|
On May 26 2016 00:21 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2016 00:11 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, I was starting to think palmar is kinda towny but I don't think he can actually believe this. Did you think this through? I would _never_ lie about this, as either alignment. It's entirely pointless for me to do so.
How?
If marv is town and just screwed by his job and we lynch him you can play the "told you so card" instead of having to answer hiw it is possible for you of all people to mislynch marv.
If marv is mafia there is obvious reason to lynch someone else.
Why would you NEVER lie about that?
|
JAT can you please lynch Palmar with me? I gave you guys my case on him and I think he should be lynched right now.
|
On May 26 2016 00:29 LightningStrike wrote:
JAT can you please lynch Palmar with me? I gave you guys my case on him and I think he should be lynched right now.
Your case doesn't make him mafia though. It just makes him an ass.
|
Leaving work, see you in a few hours! Everyone should vote marv
|
Although marv is a coinflip, I have a hunch he's going to flip town.
So basically, if he's town I get to say I told you so. And if he's scum, it doesn't count as me being wrong.
|
On May 26 2016 00:45 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
Although marv is a coinflip, I have a hunch he's going to flip town.
So basically, if he's town I get to say I told you so. And if he's scum, it doesn't count as me being wrong.
Explain the hunch.
|
If it is what you said earlier it is bullshit.
|
On May 26 2016 00:48 justanothertownie wrote:
If it is what you said earlier it is bullshit.
It is. I know it offends your sensibilities of how the game should be played, but I am a realist.
Where he said "I shouldn't have joined this game but I wanted to play with HF," that looked really genuine. That makes me disregard any scumread from inactivity. So he's back at an equal to random chance of flipping scum.
Calling SL's "I'm scum" comment sincere was slightly townie in how vague Marv was.
I think he's the top plynch, though. And I am a firm believer in day 1 plynches, which is why my vote has been on him since early game.
|
Day 1 Votecount
marvellosity (3): nnn_thekushmountains, Rels, sicklucker
ritoky (2): Superbia, Tumblewood, sicklucker
Palmar (2): Koshi, LightningStrike
LightningStrike (1): Holyflare, Damdred, Palmar
Superbia (1): Holyflare
Holyflare (1): Palmar
justanothertownie (0): Koshi
Tumblewood (0): Holyflare
Not Voting (3): ritoky, marvellosity, justanothertownie
Do not forget to format your votes correctly.
Day ends Wednesday, May 25 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00).
You have to place your votes.
|
On May 26 2016 00:55 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2016 00:48 justanothertownie wrote:
If it is what you said earlier it is bullshit. It is. I know it offends your sensibilities of how the game should be played, but I am a realist. Where he said "I shouldn't have joined this game but I wanted to play with HF," that looked really genuine. That makes me disregard any scumread from inactivity. So he's back at an equal to random chance of flipping scum.Calling SL's "I'm scum" comment sincere was slightly townie in how vague Marv was. I think he's the top plynch, though. And I am a firm believer in day 1 plynches, which is why my vote has been on him since early game.
To the bolded: Sure, it can be genuine. That doesn't mean anything for his alignment though. Being this inactive is hard to imagine for a town marv. His justification was a new job. He could have played or at least posted SOMETHING when he was done with work whil as scum the combination of rl + his general detest for the alignment could easily lead to this kind of play.
This has nothing to do with how I think the game should be played. It has everything to do with how I know marv plays this game. That's why as a realist you should realize that this is far more likely to come from mafia marv than from town marv.
The SL thing isn't towny.
So yeah, no reason to read him town at all.
|
On May 25 2016 20:49 Koshi wrote:
1. Holyflare obvious town
2. Damdred obvious trash
3. ritoky obvious town
4. Rels nullish town
5. LightningStrike pretty town
7. Palmar mafia
8. marvellosity afk
9. justanothertownie boring turtle
10. sicklucker obvious town
11. Superbia wounded animal
12. Tumblewood obvious town
13. nnn_thekushmountains nullish mafia
|
On May 26 2016 00:27 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2016 00:21 Palmar wrote:On May 26 2016 00:11 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, I was starting to think palmar is kinda towny but I don't think he can actually believe this. Did you think this through? I would _never_ lie about this, as either alignment. It's entirely pointless for me to do so. How? If marv is town and just screwed by his job and we lynch him you can play the "told you so card" instead of having to answer hiw it is possible for you of all people to mislynch marv. If marv is mafia there is obvious reason to lynch someone else. Why would you NEVER lie about that?
he would just correct me. It's not "I told you so" if he comes in and says "actually I do want to maintain high level of activity on day 1, I was just busy".
Anyway this is a dumb argument. You're just bad.
|
On May 26 2016 00:29 LightningStrike wrote:
JAT can you please lynch Palmar with me? I gave you guys my case on him and I think he should be lynched right now.
I haven't even read your case, but if you wrote one you're either bad or scum. The only case on me that is valid prior to today is "Palmar is afk, let's policy lynch him". If your case was more than 20 words then it's full of shit regardless of your alignment,
|
kush is now best player on tl, will sheep if required.
|
Palmar so mad. Will report after game for BM.
|
Hi I'm playing now
Given everyone else's apparent soulreads it seems I should reconsider my read on Superbia. I could buy that this is kinda like Storm where he had 20+ pages of nothing. 6/10 would sheep
Also rit might be town. Confirmation bias is a real thing to consider. Also he's kind of breaking the bot persona which could show that he actually cares, and it's a fine thing to hide behind as scum.
|
Palmar is exceptionally stubborn and useless, even more than jat game
|
On May 26 2016 01:13 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2016 00:27 justanothertownie wrote:On May 26 2016 00:21 Palmar wrote:On May 26 2016 00:11 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, I was starting to think palmar is kinda towny but I don't think he can actually believe this. Did you think this through? I would _never_ lie about this, as either alignment. It's entirely pointless for me to do so. How? If marv is town and just screwed by his job and we lynch him you can play the "told you so card" instead of having to answer hiw it is possible for you of all people to mislynch marv. If marv is mafia there is obvious reason to lynch someone else. Why would you NEVER lie about that? he would just correct me. It's not "I told you so" if he comes in and says "actually I do want to maintain high level of activity on day 1, I was just busy". Anyway this is a dumb argument. You're just bad.
Only if he is town. Last time you 2 were mafia you continuously told bullshit about him and he obviously never corrected you. That's how I should have caught you.
I also fail to see how what you describe as a scenario where he returns as town means you would NEVER say something like that.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On May 25 2016 21:27 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On May 25 2016 00:14 Superbia wrote:
Ls wutu think of kush?
Will post some thoughts after I get home and have dinner+GoT
Prelude is kush is town Show nested quote +On May 25 2016 00:16 Holyflare wrote:
##unvote
##vote Superbia
Who asks what someone thinks of a player and then tells us that he's going to call him town later? This is such bullshit by holyflare. Yes, it's dumb from Superbia, but who cares? If Superbia is mafia this is not why. Talking a bit like a dumbass has never been and will never be a scumtell, yet hf jumps it. clearly 100% mafia no doubts no regrets ##vote Holyflare
But doing shit all and arguing for 5 pages of filter and doing nothing else is and hence why my vote has stayed.
|
Scumlist 1.1
Damdred
Hf
Ls
Ritoky
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
