks is mafia. I know it!
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Show nested quote + On July 24 2010 14:36 BloodyC0bbler wrote: On July 24 2010 14:25 Divinek wrote: On July 24 2010 14:18 BloodyC0bbler wrote: On July 24 2010 14:13 youngminii wrote: What's suspicious is that you're trying to block this from happening. Not pointing fingers but it's quite obvious that this is a pretty solid plan with minimal chances of being infiltrated by scum, even then it will be obvious as the game progresses if he's lying or not.
From blocking it? I actually contest many claims in many games that are completely out of left field. No one agreed to claiming to someone who thought d3 was almost fully legit, yet your agreeing to claim to someone who has appeared out as the last KP role? as well as saying "sup im the medic spokesmen, got myself a circle already" etc...
Its too good to be true this early.
But surely if he's coming out as the last kp role it would have to be contested if he's lying? Though I could think of some reasons why the remaining kp person might not want to counter claim him it seems like it would be worth it to bust a fake circle of trust
Say for instance He is lying.
It means two dts (if not in contact with eachother) pm him themselves, or through a mouth, those mouths are then talking to him. He can put them in contact with eachother, they see it as semi legit, then a period goes by they all mass claim him (as he asked for blue roles) he then proceeds to blue snipe, where it costs the rest only one red, to off 2+ blues.
WE also don't know if the last KP role is a hatter or a vig. If its a vig, he counterclaims and then it comes down to a war of which of them gets lynched. People fearing that he is in fact a hatter, off the vig see his flip and go oh shit. Conversely the mafia could send someone up and do the same thing.
I believe the proper amendmant to citi.zens plan is if HE is not the center of said circle. Or be lynched to prove the legitmacy of his claim. He can put the other checked person his dt has checked with the the other dt's liason and by dying confirms his claim DT's can then claim straight through the liasons, and one of those liasons can take part of town leadership and pass roles to dts. There would be two people to counterclaim if someone tried to jump up and take info, and would be alot more reliable than trusting one persons word.
The only issue with that plan is if he is infact hatter then the town would have lost its last kp role and hope that his current bomb placement takes reds out.
Look, again, Tricode is not 100% confirmed. We have three conflicting blue claims, and it's just as possible as the others faking for Tricode to be faking, meaning him and BloodyC0bbler are in conjunction. Why else would he say to keep BloodyC0bbler alive as long as possible when he shot him? The point is, you don't mass claim unless you are certain, since it's a lose-all strategy if he isn't genuine. I'm not saying I don't believe he is, but being skeptical wins you Mafia games. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: 1. What exactly was the addendum bc offered? 2. How should we adjust it to make it as useful to town as possible.
I personally think we SHOULD roleclaim to tricode. I think he's confirmed. I'm sure of it. Citizen only claimed because "he saw an opportunity" (if he's really blue" and south only claimed because "he saw it getting way out of control." quotes doesn't indicate what they word for word said, just what their overall message said.
Tricode is the real genuine one. He has a reason(must...kill...bc) and claimed only after arguing whether it was worth it. Seems honest to me.
I'm still confused why you wouldn't want to roleclaim to him. + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: My conspiracy theory Date: 7/25/10 06:09 In tree huggers post, is he saying that subversion, young, and citizen are all mafia? or town? 'Or what.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Yeah, he's definitely new to this, you can tell. Chat Mafia is a lot different and it's easy to be overwhelmed. Telling where the bomb was placed was probably not a good idea, but now that it's out we need parity from citi.zen. It really is starting to bother me. citi.zen has not address BloodyC0bbler's main points (the addendum that makes the plan a lot stronger), Infundibulum's critiques (no response), and he hops on SouthRawrea instantly but disappears after the post. All in all, it's not inspiring confidence in me.
Furthermore, I have a PM from tree.hugger myself. Received it a while ago, but I believe tree.hugger has a circle himself. From: tree.hugger [ 3260 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: youngminii... Date: 7/22/10 13:42 Subversion, youngminii, citi.zen, BC(probably), lakrismamma(possibly), and.... we'll say... Siniquity.
The first five are on the same team. Watch for it, and read about it on day one. They have cute little fake arguments, and then citizen and BC throw away their votes, and the others mix it up a little bit. Dunno about siniquity. I'm... 30% sure about the whole bunch, and about 90% sure of the first three.
I'm going to be voting citi.zen if he doesn't attend to these points in a timely fashion. There's no logical sense in proclaiming a town plan with himself as the absolute head if he isn't around to argue for it.
Going to respond to your other PM here as well, to consolidate. Experience makes you seem pro-town. SouthRawrea may be Mafia, but he plays from a genuinely new perspective, while citi.zen has been both town and Mafia enough times. Conclusively, just because somebody seems pro-town doesn't mean they are. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: I found some holes in south rawrea's plan's such as revealing who the bombs are on. Maybe a newb mistake but idk. The last post by him seems pretty genuine though. Youngmini's saying we should lynch on information. Based on that, lynching BC might sound like an even better option but at the same time I wouldn't want to lose a townie.
I want to vote zeks but that's never going to fly. Not even sure about him either.
This game is so hard rofl.
In truth, I would want to vote....citizen. I need more info tbh.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Check SouthRawrea's last post. It would be nice to know who the bombs are on, right? citi.zen is definitely more dangerous/experienced than SouthRawrea, and if he is truly the Hatter then his bombs should at least be on one Mafia. I agreed with citi.zen's plan initially but now that Infundibulum has found so many holes that citi.zen refuses to respond to, I'm leaning more toward citi.zen. Not sure yet, which is why I will hold my vote. What about you?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: arghhh.... who to pick. It's either citizen or south, that much I know.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: He could, but with two claims (and we don't even know about the outside) he could just be fishing for DTs.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Haha I have no idea why I sent that or what it means. Maybe I was asking if you thought Citizen really does have a detective in his knowlege.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: What do you mean? What's a Mafia thing?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Do you think Citizen doesn't really have a mafia thing? + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: Also: What should Subversion check tonight? Date: 7/25/10 05:27 You can? How exactly does DT work. I thought you check and recieve it once night starts.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: You can choose any time during the night?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: kk. I think we only have like 4 hours so...
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Let's think about that more so when the day is nearing an end. Tricode is fine, but how do we confirm the Detective (Subversion) who checks Tricode? Also if Tricode is really legitimate but Subversion is faking, he can just say Tricode was lying, and if BloodyC0bbler and Tricode aren't Mafia, then that offs two very strong town players.
We should think about this check later tonight.
Be back in 10 minutes.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: I'm thinking Tricode. If we get him confirmed as vigi, then we can keep doing citi's plan and since he's safe, people can mass roleclaim to him + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: FAAACK Date: 7/25/10 00:10 2 claims for DT. I'm going to be up in the spotlight. + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: What do you think of Date: 7/25/10 05:01 Whole post here. Top of the page is the most recent PM to him. I'm the first post at the bottom.
Well, there is no counter-claim to me. Him, I have no clue. 50% chance he is the "fake" Dt rep. You are stranger and stranger with every message.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: T_T caught again. Honestly not sure how to respond just because you and him might be mafia. But then again, all this ever did was plan to see if youngmini was GF. Let's just say that youngmini doesn't know who the real DT is.
faaack word slip..
Of course if you and him are both mafia that plan goes to null :/.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: was*
----------------------------------------- Original Message: <--- confused about that sentence. "he only said he as the dt rep."
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Interesting, he only said he as the DT rep.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Nah I'm just part of a trust circle. Youngmini's.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Just to be clear: you are saying you are a DT?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: The people who claimed dt.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Who is "us"?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Heh doesn't matter. It was in regards to something else. Yeah, one of us is mafia. My previous thing doesn't mean anything.
But damn, I knew it was a good plan but this far?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Just happened. The mafia is digging themselves deeper.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: If a triple claim happens PM me first. I'm going to remain purposely vague. + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: What do you think of Date: 7/25/10 03:29 What do you think of tricode getting everyone to roleclaim to him via pms. I mean, he is confirmed townie. + Show Spoiler +From: Pandain [ 682 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: ONO WHAT DO I DO Date: 7/24/10 13:26 Well no it just means one of them is mafia.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Hmm, well you know that's not true. If the Mafia wanted to off citi.zen and a Mafia member counter-claimed that basically gets citi.zen lynched for nothing during the day, right?
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
If the other vigi/mad hatter counter claims than cit.zen is mafia. Also, I had something to say in this sentence but I forgot it after Also. T_T ----------------------------------------- Original Message: It's not that I don't trust the plan--it's that I don't trust the timing of the plan. It seems very conveniently placed, but that may just be me. His posts have contributed, but they're mostly just correcting other people's mistakes. I guess that's contribution, but it's really easy to pass off not much as a lot more.
Wait a minute, I must have interpreted. Where does it say he will get himself lynched?
If that's the case then it's definitely more trust-worthy. Mafia would have to be highly intrepid to do this, but as it's been pointed out a lot we are not in a good situation right now. If this plan is genuine, then we are in a good spot. If not, then the game is over. Seems like a huge risk to take doesn't it?
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
You don't trust cit.zen? He has a solid plan. If he's a blue he'd probably have wanted to lay low a bit, and his posts have all been contributive. Finally, his plan even inlcudes a way for HIM to get lynched/pointed out as mafia. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Eh, I think the better thing to have done was to wait for Subversion to make a decision himself. It's his role and he has to play it. We should be okay this time thanks to Subversion actually not being around, but we might not get lucky next time. Let me know everything that's said okay? I don't trust youngminii, and I don't trust citi.zen and his "Detective" since citi.zen hasn't done anything for us all game.
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
Your probably right. I was just scared cause I had to either reveal to youngmini about Subversion or let youngmini pm cit.zen. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Ugh, not a good idea to act on your own, especially if Subversion had PMed.
We can work with what we have; a name is important. When I said cross-check, I meant I would go through the thread and see how said other "Detective" and citi.zen had interacted, and how Detective had interacted with town in general.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Subversion I got scared about. I think he's afk but at first I sent him a message saying
"cit.zen's plan sounds like a good one. I think you should pm him. Just because we can keep the previous plan the same so if I do you can also bust Youngmini."
But he didn't respond. 6 minutes later I told him what I did. So I was unsure whether he pmed citi/zen first. I hope not, and don't htink so.
Unfortunately, just in case so then cit.zens plan wouldn't be screwed I had to PM cit.zen saying that "If a triple claim happens, pm me first. I'm going to remain purposely vague."
Tried to handle the situation best I could. :/
Also, what do you mean "cross check how the two have intereacted." which two.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Ah, I see. Hmm... If citi.zen's got a false DT lined up, let's figure out who he is. Let me know the name, alright? I want to cross-check to see how the two have interacted.
And yeah, I won't tell youngminii. As far as I'm concerned he's still dangerous to the town with his constant urge to point fingers.
Does Subversion know you did this?
----------------------------------------- Original Message:
No all Citizen should know is that IM Dt. Therefore, Subversion is still completely safe. Youngmini still thinks I'm dt. And I'm relaying all information to you and subversion.
I didn't tell Youngmini Subversion was DT just in case he IS GF. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Ah okay... Not a good idea still, but keep me in the loop alright? Subversion didn't trust youngminii because he could be Godfather... Remember the way he was posting Day 1 (and 2... and even today...)? It's the type of posting that's begging for a check.
Still not good for us if citi.zen is faking, since he completely destroys a Detective and his circle if that happens...
----------------------------------------- Original Message: That was youngmini who pmed me. I told him I was dt, remember?
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Wait, I'm confused. citi.zen false claiming is a huge gambit, but Mafia are pretty comfortably ahead. Claiming Hatter is nice as well--he won't die during the night (Mafia is afraid of bombs) and that way it doesn't look suspicious if he looks during the day. Furthermore, his claim came in the middle of waiting for BloodyC0bbler to make his post, and right after citi.zen himself had some pressure on him. Timing doesn't seem right.
Is Subversion saying for you not to PM? I'm a bit confused by the end message.
----------------------------------------- Original Message: Him: The idea is that we don't want the actual DT to needlessly PM at first. If citi.zen is false claiming/the DT that checked citi.zen is false claiming then were screwed if you PM. If someone in your group PMs then it's a lot safer.
----------------------------------------- Original MessageMe) Oh dw I'll do it.
----------------------------------------- Original MessageYoungmini) Yo I'm gonna go ahead and contact citi.zen about the whole DT claim thing (read his post). I'll wait until you reply before doing it.
-----------------------------------------
fuck now what?
Posting these first, going back to find my (earlier) PMs with Subversion. I haven't had many of them recently since we've both not been around the computer it seems.
Once again, this doesn't say anything definitive about Pandain. I want people to look over these PMs before jumping to conclusions though.
|
heyyy pandain can you post the pm that bc supposedly sent you
|
On July 26 2010 16:06 Divinek wrote: heyyy pandain can you post the pm that bc supposedly sent you
??? Quote me where I said he sent me that.
|
On July 26 2010 15:58 ~OpZ~ wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:50 BloodyC0bbler wrote:On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more. Your roleclaim plan was flamed by more than me, don't try to finger me on that. South was analyzed and pulled out by me? then I went for a person who turned out to be lying and whos plan lost tons of credibilty for it. Surprise, surprise, I was wrong about his alignment, but correct on his plan being riddled with issues. Sparking town discussion? I have been doing so since I got back from work, hell, i started the discussion on citizen's plan that till then everyone was like "YEA LETS AUTO TRUST 100%" and the guy was lying. As for wrong side of vote so far? Citizen flipped liar. Amberlight has not flipped period, nor has pandain, and look pandain has turned out to be a liar as well. Dude, if you want to analyze and finger me to death, care to well not blatantly lie? Details of citizens plan became apparent on his death. Do you not understand that? Their were reasons he lied. But you're right. We should lynch zeks anyway JUST BECAUSE he has a bomb on you/south kill 4 people (lynch zeks/someone else, BC/South/someone else if bomb moves), 3 mafia or, 2 mafia and 1 possible mafia, and lose a hatter that's used both bombs....
IF town was so sure of my guilt, they would be lynching zeks to do a few things. Prove his alignment, prove mine, prove southrawrs. INSTEAD he has said
On July 26 2010 11:18 zeks wrote: ##vote double lynch ##vote BloodyC0bbler ##vote SouthRawrea
don't worry about me wasting bombs i had that covered long ago
which means he has no bombs on me or SR. IE they could be anywhere. The soul means of proof he had to 100% clear his dt, clear himself, get info from me and SR is now moot. Effectively saving himself from having to prove his own identity.
Do I think he is likely real based on SR/Rasta trying to off me? Yes, but he moved his bombs regardless, so him dying now becomes potentially harmful to the town depending on where those bombs went.
|
On July 26 2010 16:08 BloodyC0bbler wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 15:58 ~OpZ~ wrote:On July 26 2010 15:50 BloodyC0bbler wrote:On July 26 2010 15:43 BrownBear wrote:On July 26 2010 15:40 Tricode wrote:On July 26 2010 15:35 BrownBear wrote: Guys, why are you even bothering arguing with BC. He's mafia. He's just trying to cause as much ruckus as possible before he gets lynched and has to shut up.
Just ignore him and the problem will resolve itself. In a very short, terminal fashion. Can you provide any definite proof of your claim of BC? I would like an explanation that isn't bullshit or a manipulative of what actually occurred. If you can provide me with that information then I will ignore BC and vote for him. 1) BC decided my roleclaiming plan was idiotic, despite the fact that it benefits town. 2) BC decided instead of going for South (who was 99% confirmed mafia) we should go for citi.zen. You see how that turned out. 3) BC hasn't really been sparking town discussion, he's been flaming people, calling every plan stupid, deriding every player as playing poorly, etc. This is very scummy, as he is intentionally trying to break down town unity rather than build it. 4) BC has been on the wrong side of every vote so far. You want more? I've got more. Your roleclaim plan was flamed by more than me, don't try to finger me on that. South was analyzed and pulled out by me? then I went for a person who turned out to be lying and whos plan lost tons of credibilty for it. Surprise, surprise, I was wrong about his alignment, but correct on his plan being riddled with issues. Sparking town discussion? I have been doing so since I got back from work, hell, i started the discussion on citizen's plan that till then everyone was like "YEA LETS AUTO TRUST 100%" and the guy was lying. As for wrong side of vote so far? Citizen flipped liar. Amberlight has not flipped period, nor has pandain, and look pandain has turned out to be a liar as well. Dude, if you want to analyze and finger me to death, care to well not blatantly lie? Details of citizens plan became apparent on his death. Do you not understand that? Their were reasons he lied. But you're right. We should lynch zeks anyway JUST BECAUSE he has a bomb on you/south kill 4 people (lynch zeks/someone else, BC/South/someone else if bomb moves), 3 mafia or, 2 mafia and 1 possible mafia, and lose a hatter that's used both bombs.... IF town was so sure of my guilt, they would be lynching zeks to do a few things. Prove his alignment, prove mine, prove southrawrs. INSTEAD he has said Show nested quote +On July 26 2010 11:18 zeks wrote: ##vote double lynch ##vote BloodyC0bbler ##vote SouthRawrea
don't worry about me wasting bombs i had that covered long ago which means he has no bombs on me or SR. IE they could be anywhere. The soul means of proof he had to 100% clear his dt, clear himself, get info from me and SR is now moot. Effectively saving himself from having to prove his own identity. Do I think he is likely real based on SR/Rasta trying to off me? Yes, but he moved his bombs regardless, so him dying now becomes potentially harmful to the town depending on where those bombs went.
I think (well) The reason I believe zeks is because he was foretold by Citizen. Since citizen is townie, than zeks is truly a mad hatter. Either that or GF and tricked Citizen/dt, but then we're screwed anyway so doesn't matter.
|
|
|
|