EPT
soO2.
ByuN3.
TY4.
ByuL5.
Stats6.
INnoVation7.
Dark8.
herO9.
Maru10.
RyungCommunity Power Rank v7: Hard decisions - Page 5
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
yesterhead
Sweden19 Posts
soO2. ByuN3. TY4. ByuL5. Stats6. INnoVation7. Dark8. herO9. Maru10. Ryung | ||
|
The_Red_Viper
19533 Posts
It's basically based on results since the last power rank 1. INnoVation2. herO3. Maru4. Solar5. ByuL6. GuMiho7. soO8. Classic9. aLive10. Statsedit: after realizing that the last PR was already 4 months ago, i guess it's a bit questionable to include all the results since then. (more a fault of going 4 months without it tbh) I will look at the results of the past 2 months now (anything below that seems to have not enough data) and change the list accordingly. edit2: next edit will happen after Inno vs Solar edit3: ok final list after the ssl finals | ||
|
KalWarkov
Germany4126 Posts
| ||
|
RKC
2847 Posts
soO2. Stats3. INnoVation4. Solar5. herO6. TY7. Classic8. Maru9. ByuL10. DarkMy assessment is a mix of past results as far back as IEM World Championship (with some depreciating value attached to older results, of course), and the most current results. Controversially missing the cut would be aLive, ByuN and GuMiho. If I had to choose between the three, aLive gets the nod over them. Not sure why ByuN figures so highly on other people's list. Sentimentality perhaps? Results wise, he just hasn't done enough at all this whole year. Didn't go far in IEM and Super Tournament. And his recent form in SSL and GSL hasn't been great too. GuMiho is capable of picking off a top scalp or two, but his results hasn't translated into deep runs (except for GSL now). He's quite similar to aLive, with the only difference being that aLive had a string of deep runs earlier this year (and his SSL record ain't too shabby too). Having a good H2H against top players is credible, but ultimately what matters result-wise (to me) is winning tournaments, or coming to close to winning (ironically in the case of my No. 1 choice). | ||
|
ZertoN
Germany214 Posts
INnoVation2. Maru3. soO4. herO5. Classic6. TY7. ByuL8. GuMiho9. Dark10. ByuN | ||
|
The_Red_Viper
19533 Posts
| ||
|
| ||
|
ruypture
United States367 Posts
soO2. Maru3. GuMiho4. Classic5. ByuN6. TY7. Stats8. herO9. Dark10. Scarlett | ||
|
pvsnp
7676 Posts
On June 12 2017 14:44 ruypture wrote: 1. soO2. Maru3. GuMiho4. Classic5. ByuN6. TY7. Stats8. herO9. Dark10. ScarlettYou must be a really huge Scarlett fan, but I'm sorry to say that under any objective measurement of skill there's absolutely no way Scarlett should be there instead of INnoVation, ByuL, Solar, or aLive. It's not even like she won some big tournament yesterday and showed she was in the form of her life (maybe she is but we have no way of knowing). I'd be curious to hear your reasoning behind putting her at #10 though. | ||
|
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
On June 12 2017 15:16 pvsnp wrote: You must be a really huge Scarlett fan, but I'm sorry to say that under any objective measurement of skill there's absolutely no way Scarlett should be there instead of INnoVation, ByuL, Solar, or aLive. It's not even like she won some big tournament yesterday and showed she was in the form of her life (maybe she is but we have no way of knowing). I'd be curious to hear your reasoning behind putting her at #10 though. Hey! You're getting on him for Scarlett, but you both have Dark on your lists.  He doesn't even deserve top 3 of the Zergs atm let alone a spot in the top 10 among players. Middling results in SSL Premiere. Still never been past GSL ro16. Still absent from VSL. Only narrowly edged out ByuN in the Super Tournament. IEM WC is his only great result this year and that was some time ago. | ||
|
AbouSV
Germany1278 Posts
| ||
|
Mun_Su
France2063 Posts
INnoVation2. Classic3. soO4. TY5. herO6. Stats7. Solar8. aLive9. herO10. ByuNMan that was so hard... #11 to Byul, | ||
|
RKC
2847 Posts
On June 12 2017 16:55 FrostedMiniWheats wrote: Hey! You're getting on him for Scarlett, but you both have Dark on your lists. He doesn't even deserve top 3 of the Zergs atm let alone a spot in the top 10 among players. Middling results in SSL Premiere. Still never been past GSL ro16. Still absent from VSL. Only narrowly edged out ByuN in the Super Tournament. IEM WC is his only great result this year and that was some time ago. "Middling" achievements as they may be, Scarlett has not done any better by a clear margin. There's an arguable case for Dark to make Top 15, but not Scarlett (even Top 20 seems a stretch). | ||
|
zombieelephants
United States43 Posts
INnoVation2. soO 3. Classic4. Solar5. Maru6. ByuN7. herO8. TY9. GuMiho10. Rogue | ||
|
| ||
|
egrimm
Poland1199 Posts
INnoVation2. soO3. herO4. GuMiho5. Maru6. Solar7. Classic8. TY9. ByuL10. StatsHonorable mention: 11. ByuN12. Dark13. aLive | ||
|
Witege
Germany5 Posts
GuMiho2. INnoVation3. soO4. Classic5. Solar6. Maru7. ByuN8. Dark9. TY10. ByuL | ||
|
opisska
Poland8852 Posts
The Best and crucial and whatever tournament Has been always GSL, Which however isn't done. Here we easily get 8 players in two tiers depenending on How they did in Ro8: tier 1: GuMiho, Maru, Classic, soO tier 2: TY, ByuN, Stats, Rogue As for the SSL, I still consider it rather Less important, because of the format, but it comes in handy because it gives us tier 3: INnoVation, Solar and ByuL from playoffs, puting us to 11 players, so ByuL is gonna clearly bite the dust Here. Now How do we order those players? Let's Try ordering players in each tier by SSL results, because what else do we have? 1. Maru2. Classic3. GuMiho4. soO5. Stats6. ByuN7. TY8. Rogue9. INnoVation10. SolarIn the absence of Proleague and any reasonable global events, this is the only meaningful Way of doing this. edit: lol, my tlpd/un-tlpd attempts have done some funny things to the capitalisation, no way I am gonna waste my time on fixing that  | ||
|
ruypture
United States367 Posts
On June 12 2017 17:14 RKC wrote: "Middling" achievements as they may be, Scarlett has not done any better by a clear margin. There's an arguable case for Dark to make Top 15, but not Scarlett (even Top 20 seems a stretch). brb lemme go sit down for a couple hours and think of the most accurate tier list i can come up with | ||
Seeker
Where dat snitch at?36901 Posts
INnoVation2. soO3. ByuN4. TY5. Stats6. herO7. Classic8. GuMiho9. Maru10. Dark | ||
| ||
